Saawariya Blu-ray Review
Score: 61
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Despite weak plot & chemistry, Saawariya's stunning visuals & sound make it a unique, intriguing watch - not for all, but worth renting.
Disc Release Date
Video: 79
Saawariya's Blu-ray transfer shines in 1080p HD at 2.40:1 ratio, boasting exceptional detail, vibrant colors, and flawless execution, setting a new benchmark for video presentation quality.
Audio: 69
The film's original Hindi Dolby TrueHD 5.1 and standard Dolby Digital 5.1 tracks impress, with rich, immersive audio and precise instrument clarity, though slightly marred by occasionally lost low voices and overly loud bass, still achieving near reference-quality sound.
Extra: 16
Extras on Saawariya's disc, like behind-the-scenes music discussions and premiere footage, feel disjointed and recycled, overshadowing the film's memorable score and detailed production.
Movie: 56
Saawariya enchants with stunning visuals and music, but its storyline wavers, proving a mixed yet ultimately rewarding Bollywood dive.
Video: 79
"Sawariya" makes its way onto Blu-ray with a presentation that is nothing short of spectacular, elevating it to the status of reference material for aficionados seeking the pinnacle of video quality in their collections. Exhibiting a shift from its original 2.35:1 framing to a slightly wider 2.40:1 aspect ratio, the transition is facilitated flawlessly using the MPEG-4/AVC codec, showcasing the film in glorious 1080p. This enhancement not only suits the film’s aesthetic but also accentuates the meticulous detail captured in its closed set environments, from the cluttered RK bar to the picturesque canals and shadowy backstreets, each scene overflowing with visual information that begs for repeated viewings.
The extraordinary transfer boasts impeccable contrast and depth, particularly noteworthy in scenes shrouded in shadow, a frequent motif of the film. This, coupled with an outstanding color palette, brings scenes to life with incredible three-dimensionality; foreground figures seem to pop against the beautifully rendered backgrounds, enhancing the visual storytelling. Particularly commendable are the skin tones and the vivid, yet tightly contained colors of the costumes, rich and bold yet never bleeding out of their intricate embroideries. Such visual fidelity is backed by an absence of grain, even in darker sequences, which maintain clarity and detail without compromise.
In essence, "Saawariya" on Blu-ray surpasses expectations, rendering an image that is not only mesmerizing from the onset but maintains this high level of quality throughout. Every aspect of the video presentation - from the deep blacks and lush, vibrant colors to the incredible level of detail observable in every frame - contributes to a viewing experience that is as close to perfect as one might achieve on the format. It stands shoulder to shoulder, if not a step above, other reference-quality discs, making it an essential showcase piece for demonstrating the full capabilities of Blu-ray technology.
Audio: 69
The audio presentation of "Saawariya" on Blu-ray features two distinct tracks for audiences to experience: the original Hindi Dolby TrueHD 5.1 and a comparatively weaker standard Dolby Digital 5.1. Purists will naturally gravitate towards the original Hindi track, not just out of respect for the film's linguistic integrity but also for the superior auditory experience it offers. This track envelops you in a rich tapestry of sound, particularly during the film's elaborate song and dance numbers. The mix excels in balancing the intricate sounds of traditional instruments like sitars and the deep, resonant beats of chenda drums, creating an immersive soundscape that extends the auditory stage far beyond the screen. The dynamic range is broad, with explosive musical entries and nuanced panning across the front channels that underscore the meticulous sound design.
However, the soundtrack isn't without its flaws. Dialogue can occasionally recede into the background, losing some clarity among the film's more sonorous moments. It's a minor quibble in an otherwise stellar audio presentation but one that slightly mars the overall clarity. Moreover, the volume levels on this TrueHD track are notably aggressive; some may find themselves reaching for the remote to dial down the intensity. Once adjusted, though, the sonic environment it creates is unparalleled, offering a veritable feast of auditory delights. The bass is deep and authoritative without overwhelming, providing a solid foundation for both energetic musical numbers and more subdued scenes.
From an audiophile perspective, "Saawariya's" Dolby TrueHD 5.1 mix is a reference-quality achievement despite its tendency towards higher volume levels. Every channel is optimally utilized, crafting a soundstage that feels fully alive and three-dimensional. Whether it be the lilting melodies of a love song or the lively exchange of dialogue between characters, the audio track maintains a fidelity to natural sound reverberation that is rare and commendable. The soundtrack, much like the visuals of the film itself, is a vibrant showcase of technical prowess and artistic sensibility, only slightly dimmed by minor issues in vocal clarity and volume calibration.
Extras: 16
The Blu-ray extras for "Saawariya" present a conflicting mix of content that ranges from insightful to redundant. The highlight is indisputably "Making the Music of Saawariya," a featurette where Monty Sharma shares the creative process behind the film's captivating score, offering a mix of behind-the-scenes material and discussions that provide a rich backdrop to the film's musical aspect. However, its impact is somewhat diluted by the inclusion of "Premiere Night Footage," which not only repeats much of the material found in the music featurette but also includes additional, albeit genuine, praise for Sanjay Leela Bhansali's work from cast and crew. This repetition compels the suggestion that a more cohesive, single documentary might have served better. The addition of unrelated commercials and a trailer for "The Water Horse: Legend of the Deep" further emphasizes the lack of focus in the supplemental package, leaving a sense of missed opportunities to enrich the viewer's experience with more substantial, film-related content.
Extras included in this disc:
- Making the Music of Saawariya: A detailed insight into the creation of the film's score by Monty Sharma, mixed with opening night footage.
- Premiere Night Footage: Features repeat and extended premiere night content, with cast and crew praising the film, alongside unrelated trailers and commercials.
Movie: 56
"Saawariya," presented on Blu-ray, is an enigmatic blend of breathtaking visuals and a high-quality audio mix, setting a benchmark for Blu-ray presentations. Initial impressions reveal a disc set that, despite its captivating aesthetics, faces criticism for its storyline and supplementary content. The movie’s visual splendor and choreographically rich scenes are lauded, making it an undeniable keeper for both aficionados of cinema and connoisseurs of technical brilliance in home entertainment. Its unmatched visual fidelity positions it as a potentially prized possession in any collection, emphasized by vibrant blues that deeply enrich the viewing experience.
Venturing into "Saawariya" is likened to exploring uncharted territories beyond one's cinematic comfort zone, reminiscent of embracing genres outside conventional preferences for action, sci-fi, or classic comedies. This film serves as an introductory voyage into Bollywood, marked by a leap of faith akin to a first-time skydiver’s hopeful yet anxious plunge. While the movie embarks on a promising start, akin to an exhilarating jump, it encounters turbulence midway. The narrative, rooted in a classic love story within an enchantingly visual framework, tends to meander into tedium despite its visually arresting setup and compelling music.
Despite its slow middle act, "Saawariya" recovers gracefully in its final stretch, delivering an engaging conclusion that aligns well with its initial allure. The film's ability to regain its momentum illustrates a significant storytelling arc, salvaging the viewer's journey from potential disillusionment to satisfaction. This recovery is crucial in affirming "Saawariya’s" place within the realm of cinema that dares to be visually opulent while navigating the intricacies of love and hope. As such, the movie, through its Blu-ray presentation, becomes an embodiment of technical excellence and a testament to the emotive power of storytelling, albeit with noted narrative imperfections.
Total: 61
"Saawariya," a Bollywood offering on Blu-ray, brings forth a presentation that's as polarizing as it is mesmerizing. While the storyline and character dynamics between the two leads fall short of captivating the audience, the technical achievements of this disc shine brightly. The visual and auditory experience provided is top-notch, arguably setting a benchmark for Blu-ray presentations. However, despite its stunning visual appeal and exceptional sound quality, the shortcomings in narrative depth and a lack of substantial extras cannot be overlooked. The film's attempt to weave a compelling love story seems to falter with performances that fail to ignite a believable chemistry, leaving much to be desired in the heart of its storytelling.
The disc itself is a marvel for aficionados of high-quality home cinema, boasting what many might consider the finest picture and sound quality available on the format to date. "Saawariya" is undeniably a feast for the senses, draped in exquisite visuals and underscored by a soundtrack that exemplifies auditory grandeur. Yet, the film's pacing and engagement levels waver, leading to a viewing experience that veers between captivating and occasionally tedious. This disjointedness, paired with sparse and repetitive supplemental content, marks a missed opportunity to elevate the overall package to its full potential.
In conclusion, "Saawariya" on Blu-ray emerges as a conundrum. It's a technical masterpiece that showcases the heights of visual and sound quality attainable in the format, making it a must-see for enthusiasts seeking to push their home entertainment systems. Despite its storytelling pitfalls and underwhelming extras, the disc deserves recognition for its sensory excellence. Whether as a rental for the curious or a purchase for collectors and fans driven by audiovisual fidelity, "Saawariya" proves itself worthy of attention, albeit with reservations concerning its narrative and supplementary offerings. Recommended, with the caveat that its allure lies predominantly in its presentation rather than its plot or extra content.
avforums review by AVForumsRead review here
Video: 100
The extra width suits the film well, even though it was shot on closed sets there's a wealth of information available to the viewer and it's all there for you to pick out as you see fit....
Audio: 90
The surrounds do not detract from the audio coming from the frontal stage during these moments though they simply add to it and widen the stage somewhat....
Extras: 20
It's a rather odd extra as it's not just the music which is discussed, but also footage from the opening night of Saawariya which whilst welcome does seem a little out of place....
Movie: 50
Now though I'll be keeping this on my shelves as there are some wonderfully choreographed scenes in there I will want to watch time and again....
Total: 60
I can say though that it's well worth watch just for the visual imagery up on screen and because of that perhaps you might want to give this one a rental....
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 100
The movie is almost always bathed in a blue glow, but that doesn't stop colors from being rich and lush, or blacks from being inky and pure....
Audio: 90
The soundstage is used to perfection, as every single sound seems impeccably placed in every channel; nothing sounds artificial or forced, again the only drawback being that this seems awfully loud in...
Extras: 20
It features plenty of recycled material (not to mention some badly reproduced music), but there is some new material here, so depending on your inclination (music or premiere), only watching one of these...
Movie: 70
Thankfully, as the third act rolled around, the movie subliminally reminded me of the secondary parachute and I pulled the cord just in time to have a harrowing yet completely safe landing....
Total: 80
Certainly unique, oftentimes mesmerizing, at times a bit dull, but always intriguing and also wonderful to look at and listen to, Saawariya is undeniably one of the most interesting titles to arrive on...
Director: Sanjay Leela Bhansali
Actors: Ranbir Kapoor, Sonam Kapoor, Salman Khan
PlotIn a picturesque but mystical town awash in blue hues, a young, idealistic musician named Raj arrives with dreams in his eyes and a song in his heart. With nowhere to go and not a penny to his name, he takes refuge on a bridge under the stars, making friends with the quirky inhabitants of the town. His life takes a turn when he meets Sakina, a mysterious young woman waiting on the bridge, looking out for the return of her lover who had left her with a promise to return on a rainy night. Captivated by her beauty and sorrow, Raj befriends Sakina, and as they spend time together, he falls hopelessly in love with her.
Unaware of Raj's feelings, Sakina continues to cling to the hope of her lover's return, sharing her dreams and melancholy with Raj, who listens and comforts her with his music. As days pass, Raj's love grows stronger, and he decides to confess his feelings, hoping to win Sakina's heart before her lover comes back. Their budding friendship and Raj's unwavering affection set the stage for a tale of love, longing, and dreams in the face of the realities of life and love lost. However, the arrival of a stranger in town, whom Sakina eagerly awaits, threatens to change the course of their lives forever.
Writers: Sanjay Leela Bhansali, Fyodor Dostoevsky, Prakash Kapadia
Release Date: 09 Nov 2007
Runtime: 142 min
Rating: PG
Country: India, United States
Language: Hindi