To Kill a Mastermind Blu-ray Review
Qi sha Chat sat 七煞
Score: 53
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
A martial arts gem with dazzling acrobatics and abundant fight scenes, though the video transfer is inconsistent and audio overly bright.
Disc Release Date
Video: 76
To Kill a Mastermind's Blu-ray from 88 Films offers a solid 1080p transfer in 2.35:1, sourced from the original negative. While a yellowish tint occasionally mars the image, resulting in splotchy grain, the presentation delivers commendable detail, rich costumes, and vibrant colors, though black levels are slightly imperfect.
Audio: 61
The Mandarin LPCM 2.0 Mono track of 'To Kill a Mastermind' delivers clear dialogue despite sync issues, though it often feels high and tinny. Sound effects like gongs resonate more effectively than the recessed dialogue, with optional English subtitles available.
Extra: 2
88 Films delivers a long-awaited high-quality release of 'To Kill a Mastermind' with limited features, but enhanced by exquisite packaging, including a reversible sleeve and art cards, catering to avid Shaw Brothers collectors across Regions A and B.
Movie: 51
To Kill a Mastermind, while lacking A-list star power and a coherent plot, delivers stunning production design, dazzling kung fu, and kinetic action sequences that typify late-period Shaw Brothers' excellence, though its familiarity and chaotic narrative may have contributed to its initial disappearance from recognition.
Video: 76
"To Kill a Mastermind" receives a commendable Blu-ray release from 88 Films, presented with an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in a 2.35:1 aspect ratio. The restoration utilizes the original camera negative sourced from Celestial Pictures, ensuring a presentation that captures the film's intricate details. While the film's print quality is impressive given its historical scarcity outside Asia, nuances such as the slightly yellowish color timing can be observed in certain scenes. Despite some grain issues in mist-laden shots, the overall palette remains vibrant and healthy. The theatrical costumes and detailed set designs are well-highlighted, bringing clarity and definition to the viewing experience.
The 99-minute feature is housed on a BD-50 disc and benefits from a proficient AVC encode, which handles the film's varied grain structure without difficulty. The warm contrast and lively colors adeptly complement the film's action-packed scenes, enhancing the Blu-ray viewing experience. Black levels are strong, though not entirely flawless, contributing to an overall film-like quality that maintains excellent grain reproduction. Notably, the ShawScope format ensures a cinematic presentation; however, some softness is evident in scenes featuring high-flying acrobatic stunts. This does not detract significantly from the fine detail achieved elsewhere in the cinematography, resulting in a generally satisfying video presentation.
Audio: 61
The audio presentation of "To Kill a Mastermind" on Blu Ray features LPCM 2.0 Mono in the original Mandarin, delivering a mixed sonic experience. The track is characterized by a somewhat high and tinny quality, particularly noticeable during the Shaw Brothers masthead music and the film's opening theme. Although the brightness of the high end sees some improvement as the film progresses, it remains discernible, notably during key cues such as the entrance of the main trio to the Supreme Leader. Despite these issues, dialogue is rendered with clarity, albeit with loose synchronization at times. Optional English subtitles are available, although the translation has been reported to diverge from the original Mandarin.
Sound effects present a distinct variance across different frequencies. Lower sound effects, such as gongs and those accompanying fight sequences, resonate more effectively. However, the overall audio track suffers from a flat characteristic with often absent lower frequencies. This results in dialogue occasionally sounding distant and recessed when juxtaposed against overpowering sound effects and score elements. While the film's score maintains acceptable fidelity, it can become harsh in the upper frequencies when pushed beyond typical levels. The subtitles appear in a white font within the scope presentation, providing a functional yet imperfect solution for non-native speakers due to translation discrepancies.
Extras: 2
The Blu-ray release of "To Kill a Mastermind" by 88 Films caters to the long-standing demand from kung fu enthusiasts for a high-quality version of this formerly elusive Shaw Brothers' classic. Highlighting its dual-region encoding, this release makes the film accessible to audiences across both North America and the UK. While the extras selection is limited, the physical packaging stands out, offering supplementary artistic elements that collectors will appreciate. The reversible sleeve features original Hong Kong poster art, and the package includes a slipcover with striking new artwork by Sean Longmore coupled with four collectible art cards. A perfunctory Stills Gallery is the sole digital extra, offering a brief glimpse behind the scenes in high definition.
Extras included in this disc:
- Stills Gallery: A brief collection of stills presented in high definition.
Movie: 51
"To Kill a Mastermind" exemplifies the late-stage Shaw Brothers cinematic style, teeming with opulent action and intricate kung fu choreography characteristic of this era. Directed by Sun Chung, the 1979 film compensates for its lack of prominent stars with a vibrant ensemble cast, engaging cinematography, and excellent production design reminiscent of Hong Kong opera. Despite its commercial failure and subsequent obscurity, the film’s appeal lies in its sprawling, high-energy combat scenes. The Qi Sha clan serves as antagonists, led by a shadowy Supreme Leader, with an espionage sub-plot providing a layer of intrigue amid the relentless battles and complex character interactions.
The movie's narrative backbone may be criticized for its disorganized structure and over-reliance on familiar tropes, causing it to fall short of deeper story development. The imposing ensemble cast battles through a disjointed plot that merely supports the action-oriented spectacle, often resembling a series of vignettes more than a cohesive story. The rapid introduction and subsequent demise of characters further muddy the narrative waters, potentially leaving even ardent Shaw Brothers fans puzzled.
While "To Kill a Mastermind" lacks the renown of iconic entries like "The Five Deadly Venoms," the stunning choreography is undeniably its saving grace. The film captures the kinetic energy and technical prowess valued by kung fu aficionados. Although missing A-list star power and perhaps failing to etch a memorable mark in Shaw Brothers' storied history, its visual style and combat sequences make for a compelling viewing experience. Fans of the genre will appreciate the martial arts artistry on display, reflecting the studio's legacy of crafting high-octane, visually engaging cinematic experiences even in its less celebrated works.
Total: 53
"To Kill a Mastermind" on Blu-ray is a notable release that will attract kung fu enthusiasts with its captivating martial arts choreography. The film, directed by Chung Sun, is rich in acrobatic fight scenes that demonstrate the Shaw Brothers' signature style. Although the plot may be convoluted at times, the action sequences provide a compelling experience that will engage viewers and compensate for narrative weaknesses. This release marks a significant improvement in availability, making it accessible for audiences previously unable to find a watchable version.
The Blu-ray transfer delivers a generally solid visual presentation, though it shows some inconsistencies compared to releases like "The Golden Lotus". Despite this, the picture quality remains acceptable for a film of its age, showcasing the dynamic fight choreography with reasonably clear detail. The audio quality, while listenable, exhibits characteristics of being overly bright and thin, which can detract from the overall experience. Unfortunately, the release is sparse in supplementary content, offering only a stills gallery and minimal packaging inserts.
In conclusion, "To Kill a Mastermind" may not bring anything particularly new to seasoned fans of the genre but succeeds in delivering high-quality martial arts entertainment with its well-executed fight scenes. While there are areas for improvement in terms of video consistency and audio depth, this Blu-ray represents a worthy addition to any kung fu aficionado’s collection given its newfound accessibility and intrinsic action appeal.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 80
This is an often great looking presentation, but I have to say to my eyes it didn't quite make it to the levels seen in 88 Films' simultaneously released Blu-ray of The Golden Lotus....
Audio: 70
As things progress, the brightness of the high end can be at least marginally better, but you can still hear it in, for example, the cue underscoring the entrance of the focal three to Supreme Leader fairly...
Extras: 10
...
Movie: 50
If The Golden Lotus may strike some as a positively weird outing from the studio, it's probably a given that To Kill a Mastermind fits more snugly into the perceived "category" that Shaw Brothers productions...
Total: 50
There are nicely staged fight scenes in abundance here, which may be enough to attract interested eyes, along with the previous rarity of finding this title in anything approaching watchable shape....
DoBlu review by Christopher ZabelRead review here
Video: 80
Shot in ShawScope, Shaw Brothers studio’s name for CinemaScope, the transfer is smoothly film-like with excellent grain reproduction and decent fine detail....
Audio: 60
Dialogue is distant and recessed at times, especially in relation to occasionally overpowering sound effects and the backing score....
Extras: 2
The disc is coded for Regions A and B as 88 Films issues the movie in both North America and the UK.Special features are absent outside of a perfunctory stills gallery....
Movie: 60
It’s a fight to the finish packed with bloody deaths, double-crosses, and betrayals in almost confusing detail....
Total: 51
A muddled plot doesn’t drag down this high-flying kung fu adventure from Shaw Brothers and director Chung Sun packed with dazzling acrobatic fights...
Director: Chung Sun
Actors: Wei-Hao Teng, Sheng Lo, Kang Shih
PlotIn a politically volatile empire where deceit and treachery reign, an enigmatic mastermind holds the reins of power, orchestrating chaos from the shadows. A seemingly unconnected series of assassinations and sabotage incidents keep the imperial court in disarray. In this tense climate, a skilled martial artist and detective is covertly tasked with unraveling the truth. Armed with his prowess and intellect, he sets out on a perilous journey to expose the hidden puppet master pulling the strings. Along the way, he encounters a network of allies, each with their own motives and secrets. Navigating treacherous societal landscapes, he must discern friends from foes as he inches closer to the mastermind's true identity.
As his investigation deepens, the detective uncovers layers of conspiracy that reach high into the echelons of power, threatening to destabilize the empire itself. The closer he gets to uncovering the mastermind’s identity, the more danger looms. Twists and alliances shift unexpectedly, planting seeds of doubt about who can truly be trusted. Tension mounts as each new lead draws the detective into a labyrinth of deception. With time running out and lives hanging in the balance, he must rely on his skills, wit, and resolve to confront an enigmatic opponent. The stakes climb as the pieces fall into place, setting the stage for a confrontation that will determine not only his fate but the future of the empire.
Writers: Kuang Ni
Release Date: 23 Nov 1979
Runtime: 99 min
Rating: N/A
Country: Hong Kong
Language: Mandarin