The Silence of the Lambs Blu-ray Review
Score: 59
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
Upgrade worthwhile for insights & quality; classic film with adequate tech but room to improve.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 52
The Silence of the Lambs Blu-ray offers a natural, detailed visual upgrade with some grain and noise, enhancing its muted, character-driven mood.
Audio: 49
'Silence of the Lambs' Blu-ray presents a clear, dialogue-focused DTS-HD MA 5.1 audio with subtle ambient effects and Shore's score, lacking immersive surrounds but maintaining story-driven fidelity.
Extra: 71
The Silence of the Lambs' Blu-ray boasts a rich collection of extras, including documentaries, deleted scenes, and insights from cast and crew, offering a deep dive into its making and legacy.
Movie: 91
'The Silence of the Lambs' is a cinematic triumph, blending masterful performances with a chilling narrative, heralded as a must-see that transcends horror to become a beacon of filmmaking artistry.
Video: 52
"The Silence of the Lambs" receives a meticulous high-definition treatment on Blu-ray, presented in its original aspect ratio of 1.85:1 with MPEG-2 encoding at 1080p resolution. This release, while not reaching the pinnacle of contemporary visual clarity due to the inherent limitations of its source material, marks a significant upgrade from previous DVD versions. Throughout, there's a fine but perceptible grain that preserves the film's gritty aesthetic, particularly noticeable in early outdoor sequences and the dimly lit corridors of Quantico. Despite some instances of print damage and noise, especially in darker scenes and black backgrounds, the overall detail in facial close-ups and mid-scenes is enhanced, revealing subtleties previously lost or softened.
The color grading on this Blu-ray leans towards a warmer palette, with reds being more pronounced, an adjustment that enriches the film's visual mood and aids in the natural rendition of skin tones. However, this shift does slightly affect scenes with dominant red elements, causing minor color bleed. The increase in resolution brings forward more nuanced details, such as the textures in Lecter's cell, Starling's attire, and particularly in the unsettling meticulousness of Bill's grisly photographs. Although some outdoor and wide-angle shots demonstrate limited depth and sharpness compared to modern releases, the high definition upgrade substantially benefits darker sequences, offering clearer shadow details without veering into excessive enhancement.
While some fans may find selective noise reduction and the presence of grain during certain scenes objectionable, this Blu-ray edition represents the most authentic and visually compelling version of "The Silence of the Lambs" to date. It carefully balances between retaining the film's original atmospheric cinematography and providing a noticeable improvement in visual fidelity. Despite a few instances of softness and minor digital anomalies, the transfer does justice to this cinematic masterpiece, making it a worthy addition to any collection, even if it falls short of being considered reference quality.
Audio: 49
The audio presentation of “The Silence of the Lambs” on Blu-ray, featuring a 5.1 DTS-HD Master Audio soundtrack, focuses heavily on clarity and precision in dialogue reproduction, a critical aspect given the dialogue-driven nature of the film. The soundtrack’s fidelity shines with its sibilant-free quality, allowing for the distinct discernment of spoken words and subtle vocal inflections. Music, scored by Howard Shore, is reproduced mainly through the front three channels with the surrounds offering a mild ambient support. Although there's an acknowledgment of occasional subwoofer activity, providing a touch of low-end presence, the mix overall lacks significant bass depth and dynamic power. This results in an audio experience that, while reliable for its narrative-centric approach, does not fully explore or utilize the immersive potential offered by the 5.1 surround setup.
Surround use is infrequent and when engaged, often for atmospheric enhancement rather than aggressive effects placement. Notable scenes that could potentially benefit from a more encompassing surround presence, such as the mechanical and industrial sounds during Dr. Lecter’s scenes or the environmental ambience during FBI operations, remain primarily anchored to the front channels. This front-heavy mix delivers precise sound effects and vehicle movements across the soundstage with adequate clarity but misses opportunities to elevate the tension and immersion with broader spatial distribution. The score sneaks through the setup with grace but rarely takes center stage, maintaining the emphasis on dialogue and story rather than audio spectacle.
Despite being touted as a high-resolution audio upgrade, the DTS-HD MA 5.1 soundtrack struggles to mark a significant improvement over previous DVD releases. Listeners might find the presentation serviceable and competent in handling the film’s restrained sonic palette—where dialogue prominence and narrative delivery are paramount. However, the potential for a more dynamic and spatially engaging soundscape seems underexploited. Consequently, while the audio does its job commendably in supporting the storytelling without overwhelming or impressing with its technical prowess, it leaves a sense of missed opportunity to truly immerse the audience in the chilling atmosphere of “The Silence of the Lambs.”
Extras: 71
The Blu-ray release of "The Silence of the Lambs" is a comprehensive collection that will delight fans with its extensive array of extras, showcasing the depth and breadth of the making of this iconic film. Breaking the Silence, a standout picture-in-picture feature, merges text-based trivia with interviews, although it occasionally suffers from inactive segments. Understanding the Madness offers an enthralling glimpse into FBI profiling, enrichening the viewing experience with real-world context. The documentaries Inside the Labyrinth and Page to Screen delve deep into the film's creation and adaptation process, although notable absences in interviews are felt. Scoring the Silence provides intriguing insights into Howard Shore's musical contribution, enhancing appreciation for the film's score. Despite some content overlap and periods of inactivity, the extras effectively illuminate the film's production complexities and its enduring impact on audiences and the thriller genre.
Extras included in this disc:
- Breaking the Silence: A unique picture-in-picture commentary and trivia track.
- Understanding the Madness: An exploration of FBI profiling techniques.
- Inside the Labyrinth: Making of 'The Silence of the Lambs': A comprehensive look at the making of the film.
- The Silence of the Lambs: Page to Screen: A two-part documentary on adapting Harris' novel for the screen.
- Scoring the Silence: Insight into Howard Shore's musical choices.
- Original 1991 Making Of Featurette: A nostalgic look back at the film's original promotional material.
- Deleted Scenes: A collection of cut content from the film.
- Outtakes Reel: Light-hearted bloopers and goofs.
- Anthony Hopkins Phone Message: An audio clip from Hopkins intended as a novelty voicemail greeting.
- TV Spots: A compilation of television spots for the film.
- Theatrical and Teaser Trailers: Promotional trailers for the movie.
Movie: 91
"The Silence of the Lambs," a towering achievement in the crime thriller genre, stands as a cinematic marvel that redefines the intersection of horror and psychological drama. This film, praised for its intricate storytelling and exceptional character development, delves into the darkest corners of the human psyche with an intensity rarely seen on screen. The interaction between Clarice Starling and Dr. Hannibal Lecter serves as a central pillar, showcasing an unparalleled on-screen chemistry that elevates the narrative to unprecedented levels. Their complex relationship, rooted in psychological manipulation and mutual fascination, drives the plot forward, making the film not only a journey into the mind of a serial killer but also an exploration of human vulnerability and resilience. Despite some critiques pointing out the use of well-tread horror tropes, the film’s adept handling of these elements, combined with top-tier performances by Jodie Foster and Anthony Hopkins, transcends genre limitations, offering a richly layered and morally complex narrative.
Technically, "The Silence of the Lambs" is a masterclass in filmmaking, with Director Jonathan Demme and Cinematographer Tak Fujimoto providing a visually subdued yet emotionally charged palette that mirrors the narrative's grim reality. The attention to detail in the set design, particularly the stark contrast between Lecter's cell and Buffalo Bill's lair, underlines the thematic dichotomies at play—confinement vs. freedom, predator vs. prey, and civility vs. barbarism. Though the Blu-ray presentation boasts moments of exceptional clarity, particularly in close-ups that accentuate the actors' nuanced performances, both video and audio aspects occasionally lack the vibrancy expected from such a format, retaining a serviceable but somewhat muted quality that does not fully detract from the film’s overall impact.
In essence, "The Silence of the Lambs" is not merely a film but an experience that stays with viewers long after its conclusion. Its multilayered narrative, anchored by stellar performances and deft direction, offers more than just suspense—it invites a deep contemplation on the nature of evil and redemption. Despite some limitations in its Blu-ray presentation, the movie’s enduring appeal lies in its ability to engage, horrify, and ultimately move its audience, cementing its status as a necessary addition to any Blu-ray library and a landmark film that continues to resonate within popular culture.
Total: 59
The Blu-ray release of "The Silence of the Lambs" is a commendable effort, presenting one of cinema's most iconic films with a dedication that fans and newcomers will appreciate. The video quality, while not reaching the pinnacle of what current technology can offer, provides a clear improvement over previous DVD versions, effectively capturing the movie's atmospheric and intense visual style. However, it falls short of the transformative upgrade some might expect from Blu-ray. Audio, similarly, is adequate, offering a faithful reproduction of the film's soundscape but lacking the depth and clarity that would elevate the experience to new heights. The assortment of bonus materials is robust, offering a treasure trove of insights into the film's production, its cultural impact, and the intricacies of its memorable characters and performances, despite the notable absence of commentary tracks previously available on the Criterion DVD.
The equipment used for evaluating the release, from the JVC DLA-RS20 1080p High Definition Front Projector and Carada Precision Brilliant White screen to the array of players including Oppo 970HD and Sony Playstation 3, and complemented by high-end audio systems like the Marantz DV7001 Universal Disc Player and Denon AVR 5308CI Preamp, underscores a testing environment designed to rigorously assess the Blu-ray's audio and visual fidelity. This professional setup, augmented by leading-edge speakers and cooling components, ensures a comprehensive evaluation of the disc's performance across varying playback scenarios.
In conclusion, while "The Silence of the Lambs" Blu-ray release may not epitomize the ultimate in picture or sound quality, it stands as a worthwhile addition for those looking to experience the film in a home theater setting. The strength of the movie's narrative, combined with superior acting and direction, ensures its place in cinematic history. This release, backed by an expansive collection of extras, albeit with room for improvement in technical specifications and missing pieces from previous editions, is highly recommended for enthusiasts eager to dive deeper into this masterful film.
avforums review by AVForumsRead review here
Video: 70
With the focus of the movie lying firmly with character interaction and dialogue, the video presentation takes on a semi-monotonic muted appearance, that although noticeable, really suits the drab interiors...
Audio: 60
The industrial hissing and mechanical effects during our first introduction to Lecter's orderlies is one of these occasions, and while this sequence sounds good, instances of surround activity are far...
Extras: 80
the Madness” (16x9 HD 19min) - A feature on profiling techniques used by the FBI, with participation from retired FBI agents, and the manner in which they try and unravel the motivation and psyche of real...
Movie: 90
While both the video and audio presentations are very serviceable, they are unfortunately just that for the majority of the movie....
Total: 80
This release also contains a very strong and expansive extras package providing plenty of worthwhile insight into the creation of the movie and its characters, with a commentary track or two being the...
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 70
Blacks, aside from seeing a rather heavy level of noise, are dark but not always deep and inky, and there is occasionally a slight loss of fine detail in the darker corners of the image....
Audio: 70
Music and effects sound slightly rough around the edges and somewhat undefined; the tussle in the prison after Starling's first meeting with Lecter, for example, features a ruckus from the prisoners who...
Extras: 70
Inside the Labyrinth: Making of 'The Silence of the Lambs' (480p, 1:06:28) is a ten-year retrospective look back at the film, beginning by examining the time in which the film was made and America's obsession...
Movie: 100
Hopkins' performance is rare, one of the finest in the history of motion pictures, his a complete transformation not physically but rather emotionally and psychologically, the actor exuding all the qualities...
Total: 80
The film is a classic in the truest sense of the word, a picture that remains as intriguing, frightening, and compelling as ever thanks to its virtually flawless presentation, made possible by the contributions...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
'The Silence of the Lambs' is one of those films that has been released so many damn times on VHS, LaserDisc and DVD that it's problematic to try and make a Blu-ray comparison....
Audio: 60
Dialogue is still the most prominent aspect of the mix, and is generally well-balanced, though some lower speech still sounds flat....
Extras: 60
TV Special: "Silence of the Lambs: Page to Screen" (SD, 42 minutes) - Originally produced for the Bravo network, "Page to Screen" focuses on the development of 'Silence of the Lambs' from novel to screenplay,...
Movie: 80
But more than just a commercial, critical, and artistic success (as if that wasn't enough), 'The Silence of the Lambs' has fully entrenched itself in our shared pop culture consciousness -- it's story,...
Total: 60
I'm not sure this is the definitive version -- the tech specs could probably be improved, and I long for some of the extras found on the old Criterion DVD edition -- but for fans of the film (which is...
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 78
It is apparent that some noise reduction has been selectively applied which diminishes the presence of grain during some scenes....
Audio: 76
Extras: 80
The Silence of the lambs: Page to screen two-part documentary hosted by Peter Gallagher - 41 minutes A wealth of talent Preparation and authenticity Scoring the Silence - 16 minute featurette Original...
Movie: 100
As their relationship develops, Starling is forced to confront not only her own hidden demons but also an evil so powerful that she may not have the courage - or strength - to stop it!...
Total: 84
Marantz DV7001 Universal Disc Player Denon AVR 5308CI THX Ultra 2 Preamp/Video Processor B&K Reference 200.7 Series 2 seven Channel amplifier Philips TSU9400 Pro Series Touch Panel Remote Control Canton...
Director: Jonathan Demme
Actors: Jodie Foster, Anthony Hopkins, Scott Glenn
PlotClarice Starling, an ambitious FBI trainee haunted by her troubled childhood, is pulled from her training by Jack Crawford, head of the Bureau's Behavioral Science Unit. She is assigned to interview Dr. Hannibal Lecter, a brilliant psychiatrist and cannibalistic serial killer, in hopes of gaining insights into the psychology of a then-active serial killer nicknamed "Buffalo Bill." Bill is known for kidnapping and skinning his female victims; the FBI believes Lectilecte's understanding of the criminal mind might help them capture this elusive murderer.
As Starling engages Lecter in a series of intense conversations, he offers cryptic clues in exchange for personal details about her own past. Their complex interactions form a game of psychological cat and mouse. As Starling deciphers Lecter's vague hints and unravels the puzzle, she grows closer to predicting Buffalo Bill's next move and discovering his true identity. Meanwhile, Bill has captured a new victim, and the stakes become increasingly personal and desperate for Starling as she works against time to prevent another killing.
Writers: Thomas Harris, Ted Tally
Release Date: 14 Feb 1991
Runtime: 118 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English, Latin