A Private War Blu-ray Review
Score: 73
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
A Private War: Grim, raw bio-pic with top-notch Pike performance; essential, tough viewing. Quality Blu-ray.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 80
A Private War's 1080p transfer excels in detail and texture, despite some noise and compression issues in low-light, maintaining a grim, muted palette.
Audio: 85
The DTS-HD MA 5.1 audio mix excels in immersive war zones and nuanced PTSD sequences, with precise sound effects, clear dialogue, and deep bass, making for a highly detailed and engrossing experience.
Extra: 36
A Private War's release includes a digital copy, embossed slipcover, and three extras focusing on character insights, a summit Q&A, and a song tribute, though lacking in-depth production details.
Movie: 81
'A Private War' poignantly explores Marie Colvin’s devastating journey through the world's deadliest conflicts, revealing the heavy personal tolls of war journalism.
Video: 80
A Private War" on Blu-Ray boasts an impressive 1080p transfer, displaying a plethora of detail across varied and challenging environments – from the sandy expanses of Afghanistan to the devastated, rubble-filled scenes in Homs. The video presentation excels in conveying the gritty reality of the film's settings, offering a range of textures that enhance the overall cinematic experience. Fine details in facial expressions, clothing, and even the more mundane objects like guns and cameras are captured with remarkable clarity, pulling the viewer deeper into the story's intense atmosphere. The color palette is intentionally subdued, with muted tones that underscore the film’s somber themes, yet critical elements like blood and natural scenery are depicted with sufficient vibrancy to maintain visual interest. Skin tones and black levels are consistent, contributing to a cohesive visual style that complements the movie's narrative and emotional tone.
However, the Blu-Ray transfer is not without its flaws. Noise is noticeable in lower light conditions and darker scenes, which can occasionally detract from the film's otherwise striking visual quality. While these disruptions are relatively minor, they hint at the potential benefits of a 4K UHD release with HDR, which might alleviate these issues and enhance both depth and detail. Compression artifacts also sporadically appear, though they do not significantly impair the viewing experience. Such imperfections mildly distract but do not fundamentally undermine the overall high-quality presentation of the film.
Despite these minor issues, the Blu-Ray delivers an often stunning visual experience that does justice to "A Private War's" powerful storytelling and production design. The effort to maintain visual fidelity to the narrative’s grim reality is evident, making it a generally solid presentation that only occasionally falters due to technical limitations. This release effectively balances the need for technical precision and artistic integrity, making it a commendable addition to any collection.
Audio: 85
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 lossless soundtrack accompanying "A Private War" is an auditory journey that exemplifies the prowess of its sound design, bringing to the fore the essence and intensity of journalistic adventurism in conflict zones. The soundscape is meticulously crafted, immersing viewers right from the tranquility of the news office's daily hustle to the chaotic throes of war. Specifically, the opening scenes set in an animated newsroom and the vivid aural painting of Sri Lanka with its ambient wildlife and distant tumults demonstrate a keen attention to detail. This intricacy is mirrored in later sequences, particularly at an awards dinner where the natural reverberation of applause and speech enhances the realism, making each scene stand out with remarkable clarity.
The soundtrack truly shines during its depiction of warfare, where each gunshot and explosion is rendered with startling authenticity. The use of surround speakers is exemplary, creating a sonic environment where the listener is enveloped in the film's intense battle scenes, especially those set in Homs. The audio track excels in delivering a visceral experience of civil conflict, with bullets and shrapnel moving through the soundstage with such precision that one cannot help but feel catapulted into the midst of action. The robust bass during explosions adds a layer of profundity to the overall experience, ensuring that every detail, from the subtlest to the most explosive, is palpably felt.
Moreover, the soundtrack’s nuanced handling of delicate subject matter such as PTSD, as experienced by Marie Colvin (portrayed by Rosamund Pike), showcases the audio mix’s dynamic range and emotional depth. Through adept manipulation of sound across channels, it conveys Colvin’s internal tumult and disorientation with unsettling effectiveness. While it is lamentable that the audio presentation is not available in Atmos or DTS:X formats, which could potentially elevate the immersive experience even further, the existing DTS-HD MA 5.1 mix stands as a testament to superior sound design. It underscores not just the dialogue and frontal audio cues but engulfs the viewer in an encompassing auditory environment that significantly enhances the storytelling.
Extras: 36
The Blu-ray release of "A Private War" offers a limited glimpse into the making of the film and its inspiration, summing up to a slightly underwhelming extras package. Included is a digital copy code and an embossed slipcover, which adds a touch of physical quality to the release. The extras themselves, featuring a brief look into Rosamund Pike's transformation into Marie Colvin, a Q&A session from the Women in the World Summit with key figures from the film, and a snippet on Annie Lennox’s song for the film, lean towards promotional material rather than providing an in-depth exploration of the film's production or the real-life heroism of Colvin. While there are morsels of interesting information, particularly in the performances and thematic discussions, the overall collection of extras doesn't delve as deeply into the behind-the-scenes or conceptual development as one might hope, reflecting a missed opportunity to further enrich the narrative of "A Private War."
Extras included in this disc:
-
Becoming Marie Colvin: A brief overview of Rosamund Pike's transformation into the iconic journalist, detailing both character and story development.
-
Women in the World Summit Q&A: A discussion featuring Tina Brown, Matthew Heineman, Jamie Dornan, and Rosamund Pike, delving into Marie Colvin's life and legacy.
-
Requiem for A Private War: Insight into Annie Lennox’s contribution to the film through her music.
-
Movie: 81
A Private War," directed by Matthew Heineman, is a compelling and grim portrayal of Marie Colvin’s life. As a celebrated war correspondent for the London Sunday Times, Colvin's relentless pursuit of truth through the darkest corners of conflict zones, from Sri Lanka to Syria, is brilliantly captured. Rosamund Pike delivers a monumental portrayal of Colvin, embodying the intricate mesh of valor and vulnerability that marked Colvin's career and personal battles. The film does not just chronicle her brave expeditions across war-torn landscapes but delves deep into the psychological toll it exacts on her, showcasing her struggles with PTSD and the heavy cost of her unyielding commitment to journalism.
The storyline is enriched by Heineman's background in documentary filmmaking, ensuring that the depiction of war's brutal realities and Colvin’s personal demons are unflinchingly genuine. The narrative smartly navigates through her professional achievements and the intimate facets of her life, uncovering her motivations and the profound impact of her work on her loved ones. The screenplay doesn’t shy away from asking hard-hitting questions about the true price of bearing witness to humanity's darkest moments, making this biopic stand out for its depth and realism. The chemistry between Pike and Jamie Dornan, who plays photographer Paul Conroy, adds a tangible layer to the storytelling, especially in scenes that confront the ethical quandaries inherent in their line of work.
Technical details enhance the viewing experience, with cinematography that brings the visceral horrors of war into sharp focus while exploring the complex emotional landscape of its central character. The film’s pacing and nuanced writing ensure that viewers are drawn into Colvin’s world, feeling every ounce of her dedication and despair. “A Private War” succeeds in creating a powerful homage to Colvin’s legacy and war correspondents' sacrifices worldwide, inviting introspection about the cost of uncovering the truth amidst chaos. This Blu-ray presentation honors the film’s technical and narrative excellence, making it an important addition for those seeking a profound understanding of journalism's impact on both global awareness and individual lives.
Total: 73
A Private War," the cinematic recounting of journalist Marie Colvin's harrowing experiences in combat zones, emerges as a stark portrayal of the toll that relentless pursuit of truth in war-torn regions inflicts on individuals and those close to them. The film doesn't shy away from depicting the harsh realities of conflict and the personal sacrifices made by correspondents on the front lines. Rosamund Pike delivers a compelling performance as Colvin, bringing depth and a palpable sense of urgency to the role. Universal's Blu-ray presentation enhances this gritty narrative with exceptional video and audio quality, immersing viewers in the visceral intensity of the story. However, the Blu-ray package slightly underwhelms with its sparse selection of bonus features.
The film's unflinching approach in presenting Marie Colvin's life underscores not only her fearless journalism but also illuminates the broader human cost of war. Through its meticulous depiction and outstanding lead performance, "A Private War" transcends typical biopic boundaries, offering an unvarnished look into the complexity of its protagonist and the chaotic environments she navigated. While the Blu-ray release boasts high-quality visual and audio elements that faithfully convey the film's atmospheric tension, the limited extras leave a bit more to be desired for those intrigued by the behind-the-scenes aspects of both the film and Colvin's life.
In conclusion, "A Private War" on Blu-ray is a compelling acquisition for those interested in the raw and impactful storytelling of war correspondents' lives. Its superior technical presentation enhances the film's gritty realism, though a more robust collection of special features would have provided valuable additional context. Despite this minor shortfall, the release remains a crucial viewing experience, recommended for its powerful narrative and remarkable portrayal by Pike. This Blu-ray not only serves as a tribute to Marie Colvin's legacy but also as a poignant reminder of the profound impact of journalism in wartime.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
Red blood, some natural greens, and various colors of clothing and location specifics back in London are handled well, as are little, but crucial, elements like characters awash in the glow emanating from...
Audio: 90
Surround speakers carry various shots across several different conflict zones seen throughout the film, and those coming out of Homs in the film's final act are particularly terrifying with strong pop...
Extras: 40
Becoming Marie Colvin (1080p, 3:45): A character and story recap followed by a look at Pike's performance as Colvin, including her real and practiced physical changes during the shoot....
Movie: 80
The picture is unmistakably and unabashedly grim, both in its depiction of warfare and in its depiction of Colvin's personal crises, the post traumatic stress disorder that shaped her life and career and...
Total: 70
A Private War is an unforgivingly grim, true-life account of Journalist Marie Colvin's life in combat zones around the world and death during the Syrian civil war....
High-Def Digest review by Matthew HartmanRead review here
Video: 90
Occasionally there were a few scenes that look strangely flat and I couldn't figure any narrative style reason for them to be other than possible reshoots in front of stagnant image backgrounds....
Audio: 100
What really stood out to me in the sound design is a few moments in the middle stretch where Pike's Colvin is struggling with her PTSD and you're not completely aware where in time and place she is....
Extras: 40
Unfortunately, the bonus features department is where this release follows the common practice of dropping the ball with a string of EPK featurettes that would be better suited on YouTube and don't really...
Movie: 90
But in the wake of various world affairs and events, going through that journey if only to learn a little more about Colvin and other war correspondents and their work is worth any potential personal discomfort....
Total: 80
Marie Colvin was a relentless seeker of the truth in nightmare war-torn areas of the world, but her accomplishments came at a deeply personal cost - not only for herself and her life but also friends and...
Director: Matthew Heineman
Actors: Rosamund Pike, Alexandra Moen, Tom Hollander
PlotCelebrated war correspondent Marie Colvin, known for her fierce dedication and willingness to bear witness to the horrors of conflict, works for The Sunday Times in London. Renowned for her distinctive eye patch, a result of an injury sustained while covering the civil war in Sri Lanka, Marie is a complex character—a woman grappling with the toll her career takes on her personal life and mental health. The challenges of PTSD and the strain on her relationships at home contrast sharply with her fearless approach to journalism in the world's most dangerous hotspots. Marie's story is one of unyielding commitment to reporting the truth, often at great personal risk.
In the depths of war-torn landscapes, Marie partners with freelance photographer Paul Conroy to cover the most volatile conflicts of the early 21st century. Together, they venture into rebel-held areas in Syria during the siege of Homs, exposing the scale of the humanitarian crisis and the suffering of civilians trapped by the conflict. Their relationship highlights the bond forged in extreme circumstances and the importance of collaboration in unveiling the realities of war. Despite the physical and emotional scars that accumulate with each assignment, Marie's pursuit remains unshaken: bearing witness and giving a voice to the voiceless, all while navigating an industry and a world often ambivalent to her mission.
Writers: Arash Amel, Marie Brenner
Release Date: 16 Nov 2018
Runtime: 110 min
Rating: R
Country: United Kingdom, United States
Language: English