Three Outlaw Samurai Blu-ray Review

Criterion's "Three Outlaw Samurai" Blu-ray presentation offers an impressive high-definition transfer. Utilizing a Spirit Datacine from a 35mm print struck from the original negative, the film is aptly presented in its original 2.35:1 aspect ratio with a 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 encode. The high-definition transfer demonstrates exemplary fluidity and depth in outdoor scenes, with a well-balanced grain structure across the majority of sequences. Black levels and contrast are meticulously calibrated, eliminating concerns of color and brightness inconsistencies. Notably, there are no significant artifacts such as banding or aliasing, and damage marks are virtually absent.

The meticulous restoration process included manual removal of dirt, debris, scratches, and warps using MTI's DRS and Pixel Farm's PFClean. For minimal grain and noise reduction, Image Systems' DVNR was employed sparingly, avoiding the oversmoothing commonly associated with digital noise reduction tools. As such, there are only a few instances where minor specks are visible on screen, which is commendable for a black & white film with predominantly dark settings. The occasional presence of subtle softness and an isolated instance of overly smoothed detail during a close-up shot are inherited limitations from the original materials rather than post-production shortcomings.

Overall, this Blu-ray release stands as a testament to Criterion’s commitment to quality, offering visuals that rival contemporaneous releases. While occasional jitter around the 19:35 mark and minor image softness can be noted, these do not significantly detract from the overall viewing experience. The level of detail and sharpness often approaches that expected from modern releases, making "Three Outlaw Samurai" an exemplary blueprint for high-definition transfers of mid-1960s films.

The Blu-ray release of "Three Outlaw Samurai" features a single audio track: Japanese LPCM 1.0, complemented by optional English subtitles that integrate seamlessly within the image frame. This monaural track, remastered at 24-bit from a 35mm optical soundtrack print, embodies the authentic experience of watching a vintage film. Although the dynamic amplitude is somewhat restricted, this is a foreseeable characteristic of historical recordings and not an indication of transfer defects. The remastering work executed using Pro Tools HD and AudioCube's integrated workstation ensures that all clicks, thumps, hiss, and hum have been meticulously removed, resulting in a pristine listening experience.

Despite its limited dynamic range, the track excels in delivering clean, stable dialogue that is consistently easy to follow. The action sequences retain a crispness that maintains engagement, even though they may lack the intense dynamism found in modern soundscapes. While high frequencies during musical segments might not have the same richness as contemporary films, the overall absence of audio distortion ensures an enjoyable auditory presentation. Although some may yearn for an expanded mix that utilizes more than just the front speakers, it’s undeniable that the mono track significantly amplifies the film's historical ambiance and complements its stylistic elements adeptly.

The Blu-ray extras for "Three Outlaw Samurai" offer valuable context and behind-the-scenes insight that will satisfy both enthusiasts and casual viewers. The original theatrical trailer, presented in high definition, highlights the stark difference between the un-remastered and meticulously restored film versions. This comparative look underscores Criterion's substantial restoration efforts. Another fascinating element is the introduction featuring the head of the film studio presenting a heirloom samurai sword to director Hideo Gosha, symbolizing their confidence in his direction. Additionally, the included illustrated booklet enriches the viewer’s experience with an insightful essay by noted film critic Bilge Ebiri, providing deeper understanding and appreciation of the film’s themes and historical background.

Extras included in this disc:

• Trailer: The original theatrical trailer for Three Outlaw Samurai in Japanese, with optional English subtitles.
• Booklet: An illustrated booklet featuring an essay by film critic Bilge Ebiri.

Hideo Gosha's 1964 film "Three Outlaw Samurai" arrives on Blu-ray courtesy of Criterion in a stellar transfer, accompanied only by its original theatrical trailer and an insightful essay by Bilge Ebiri. This directorial debut adapts the Japanese television series phenomenon of the same name into a cinematic gem that amalgamates elements of classic Westerns with robust period detail, all underscored by Toshiaki Tsushima's evocative score.

The narrative unfolds with the wandering samurai Shiba (Tetsuro Tanba) encountering three peasants who have kidnapped a magistrate's daughter in a desperate plea for lower taxes. As Shiba decides to aid them, two more masterless samurai, Sakura (Isamu Nagato) and Kikyo (Mikijiro Hira), are introduced, initially tasked with thwarting the peasants' efforts. However, alliances shift as the magistrate's daughter displays unexpected valor and compassion. Filmed with an acute sense of rhythm by cinematographer Tadashi Sakai, the film effectively balances action and drama, capturing both sweeping panoramas and intricate fight choreography. The cast delivers compelling performances, from Tanba's dignified stoicism to Nagato's portrayal of a flawed but ultimately noble warrior.

"Three Outlaw Samurai" is notable for its distinctly cynical outlook; the protagonist samurai must earn the viewer’s respect through their vulnerabilities and moral complexities. Unlike other jidaigeki films such as Kurosawa's "Seven Samurai" or "Yojimbo," this film eschews humor in favor of a grittier, more serious examination of feudal Japan's injustices. The restrained depiction of violence adds to its period authenticity, showing just enough to drive the tension without falling into gratuitous spectacle. This Blu-ray edition is essential for enthusiasts of samurai cinema, offering a quintessential blend of story, suspense, and well-executed action that holds up against genre classics.

"Three Outlaw Samurai" emerges as a remarkably assured debut, standing shoulder-to-shoulder with some of the finest samurai films that have ever reached Western shores. The film's dark and unyielding narrative, devoid of any glamorization of its characters, leaves a lasting impression. Tadashi Sakai’s cinematography is notably effective, providing a visually arresting experience that complements the film's tone and themes. One minor drawback is the lack of supplementary features; however, the transition of lesser-seen films to Blu-ray without them is preferable to their obscurity in Criterion's DVD-exclusive Eclipse Series.

Criterion's remastering prowess is evident in this release, transforming aged prints into pristine versions that are impressively sharp and clean with minimal DNR application. The original mono audio remains intact and flawlessly presented, highlighting the immersive sound design despite its single-channel limitation. The film itself is a gem, masterfully blending story, humor, action, tension, and rich character development. Criterion's expertise ensures that this powerful yet understated movie reaches a broader audience, adding another laudable title to their catalogue.

Conclusion "Three Outlaw Samurai" is a surprisingly strong and confident debut that easily rivals many of the best samurai films that have reached America during the years. I particularly liked how dark and uncompromising the film is as well as the fact that it does not glamorize its characters. Tadashi Sakai's lensing is also very effective. It would have been great to have some informative supplemental features, but I prefer to have these lesser seen films transition to Blu-ray without extras rather than have them appear on DVD via Criterion's Eclipse Series. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.