Election Blu-ray Review

Presented with a 2.35:1 aspect ratio and encoded with MPEG-4 AVC, the Criterion Blu-ray release of Alexander Payne's "Election" features a meticulously executed 1080p transfer. Created from the Super 35mm original camera negative at 16-bit 4K resolution using a Lasergraphics Director film scanner, this transfer showcases outstanding image quality. Thousands of dirt, debris, and scratches were meticulously removed using MTI Films’ DRS, while Digital Vision's Phoenix tackled jitter, flicker, and noise management, resulting in a clean and stable presentation. The 5.1 surround soundtrack was remastered for clarity using Pro Tools HD and iZotope RX, removing clicks, thumps, hiss, and crackle. Criterion's attention to detail significantly improves upon the already commendable 2009 Paramount release.

The Criterion edition boasts exceptional clarity and fine object detail, particularly noticeable in both well-lit panoramic scenes and indoor footage. The film maintains an organic appearance thanks to stable color reproduction and deep black levels. Original film grain is preserved without any digital anomalies, offering an excellent range of nuances that enhance depth and dimensionality, especially in high school hallway scenes. While the new transfer exhibits a cooler color temperature with a blue push that slightly affects flesh tones and overall color warmth, the result remains visually appealing and true to the original cinematographic intent.

Significant for its fidelity to the original material, Criterion’s 4K master supervised by Alexander Payne handles grain more effectively than the previous Paramount release and is free from dirt and debris. The overall image quality is noticeably superior on larger screens. Though some viewers might prefer the warmer tones of Paramount's version, Criterion’s more neutral color scheme delivers a clean and nuanced viewing experience that purists and casual viewers alike can appreciate.

The Blu-ray presentation of "Election" features an English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 soundtrack, which is both technically sound and user-friendly, offering optional English SDH subtitles that appear within the image frame. This audio track is noted for its clarity and stability, free of any technical anomalies such as audio dropouts, pops, background hiss, or digital distortions. While Rolfe Kent's score is decently highlighted, the film does not heavily rely on musical themes and effects to convey its narrative.

Despite being remastered from the original 35mm magnetic tracks and transitioning from a previous 5.0 configuration to a 5.1 mix, there is minimal bass activity, reflecting its limited dynamic range. The surround channels are primarily used for ambient noises and occasional music bleed, with crowd sounds in the school auditorium providing some level of atmospheric presence. The track's deliberate and well-balanced audio elements ensure that the quirky character comedy maintains its charm without requiring an aggressive soundtrack.

The dialogue is consistently crisp and intelligible throughout, ensuring clear communication of the film’s narrative. The low-frequency extension is understated, adding minor elements such as audience applause that modestly enhance the overall audio experience. Overall, the front and rear channels factor in effectively when necessary, offering a pleasant surround sound experience appropriate for the film's genre while keeping most of the focus on the vibrant and bouncy dialogue.

The Blu-ray release of "Election" by Criterion offers a diverse selection of extras that both complement and enhance the viewing experience of this cult classic. The highlight includes Alexander Payne's early work with his thesis film presented in excellent quality alongside a candid director's statement and introduction, providing insight into his creative beginnings. The newly conducted interviews, especially Reese Witherspoon's reflection on her role as Tracy Flick, add significant value for fans and newcomers alike. Furthermore, the inclusion of vintage and nostalgic content such as truInside: Election and local news clips lend a comprehensive chronicle of the film's production history. Despite the absence of an alternate ending, the overall package remains substantial and informative.

Extras included in this disc:

• Audio Commentary: Director Alexander Payne discusses the novel adaptation, shooting locations, and thematic elements.
• Trailer: Original U.S. trailer, humorous but misleading marketing.
• The Passion of Martin: UCLA thesis film by Alexander Payne including a director’s statement and an introduction.
  • Director's Statement: Text format statement about the thesis film.
  • Introduction: Newly filmed introduction where Payne discusses his filmmaking journey.
• Reese Witherspoon: A recent interview about her role in the film and its impact on her career.
• TruInside: Election: A truTV documentary on the production of Election.
• Local News: Report featuring behind-the-scenes footage from 1997.
• Leaflet: Illustrated leaflet with an essay by critic Dana Stevens.

Alexander Payne's "Election" (1999) on Blu-ray remains a piercing satire of American politics and human nature. Set in a high school election, the film follows Tracy Flick (Reese Witherspoon), a tenacious and ambitious student running for class president, alongside the well-meaning but intellectually lacking jock, Paul Metzler (Chris Klein), and his disillusioned sister, Tammy (Jessica Campbell). Narratively structured with multiple perspectives and laced with a dark comedic tone akin to Todd Solondz's films, "Election" unravels the intricate dynamics of electoral campaigns and the moral ambiguities that accompany them.

The performances are stellar, with Witherspoon delivering a career-defining portrayal of a complex character driven by both commendable ambition and ethical lapses. Matthew Broderick’s turn as Jim McAllister, the embittered social studies teacher, adds depth through his excellent narration that reveals much about his flawed nature, starkly contrasting his outwardly cheerful demeanor. This expertly balanced character ensemble is well-supported by brilliant writing from Payne and Jim Taylor, which secured an Oscar nomination. The film’s ability to remain relevant, even prescient, over decades is notable - capturing parallels to real-world political scenarios from the 2000 and 2016 U.S. elections.

Critically acclaimed for its sharp humor and perceptive commentary on the political process, "Election" showcases an uncanny foresight without sacrificing its entertainment value. Payne’s meticulous direction pairs with Ennio Morricone's evocative soundtrack, further enhancing the film's sardonic yet insightful reflection on societal norms. Despite its muted initial reception at the box office, the film has garnered a well-deserved reputation as one of the finest high school comedies that transcends its genre to deliver enduring satire. Criterion’s Blu-ray release ensures that this modern classic remains accessible in high-quality format for both new viewers and long-time fans.

Alexander Payne's "Election" remains a pertinent and sharply witty satire, critiquing American politics with an unflinching eye that has only grown more relevant since its 1999 debut. Its incisive portrayal of the absurdities and power struggles within a high school setting continues to resonate, as the parallels to real-world elections and institutional dynamics become strikingly clearer. The performances are universally commendable, channeling the script’s clever tone and elevating it into an enduring comedy classic.

The Criterion Collection's new Blu-ray edition offers noteworthy technical enhancements. Sourced from a robust 4K master, the video transfer showcases significant improvements in clarity and color accuracy compared to the 2009 Paramount release. However, it's not without its imperfections; some may find the differences subtle. The audio remains crisp, effectively capturing the ambiance of each scene. Bonus features in this edition provide valuable insights into the film’s production and thematic depth, though they are somewhat limited in scope.

In conclusion, "Election" serves as both a humorous yet biting satire of electoral politics and a reflection on contemporary academic climates. Given its enduring relevance and critically acclaimed presentation through Criterion's edition, including notable technical improvements, this Blu-ray release is highly recommended. While previous releases may suffice for budget-conscious viewers, those seeking the best possible version of this comedy will find the Criterion edition worthwhile. Whether you’re revisiting the film or experiencing it for the first time, it's a timely reminder of the complexities of modern democracy and institutional behavior.