Straight Shooting Blu-ray Review
Score: 77
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Kino Lorber’s Blu-ray of John Ford's 'Straight Shooting' delivers a stunning 4K restoration, top-notch filmmaking, and an exceptional new score.
Disc Release Date
Video: 76
Straight Shooting's Blu-ray from Kino Lorber presents an outstanding 1080p 4K restoration in a 1.33:1 aspect ratio. Despite minor wear and some lost segments, the transfer boasts superb detail, strong grayscale, and stable imaging, making this over-100-year-old silent film a revelatory experience.
Audio: 91
Featuring a pristine DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track, the audio presentation of 'Straight Shooting' excels in clarity and vitality, with Michael Gatt's lively piano and guitar score beautifully enhancing the film without overwhelming it. Optional English subtitles are provided.
Extra: 56
The Blu-ray extras for 'Straight Shooting' offer high-quality content with an engaging commentary by Joseph McBride, an insightful video essay by Tag Gallagher on John Ford's work, and a noteworthy, although incomplete, fragment of Ford's 1920 film 'Hitchin' Posts.'
Movie: 76
"Straight Shooting" is praised for John Ford's confident direction, dynamic editing, and the well-preserved 4K restoration that showcases George Scott's breathtaking cinematography. The score by Michael Gatt is lauded for its energy and appropriateness. Overall, it stands out as a foundational, action-packed western landmark.
Video: 76
The Blu-ray presentation of 'Straight Shooting' is a revelatory experience for enthusiasts of classic silent cinema. Released by Kino Lorber, this edition features a 1080p MPEG-4 AVC encoded high definition transfer in the original 1.33:1 full frame aspect ratio. Courtesy of an impressive 4K restoration by Universal Pictures, the black and white cinematography showcases remarkable clarity and detail unprecedented for a silent film of this age. The meticulous restoration process has preserved much of the film's visual integrity, bringing forth a level of detail that reveals intricate facial expressions and the simplistic yet effective set design with stunning precision.
Despite its age, the restored print of 'Straight Shooting' maintains overall high standards, although a few fine-line scratches and occasional wear are evident. These minor imperfections do not detract from the immersive viewing experience. The grayscale rendering is especially praiseworthy, delivering appreciable black levels and well-balanced whites throughout, while maintaining stability across the entire film. The newly generated title cards blend seamlessly with the original footage, contributing to the cohesive visual narrative. The high bit-rate encode utilized by Kino ensures that even with such historical material, the cinematic presentation remains robust and stable, free from distracting frame judder commonly seen in inferior silent film transfers.
Audio: 91
The Audio presentation of "Straight Shooting" on Blu-ray features an outstanding DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track. This audio track delivers exceptional clarity and crispness, ensuring that the viewer experiences every note of the score with remarkable vitality. As a silent era film enhanced with a new score, typical audio issues like hiss, crackle, and warp are non-existent here, making the track superb from start to finish. Each element of the score is intricately detailed, supporting the newly restored 4K visuals seamlessly.
Michael Gatt's lively score accompanies the presentation, employing just a piano and guitar to evoke tension, mood, and levity. The minimalist approach and use of period-appropriate instruments create an immersive atmosphere without overwhelming the visual narrative. The score’s simplicity is its strength, allowing it to blend beautifully with the on-screen action, much as it would have been experienced a century ago. The optional English subtitles further aid accessibility, ensuring a complete and thoroughly enjoyable viewing experience.
Extras: 56
The Blu-ray extras for "Straight Shooting" are a testament to quality over quantity, providing insightful and engaging supplements for fans of John Ford. The audio commentary by film historian Joseph McBride is not only informative but also captivates with its deep analysis of Ford's work. Film critic Tag Gallagher’s video essay, "Bull Scores a Touchdown," delivers a compelling exploration of the director's rich history and recurring themes, making it a must-watch for enthusiasts. The fragment of "Hitchin' Posts," preserved by the Library of Congress, offers a fleeting yet fascinating glimpse into Ford's early work, despite its incomplete status. film.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary by Joseph McBride: An engaging and informative analysis by the film historian.
- John Ford's Hitchin' Posts: Fragment from the 1920 production, preserved by the Library of Congress.
- Bull Scores a Touchdown: A video essay by film critic Tag Gallagher.
Movie: 76
John Ford's debut feature film, "Straight Shooting," is an exhilarating western that pushes the boundaries of early cinema. Set in a sparse, unforgiving landscape, the narrative revolves around Sweet Water Sims (George Berrell), a downtrodden farmer battling the conniving cattleman Thunder Flint (Duke R. Lee). Flint's ruthless tactics prompt conflict, culminating in the murder of Sims' son and the subsequent defection of Flint’s top henchman, Cheyenne Harry (Harry Carey). The story serves as a thrilling clash between cattlemen and farmers, punctuated with breathtaking shootouts and dramatic shifts.
Ford’s early directorial prowess shines through in this 4K restoration. The cinematography by George Scott is preserved brilliantly, showcasing creative framing and dynamic camera angles unexpectedly sophisticated for a film over a century old. The action sequences are imbued with a sense of immediacy due to the film's vigorous editing style. John Ford’s knack for fast-paced, quick-cut scenes keeps the audience engrossed, illustrating an early mastery of cinematic pacing.
Accompanying the film, Michael Gatt’s original score enlivens the narrative, enhancing its dramatic and action-packed moments. The musical composition is pivotal in maintaining the emotional tone throughout. "Straight Shooting" exemplifies Ford's seamless transition from short films to feature-length storytelling, highlighting his inventiveness and command over visual storytelling. The film's survival is particularly noteworthy given the unfortunate fate of many silent-era works, marking it as both a significant piece of film history and a testament to Ford’s indelible influence on the western genre.
Total: 77
Kino Lorber Studio Classics has outdone themselves with their Blu-ray release of John Ford's Straight Shooting. This silent western, an early masterpiece from Ford, has undergone a stunning 4K restoration courtesy of Universal Pictures. The new transfer enhances the film’s original visuals, bringing out intricate details and depth that were revolutionary at the time of its release. The geometric framing and innovative cuts employed by Ford are showcased in striking clarity, giving long-time fans and newcomers alike a fresh appreciation for this groundbreaking work.
Accompanying the visual restoration is an outstanding new score by Michael Gatt. The music perfectly complements the silent feature, heightening the action-packed sequences and enhancing the emotional beats without overshadowing Ford's cinematic vision. The Blu-ray edition also includes a selection of bonus features. While not extensive, they are thoughtfully curated and provide valuable insights into the film’s production and historical significance. It's a package that fans of the genre and serious collectors will find well worth their investment.
Conclusively, Straight Shooting is the action-packed silent western you are looking for. The filmmaking is top notch. The visuals are ahead of their time. The direction of Ford is confident and surprisingly daring for the period. The Blu-ray has a stunning 4K restoration and an outstanding score to accompany the silent-feature visuals. What a treat. Don't miss it.
Blu-ray.com review by Neil LumbardRead review here
Video: 90
Though the scan does showcase some thin scratches and the print occasionally demonstrates some unfortunate wear, the overall clarity of the restoration is simply outstanding....
Audio: 100
As a silent era feature with a new score, the film doesn't have any issues with hiss, crackle, and other warps....
Extras: 80
Inside of the package, the release features a printed booklet featuring an essay written by film critic Tag Gallagher....
Movie: 80
The music accompanying the film manages to give the visuals a real sense of energy that is dynamic and enthralling....
Total: 80
The Blu-ray has a stunning 4K restoration and an outstanding score to accompany the silent-feature visuals....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Throughout the film detail levels are strong allowing for intricate facial features and the simple but effective set design to come through....
Audio: 100
You didn't need a full orchestra to bring this to life, a simple set of one or two instruments like you would have heard 100 years ago is all that's needed....
Extras: 40
The video essay from Tag Gallagher is a lot of fun as it highlights all of the familiar setups and locations and direction John Ford brought to his films....
Movie: 80
Ford's keen eye for the camera, staging, and natural ability to craft a tall tale is what made him one of the best Hollywood directors....
Total: 80
This wasn't my first outing with John Ford's Straight Shooting - but this is easily the best condition release I've laid eyes on and it felt like I was seeing a lot of it for the first time....
Director: John Ford
Actors: Harry Carey, Duke R. Lee, George Berrell
PlotA notorious gunfighter, Cheyenne Harry, finds himself at a crossroads in a rough and tumble frontier town dominated by feuding factions. On one side, the ruthless cattle baron Flint cuts down anyone who stands in his way of free-ranging his herd, caring little for human life or legal boundaries. Opposing him are the homesteaders led by the plucky Joan Sims and her father, who struggle to protect their land from Flint's relentless aggression. As tensions escalate, Harry initially aligns with Flint’s gang for personal gain but begins to question his path after witnessing the innocent Sims family being trampled both figuratively and literally by injustice and violence.
Amidst the chaos, Harry’s interaction with the resilient Joan sparks a transformation in him. His hardened exterior starts to soften as he realizes the potential for redemption and the importance of standing up for what’s right. Torn between loyalty to Flint, the allure of easy money, and a growing sense of moral duty, Harry faces a series of challenging decisions that could reshape the town's future. As he gets entangled deeper into the conflict, he must navigate betrayal, frontier lawlessness, and his own redemption journey. The eventual path he chooses will have consequences not only for himself but for everyone caught in the brutal clash between cattlemen and homesteaders.
Writers: George Hively
Release Date: 27 Aug 1917
Runtime: 62 min
Rating: Passed
Country: United States
Language: English