Sword Master Blu-ray Review
三少爷的剑 San shao ye de jian
Score: 57
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Sword Master offers engaging wuxia visuals and outstanding audio, though inconsistent CGI and minimal bonus features may deter newcomers.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 68
Sword Master on Blu-ray by Well Go USA features a stunning 1.85:1 1080p transfer with vibrant color palettes, detailed imagery, and deep black levels. While the CGI occasionally appears soft and artifact issues are noted, the primary drawback is the lack of a 3-D option for this digitally-shot film designed with 3-D effects in mind.
Audio: 78
Sword Master's audio shines with a highly immersive DTS:X (DTS-HD MA 7.1 core) Mandarin track, delivering precise spatial effects and clean dialogue. While the English dub in DTS-HD MA 5.1 lacks the same appeal, the overall mix offers dynamic immersion, especially during action sequences, despite some level fluctuations.
Extra: 6
The Blu-ray extras for 'Sword Master' are notably sparse, offering just a brief behind-the-scenes featurette (1080i; 1:27) that serves more as an extended trailer and the official theatrical trailer (1080p; 1:32). The supplements auto-play consecutively, but are disappointingly minimal for such an action-heavy film.
Movie: 51
Sword Master delivers stunning fantasy martial arts with impressive stunt work and beautiful CGI, but its narrative suffers from a fragmented structure and inconsistent tone, wavering between fantastical flying swordplay and grounded realism. The forced 2D presentation undercuts the film's visual ingenuity.
Video: 68
"Sword Master" is presented on Blu-ray with an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in its original 1.85:1 aspect ratio, manifesting a crystal-clear image that exemplifies the precision of modern digital cinematography. Shot using the Red camera system, the film boasts an incredibly detailed presentation, particularly evident in scenes featuring intricate designs, such as sword etchings and elaborate costuming. The color palette is expansive and visually striking, ranging from vivid primaries to more muted yet evocative grays, contributing to the film’s visually rich dreamlike ambience. However, it is worth noting some intermittent artifact issues like temporary yellow webbing, which disrupt the otherwise stellar visual quality.
Unfortunately, the film’s original 3-D intent is not supported in this Blu-ray release, limiting viewers to a 2-D presentation. While this format showcases deep, inky black levels and accurate, healthy flesh tones that contribute to a tangible sense of depth, certain CGI elements appear awkward without the intended 3-D environment. This limitation impacts the visual experience during specific scenes, such as those involving CGI creatures which might have been more convincing in three dimensions. Despite this, Well Go USA's release largely remains a visually arresting display of the film’s aesthetic and technical achievements.
Audio: 78
The Blu-ray release of "Sword Master" offers an exceptional audio experience, primarily due to its powerful DTS:X (DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 core) Mandarin track. This audio mix exhibits remarkable spatial placement and immersive qualities, bringing forth the sounds of swords slicing through the air, the resonating impacts of bodies breaking through wooden structures, and the crunching of stone. These elements create a vivid and engaging auditory landscape that heightens the viewing experience. Additionally, ambient environmental noises contribute to the immersive quality, effectively capturing the essence of bustling outdoor scenes and the dreamlike passages visited by Yen.
While the primary DTS:X audio track is highly commendable, the English language dub in DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 is less impressive and not recommended unless absolutely necessary. With cleanly rendered dialogue and score, listeners can appreciate every vocal nuance and musical element without difficulty. The mix maintains active surrounds throughout its entirety, creating a continuous immersive atmosphere. However, some viewers may notice fluctuations in audio levels, particularly between high-energy action sequences and calm conversations. Although this may prompt occasional adjustments, the mix remains consistently balanced overall, ensuring a clear and enjoyable auditory experience.
In conclusion, "Sword Master" delivers a thunderous and immersive audio presentation that excels with its Mandarin DTS:X track. The precision in sound effects, dynamic range, and clean dialogue ensure that this Blu-ray stands out for its technical audio fidelity. For the best experience, the original Mandarin track is highly recommended over the English dub.
Extras: 6
The extras section of the Blu Ray release of "Sword Master" underwhelms with its limited offerings. The primary feature, "Mastering the Sword," provides fleeting insights into the behind-the-scenes aspects, albeit functioning more as an extended trailer with a focus on cast rundowns rather than a deep dive into sword fighting choreography or production nuances. Despite the impressive action and production design of the film, the supplementary material falls short in delivering substantial content. The disc automatically sequences through the extras, ending with trailers for other releases by Well Go USA.
Extras included in this disc:
Mastering the Sword: Brief behind-the-scenes footage and cast overview.
Theatrical Trailer: The official trailer for "Sword Master."
Movie: 51
Sword Master, directed by Derek Yee and produced by Tsui Hark, is a visually entrancing yet tonally disjointed entry in the wuxia genre. The film's narrative is rooted in the classic story "Death Duel" by Gu Long, harkening back to its 1977 cinematic predecessor that also starred Yee. The plot follows two central characters: Yen Shih-San (Peter Ho), a terminally ill swordsman with a mission to find his equal, and Hsieh Shao-Feng (Kenny Lin), who has renounced his past as the greatest sword master and now lives under the alias Ah Chi. Despite its rich premise, the film quickly signals its design for a 3D viewing experience, though only presented in 2D on the Blu-ray release, diminishing some of its visually intended impact.
The film begins with intense action sequences that may leave viewers perplexed due to scant exposition. Yen's journey as a death-marked wanderer and Ah Chi's transition from a lethal swordsman to a peace-seeking drifter are juxtaposed through a series of flashbacks and intersecting storylines. The dynamic between the CGI-laden fantasy world and the more gritty, traditional settings presents a jarring contrast that undermines the film's potential cohesiveness. Ah Chi's inevitable return to swordsmanship to reclaim honor unfolds amidst predictably coincidental revelations and interactions, which may test narrative suspension for some viewers.
What Sword Master does excel at is presenting captivating set pieces and stunt work, enhanced by visually stunning (albeit predominantly digital) cinematography. Action sequences, especially those relying less on CGI, carry a tangible weight and visceral excitement. Ho and Lin deliver commendable performances, each embodying their roles with a blend of dramatic gravitas and athletic precision. However, the film’s oscillation between ethereal mythos and slapstick-like tones creates a somewhat fragmented experience. Ultimately, Sword Master offers visual splendor and engaging action but falls short in unified narrative and tonal execution.
Total: 57
Sword Master is a fascinating attempt to revitalize the wuxia genre, albeit with a few notable shortcomings. Director Derek Yee's vision brings forth a visually engaging film heavily influenced by classic wuxia cinema. The storyline, while occasionally marred by pacing issues and an uneven blend of practical and CGI effects, manages to capture the essence of martial arts epics. Yee's direction ensures that each scene is staged beautifully, making the visual component one of the film's strongest aspects. However, those nostalgic for the more whimsical antics of Shaw Brothers productions might find themselves longing for more cohesive storytelling in the initial segments of the film.
The Blu-ray release by Well Go USA delivers a high-quality home viewing experience. The video presentation, though not entirely without its flaws, remains highly commendable. The audio track is particularly impressive, enveloping viewers in the intricate soundscapes of Sword Master's battle sequences and atmospheric moments. Despite this, some fans might be disappointed by the absence of a 3-D viewing option and the lack of substantial bonus features which could have enhanced the overall package. Nevertheless, the Blu-ray's technical strengths make it a worthwhile purchase for dedicated wuxia enthusiasts.
In conclusion, Sword Master was a near miss for me personally, but that may be because I have something of a soft spot for wuxia films from decades ago, notably some of the goofier Shaw Brothers outings. Those of you who share my sensibilities may get a kick (so to speak) out of this film, though many of you will probably find deficits in the storytelling, especially in the early going, much as I did. Yee stages things very nicely and the film is often quite ravishing from a purely visual standpoint. Video encounters some minimal issues, but audio is outstanding for those considering a purchase.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 80
The IMDb lists the Red camera as the technology utilized, and a lot of the imagery on display is crystal clear and nicely detailed, at least when some pretty soft looking (and perhaps intentionally so,...
Audio: 100
The DTS:X track is a riot of spatial placement, with some excellent panning and whooshing effects when swordplay enters the fray....
Extras: 10
As is usually the case with Well Go USA releases, the supplements have been authored to follow each other automatically....
Movie: 50
Those who are already familiar with Hark's hyperbolic tendencies (admittedly more on display in films he directed rather than produced) will know what to expect from a visual standpoint here, and in fact...
Total: 60
Sword Master was a near miss for me personally, but that may be because I have something of a soft spot for wuxia films from decades ago, notably some of the goofier Shaw Brothers outings....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Now, this isn't necessarily a fault of the transfer but as this film was designed with 3-D in mind, there are a number of CGI effects and tricks that look downright awkward in 2-D. A scene with a snake...
Audio: 80
Levels are a bit up and down, some of the big action scenes can be followed by a very calm and quiet conversation making you want to reach for the volume....
Extras: 0
For a film with this much action and impressive production design work, there is a sad lacking of even the most rudimentary behind-the-scenes bonus content....
Movie: 60
Where the film starts to hit rough patches is when it moves away from the CGI rendered universe into a more traditional, practical world without the blue screen....
Total: 60
I liked the film, even enjoyed the story and the great performances, but I can't shake Derek Yee's handling of the realistic practical worlds with the obvious CGI-enhanced fantasy elements....
Director: Tung-Shing Yee
Actors: Kenny Lin, Peter Ho, Yiyan Jiang
PlotIn a world of skilled martial artists and legendary swordsmen, a formidable warrior named Hsieh Shao-Feng grows weary of his violent past and seeks to escape it by living a life of anonymity in a remote village. As he attempts to find solace in the mundane tasks of everyday life, he crosses paths with Ah Chi, a former sword master who has also given up his violent ways and chosen a life of humility. The village is soon threatened by the ruthless Yu Sheng Wu, a notorious killer seeking to become the most powerful swordsman by eliminating any potential rivals, including Hsieh.
Trouble escalates as old enemies resurface, forcing both Hsieh and Ah Chi to confront their pasts. Their connection strengthens as they train together, rediscovering their skills while confronting their inner demons. As Yu Sheng Wu brings chaos to the village, Hsieh and Ah Chi must make critical decisions that challenge their convictions and impact their destinies. The villagers' lives hang in the balance as an epic battle of honor, redemption, and mastery unfolds.
Writers: Tin-Nam Chun, Lung Ku, Hark Tsui
Release Date: 09 Dec 2016
Runtime: 108 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: China, Hong Kong
Language: Mandarin