The Class Blu-ray Review
Entre les murs
Score: 56
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
The Class offers solid video and clear audio, complemented by vast special features, creating a charming, intelligent, and engrossing cinematic experience—highly recommended.
Disc Release Date
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 56
"The Class" boasts a filmic, warm 1080p/AVC-encoded transfer with strong color saturation and good clarity, especially in close-ups. While shot in high definition, the occasional softness and unfocused scenes detract slightly. Overall, it’s a solid presentation with naturalistic tones but lacks the sharpness of top-tier Blu-rays.
Audio: 48
The Class' features an unusual French Dolby TrueHD 3.0 surround track, heavily centered on dialogue with minimal ambient effects, resulting in a tightly-focused audio experience. The lack of surround or subwoofer activity is compensated by clear voice prioritization, delivering an immersive classroom atmosphere without the need for a wide dynamic range or music.
Extra: 56
The Blu-ray extras for 'The Class' are both insightful and exhaustive, featuring detailed audio and scene-specific commentaries by director Laurent Cantet and writer/actor François Bégaudeau, a 41-minute 'Making of The Class' documentary, a 30-minute 'Actors Workshop' featurette, 12 minutes of students' self portraits, and various HD trailers. While the behind-the-scenes content is extensive, some may find it a bit lengthy but overall, the extras successfully provide a deep dive into the film's production and the actors' experiences.
Movie: 81
"The Class," directed by Laurent Cantet and based on Francois Begaudeau’s semi-autobiographical novel, provides a gripping, documentary-like portrayal of the raw dynamics in an inner-city Parisian school, featuring impressive improvisation by non-professional actors, subtle direction, and realistic sound design, making it a compelling social commentary on France's education system.
Video: 56
"The Class" is presented in a widescreen 2.35:1 aspect ratio with an MPEG-4 AVC codec, encapsulating the high-definition video initially shot using three cameras and then transferred to 35mm film. This technique provides a consistently warm and filmic texture throughout the viewing experience. The image quality is clean and devoid of damage or imperfections, supported by a subtle yet noticeable grain that maintains an organic feel. The color palette eschews vibrancy for a more pastel-heavy and naturally pleasing aesthetic, fitting impeccably with the neutral interior of the school setting. The overall contrast is adequate, with black levels not plunging into the depths that Blu-ray can offer due to the film’s almost exclusive daytime scenes.
The resolution is praiseworthy, with fine textures clearly visible on clothing and varying skin tones rendered accurately. Facial close-ups are particularly impressive, revealing minute details such as veins and facial textures. However, quick changes in focus introduce occasional softness, an artifact of the handheld camera work rather than the transfer process itself. Wide-angle shots sometimes lack the refinement seen in closer shots, resulting in smoother lines and average definition.
The high-definition transfer demonstrates good clarity with notable but not razor-sharp detailing. The film's intentional cooler palette is consistent, though some scenes appear slightly softer, likely due to the inherent difficulty of manual focus adjustments during dynamic shooting setups. There are no overt signs of video anomalies or compression artifacts throughout the pristine encoding. Although the presentation lacks the impactful depth or three-dimensional pop characteristic of the highest tier of Blu-ray quality, it aligns well with the film's aesthetic tone. Subtitles are large and readable, with minimal intrusiveness into the image, despite stretching into the letterbox black bars at times. Overall, "The Class" offers a satisfactory visual experience that authentically represents its source material within high-definition parameters.
Audio: 48
"The Class" delivers an intriguing audio presentation through its uncommon French Dolby TrueHD 3.0 surround track, with an equally available English dubbed 3.0 track and additional English subtitles. As a classroom-based drama, the audio is predominantly dialogue-driven, utilizing the center channel to provide clear and commanding voices amidst the omnipresent classroom chatter. This endless flow of dialogue through the front channels is designed to immerse the audience in the chaotic environment seamlessly.
The soundstage, although limited in width, is skillfully utilized to emphasize the bustling schoolyard and classroom dynamics. Each voice maintains its clarity even during moments of overlapping conversations without any unwanted pops, hisses, or compression artifacts. Silence is also adeptly used to convey calm moments, sharply contrasting the constant noise. While ambient effects are sparse—limited to school bells and shifting furniture—the understated sound mix effectively bolsters a sense of authenticity.
Technical aspects such as bass presence are nearly nonexistent, aligning with the subdued nature of the film's audio dynamics. The absence of surrounds and subwoofer channels does not detract from the experience due to the track’s focus on clear, front-channel prioritization. This stripped-down approach avoids any extraneous sound theatrics, perfectly complementing the small-scale, human drama depicted in "The Class." Whether in the primary French TrueHD 3.0 or the English dubbed option, the audio mix executes its goals admirably, delivering an immersive yet nuanced auditory experience.
Extras: 56
The Blu-ray extras for "The Class" offer a substantial and insightful package, albeit entirely in standard definition, with English subtitles available throughout. While lacking a full-length commentary, alternative scene-specific commentaries provide significant value, featuring director Laurent Cantet and writer/actor François Bégaudeau dissecting key movie sequences. For those interested in the film's production, an exhaustive “Making of” featurette delves into the creative process and includes substantial behind-the-scenes footage. Additionally, the disc offers raw improvisation workshop footage and personalized self-portraits from the young actors. These extras collectively underscore the film's emphasis on realism and authenticity, and provide deeper context on both artistic and production fronts.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio and Video Scene Commentaries: Laurent Cantet and François Bégaudeau dissect three key scenes.
- Making of The Class: Detailed documentary covering comprehensive behind-the-scenes elements.
- Actors Workshop: Raw footage from improvisation workshops.
- Actors Self Portraits: Young actors’ personal self-portraits.
- Theatrical Trailer: High-definition trailer for the film.
- Trailers: Includes multiple HD trailers for other movies.
- BD-Live enabled: Access to additional HD trailers and interactive mini-games.
Movie: 81
"The Class" (2008), directed by Laurent Cantet and based on Francois Begaudeau's semi-autobiographical novel, presents a gripping and authentic portrayal of a Parisian high school. The narrative revolves around Francois Marin, a beleaguered teacher portrayed by Begaudeau himself, who navigates the turbulent waters of educating a diverse classroom in an underprivileged neighborhood. The students, played by real youths with no prior acting experience, deliver performances that highlight the raw, tumultuous atmosphere of the classroom. The film's unique structure embraces a nearly shapeless, micro-dramatic approach spread across a school year, eschewing conventional narrative arcs in favor of capturing the organic evolution of student-teacher interactions. This approach, combined with on-set improvisation, amplifies the film's realism and emotional depth.
Cantet's direction skillfully employs elements of documentary filmmaking, with handheld camera work and micro-zooms that navigate the confines of the classroom, creating a sense of immediacy and intimacy. The sound design further complements this realism, faithfully transitioning from the cacophony of the schoolyard to the subdued dialogues within the teachers' boardroom. These technical choices ensure an immersive experience that feels remarkably genuine.
At its core, "The Class" provides an incisive social commentary on contemporary French society and education. It explores themes of race, class, and adolescence with unflinching honesty, as seen in the character of Souleymane, whose narrative arc offers a glimpse into the systemic challenges faced by marginalized students. The film abstains from offering easy answers or idealistic resolutions, instead presenting a candid depiction of the complexities within the educational system. This refreshing honesty sets "The Class" apart from other inspirational teacher films, making it not just an engaging watch but also a profound reflection on the realities of modern education.
Total: 56
"The Class" presents a compelling narrative that brings the authentic energy of an inner-city classroom directly into your living room. Originally filmed in high definition and transferred to 35mm for a cinematic touch, the Blu-ray's video quality is admirable, featuring vibrant coloring and remarkable clarity. However, a certain softness occasionally permeates the visuals due to director Laurent Cantet’s quick-focus techniques used during dynamic classroom scenes. The audio track, utilising an uncompressed Dolby TrueHD format, is exclusive to three channels: left, right, and center. Despite lacking in immersive surround effects, the dialogue remains crystal clear, enhancing the film's engagement with its audience.
Complementing this technical presentation is a comprehensive collection of extras that delve into the film's production. Behind-the-scenes footage and insightful commentary richly expand the viewer’s understanding of "The Class". However, the absence of a feature commentary track and a retrospective documentary slightly dampen the extras package. Nonetheless, these omissions do not detract significantly from the overall experience.
Ultimately, the sum of perfectly harmonious elements in "The Class" elevates it beyond typical educational dramas. It resists simplistic narratives and instead offers a nuanced, intelligent observation of the complexities inherent within the educational system. With its solid video and audio presentation, along with substantial extras, "The Class" on Blu-ray is highly recommended for discerning viewers who value thought-provoking cinema. Whether you watch it for its filmmaking craft or its profound social commentary, this Blu-ray release promises an enriching experience.
avforums review by AVForumsRead review here
Video: 70
Overall this is a fine presentation which performs adequately with the source material but never reaches the level high definition excess, impressive depth or three dimensional pop which BD is capable...
Audio: 60
Without a shadow of a doubt this track will not wow or impress but what it does do it bolster the feeling of being in a living, breathing classroom where the many voices of the various students come through...
Extras: 60
There is, however, a commentary feature wherein director Laurent Cantet and writer/actor Francois Begaudeau dissect some of the scenes from the movie and provide in depth commentary on each....
Movie: 80
With improvisation encouraged on set, this movie really serves to accurately depict the organic and evolving relationship that a teacher has with his class, while also providing a social commentary on...
Total: 70
This is a worthwhile package and while the audio and video presentations will not make their way into the demo category, they none the less do a fine job with the source material....
Blu-ray.com review by Casey BroadwaterRead review here
Video: 80
There isn't a lot of opportunity for variety, considering the film is shot during the day and mostly in one classroom, but colors are saturated and strong, from the robin's egg blue of the back wall to...
Audio: 70
While some immersive ambience would've done a lot to put me in the classroom, so to speak, the front channels have a decent spread and are active with plenty of environmental sounds, like the bustle of...
Extras: 50
In a somewhat unusual way of doing a commentary, Cantet and B�gaudeau dissect three scenes from the film (The Imperfect of the Subjunctive, The Courtyard Dispute, and The Disciplinary Board) and, when...
Movie: 90
Though he's an optimist at heart�he really wants the kids to grow and learn, and believes whole-heartedly that they can�the students, especially Souleymane, force him into disciplinary ultimatums that...
Total: 80
The film makes very few missteps�a minor thread about a Chinese student with an illegal immigrant mother gets all but dropped near the end, but that's about it�and so I have no trouble putting The Class...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
The film boasts a warm color palette that does a lot to soften the overall image quality (this could also have something to do with the digital-to-35 mm conversion process), but I would in no way describe...
Audio: 60
There's never any muffled sound, everything is well prioritized, and the full-bodied life of the classroom comes across marvelously....
Extras: 60
This is a very strong, very long, very in-depth look at the making of 'The Class,' from its inception to its development, shooting, and then finally the hubbub surrounding its acceptance to Cannes and...
Movie: 80
Cantent's use of sound is also admirable - from the cacophony of the schoolyard to the quiet of the teachers' boardroom as they discuss their students, it works without ever being overt....
Total: 60
It's a deeply affecting film, unconcerned with pretentious flights of fancy or big emotional moments meant to wring sentimentality out of the situation....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 84
This video presentation offers little in the way of highly polished, razor sharp images but it seems to represent the film's elements well....
Audio: 72
The soundtrack is almost entirely dialogue driven and makes primary use of the center channel speaker with low level ambience spread to the left/right speakers....
Extras: 60
Audio and scene specific commentary by director Laurent Cantet and writer/actor Making of The Class - Documentary (41 minutes)...
Movie: 80
Taking on a class comprised of a melting pot of modern-day French society, he pushes and prods his pupils while striving to gain their respect....
Total: 74
Denon AVR 5308CI THX Ultra 2 Preamp/Video Processor Sherbourn Technologies - 7/200 Seven Channel Amplifier Philips TSU9400 Pro Series Touch Panel Remote Control Canton "Ergo" Series speakers Axiom Audio...
Director: Laurent Cantet
Actors: François Bégaudeau, Agame Malembo-Emene, Angélica Sancio
PlotFrançois Marin is a dedicated French teacher at a diverse inner-city middle school in Paris. He begins the school year with optimism, aiming to engage his multicultural class in meaningful education. The students, coming from various ethnic backgrounds, bring unique perspectives but also present significant challenges. Tensions slowly build as cultural conflicts and language barriers manifest, with some students resisting authority and questioning Marin's methods. Despite his efforts to maintain a constructive environment, misunderstandings and disrespectful behavior occasionally derail his attempts to foster mutual respect.
The evolving dynamics between Marin and his students reveal deeper issues within the educational system and society at large. Marin's patience is tested as he navigates sensitive topics and tries to inspire his students to rise above their circumstances. His genuine concern for their futures is palpable, but the obstacles he faces highlight the complexities of addressing social inequalities in a classroom setting. The interactions become a mirror of larger societal struggles, encapsulating the hopes, frustrations, and aspirations of both the teacher and his pupils. As the school year progresses, the narrative delves into the transformative power of education and the poignant reality of its limitations.
Writers: Laurent Cantet, Robin Campillo, François Bégaudeau
Release Date: 13 Mar 2009
Runtime: 128 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: France
Language: French, Bambara, Spanish