Natural Selection Blu-ray Review
Score: 58
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Natural Selection impresses with solid performances and an original story, though it rushes its finale; audio and video are commendable, extras are lacking.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 64
The AVC encoded 1080p HD transfer of 'Natural Selection' impresses with its crisp detail and vibrant colors, thanks to the RED HD camera. The 2.35:1 aspect ratio showcases clear skin tones and deep blacks, while daytime sequences offer generous illumination, enhancing the overall viewing experience.
Audio: 64
The 5.1 DTS-HD MA soundtrack delivers crisp, clear dialogue with strong center channel presence, effective ambience in the surrounds, and solid yet restrained music, capturing the Floridian mood without distortion or overbearing elements, making it perfect for this dialogue-driven film.
Extra: 26
Interviews with cast and crew provide insightful details on character development and the creative freedom on set, while the trailers offer a glimpse into 'Natural Selection' and other Cinema Guild titles. Engaging and informative, the extras enhance appreciation for the film’s production.
Movie: 76
Natural Selection, with Robbie Pickering's inventive direction, offers a refreshingly original spin on the road trip genre, driven by stellar performances from Rachael Harris and Matt O'Leary. The film deftly balances dark comedy and drama, exploring deep emotional themes through a fascinating and atypical narrative.
Video: 64
The AVC encoded presentation of "Natural Selection" delivers a crisp and detailed 1080p HD transfer in a 2.35:1 aspect ratio, leveraging the strengths of HD cinematography to create an immersive viewing experience. Fine details are prominently showcased, from the actors' skin textures to the intricate environments that build the film's Southern backdrop, filmed in Texas. The subdued yet expressive color palette enhances the mood, with natural skintones and costuming adding depth and variety. Shadow details can be somewhat thick during low-light scenes, but daylight sequences benefit from generous clarity and illumination, ensuring a well-rounded visual presentation.
The film's use of the RED HD camera contributes to its sharp and vibrant image quality. The colors maintain a lively presence, with rich blacks and natural skin tones enriching the overall aesthetic. Notably, as a road trip film, the numerous exterior and car-based scenes exhibit impressive depth and clarity, reinforcing the narrative's dynamic settings. There are no noticeable print defects, aliasing, halos, or edge enhancements, attesting to the meticulous transfer quality. Overall, this Blu-ray offers a visually satisfying experience that captures the film's raw and textured essence effectively.
Audio: 64
The 5.1 DTS-HD Master Audio sound mix for "Natural Selection" is exceptionally adept at balancing a range of auditory elements, delivering a robust and immersive experience. The audio presentation is tailored to capture the intricate instrumentation and clear, full-bodied sound across the soundstage. The front stage is well-defined, while the surround channels provide subtle yet effective ambiance, meticulously capturing environmental cues such as water movement and freeway bustle that set the Floridian mood.
Dialogue is a clear standout, anchored firmly to the center channel with impressive separation and depth, ensuring that each exchange is easily comprehensible. The audio mix supports emotional nuances, maintaining clarity and avoiding distortion even during accents and chaotic scenes. Ambient noises from various settings, like car interiors and public spaces, are distributed effectively through the surround channels, enriching the overall listening experience. While low-frequency effects are present, they are utilized sparingly given the film's intimate dramedy nature.
Overall, this DTS-HD 5.1 mix excels in presenting dialogue with precision and maintaining an excellent balance with ambient and musical elements. The soundtrack selections are crisp and full, providing significant support without overwhelming the narrative or performances. Despite its restrained use of bass, the mix delivers a rich auditory landscape that enhances the film's immersive qualities.
Extras: 26
The Blu-ray of "Natural Selection" delivers a compelling array of extras that provide an in-depth look into the film's production and creative process. Rachel Harris, Matt O'Leary, and crew members share their behind-the-scenes experiences and thoughts on the movie's thematic elements, spotlighting the collaborative spirit fostered by director Robbie Pickering. Each interview delves into character motivation, actor interactions, and the dynamic atmosphere on set. These features are both insightful and entertaining, enriching the viewer's appreciation of the film. The inclusion of theatrical trailers further enhances the package by contextualizing "Natural Selection" within Cinema Guild's broader catalog.
Extras included in this disc:
- Interview with Rachael Harris: Chats about her approach to the character, interaction with co-star O'Leary, and her thoughts on Pickering’s creativity.
- Interview with Matt O'Leary: Discusses interplay with Harris, creative freedom on set, and reaction to bruise make-up.
- Interview with Crew: Features Pickering’s humor and producers’ insights on the filmmaker's skills.
- Cast and Crew Interviews: In-depth discussions on character motivation and work experience.
- Trailers: Includes the film's trailer and others from Cinema Guild.
Movie: 76
"Natural Selection" stands out in the indie film realm, presenting a refreshing spin on the traditional road trip narrative, underpinned by Robbie Pickering's meticulous direction. This dark comedy effectively melds humor with emotional depth, tackling themes of devotion, isolation, and self-discovery. Through HD cinematography and an evocative soundtrack, the film’s technical aspects complement the raw performances of the cast, particularly Rachael Harris (Linda) and Matt O’Leary (Raymond). Harris, known for her roles in comedic films, delivers a surprising and award-worthy performance, embodying a sexually frustrated, devout wife grappling with revelations about her husband’s secret life. O'Leary's portrayal of Raymond, a disillusioned and chaotic character, is equally compelling.
Pickering's storytelling strength lies in his character development and exploration of unconventional relationships. The narrative kicks off with Raymond’s inventive prison escape, establishing the film's tone of sudden bursts of activity amidst moments of quiet reflection. Linda’s journey from Texas to Florida to locate Raymond—medical specimen turned prodigal son—is both heartwarming and heart-wrenching. Their dynamic evolves from mutual exploitation to a deeper understanding, with Raymond acting as the embodiment of Linda's unmet desires from her distant husband, Abe (John Diehl). The film cleverly critiques religious devotion, portraying Linda's unraveling beliefs with a nuanced approach that prevents caricature while providing significant character depth.
Supporting characters, such as Linda's pastor/brother-in-law Peter (Jon Gries), inject additional humor and conflict, though at times they divert from the primary narrative. Nevertheless, Peter’s misadventures highlight the absurdities of misunderstanding and the often-misguided search for meaning and connection. The film truly shines in its intimate moments—whether in motels or restaurants—where Linda and Raymond, through drunken confessions and shared vulnerabilities, develop a genuine bond. Overall, "Natural Selection" offers a compelling mix of tragic humor and heartfelt storytelling, supported by exceptional performances and thoughtful direction.
Total: 58
"Natural Selection" is a film that utilizes its unique narrative and strong character portrayals to deliver a compelling indie movie experience. Directed by first-time filmmaker Robbie Pickering, the film stands out with exceptional performances by Rachael Harris and Matt O'Leary, who bring depth and authenticity to their roles. The film manages to sustain a quirky, catastrophic mood that adds to its unique appeal, although it does rush through its concluding revelations, which could have benefited from more deliberation.
From a technical perspective, the Blu-Ray edition offers a solid audio and video presentation that enhances the viewing experience. The visual fidelity captures the film's detailed imagery nicely, while the audio mix maintains clarity and engagement throughout. However, the Blu-Ray extras are somewhat lacking, which might be disappointing for those who seek in-depth behind-the-scenes content or extended features.
In conclusion, "Natural Selection" is a noteworthy entry into the indie film genre, displaying a promising directorial debut from Pickering. While it may not be an expansive feature, it artfully crafts a satisfying narrative from familiar elements. The film's awards from various festivals are a testament to its quality, and despite its hurried final act, it remains an enjoyable watch that captures the essence of independent cinema.
Blu-ray.com review by Brian OrndorfRead review here
Video: 80
Shadow detail thickens during low-light sequences, muddying screen activity to a modest degree, though much of the movie is captured in daylight, which provides a generous illumination to ease clarity....
Audio: 80
The 5.1 DTS-HD MA sound mix marches forward with confidence, providing a wealth of soundtrack selections that register crisp and full, capturing the moment with precise instrumentation and a solid front...
Extras: 30
Interview with Matt O'Leary (3:48, SD) sits down with the actor to talk about his interplay with Harris, his feelings on the creative freedom of the set, and his reaction to the bruise make-up he wears...
Movie: 80
The interplay between the characters drives "Natural Selection," observing the pair getting to know each other through conversation and side adventures, though Raymond spend most of the midsection of the...
Total: 80
"Natural Selection" takes a few unexpected turns in its final act, rushing to a finale when the revelations demand a little more time to sink in....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
This is more or less a road trip film, so most of the film takes place in a car or outside, and the landscapes look great with wonderful depth....
Audio: 80
The ambient sounds of the car, wilderness, and people talking in public places get great use from the surrounds, giving the audio a bit of depth, in an otherwise shallow audio presentation....
Extras: 0
-Here are three separate standard interviews where actors Matt O'Leary, Rachael Harris, and director Robbie Pickering answer the same questions about the film....
Movie: 80
However, Linda is very sexually frustrated, as she hasn't been intimate with her husband for a long, long time now, the reason being that since Linda is unable to have a child, Abe believes they shouldn't...
Total: 60
The performances by O'Leary and Harris are phenomenal and the story is original and fun to watch....
Director: Robbie Pickering
Actors: Matt O'Leary, Rachael Harris, John Diehl
PlotLinda White is a devoted, yet unfulfilled, Christian housewife living in Texas. Her life takes an unexpected turn when she discovers that her deeply religious husband Abe has been secretly donating sperm to a fertility clinic for years and is now in a coma after suffering a stroke. Shocked and desperate for a sense of purpose, Linda decides to track down Abe’s biological offspring, hoping it will provide her with answers and a new sense of direction. Her quest leads her to Raymond, a troubled and estranged young man from Florida, whose lifestyle starkly contrasts with everything Linda holds dear.
As Linda attempts to bond with Raymond, she finds herself thrust into a world that challenges her rigid beliefs and sheltered existence. Their journey together becomes a transformative experience, forcing Linda to reevaluate her faith, identity, and what it truly means to be a mother. Simultaneously, Raymond grapples with his own issues, including his criminal past and strained family relationships. Along the way, both individuals embark on a path of self-discovery, facing numerous conflicts and obstacles that test their resolve and reshape their futures.
Writers: Robbie Pickering
Release Date: 16 Mar 2012
Runtime: 90 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English