No Room to Die Blu-ray Review
Una Lunga fila di croci
Score: 32
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
An uninspired spaghetti western marred by disappointing DNR'd 1080i transfer and troubled lossy audio; a release best skipped unless you're a Django completist.
Disc Release Date
Video: 30
The Blu-ray of 'No Room to Die' suffers from a 1080i/AVC transfer plagued by digital noise reduction, combing artifacts, and telecine judder, resulting in a cloudy contrast and unnatural flesh tones. While the HD transfer lifts overall clarity and provides strong black levels, it falls short of providing a sharp, detailed presentation.
Audio: 30
The Blu Ray audio presentation of 'No Room to Die' falls short, with lossy Dolby Digital 2.0 tracks in both Italian and English plagued by hissing, harsh high-end for Italian, muddied mids for English, and limited mono soundtrack, making dialogue undefined despite clear delivery and effective musical score highlight.
Extra: 36
Two Bounty Killers for a Massacre (SD, 15 min): A retrospective by Manlio Gomarasca detailing the film's unique position in Garrone's oeuvre, highlighting its departure from the director's usual gothic tendencies.
Movie: 41
"Hanging for Django" is a misnamed spaghetti western with abundant, albeit shallow, violence and a predictable plot, failing to capture the essence of classic Django films. The Blu-ray offers decent visual flair but lacks depth in character development, making it a forgettable, routine entry in the genre.
Video: 30
The Blu-ray presentation of “No Room to Die” comes with noticeable technical flaws that detract from the viewing experience. Despite being digitally restored with a transfer from the original 35mm negative, the film is inexplicably presented in interlaced 1080i/AVC. This choice proves detrimental to a movie featuring quick pans and zooms, as the image frequently stutters and displays combing artifacts, which impact the overall fluidity of motion. Additionally, significant digital noise reduction (DNR) has been applied, erasing the natural film grain and resulting in overly smooth, waxy faces. While the print itself appears relatively clean with only minor scratches and specks, the high definition transfer does provide some clarity improvement over standard definition sources. Nonetheless, the focus is often soft, a common trait in spaghetti westerns, and the image would benefit from less aggressive DNR.
Moreover, the overall contrast is bland and flat, imparting a grayish and cloudy overtone that dulls the visual appeal. The color palette suffers as well, with sluggish and lifeless hues despite some primaries achieving decent boldness. Flesh tones are particularly problematic, appearing sickly and unnatural throughout the runtime. Instances of minor aliasing, jaggies, telecine judder, combing, and mild ghosting further plague the transfer. However, there are some positives; black levels are robust and offer good shadow detail. Unfortunately, these upsides do little to offset the otherwise underwhelming 2.35:1 image quality that leaves much to be desired for a truly enjoyable viewing experience.
Audio: 30
The audio presentation of "No Room to Die" on Blu Ray falls short of expectations, providing a dissatisfying listening experience. The disc offers two tracks, one in the original Italian and another in English, both presented in lossy Dolby Digital 2.0. The Italian track comes across as brighter and harsher with a high-end that can be quite grating, while the English mix suffers from muddied, mid-heavy sound lacking in clarity. Both tracks are marred by a persistent, distracting hiss, undermining their overall quality. Despite these setbacks, the score by Vasco Vassilli is a highlight, capturing the essence of the spaghetti western genre with its plaintive harmonica, strummed guitar, and piercing trumpet solos.
Unfortunately, the soundtrack feels limited and restrained, falling prey to several technical issues. ADR work and Foley effects are notably intrusive, likely a product of the original production rather than the transfer process. There's a noticeable echo in certain segments, possibly due to the dated codec. Dialogue in both tracks tends to be either overly hot or muddled, though it remains intelligible. Sound effects retain the expected tinny quality typical of the genre, but the narrow mid-range and lack of low-frequency effects result in an overall hollow and unfulfilling mix. Optional English subtitles are available, which adds some accessibility despite these considerable audio issues.
Extras: 36
The extras on the Blu-ray release of “No Room to Die” provide a captivating and thorough exploration of the film’s unique position within Paolo Garrone’s oeuvre. The documentary, “Two Bounty Killers for a Massacre,” is a standout feature, delivering insights from Manlio Gomarasca. Gomarasca, a noted curator of spaghetti western retrospectives, delves into how the film diverges from Garrone's more gothic tendencies found in his other works. This documentary is rich with anecdotal information about the film's production, cast, and Garrone's directorial nuances, making it a must-watch for both ardent fans and newcomers seeking to understand the distinctions within Garrone's repertoire.
Extras included in this disc:
- Two Bounty Killers for a Massacre: Manlio Gomarasca discusses the film's place within Garrone's body of work and its divergence from his gothic tendencies.
Movie: 41
The film "No Room to Die," misleadingly retitled as "Hanging for Django," is a spaghetti western that bears little connection to its purported namesake, Django, a character popularized by Franco Nero in Sergio Corbucci's 1966 classic. Directed by Sergio Garrone, this 1969 movie features Anthony Steffen as Brandon, a bounty hunter motivated by a sense of justice rather than greed, and William Berger as Everett Murdoch, a preacher-turned-assassin equipped with a seven-barreled shotgun. The central narrative revolves around these two figures combating a gang led by the genocidal Fargo (Riccardo Garrone), who exploits and murders Mexican immigrants.
While Garrone's film captures the violent and nihilistic tone characteristic of the genre, it falters in other departments. The plot, though engaging on paper, is poorly executed and riddled with continuity errors and tedious sequences. The character arcs lack depth, and potential friction between Brandon and Murdoch devolves into banal interactions. Additionally, action sequences fail to deliver the visceral impact expected of the genre, often feeling staged and bloodless.
Notably, the film's subplots and supporting characters are underutilized. Nicoletta Machiavelli's Maya, intended to add dramatic heft, ends up a peripheral figure with minimal impact on the main storyline. Despite moments that showcase Garrone’s capacity for genre-specific visual flair, "No Room to Die" ultimately underwhelms. It lacks the pacing and narrative coherence necessary to elevate it beyond a low-budget genre piece. While die-hard spaghetti western fans may appreciate familiar faces and thematic nods to genre staples, the film offers little for audiences seeking substantive storytelling or dynamic action.
Total: 32
Sergio Garrone's "No Room to Die" (also marketed as "Hanging for Django") offers a conventional but ultimately unremarkable entry into the Italian western genre. Despite its incidental association with the Django character, the film does not contribute any significant innovation to the spaghetti western canon. Visually, the film adheres to genre clichés, but lacks the flair and dynamism necessary to truly captivate an audience. Director Garrone appears to be borrowing heavily from other, more accomplished westerns, resulting in a derivative experience.
Raro Video's Blu-ray release is particularly underwhelming. The transfer is presented in 1080i, which is both technically inferior and outdated for a 2013 release. The digital noise reduction (DNR) applied heavily impacts the visual quality, stripping the film of its intended textures. Additionally, the audio tracks only come in lossy formats, which further detracts from aural clarity and immersion. This poor quality is surprising given the current technological standards and significantly hampers the overall viewing experience.
Given the resurgence of interest in the character after Tarantino's Django Unchained, it's not particularly surprising that we're seeing some of the unofficial Django sequels and knock-offs appear on Blu-ray. Hanging for Django is an odd choice, though. Not only does it not feature Django or a hanging, both contrary to its title, it's an all-around boring spaghetti western, drama-wise and visually. Yes, there's a gunfight in every other scene, but the action quickly becomes rote. Raro Video's Blu-ray release is equally disappointing, with a DNR'd 1080i transfer (yes, i as in interlaced, in 2013, for reasons inexplicable) and two lossy audio tracks with issues of their own. Unless you're some sort of Django completist, I wouldn't bother with this one.
Blu-ray.com review by Casey BroadwaterRead review here
Video: 50
There has also been a significant amount of digital noise reduction applied to the picture; film grain has been wiped outalthough, sometimes, you can still see the movement of the grain, but not the grain...
Audio: 50
Sounds effects are as tinny as you'd expect from the genre, and while the dialogue can be either too hot or too muddled depending on which track you go with, it's at least reasonably easy to understand...
Extras: 40
Video Documentary: Two Bounty Killers for a Massacre (SD, 14:33): Manlio Gomarascacurator of a retrospective of spaghetti westerns at the 2007 Venice Film Festivaldiscusses the film's place within Garrone's...
Movie: 50
Besides a badly edited cockfight, the pro-Mexico undercurrent, and a few weird, unnecessary sepia-toned flashbacks to Fargo's past, there's not much about Hanging for Django that stands out....
Total: 50
Given the resurgence of interest in the character after Tarantino's Django Unchained, it's not particularly surprising that we're seeing some of the unofficial Django sequels and knock-offs appear on Blu-ray....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 40
Fine object and textural details are also passable, yet much of the transfer seems to be the result of general dose of digital noise reduction, giving a few close-ups an ultra-smooth waxy appearance....
Audio: 40
The ADR work and Foley effects are severely distracting and although much of it can be chalked up as the fault of the original design and production, several moments come with a strange, just audible echo...
Extras: 0
Two Bounty Killers for a Massacre (SD, 15 min) — Short retrospect on how the film differs from Garrone's body of work, the production, cast, and a little on the director....
Movie: 40
They simply followed a similar plotline about greed, the cruelty of men, and the passionate fixation for revenge....
Total: 40
Although it passes as a decently entertaining entry in the genre, the film is sadly mundane, with directing that mostly feels like an imitation of better movies....
Director: Sergio Garrone
Actors: Anthony Steffen, William Berger, Nicoletta Machiavelli
PlotDavid, a relentless bounty hunter, teams up with the enigmatic and equally tough ranger Martinez to track down a ruthless gang of Mexican bandits terrorizing the borderlands. As they pursue the elusive outlaws, they uncover a diabolical human trafficking operation led by the cunning town boss, Fargo, who uses his criminal empire to smuggle illegal immigrants for profit. Along the way, David and Martinez face a maze of deception, perilous shootouts, and betrayals, each step bringing them closer to unraveling Fargo's sinister schemes. Their journey is marked by moral dilemmas and shifting alliances, forcing them to navigate the grey areas of justice and vengeance in a lawless land.
While David and Martinez attempt to dismantle Fargo's criminal network, they face resistance from local authorities compromised by corruption and fear. The tension escalates as they confront their own haunted pasts and limitations in the unforgiving landscape. As the plot thickens, with suspense mounting and danger lurking around every corner, David and Martinez's determination is put to the ultimate test. Their quest for justice and redemption becomes increasingly personal, and their resolve hardens into an all-consuming mission. The film weaves a narrative of gritty perseverance and high stakes, culminating in an explosive confrontation that questions the price of justice in an era of lawlessness.
Writers: Sergio Garrone
Release Date: 18 Apr 1969
Runtime: 97 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: Italy
Language: Italian, English