It's a Gift Blu-ray Review

The Blu-ray release of "It's a Gift," presented by Kino Lorber, features a 1080p transfer with an aspect ratio of 1.35:1, encoded using MPEG-4 AVC. The source material originates from an older Universal Pictures master, lacking comprehensive restoration to enhance its visual appeal. Close-ups are generally well-represented, but panoramic shots fall short in delivering depth and delineation. While the master avoids excessive digital manipulation, the visuals exhibit a telecine-like surface with lacking natural film grain. Although the grayscale is commendable, encompassing solid blacks and fine gradients, an enhanced master could further refine this aspect. Image stability is consistent, albeit with minor scratches and blemishes present.

Cinematographer Henry Sharp's original work on 35 mm film using spherical lenses, framed at 1.37:1 for its theatrical release, is acknowledged. This release claims to stem from a "2017 4K Scan," though specifics about the source elements remain undisclosed. Given the probable absence of the original nitrate negative, the transfer likely employs a dupe element of moderate condition. Despite retaining persistent scratches and damage marks, which include a dropped frame at 31:47, the decision to forgo aggressive digital cleanup preserves the cinematic texture, yielding an authentic filmic appearance.

This release may not represent the pinnacle of restoration but marks an improvement over previous DVD versions. The video exhibits adequate fine detail and maintains good contrast and black levels, reinforcing its cinematic integrity. The lack of significant restoration efforts is noticeable, yet it ensures the film’s classic essence remains intact, offering an engaging experience that adheres to the original visual intent. Note: This Blu-ray is Region-A locked, necessitating a compatible player for access.

The Blu-ray edition of "It's a Gift" features an English DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track, complemented by optional English SDH subtitles. Given the film's origins in the early 1930s, the audio presentation is quite commendable. The track maintains clarity and stability, showcasing a dynamic balance that is admirable for its era. Listeners should be aware of some minor pops, although they are not particularly intrusive and may go unnoticed by most viewers. Overall, the lack of noticeable distortions or dropouts ensures an engaging auditory experience.

As an early talkie, "It's a Gift" naturally comes with certain limitations in audio fidelity. The DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 Mono track offers a reasonably clean listen, albeit with some background noise characteristic of films from this period. While there is slightly more ambient hum than found in later Fields films, it remains within typical bounds for early sound films. Importantly, dialogue stands out clearly, which sustains viewer engagement despite the inherent noise challenges associated with this era of filmmaking.

In summary, while the audio track isn't perfect, it stands as a faithful representation of "It's a Gift's" historical context, allowing modern audiences to appreciate it without significant distractions.

The Blu-Ray release of "It's a Gift" offers a compelling collection of extras that provide rich historical insights and production stories. Highlighted by a detailed audio commentary from film historian James L. Neibaur, author of "The W.C. Fields Films," the extras deliver an informative dive into the 1934 film. Neibaur provides broader historical context by discussing other films released in the same year and shares biographical details about the actors and anecdotes from production. This includes enlightening points on ad-libbed lines, deleted scenes, and significant production challenges, like the condensed shooting schedule for the porch scene. Although at times Neibaur narrates on-screen events, his expertise significantly enriches the viewer's understanding of the film.

Extras included in this disc:

• Commentary: Exclusive audio commentary by James L. Neibaur exploring historical context, actor biographies, production anecdotes, and more.

"It's a Gift" on Blu-ray from Kino Lorber is a masterclass in comedic cinema courtesy of W.C. Fields under the direction of Norman Z. McLeod. This 1934 film remains a timeless comedy that showcases Fields' unique ability to thrive in absurd situations while delivering unforgettable lines. Despite the presence of other technically superior Fields films, "It's a Gift" stands out for its consistent and multidirectional humor, maintaining its comedic pace until the final frame. Kathleen Howard's portrayal of Amelia Bissonette, the domineering wife, is key to elevating Fields' performance, creating the perfect comedic backdrop through relentless interactions and sarcastic engagements. The dynamics between Mr. and Mrs. Bissonette form the backbone for Fields' comedic genius to shine.

The plot serves as a slender foundation designed purely to support an array of clever gags, driven by Fields’ dream of purchasing an orange farm in California—a whimsical prospect that fuels much of the storyline. The narrative is less about plot progression and more about exploring comic set pieces with methodical variations, supported by contributions from both credited and uncredited writers, leading to a film rich in visual and verbal wit.

Under McLeod’s confident direction, aided by cinematographer Henry Sharp, the film seamlessly combines organic performances with carefully choreographed scenes, although distinguishing directoral influence remains challenging. Known for creative independence, Fields’ input is palpable yet intricately intertwined with collaborative efforts, enhancing the natural yet meticulously executed comedy. "It's a Gift" is a pioneering cinematic piece where exceptional actors alongside Fields enrich each scene without overshadowing his iconic presence, making it a testament to early 20th-century comedic art.

"It's a Gift" stands as one of W.C. Fields’ most celebrated films, lauded for its seemingly casual brilliance and comedic mastery. The film is packed with humor that feels spontaneous and unforced, yet intricately planned to support Fields’ persona—a mix of whimsical aloofness and endearing clumsiness. The unique combination of choreographed gags and Fields’ effortless humor creates a viewing experience comparable to the greats like Chaplin or Lloyd. Despite Fields portraying his character with what appears to be natural ease, each scene showcases his ability to blend structured performance with an illusion of spontaneity. This film exudes a timeless charm, constantly engaging audiences with its quintessential comedic appeal.

Adding considerable value to the Blu-ray version is James L. Neibaur’s informative commentary track. As a recognized historian and author, Neibaur offers in-depth insights, providing historical context and biographical details. His commentary enhances the viewing experience by revealing production secrets that clarify Fields' comedic decisions and story structures. Astonishing tidbits, such as the significantly shortened duration of the porch scene's filming, unveil the dynamic challenges faced during production. Neibaur’s in-depth analysis enriches viewers’ appreciation of the film’s narrative nuances while acknowledging diverse perspectives on Fields' comedic style.

In essence, "It's a Gift" is an indispensable piece of cinematic history, imbued with Fields' unique comedic fingerprint. The Blu-ray edition not only revives its visual splendor but also guides enthusiasts through its historical and artistic facets. Fields' genius, manifest in his ability to blend meticulous choreography with apparent nonchalance, positions "It's a Gift" alongside iconic works of masters like Chaplin and Lloyd. This release is an essential acquisition for those who cherish classic comedy—HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.