According to Greta Blu-ray Review
Score: 54
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
"According to Greta" offers excellent video quality and a good lossless soundtrack, but limited extras; its appeal hinges on viewer relatability to its teen-centric story.
Disc Release Date
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 68
Anchor Bay’s 1080p transfer of 'According to Greta' delivers sharp, richly detailed visuals with slightly over-saturated colors and realistic flesh tones. The image retains strong clarity and definition, though blacks can be a bit messy. The audio presentation is clear but lacks dynamic enhancement.
Audio: 57
The Blu-ray release of 'According to Greta' delivers a clear but unremarkable Dolby TrueHD 5.1 soundtrack, with precise dialogue and sparse use of surround channels, creating an adequate yet flat audio experience that neither enhances nor detracts from the film’s presentation.
Extra: 26
According to Greta's Blu-ray includes essential extras: a 19-minute behind-the-scenes feature exploring cast performances and crew contributions, along with 7 minutes of deleted and alternate scenes, and a 1.5-minute alternate ending, all presented in 1080i HD.
Movie: 51
According to Greta, a teen drama featuring Hilary Duff in a surprising role, presents a solidly acted yet predictably clichéd story of youthful rebellion and family dynamics. Despite its strong performances and nice character development, the film's generic script and conventional plot make it a passable but ultimately unremarkable entry in the coming-of-age genre.
Video: 68
The Blu-ray release of "According to Greta" delivers an impressive visual experience, showcasing a sharp, 1080p, 1.85:1-framed transfer that highlights the film's meticulous cinematography by Michael Lohmann. The clarity of fine detail stands out prominently—the textures of pavement, Greta's frayed hat, and minute elements around her grandparents' house are presented with exceptional sharpness and precision. The slight but intentional over-saturation of colors adds an authentic feel to the film, rendering flesh tones with remarkable accuracy and making the visuals pop with a palpable realism. Despite the slightly boosted contrast, each scene retains a sense of depth and precise definition, both in foreground and background elements.
However, there are some minor drawbacks. Though generally pleasing to the eye, flesh tones can occasionally take on a reddish hue, but not to an overly unsettling extent. Additionally, darker scenes sometimes suffer from blacks appearing a bit too bright and mildly undefined, detracting from the naturalism of nighttime sequences. Nonetheless, the transfer maintains a consistent layer of grain that enriches the film’s overall cinematic authenticity. Colors are vibrant yet controlled, ensuring that every shade is beautifully rendered on Blu-ray, contributing to a finely-tuned and visually sparkling presentation.
Audio: 57
The audio presentation of "According to Greta" on Blu-ray demonstrates an adequate but not particularly engaging Dolby TrueHD 5.1 lossless soundtrack. While the dialogue is clear and easy to follow, the overall dynamics lack the depth that would elevate the auditory experience. The surround speakers are sparingly utilized, primarily enhancing background atmospherics such as chirping birds and distant traffic, which subtly injects realism without being intrusive.
Despite its shortcomings in dynamic range, the soundtrack caters well to the film's steady pacing and subdued sound design. Music and sound effects are reproduced with acceptable precision, contributing a sufficient layer of audio clarity. However, the mix does not go beyond providing the essentials, and there are no remarkable moments where one would notice particularly immersive sound effects or impactful musical presentations. This restrained auditory approach makes for a competent yet unremarkable soundtrack that complements the film's focus without either enhancing or detracting from the viewing experience.
Extras: 26
The Blu-ray extras for "According to Greta" provide insightful content though relatively few in number. The highlight is "Greta: Behind the Scenes," a standard but well-rounded featurette that delves into the thematic elements of the movie, with particular focus on the performances of Hilary Duff and Ellen Burstyn as well as the crew's contributions. It includes the usual montage of interviews, film clips, and raw production footage, all presented in high-definition. Additionally, the disc offers a selection of deleted and alternate scenes and an alternate ending, each enriching viewer understanding of the film's narrative choices.
Extras included in this disc:
- Greta: Behind the Scenes: A comprehensive look at film themes and cast performances.
- Deleted and alternate scenes: Additional scenes not included in the theatrical release.
- Alternate Ending: An alternative conclusion to the film's story.
Movie: 51
"According to Greta" is a nuanced take on the coming-of-age genre, marked by strong character development and solid performances. Challenging typical teen-centric narratives associated with Hillary Duff, who plays Greta, the film transcends into a more mature character study. Greta, sent to her grandparents in New Jersey for the summer, starts off as a typical angst-ridden teen but gradually evolves into a character of depth and relatability. Duff delivers a surprisingly adept performance, transforming Greta from an irritatingly self-centered teenager to one evoking genuine empathy. Her interactions with her grandparents, played by the formidable Ellen Burstyn and Michael Murphy, provide some of the movie's best moments, showcasing a dynamic family grappling with unresolved issues.
The plot, while predictable, offers moments of comic relief and emotional resonance. Greta’s arc is punctuated by her job as a waitress and her relationship with Julie (Evan Ross), a reformed young man with a criminal past. While this romance feels somewhat contrived and fails to add substantial depth, it serves its purpose in Greta’s transformation. The portrayal of teenage rebellion and angst is familiar but effectively presented. The film’s well-developed characters and competent direction result in a narrative that, though not groundbreaking, holds the audience’s attention.
Despite its formulaic three-act structure and moments of predictability, the movie effectively addresses themes of teenage disillusionment, perseverance, and self-worth. Duff's performance shines brightly through her character's gradual maturation, assisted by Burstyn's seamless embodiment of her role. "According to Greta" may not offer much novelty to seasoned film enthusiasts, but it strikes a chord within its target audience, making it a serviceable exploration of the trials and tribulations of adolescence.
Total: 54
The film "According to Greta" occupies an intriguing niche, straddling a line between a teen drama and a cross-generational family story. While initially presenting itself as a “boohoohoo memem” drama-fest, it gradually reveals deeper themes of familial cohesion and self-discovery. The film, led by a suitably strong performance from Hillary Duff as a troubled teenager, holds particular resonance for younger viewers grappling with similar life issues. However, the somewhat formulaic nature of her character's journey may limit its appeal for other audiences.
Anchor Bay’s Blu-ray release of "According to Greta" boasts significant strengths in its visual presentation, offering superb 1080p picture quality that enhances the viewing experience. The audio quality, presented in a solid lossless format, complements the visual fidelity, ensuring that the technical aspects of the movie meet high standards. Nevertheless, the release falls short in the extras department, providing only a handful of filler features that do not add much value to the overall package.
In conclusion, ‘According to Greta’ finds itself in a liminal space — not exactly a groundbreaking film but certainly worthwhile for its standout video quality and competent lead performance. Whether you ultimately find it engaging or just passable hinges on your connection to the subject matter. Though it may not cater to everyone, it remains a recommendable watch for those who might find personal relevance in its themes. On balance, it is worth a rental for fans of the cast or viewers navigating similar challenges to those depicted in the film. Give Greta a spin for its visual merits.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 80
Fine detail is generally exceptional throughout; the rough texture of pavement, Greta's frayed polka dot hat, small cracks and chipped paint around her grandparents' house, and any number of other assorted...
Audio: 70
Also featuring sound dialogue reproduction, According to Greta sounds just fine within its limited confines, and listeners expecting nothing more than a soundtrack that offers the mere essentials should...
Extras: 20
Behind the Scenes (1080i, 18:39) is a basic piece that touches the surface of the film's themes, explores the performances of the cast with emphasis on Duff's and Burstyn's performances and careers, and...
Movie: 60
Coming-of-age movies are nothing new to the Hollywood scene, and According to Greta is another in the genre's long lineage, a serviceable all-around picture that might find favor with fans of the talent...
Total: 60
A film with purpose but also a narrow audience, According to Greta may find meaning with younger audiences coping with issues similar to those that have come to define the life of its lead character, but...
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 94
Even with the over-saturation, the film looked amazingly real and the flesh-tones were like looking a person next to you....
Audio: 82
Extras: 40
(HD) Greta: Behind the Scenes (19 min) (HD) Deleted and alternate scenes (HD) Alternate Ending...
Movie: 50
The feisty waitress is rude and tells the customers what to order and when, giving a bit of comic relief (she has never even tried fish)....
Total: 67
‘According to Greta’ is a movie that is floating in limbo; it appears as a teen ‘boohoohoo memem’ drama-fest and ends up being a cross generational story of a family finding its place together....
Director: Nancy Bardawil
Actors: Hilary Duff, Evan Ross, Michael Murphy
PlotGreta, a troubled and rebellious teenager, is sent to spend the summer with her grandparents in a small seaside town. As her relationship with her family is strained, she initially views the summer as a punishment. Greta's attitude is prickly and abrasive, masking her deeper pain and struggles, including a history of suicidal thoughts. Her grandparents are determined to help her turn her life around, but Greta meets their kindness with resistance and sarcasm.
Over time, Greta begins to form an unexpected bond with a local cook named Julie, who works at a nearby restaurant. Julie sees through Greta’s tough exterior and offers her both friendship and a job. As Greta spends more time with Julie and the humble townsfolk, she starts to open up and question her own behavior and choices. The previously rigid walls Greta built around herself start to crumble, offering glimpses of what might be a new beginning.
Writers: Michael Gilvary
Release Date: 11 Dec 2009
Runtime: 92 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States
Language: English