Fort Massacre Blu-ray Review
Score: 42
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Fort Wilderness competently delivers engaging shoot-outs and character tension but falls short on cultural sensitivity and robust storytelling; Kino Lorber's Blu-ray offers a decent transfer with limited extras.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 47
The Blu Ray of 'Fort Massacre' showcases stunning outdoor vistas in its 2.43:1 and 2.35:1 AVC encoded 1080p transfer but suffers from inconsistent detail, color accuracy, and noticeable wear. Despite the immersive desert scenery, close-ups can appear blurry, and black levels lack depth, highlighting the need for comprehensive restoration.
Audio: 57
The 2.0 DTS-HD MA sound mix of 'Fort Massacre' offers a clear and natural audio experience with clean dialogue and realistic sound effects. It maintains midrange balance for dialogue and music, coming to life during action sequences with thunderous gunshots and atmospheric authenticity, while minor hiss remains unobtrusive.
Extra: 0
While the Blu-ray boasts high-definition trailers for 'Man of the West,' 'Man with the Gun,' and 'The Gunfight at Dodge City,' it lacks any supplementary material, offering minimal additional content for enthusiasts seeking in-depth extras.
Movie: 56
"Fort Massacre," directed by Joseph M. Newman, is a compact 80-minute western that delivers fast-paced action and intense drama, capturing the psychological unraveling of Sgt. Vinson amidst escalating tensions. Starring Joel McCrea, Forrest Tucker, and John Russell, it features strong performances and stunning New Mexico locales. Despite its ambitious moral undertones, the film excels as an engaging frontier survival tale.
Video: 47
The 1080p transfer of "Fort Massacre," presented in a 2.35:1 CinemaScope aspect ratio, showcases both the strengths and weaknesses inherent to the film's original shooting process. The outdoor southwestern vistas with expansive blue skies and rugged mountain ranges often appear vibrant, representing the film's setting well during scenes that rely heavily on natural light. However, minor fading in the AVC encoded image, combined with inconsistent color reproduction, leads to occasional drabness. Skin tones maintain a period-appropriate warmth, despite some occasional inaccuracies. The overall visual experience benefits from the film grain presence, suggesting minimal digital noise reduction (DNR) interference, though routine restoration appears absent.
Detail clarity fluctuates noticeably. Establishing shots capture significant detail from the vast desert terrain, yet mid-range and close-up shots reveal softness and an unfortunate blur, particularly around edges. The source print is marred by vertical scratches, debris, speckling, and signs of wear and tear, including mild flicker issues. Black levels are unstable; some scenes exhibit pleasing depth while others appear flat, lacking inky blacks. Edge enhancement has introduced some haloing and crunchy sharpness to the image, impacting overall visual integrity. Despite these shortcomings, the CinemaScope format’s capacity to convey broad landscapes helps mitigate some of these technical flaws, making "Fort Massacre" visually serviceable but clearly in need of a more rigorous restoration effort.
Audio: 57
The 2.0 DTS-HD MA audio track for "Fort Massacre" provides a consistent listening experience aligned with the production quality of its era. Dialogue clarity stands out, facilitating easy comprehension even during more intense scenes. While conflict sequences occasionally overwhelm the track, there are no significant distortions, maintaining overall integrity. The scoring, while present and supportive, lacks crispness, but adequately complements the film without being intrusive. Atmospheric elements are sufficiently thick but remain acceptable with minimal distraction from hiss.
The DTS-HD 2.0 audio presentation ensures a strong, clear track that preserves the natural quality crucial to the film's historical context. Dialogue remains clean and easily discernible throughout. The sound effects are robust, devoid of any artificial tinny or hollow sensations, providing an authentic sonic landscape. Although primarily occupying midrange frequencies, the track becomes notably dynamic during action sequences; gunshots resonate with pleasing depth and realism, enhanced by impactful channel movement. Despite occasional, negligible hiss, the audio mix effectively supports the film's ambiance and narrative.
Extras:
The Blu-ray release of "Fort Massacre" includes a modest but effective selection of extras, providing nostalgic glimpses into classic westerns through well-produced high-definition trailers. Despite the limited quantity, the content highlights the era's film craftsmanship, perfectly complementing the main feature. These trailers offer a valuable, concise historical context by presenting the stylistic and thematic elements prevalent in mid-20th century westerns. The absence of comprehensive supplementary material might disappoint some enthusiasts, but the included high-definition trailers are commendable, showcasing the visual remastering consistent with the main feature's quality.
Extras included in this disc:
- Man of the West Trailer: Brief promotional look.
- Man with the Gun Trailer: Highlights the film’s central themes.
- The Gunfight at Dodge City Trailer: Captures key moments vividly.
Movie: 56
1958's "Fort Massacre," directed by Joseph M. Newman, offers an intriguing portrayal of survival under extreme duress, cleverly masquerading as a western. Starring Joel McCrea, Forrest Tucker, and John Russell, the film captures the plight of U.S. Cavalry officers navigating environmental, indigenous, and internal struggles in the southwest. With a runtime of 80 minutes, the movie takes viewers on a relentless journey through escalating violence and paranoia, supported by well-orchestrated battle scenes and exhilarating horse chases amidst the breathtaking scenery of New Mexico. The potent performances underscore the mounting tension as soldiers question their commanding officer's motives and mental state, setting the stage for an intense exploration of leadership under fire.
"Fort Massacre" begins in medias res, immediately thrusting its audience into existing conflicts and unresolved tensions among the cavalry men. The plot unfolds around Sgt. Vinson (Joel McCrea), whose questionable leadership raises concerns among his men following a devastating Apache attack that obliterates half of C. Troop. While some soldiers believe Vinson is committed to their survival, others suspect he is driven by a personal vendetta against the Apache. This dichotomy fuels much of the drama, which is heightened by the necessity for water and subsequent strategic assaults that come with perilous consequences. Key scenes highlight the soldiers' reliance on Vinson's strategic decisions while they grapple with their own doubts and fears.
While "Fort Massacre" excels in its action sequences and rapidly evolving plot, its forays into heavier moral themes occasionally feel overbearing given the runtime constraints. The repeated moral deliberations between Pvt. Travis (John Russell) and Sgt. Vinson culminate in somewhat redundant dialogues that momentarily stall the narrative momentum. Nevertheless, the performances are commendable, particularly McCrea's portrayal of Vinson’s turbulent psyche and Russell's empathetic counterbalance. In essence, despite its occasional narrative overload, "Fort Massacre" stands as a robust entry in the western genre, marrying dramatic characterization with sharp action scenes to deliver an engaging cinematic experience.
Total: 42
"Fort Massacre" is a competent Western film from the late 1950s that, while perhaps not groundbreaking, delivers a solid dose of action and adventure. It features noteworthy shoot-outs and chases that keep the tension palpable, alongside moments of effective character development. The film is particularly commendable during its more intimate scenes, where trust and suspicion among characters are explored, lending depth to the narrative. However, the movie occasionally loses its momentum when broadening its scope to address Native American concerns. Being a product of its time, these portrayals are not kind but are somewhat tempered compared to other films of the era.
On the technical side, Kino Lorber's Blu-ray release of "Fort Massacre" provides a serviceable visual transfer, presenting the film in a quality that suits its age and pedigree. The audio track is strong, ensuring that the gunfire and dialogue maintain their intended impact. Unfortunately, the additional content is minimal—comprising merely a collection of trailers, which may disappoint those looking for more behind-the-scenes insights or historical context.
In conclusion, "Fort Massacre" proves to be an engaging, if not exceptional, Western that should entertain fans of the genre. Despite some inconsistencies and its dated cultural perspectives, the film's atmospheric tension and character-driven moments make it a worthwhile viewing. Kino Lorber's Blu-ray release may not offer much in terms of extras, but it provides a respectable presentation of this 1950s action/adventure staple.
Blu-ray.com review by Brian OrndorfRead review here
Video: 60
Hues during the AVC encoded image (2.43:1 aspect ratio, with the main titles windowboxed) presentation experience a small degree of fade, but color remains with exterior travel and costumes, while skintones...
Audio: 60
Scoring is insistent throughout, and while it's not crisp, it's present, supporting as intended....
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 60
1958's "Fort Massacre" is a survival movie that's disguised as a western, tracking the efforts of U.S. Cavalry officers as they experience environmental, native, and internal pressures during a trek through...
Total: 60
"Fort Wilderness" is competent filmmaking, but never robust, laboring to fill 80 minutes with incident, slowly losing its potency as the story widens to incorporate Native American concerns (being a picture...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
Film grain is present throughout so this transfer wasn't hit with any notable DNR or smoothing program, but the lack of finer details as well as some color issues highlight the fact that this film hasn't...
Audio: 80
When the action sequences kick in, the track springs to life as gunshots have a nice thunderous presence to them and the screams of pain and the galloping horses all sound realistic and provide for some...
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 60
This isn't to say that the film shouldn't have tried this approach to give the story a little more weight, it's just that by the time the film reaches the third conversation between Travis and Vinson about...
Total: 40
It offers up some great shoot-outs, a few decent bits of character development and maintains an entertaining level of tension throughout the film....
Director: Joseph M. Newman
Actors: Joel McCrea, Forrest Tucker, John Russell
PlotA small cavalry troop in the American Southwest, isolated and besieged by Apaches, finds themselves under the command of Sergeant Vinson after their leader is killed in an ambush. Vinson bears a deep-seated grudge against Native Americans, stemming from personal tragedy in his past, which influences his every decision. Determined to survive and reach the safety of Fort Crane, the sergeant pushes his men through arduous desert terrain and hostile territory, often making harsh and ruthless choices that begin to create tension within the ranks.
As they journey on, the troop encounters various challenges that test their endurance, loyalty, and moral compass. Vinson’s aggressive leadership style leads to internal conflicts and forces each soldier to confront their own principles and fears. The sergeant's obsession with vengeance risks not only the mission but also the lives of his men, raising doubts about his fitness to lead. Escalating pressures bring underlying conflicts to a boil, setting the stage for a dramatic confrontation that will determine the fate of all involved.
Writers: Martin Goldsmith
Release Date: 01 May 1958
Runtime: 80 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United States
Language: English