Angels with Dirty Faces Blu-ray Review
Warner Archive Collection
Score: 84
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
Angels with Dirty Faces hits Blu-ray with a pristine 4K restoration and solid audio, showcasing Curtiz's direction and standout performances—must-own classic.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 90
Angels with Dirty Faces' 1080p Blu-ray from a 4K nitrate scan presents a top-tier transfer, with richly detailed film grain, impeccable grayscale, deep blacks, and crisply resolved visuals, far surpassing its DVD counterpart and offering an unrivaled home viewing experience.
Audio: 78
The DTS-HD 2.0 Master Audio mono mix offers a clean, well-restored presentation of classic soundscapes, balancing Max Steiner's dramatic score and effects with clarity. Despite minor age-related hiss and low volume issues, it surpasses older formats, maintaining the authentic 1930s auditory experience.
Extra: 78
The Blu-ray extras for "Angels with Dirty Faces" offer a rich collection, including a well-received Leonard Maltin introduction to the Warner Night at the Movies 1938 series. This set features restored cartoons, a Technicolor musical short, and extensive commentary from film historian Dana Polan, focusing on cinematic and social themes.
Movie: 91
Angels with Dirty Faces showcases Michael Curtiz's masterful direction and James Cagney's dynamite performance in a gripping crime drama, blending moral complexity with top-tier restoration on Blu-ray, all while being anchored by a tale of diverging paths and redemption set against New York's gritty backdrop.
Video: 90
The 1080p Blu-ray presentation of "Angels with Dirty Faces" exudes a fresh vitality that belies the film's age, thanks to a new HD master sourced from a 4K scan of the original nitrate camera negative. Warner Archive's meticulous effort delivers an enchanting and pristine transfer that highlights a silky smooth grain structure while capturing a wealth of fine detail, such as Cagney’s textured complexion and Sheridan’s captivating allure. The grayscale is executed with precision, producing rich blacks and crystalline whites that enrich the film's visual aesthetics. This transfer significantly surpasses previous iterations, including the 2005 DVD, by revealing stunning details and maintaining filmic integrity without visual anomalies.
The script takes full advantage of the AVC MPEG-4 codec, presented in a faithful 1.37:1 aspect ratio that stays true to the original cinematic experience. In this format, the transfer exposes sharp cinematography, particularly in scenes requiring fine grayscale differentiation and depth of field. Fluid motion and confident camera dynamics couple with the detailed imagery to furnish a lovely spatial sense between objects, enhancing visual immersion. Black levels demonstrate exceptional depth, showcasing shadows without losing detail, while maintaining an almost elegant quality throughout the duration of the film. Minor imperfections such as rare soft shots and fleeting specks do little to detract from the overall brilliance of the transfer.
Boasting beautiful resolution and contrast, "Angels with Dirty Faces" reaches its apogee in home video format through this masterful remastering effort. With no noticeable artifacts and consistent skin tones across scenes, the viewing experience is strikingly clean and immersive. This Blu-ray version will undoubtedly serve as the quintessential standard for fans and purists for years to come, encapsulating Warner Archive’s dedication to preserving classic cinema with unparalleled quality and care.
Audio: 78
The Blu Ray of "Angels with Dirty Faces" offers a DTS-HD 2.0 Master Audio mono mix, which provides a faithful reproduction of the original soundtrack, primarily occupying the left and right channels but configurable to the center with adjustments. While there are minor age-related issues like light hissing and a thin high end, the audio remains significantly cleaner and crisper than previous DVD releases, showcasing an impressively straightforward presentation for an 83-year-old film. Optional English (SDH) subtitles are available for the main feature, although the exclusion of subtitles for extras is a missed opportunity given their presence on earlier formats.
Intended to enhance the gritty ambiance of classic gangster films, the audio mix excels in delivering both high-impact and subtle sound effects, such as gunfire and ambient city noises, without distortion. A broad dynamic range presents Max Steiner's music score with clarity and integrity, although some early dialogue has a slightly muffled quality, making certain exchanges challenging to comprehend. Despite these isolated occurrences, there are no significant sync issues or noticeable audio drop-outs, ensuring a consistently engaging auditory experience.
The overall sound mix is commendable for its pristine quality, though it might modestly lack in volume. Dialogue is well-recorded, blending seamlessly with the music score and varied sound effects to achieve a near-perfect sonic amalgamation. Vocals and musical accompaniment offer commendable clarity and depth, albeit with the occasional hiss indicative of its period legacy. While modern expectations may highlight these vintage elements, they do not detract from the authentic listening experience characteristic of its 1930s cinematic origin.
Extras: 78
The Blu-ray release of "Angels with Dirty Faces" presents a comprehensive collection of high-quality extras, ported from the 2005 Warner Gangsters Collection DVD. A notable component is the "Warner Night at the Movies 1938," introduced by Leonard Maltin, which effectively recreates a full cinema experience with a trailer, newsreel, musical short, and a restored Looney Tunes cartoon. Dana Polan's audio commentary offers an insightful exploration into cinematic techniques and societal themes. The featurette "Whaddya Hear? Whaddya Say?" delivers a scholarly critique, focusing on the film’s production and cultural impact. Additionally, a vintage Lux Radio Theater broadcast featuring James Cagney and Pat O'Brien provides nostalgic value. The extensive material celebrates the film's historical significance within the gangster genre.
Extras included in this disc:
- Warner Night at the Movies 1938: A classic cinema experience introduction by Leonard Maltin.
- Audio Commentary: Insightful track by film historian Dana Polan.
- Whaddya Hear? Whaddya Say?: An analytical featurette with film historians.
- Lux Radio Theater: 1939 radio adaptation with the original cast.
- Theatrical Trailer: The film’s original HD preview.
Movie: 91
Angels with Dirty Faces, directed by Michael Curtiz, is an iconic entry in the Warner Bros. gangster film repertoire, fusing engaging character arcs with a gripping crime drama narrative. The film's raw focus is on the divergent lives of childhood friends Rocky Sullivan (James Cagney) and Jerry Connolly (Pat O’Brien), epitomizing the good versus bad dichotomy. Rocky's journey through the penal system leads to a life of crime, while Jerry becomes a priest, devoted to steering wayward youth away from corruption. In a locale as gritty as New York City’s Hell’s Kitchen, their reunion tests old allegiances amid moral complexities and criminal entanglements. The plot’s depth is fortified by John Wexley and Warren Duff’s tight screenplay, blossomed through Cagney’s magnetic screen presence, which earned him an Oscar nomination. His portrayal converses effortlessly with Pat O’Brien's steady Father Connolly, and their interplay castles the heart of this tense narrative.
In addition to its thematic richness, Angels with Dirty Faces is cinematically vibrant, showcasing Curtiz’s nuanced direction. The tension-laden climax is celebrated for its emotional sincerity and carefully constructed suspense using close-ups and shadow work—a testament to Curtiz's ability to wring deep emotion from scenes without lapsing into sentimentality. Sol Polito’s cinematography and Max Steiner’s musical score further cement the film's atmosphere of intensity and moral introspection. Although some character arcs, such as Ann Sheridan’s Laury Martin, receive less attention, the film remains an evocative study in ethical dilemmas amid systemic social issues. Additionally, Humphrey Bogart's role as a duplicitous lawyer provides a vexing adversary that adds layers to Rocky’s complex plot.
Overall, Angels with Dirty Faces stands as more than just a significant gangster film but also as an ardent narrative about the fragility of youth and the internal battles between right and wrong—a noteworthy cinematic piece whose layered storytelling and technical finesse continue to resonate.
Total: 84
Michael Curtiz's "Angels with Dirty Faces" stands as an enduring classic within the gangster film genre. Although the Hays Code imposed certain limitations on its narrative, particularly affecting its iconic finale, the film remains exceptionally entertaining. It boasts standout performances from stars like James Cagney, Pat O'Brien, and a burgeoning Humphrey Bogart. Warner Archive’s Blu-ray release of this cinematic gem is a pivotal offering that showcases both an exemplary audiovisual restoration and a slew of period-appropriate bonus features, making it a staple for both enthusiasts and newcomers.
Acclaimed for its raw storytelling and powerful directorial approach by Michael Curtiz, the film portrays a compelling, timeless narrative. This Blu-ray release is particularly remarkable due to its pristine presentation, thanks to a state-of-the-art HD master crafted from a 4K scan of the original nitrate camera negative. Accompanied by solid lossless audio and including all extras from the 2005 DVD edition, this release is indispensable to any collection of classic cinema. It offers an immersive viewing experience that captures the spirit and intensity of the Golden Age of Hollywood crime dramas.
In conclusion, the Warner Archive Blu-ray sets a new standard for presenting this seminal 1930s and 1940s gangster film. It provides a meticulously restored black and white transfer that delivers a cinematic quality worthy of its historical significance. Given its comprehensive extras and quality presentations, this release is strongly recommended to anyone interested in classic films, marking it as a must-have addition that celebrates the legacy of Hollywood’s crime film series while preserving its artistic essence.
Blu-ray.com review by Randy Miller IIIRead review here
Video: 100
But rather than split hairs, it's easy to recognized this is yet another top-tier transfer by the studio: one that reveals a stunning amount of fine detail, retains its natural film grain, and appears...
Audio: 80
It's a quality presentation that only suffers from a handful of age and source-related problems such as light hissing and a thin high end, yet still manages to sound a lot more clean and crisp than its...
Extras: 80
Warner Night at the Movies 1938 - This series of five era-specific extras is warmly introduced by celebrated film historian Leonard Maltin and includes a related promotional trailer, a newsreel, a music...
Movie: 80
It's a sappy swerve that, while not as jaw-droppingly awful as the one in San Francisco (also released during the Hays Code's infancy, just two years prior), still feels like further melodramatic mistreatment...
Total: 80
While this flattens a few otherwise memorable moments including the finale, it's a still a very entertaining picture with memorable performances by James Cagney, Pat O'Brien, up-and-coming Humphrey Bogart,...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Beautifully resolved grain produces a silky smooth picture that maintains the feel of celluloid, while excellent clarity, contrast, and grayscale highlight background details and enhance depth....
Audio: 80
Early in the film, some of the dialogue sounds a bit muffled, making a few exchanges difficult to comprehend (the young Rocky also garbles many of his lines, which doesn't help), but that's the only hiccup...
Extras: 60
(SD, 22 minutes) - A quintet of film historians, including the late, great Rudy Behlmer, discuss the film's production, censorship issues, and the evolution of the gangster picture, praise the brilliance...
Movie: 100
Not only does this crackling drama flaunt the tough, gritty, economical style that defined the studio during the 1930s, the cast and crew list comprises a veritable who's-who of Warner's top personnel....
Total: 80
Warner Archive honors this unforgettable classic with a brand new HD master struck from a 4K scan of the original nitrate camera negative, solid lossless audio, and all the bountiful extras from the 2005...
Home Theater Forum review by Matt HoughRead review here
Video: 100
Taken from the original camera negative, the imagery couldn’t be bettered with sharp, detailed cinematography and a grayscale that’s second to none in its depth of blacks and crispness of whites....
Audio: 90
All of the dialogue has been superbly recorded and has been mixed with Max Steiner’s background score and the multiple sound effects making for a near-perfect blend of sound elements....
Extras: 100
Warner Night at the Movies (SD): Leonard Maltin has a 4:20 introduction to a succession of shorts: a trailer for Boy Meets Girl, a newsreel, a musical short Out Where the Stars Begin, and the animated...
Movie: 100
Not only does Rocky know how to conduct himself with rats of his own stripe, but director Michael Curtiz directs a local basketball game in which the street gang (played by Dead End Kids Billy Halop, Bobby...
Total: 90
Michael Curtiz earned a well-deserved Best Director nomination for Angels with Dirty Faces (and ended up competing against himself for his direction of Four Daughters), one of the real landmarks in the...
Why So Blu? review by Brandon PetersRead review here
Video: 100
The image contains a terrific depth of field on display, really showing a good pushback and having a lovely sense of space between objects as accented with good confident camera movements....
Audio: 80
While a nice restoration and it sounds pretty great, it IS a product of its time and carries a little hiss with it and sounds of its era....
Extras: 80
Audio Commentaryby Dana PolanWarner Night at the Movies 1938Introduction by Leonard Maltin (SD, 4:20)...
Movie: 90
Angels with Dirty Faces is a pretty seminal film in everyone’s careers who works on it and one that influenced many a film and genres to come....
Total: 90
This is one of the most loaded Warner Archive Collection titles out there and a film more than worthy of being in anyone’s collection....
Director: Michael Curtiz
Actors: James Cagney, Pat O'Brien, Humphrey Bogart
PlotIn a gritty neighborhood, two childhood friends, Rocky Sullivan and Jerry Connolly, tread the line between morality and crime. Growing up in poverty, the duo finds themselves entangled in juvenile delinquency, leading to a fateful encounter with the law. Rocky, unable to outrun the police, is sent to reform school while Jerry escapes. Their paths diverge as they grow older; Rocky becomes a notorious gangster, while Jerry chooses a life of righteousness, becoming a priest. Despite their different lives, a bond remains, and they reconnect when Rocky returns to their old neighborhood after serving time in prison. Jerry has dedicated himself to keeping the local kids away from a life of crime, but Rocky’s return introduces temptation to their world.
Rocky finds himself embroiled in a power struggle with corrupt lawyer Jim Frazier, while also facing the gangsters he once allied with. The neighborhood kids, fascinated by Rocky’s criminal exploits and charisma, idolize him, much to Father Jerry’s dismay. As Jerry struggles to steer the boys away from crime, Rocky basks in their admiration, finding a sense of belonging and redemption in their adulation despite his misdeeds. Tensions rise as Jerry and Rocky confront each other over their influence on the youths, leading Rocky to make choices that ultimately force him to reevaluate his life and his impact on those around him. Both men are compelled to confront the consequences of their past actions as they seek to control their destinies within the community they once called home.
Writers: John Wexley, Warren Duff, Rowland Brown
Release Date: 26 Nov 1938
Runtime: 97 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United States
Language: English