Love Me Tender Blu-ray Review
Score: 59
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Elvis' historically significant debut, 'Love Me Tender,' offers a few engaging moments but remains largely unremarkable; the Blu-ray's video and audio are top-notch.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 69
Love Me Tender's 1080p/AVC-encoded Blu-ray transfer in a 2.35:1 aspect ratio delivers exceptional clarity, sharpness, and accurate monochromatic gradation. The black and white Cinemascope film remains free from digital noise reduction, edge enhancement, and compression artifacts, offering a naturally filmic and spectacularly detailed image.
Audio: 64
The Blu-ray of 'Love Me Tender' offers both DTS-HD Master Audio mono and 5.1 mixes, both nearly identical, with subtle reverb in the rears. Both tracks are cleaned and polished, with clear dialogue and minimal age-related damage. Music and sound effects are well-presented, despite occasional brittleness in high-end vocals.
Extra: 41
The Blu-ray extras of 'Love Me Tender' offer a rich tapestry of historical and personal insights, including Jerry Schilling's compelling commentary, featurettes on Elvis' film debut and Colonel Parker's influence, and the evolution of the iconic song 'Love Me Tender', all enriching the viewing experience for fans.
Movie: 46
'Love Me Tender' stands as an unremarkable postbellum melodrama with sub-par acting and lackluster pacing, yet finds its sole appeal in being Elvis Presley's cinematic debut where his charisma and musical numbers manage to inject some life into an otherwise middling western.
Video: 69
20th Century Fox delivers an exemplary treatment of "Love Me Tender" with a sublime 1080p/AVC-encoded Blu-ray presentation, maintaining the original black-and-white Cinemascope format. The transfer exhibits sharp detail and a balanced image, devoid of digital noise reduction, edge enhancement, or contrast boosting. The print has been meticulously cleaned, eliminating specks and scratches while fully preserving the film's grain structure. The monochromatic gradation is striking, providing deep, inky blacks without any crush and ensuring highlights never peak excessively.
This Blu-ray upgrade brings remarkable clarity, revealing intricate details in the actors' faces and period costumes, particularly in elements like Elvis' corduroy coat. The backgrounds are equally impressive, with deep focus ensuring even distant elements are sharply resolved. Rural landscapes and railroad scenes benefit from added depth, enhancing the overall viewing experience. The absence of issues such as banding, dirt, or compression artifacts further cements this transfer's quality, albeit with minor instances of motion blur that do not detract from the overall picture. Undoubtedly, "Love Me Tender" achieves top marks in video quality, making it a must-have for enthusiasts.
Audio: 64
Fox offers a compelling audio presentation in this Blu-Ray release of "Love Me Tender," featuring two main audio options in the lossless DTS-HD Master Audio format. The disc defaults to a 5.1 multi-channel mix, which, despite its subtle expansions, retains the essence of the original mono track. This surround expansion gently shifts ambient sounds and musical reverb into the rear speakers, creating a light, almost imperceptible surround effect. Additionally, there is a DTS-HD Master Audio mono track that will appeal to purists. Both tracks have been meticulously cleaned to remove any age-related damage, such as pops, crackles, and loud hisses.
The audio quality is exceptional throughout, with clear and easy-to-understand dialogue. Lionel Newman's score and Elvis Presley's four musical numbers are presented with noticeable presence and clarity. However, the high-end frequencies do sound slightly brittle at times, particularly in the background singers' voices. Despite this minor issue, both audio mixes excel in delivering a polished and impressive auditory experience that does justice to this nearly 60-year-old film. Dub and subtitle options in multiple languages are also included, allowing for versatile viewing experiences.
Extras: 41
The extras included on the Blu-ray of "Love Me Tender" provide a comprehensive and engaging exploration of Elvis Presley's early film career and the impact of his debut movie. Jerry Schilling's commentary is enriched with personal anecdotes and historical context, making it an essential listen for Elvis fans. Additionally, the featurettes cover various aspects of Elvis’ transition from music to film, the influence of his manager Colonel Tom Parker, and an in-depth look at the iconic song "Love Me Tender." These extras offer both informative and entertaining insights into the beginnings of Elvis’ Hollywood career.
Extras included in this disc:
- Commentary by Jerry Schilling: Schilling provides historical and personal background on Elvis.
- Elvis Hits Hollywood: A short piece on Elvis' introduction to the film industry.
- The Colonel & The King: Profile of Colonel Tom Parker, Elvis' controversial manager.
- Love Me Tender: The Birth & Boom of the Elvis Hit: Tracks the song’s origins and release.
- Love Me Tender: The Soundtrack: Background on how the movie's soundtrack was created.
- Original Theatrical Trailer: Original trailer for the film.
- Spanish Trailer: Spanish version of the trailer.
Movie: 46
"Love Me Tender," released in 1956, marks the cinematic debut of the iconic Elvis Presley. This film examines the fates of the Reno brothers, Confederate soldiers who unknowingly continue fighting and rob a Union train days after the Civil War has ended. The lead protagonist, Vance Reno, played with rugged fortitude by Richard Egan, commands most of the screen time. In contrast, Elvis doesn't make an appearance until nearly a third into the movie, somewhat incongruent to his top billing on modern releases.
The plot centers around the Renos returning home to discover a misconception of their death transformed family dynamics: Clint Reno (Presley), the youngest brother who stayed behind, has married Vance's former sweetheart, Cathy (Debra Paget). This unfortunate revelation sows tension among the brothers and sets up a series of predictable confrontations including mistrust, legal troubles, and a climactic shootout with federal agents seeking the stolen money. The narrative is peppered with Elvis' musical numbers, including the ballad "Love Me Tender" and the upbeat "Let Me." These performances inject brief but much-needed energy into an otherwise tepid script.
The film's execution feels lackluster, with Elvis attempting to establish his acting chops amidst a cast that ranges from stoic to underwhelming. Richard Egan's presence is forgettable, and Debra Paget is relegated to looking forlorn. Aside from its historical significance as Presley's first film endeavor and its smattering of musical interludes, "Love Me Tender" is largely unremarkable. The movie is rescued only by the King's charismatic face and gyrating dance moves. While this Western melodrama may hold some nostalgic allure for die-hard Elvis fans, its straightforward mediocrity falls short of captivating broader audiences or providing the unintentional comedy of Elvis' later films.
Total: 59
"Love Me Tender" marks Elvis Presley's auspicious debut in cinema, a significant moment in the annals of movie history. However, while it carries the weight of historical importance, the film itself is rather lackluster, offering little beyond its initial intrigue. This Southern-set western leans more towards a serious tone, eschewing the infectious and often campy charm of Presley’s later works. Its narrative pacing is sluggish, and the plot fails to maintain prolonged engagement, a stark contrast to the dynamic persona of its lead actor.
On the technical side, the Blu-ray release from 20th Century Fox is a solid improvement over previous DVD editions. The newly remastered 1080p high-definition presentation breathes fresh life into the visuals, with noticeable enhancements in clarity and detail that do justice to the period-set cinematography. The audio mix, too, has benefited from a meticulous upgrade, providing a more immersive auditory experience that highlights Presley's musical interludes and the film’s score. Supplementary materials include an insightful commentary track and acceptable additional content, making it a well-rounded package for enthusiasts.
In conclusion, "Love Me Tender" may not captivate general audiences with its narrative prowess, but it retains historical significance as Presley’s cinematic inauguration. For Elvis aficionados and collectors, this Blu-ray edition presents a worthwhile upgrade due to its superior audio-visual quality. However, casual viewers might find its allure limited to its place in entertainment history rather than its entertainment value.
Blu-ray.com review by Casey BroadwaterRead review here
Video: 90
While preserving the film's grain structure entirely, Fox has given the print a thorough once-over, removing all specks and scratches....
Audio: 80
The multi-channel mix is one of those light, in-name-only expansions where reverb from the ambience and music in the front channels is panned subtly into the rear speakers....
Extras: 50
Love Me Tender: The Birth & Boom of the Elvis Hit (SD, 8:06): A featurette that tracks "Love Me Tender" from its origins as the American folk song "Aura Lee" to its release as a single and appearance in...
Movie: 60
It's a shame, because Presley had a natural giftthe moves, the look, the ability to hold attention without particularly doing anythingand in the hands of the right filmmakers he might've been formidable....
Total: 60
Still, just as when it first appeared in theaters, Elvis fans are likely to enjoy Love Me Tender despite its flaws, simply because of Presley's leg-shaking presence....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
With this new upgrade, the picture even has an added depth of the rural landscapes and railroad scenes....
Audio: 80
At times, some of the higher pitched vocals during the musical numbers sound a little to tweaked , but other than that, this is one heck of an audio presentation, given this film is almost 60 years old....
Extras: 40
Love Me Tender': The Birth & Boom of the Elvis Hit (SD, 8 mins) - This extra follows the journey of the song 'Love Me Tender' as it was created and sung by many, many people, including Elvis....
Movie: 40
Oddly enough, this was one of Presley's only serious films, as over the next decade, he would star in 30 or so silly and fun films, complete with musical numbers to woo his ever-growing audience....
Total: 60
While it might not be the most entertaining or the silliest of the Elvis film archive, it certainly marks an important part of cinema history, which is the first time Elvis appeared on the big screen....
Director: Robert D. Webb
Actors: Richard Egan, Debra Paget, Elvis Presley
PlotAfter the end of the Civil War, Confederate soldier Vance Reno returns home to find that his girlfriend, Cathy, has married his younger brother, Clint. Unknown to Clint, Vance and his brothers, who had all fought together, committed a train robbery during the war, mistakenly believing the South had not surrendered. They took a large sum of federal money which now must be returned. Tension arises as Clint discovers Vance's lingering feelings for Cathy and learns about the robbery, straining their brotherly bond. Despite these challenges, the Reno family sticks together, determined to navigate the complexities arising from war's end.
As pressure mounts from authorities closing in on the stolen money and from internal family conflicts, Clint must reconcile his love for Cathy and his loyalty to his brothers. The Reno family faces mounting dangers as they try to make amends while dealing with unresolved emotions, which leads to heated confrontations and dramatic decisions. Loyalties are tested within the family as they seek a path that honors justice without further fracturing their already tested relationships. In this emotional turmoil, each character is forced to confront their deepest moral dilemmas and fight for what they truly believe in.
Writers: Robert Buckner, Maurice Geraghty
Release Date: 15 Nov 1956
Runtime: 89 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United States
Language: English