The Song of Names Blu-ray Review
Score: 75
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
The Song of Names offers a moving journey with strong performances and excellent technical presentation, though it falls short of reaching its full potential.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 78
The Blu-ray's 1080p AVC-encoded 2.39:1 presentation of 'The Song of Names' is beautifully captured with warm amber tones, deep blacks, and razor-sharp detail, despite occasional artifacting due to a limited 11 GB allocation on a BD-25 disc; colors lean towards earth tones with natural skintones and subtly changing period lighting.
Audio: 91
The 7.1 DTS-HD MA track of 'The Song of Names' delivers a beautifully immersive sound experience, with haunting violin performances resonating crisply throughout the soundstage, precise dialogue handling, and detailed atmospheric effects like weather changes and WWII bombings, while maintaining clean, front-focused dialogue and rich orchestral immersion.
Extra: 48
Extras on 'The Song of Names' Blu-ray offer a comprehensive dive into the film's creation, spotlighting standout performances by Tim Roth and Clive Owen, Howard Shore's meticulous two-year composition process, and Ray Chen's virtuoso violin contributions, all captured in high-definition featurettes.
Movie: 63
While 'The Song of Names' captivates with its poignant tale and strong performances by Tim Roth and Clive Owen, its effectiveness is hampered by jarring flashbacks and a plodding pace that dilute the emotional impact of its mystery and thematic depth, despite excellent cinematography and Howard Shore's compelling score.
Video: 78
The Blu-ray presentation of "The Song of Names" showcases a compelling blend of detail and atmospheric cinematography, effectively captured by David Franco. While the exact digital intermediate master is not disclosed, it appears to be a 2K digital shoot. The film utilizes a 2.39:1 aspect ratio, offered through an AVC encoded image. Despite the modest 11 GB disc size, the visual quality remains commendable with radiant amber tones and crisp textures. The warm, period-appropriate color palette leans towards desaturated earth tones, adding to the historical ambiance. Nevertheless, brighter colors on clothing and signage punctuate the generally restrained hues, ensuring a balanced visual presentation.
Detail and clarity are consistently strong across varied environments, from the opulent design elements in Martin’s childhood home to the distressed settings in 1980s Warsaw. The film skillfully achieves deep contrast and inky black levels, although darker scenes occasionally suffer from artifacting issues, including blockiness and banding. Such imperfections are minor and do not significantly detract from the overall visual experience. Facial and clothing details are expertly rendered, though some stylized background shots faintly lose texture.
The stylized approach captures the dreamy, surreal essence of certain historical periods. Darker sequences, such as a practice session in a dimly lit room, showcase intricate shadow details. The cinematography alternates adeptly between the clear, crisp visuals of the 1980s and the softer, more ethereal look of earlier decades. In conclusion, despite the technical limitations of the disc's size, "The Song of Names" presents an elegant and atmospheric visual composed with both technical precision and artistic finesse.
Audio: 91
The audio presentation of "The Song of Names" on Blu-ray is nothing short of exquisite, with a focus on delivering a faithful and immersive listening experience. Utilizing a 7.1 DTS-HD Master Audio track, the film demonstrates an impressive level of precision. The score by Howard Shore is beautifully haunting, prominently featuring violin performances that radiate across the entire sound stage, creating a musical cocoon that envelops the audience. Dialogues are cleanly located up front, maintaining clarity throughout, while the orchestral and atmospheric elements fill the surround channels with nuanced layers of sound. This meticulous spatial arrangement adds a circular feel to the audio, helping to create an engaging and immersive soundscape.
The inclusion of additional surround channels in the 7.1 mix greatly enhances the overall audio experience, particularly during key scenes set against the backdrop of World War II. Bombing raids and percussive moments resonate with a controlled low-end rumble, adding depth to the soundstage without overwhelming the listener. The subtle integration of ambient sounds such as wind and rain further accentuates the film's atmospheric richness. This track is not about bombastic audio effects but rather the beauty and nuance that comes from delicate placement and pristine clarity.
In summary, "The Song of Names" offers a masterfully crafted audio experience that is both expressive and immersive. Whether it’s the stirring melodies of Shore’s score or the crisp dialogue exchanges, this 7.1 DTS-HD MA track delivers high frequencies, tight mid-range, and relaxed dynamics with quiet intensity. The audio presentation truly supports and enhances the emotional weight of the film, making it an all-around great track for audiophiles and casual listeners alike.
Extras: 48
The Blu-ray release of "The Song of Names" includes a robust suite of special features that offer an insightful behind-the-scenes look at the film's creation. The "Behind 'The Song of Names'" segment provides a comprehensive overview of the filmmaking process, featuring interviews with key cast and crew members including director François Girard and actor Clive Owen. The "Howard Shore: Composing & Scoring" featurette delves into Shore’s two-year endeavor to craft the film's score, which required bespoke violin compositions recorded in a church for unique acoustics. The "Howard Shore & Ray Chen" segment highlights the collaboration between Shore and virtuoso violinist Ray Chen, underscoring the critical role of violin music in the film. Additionally, the disc includes the film’s theatrical trailer.
Extras included in this disc:
- Behind the Song of Names: Director François Girard and the cast discuss the film's production.
- Howard Shore: Composing & Scoring: Howard Shore details his extensive work on the film's score.
- Howard Shore & Ray Chen: Shore discusses the importance of violin music, featuring performances by Ray Chen.
- Theatrical Trailer: The original theatrical trailer for "The Song of Names."
Movie: 63
"The Song of Names," helmed by François Girard, who previously directed "The Red Violin," is a historical drama that attempts to weave a complex narrative set against the backdrop of post-Holocaust trauma and the poignant strains of classical music. The plot revolves around Martin, played by Tim Roth, who goes on a quest to find his childhood friend Dovidl (Clive Owen), a violin prodigy who vanished on the night of his debut performance in 1951. This journey oscillates between 1951 and 35 years later, mixing timelines in an attempt to reveal the emotional underpinnings and lifelong impact of Dovidl's disappearance.
From a technical standpoint, "The Song of Names" is undeniably well-crafted; Howard Shore's masterful score offers a soulful canvas that enhances the thematic elements. However, the film struggles with pacing and narrative execution. The frequent flashbacks can feel jarring, disrupting the viewer's immersion instead of enriching the storyline. The mystery at its core is compelling, yet it suffers from an overemphasis on Martin’s detective work in the present, which undercuts the emotional weight of both their childhood bond and the ultimate revelation.
Clive Owen and Tim Roth deliver remarkable performances, lifting a film that sometimes buckles under narrative inconsistencies. Their portrayal imprints the characters with depth and vulnerability, often compensating for the script's melodramatic tendencies. While the film tries to strike a balance between a moving character study and a suspenseful mystery, it occasionally falters in maintaining momentum, particularly through its middle act. Despite these flaws, "The Song of Names" remains an engaging exploration of how war, identity, and music intertwine to shape lives in profound ways.
Total: 75
"The Song of Names," directed by Francois Girard, brings viewers into a sentimental Holocaust drama featuring standout performances by Clive Owen and Tim Roth. The film captures an epic narrative spanning decades as it unravels profound themes of loss, identity, and the haunting legacy of history through the journey of its characters. Despite Girard's earlier achievements, "The Song of Names" falls into a more modest offering within his oeuvre, grappling to fully reach its potential. The film’s compelling storyline and heartfelt performances are slightly undermined by a lack of consistent energy and urgency.
Sony’s Blu-ray presentation is technically proficient, boasting a 2.39:1 AVC aspect ratio and exceptional audio options including English DTS-HD MA 5.1 and English DVS 5.1. The visual fidelity is commendable, and Howard Shore's exquisite scoring stands out, providing the film with a powerful musical backbone that elevates the emotional depth of the narrative. Additional features on the disc, while sparse, are a welcome enhancement. The viewing experience is enriched by these technical merits, creating an immersive atmosphere that complements the period-setting of the film.
In conclusion, while "The Song of Names" may not achieve greatness, it remains a worthwhile experience for those who appreciate period piece dramas and Holocaust narratives. The enhanced audio-visual quality of the Blu-ray ensures that viewers still receive a high-grade presentation of this poignant story. Sony Classics’ presentation does justice to the film’s aesthetic and emotional intentions, making it a decent watch despite its shortcomings.
AV Nirvana review by Michael ScottRead review here
Video: 90
Clarity is still clean and sharp though, with great facial and clothing details, although some backgrounds lose some texture due to the stylized look. ....
Audio: 90
The score is beautifully haunting, and the violin elements from David really fill out the entire sound stage with a cocoon of music....
Extras: 30
• Behind the Song of Names: Director François Girard and Producer Robert Lantos brought Norman Lebrecht's acclaimed novel to life with the outstanding performances of Tim Roth and Clive Owen. •...
Movie: 60
The best part about the entire thing is just watching Clive and Tim work their craft, as the two men give some incredibly powerful performances despite the limitations of the movie structure itself....
Total: 70
Lately the Sony Classics line of Blu-rays have all been relegated to their MOD model (Manufactured on Demand where they burn a BD-R instead of press the film on a BD-ROM), and I think this is the first...
Blu-ray.com review by Brian OrndorfRead review here
Video: 50
There's an autumnal feel to the cinematography, which offers browns and grays, with earth tones utilized by the production....
Audio: 100
Orchestral moods are immersive, offered with a circular feel, and surrounds are enveloping with atmospherics, taking note of weather changes and room tone....
Extras: 50
"Howard Shore: Composing & Scoring" (2:31, HD) spends a short amount of time with the music man, who reveals he's been working on "The Song of Names" for two years, required to create violin pieces for...
Movie: 60
The exact ramifications of this decision are revealed later in the feature, but the event carries on within Martin, who reappears 35 years later in a different life, only to be pulled back into the past...
Total: 60
"The Song of Names" only manages to impart a faint sense of urgency, with Girard unable to get the feature where it needs to be, despite showing directorial clarity early on....
DoBlu review by Christopher ZabelRead review here
Video: 100
The Song of Names is a carefully filmed 2.40:1 presentation, radiant with amber tones and razor-sharp definition....
Audio: 100
Resonating with a haunting violin performance from noted performer Ray Chen, the instrumental music is heard with effortless high frequencies and a tight mid-range....
Extras: 60
Behind the Song of Names (07:34 in HD) – Director François Girard, actors Tim Roth and Clive Owens, and author Norman Lebrecht are interviewed in this behind-the-scenes featurette that serves as a reasonable...
Movie: 60
Starring Tim Roth and Clive Owens, the earnest tale is about the close bond of two boys growing up together in London, one an enormously talented prodigy from Poland that had to leave his Jewish family...
Total: 80
Tim Roth and Clive Owens headline in this sentimental Holocaust drama that takes decades for its mystery to be solved....
Home Theater Forum review by Todd ErwinRead review here
Video: 100
Contrast is also excellent, with deep blacks that retain intricate shadow detail (the practice session in a darkened room at the beginning of chapter 5 is a great example)....
Audio: 100
The additional surround channels really help immerse the viewer in the use of music throughout the film, as well as giving a wider sense to atmospheric sounds like wind, rain, birds, etc....
Extras: 60
Behind the “Song of Names” (1080p; 7:34): This is a fairly general overlook at the making of the film, including a brief interview with the author of the source novel....
Movie: 80
His adoptive brother, Martin (Gerran Howell), tries to convince their father Gilbert (Stanley Townsend) that he’s just late or lost and will be there shortly, but alas he never arrives and Gerald is forced...
Total: 80
The Song of Names may not be a very suspenseful film, but I still found Dovidl’s journey as Martin uncover it very moving....
Director: François Girard
Actors: Eddie Izzard, Gerran Howell, Stanley Townsend
PlotIn pre-World War II London, a young Polish violin prodigy named Dovidl, is taken in by a British family, the Simmonds, to study music and escape the looming conflict. Martin Simmonds, the adoptive family's son, and Dovidl develop a deep friendship through their shared love of music. On the night of Dovidl's highly anticipated debut concert, he mysteriously disappears without a trace, leaving Martin and his family devastated. Decades later, Martin, now an adult, is haunted by the mystery of Dovidl's disappearance and sets out on a journey across multiple countries to uncover the truth about what happened to his friend.
As Martin delves deeper into the past, piecing together clues from their shared history and encounters with various individuals who might have known Dovidl, he uncovers layers of secrets that reveal the profound impact of war, faith, and music on their lives. His search becomes not just an attempt to find Dovidl but also a reflection on his own identity and reconciliation with the past. Ultimately, Martin's quest is a poignant exploration of friendship, memory, and the enduring legacy of those who disappear.
Writers: Jeffrey Caine, Norman Lebrecht
Release Date: 25 Dec 2019
Runtime: 113 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: Canada, Hungary
Language: English, Hebrew, Polish, Italian