Ip Man 2 Blu-ray Review
Yip Man 2 Legend of the Grand Master | 葉問2 | Collector's Edition
Score: 66
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Stunning fight sequences, exceptional image quality, and involving sound design make Ip Man 2 a highly recommended sequel despite its formulaic approach.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 65
Ip Man 2's Blu-ray presentation showcases a stylized visual design with a pleasing balance of muted and vibrant colors. The 1080p AVC encoded transfer offers enhanced saturation, depth, and sharpness, bringing out fine details in objects, clothing, and faces. Despite minor aliasing issues, it is a markedly better experience compared to the first film.
Audio: 65
The Blu-ray of 'Ip Man 2' features Cantonese, Mandarin, and English DTS-HD 5.1 Master Audio tracks. The Cantonese track, default and preferred, delivers dynamic range, clear dialogue, precise soundstage imaging, and immersive surround experience. Despite occasional overcrowded soundfields during fight scenes, the audio fidelity and LFE are excellent, enhancing the home theater experience.
Extra: 66
The Blu-ray extras of 'Ip Man 2' offer an engaging array of featurettes including an HD 'Making Of' documentary, trailers, in-depth set explorations, a filming diary, deleted scenes, and extensive cast and crew interviews, delivering comprehensive insights into the production and characters.
Movie: 71
Ip Man 2 builds on its predecessor’s groundwork, delivering breathtaking fight sequences and impressive visual craftsmanship while portraying a highly fictionalized but engaging martial arts narrative. With an emphasis on stylistic combat and nationalist pride, it offers both accessibility and spectacle, despite some cartoonish elements and historical liberties.
Video: 65
The Blu-ray video presentation of "Ip Man 2" stands out with its distinctive stylized visual design that utilizes a limited but effective chromatic scheme. The color palette predominantly consists of shades of gray, black, and sepia, accentuated by occasional splashes of crimson and subtle secondary hues. The inclusion of warm golden accents helps to break up the monochromatic essence, providing a visually engaging experience. Fleshtones appear natural and maintain consistency, while uneven lighting and shading are prevalent. The contrast is noticeably boosted, emphasizing whites without losing detail in the gray tones. Resolution is impressive, with clean rendering that enhances depth and reveals intricate fine details in objects, clothing, and physical features. While blacks are not as inky as some might prefer, they remain punchy within mixed lighting conditions. A fine film grain adds texture without highlighting low-level digital noise, culminating in a satisfying high-definition video experience.
Compared to its predecessor, "Ip Man 2" on Blu-ray shows significant improvements in color robustness. The AVC encoded 1080p transfer in 2.35:1 provides a vibrant color palette that noticeably elevates the visual interest of the film. Flesh tones are more saturated, and the palette overall boasts richness with deeply drenched hues that are visually arresting. Sharpness and clarity are excellent, particularly in close-up shots where fine details become especially pronounced. However, the release does have some drawbacks, with consistent aliasing affecting elements such as palm fronds and geometric patterns on costumes and sets. Despite this minor issue, "Ip Man 2" offers a robust and visually satisfying presentation that significantly surpasses the first film's Blu-ray release.
Audio: 65
The Blu-ray release of "Ip Man 2" offers robust audio presentation with three DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 tracks: the original Cantonese, an additional Mandarin track, and an English dub. The default Cantonese track is highly recommended for its superb fidelity and clear synchronization with lip movements. This track beautifully integrates the soundtrack's elements, boasting extended dynamic range that delivers fight sequences with dramatic precision and energy. Kenji Kawai’s orchestrated music and various sound effects, from breaking objects to hand-to-hand combat, are reproduced with exceptional clarity. Imaging across the front soundstage is meticulously detailed, placing sounds with great precision.
While some may find the continuous underscore and sound effects in certain fight sequences slightly distracting, the overall mix remains engaging and immersive. The surround sound mix seamlessly integrates side and rear channels, fully engaging the listening position with spatial and localizable sound effects that immerse viewers in the heart of the action. Dialogue clarity is top-notch, though some instances of looping are noticeable. Low-frequency detail is clean, well-articulated, and authoritative, providing palpable impact during contact points. The blend of audible detail and room-energizing dynamics offers a thoroughly entertaining home theater experience without veering into excessive loudness or aggression.
Extras: 66
The Blu-ray release of "Ip Man 2" offers a comprehensive selection of bonus content that thoroughly enhances the viewing experience. The primary BD disc includes a detailed 'Making Of' featurette, providing insightful interviews with director Wilson Yip, Donnie Yen, and other principal cast members, who delve into character development and progression pertaining to the film's 1950s setting. Additionally, the disc features various trailers for the movie. The supplementary DVD contains most of the extras, such as an in-depth look at several key film sets including the community rooftop studio and a recreated Hong Kong fish market. Additional content includes a shooting diary, deleted scenes without initial audio, and extensive cast and crew interviews discussing diverse topics from character background to martial arts expertise.
Extras included in this disc:
Making Of Ip Man 2: Insightful featurette with interviews.
Trailers and Teaser: Various promotional clips.
Behind the Sets: Explore key film sets.
Shooting Diary: Long-form trailer with music and titles.
Deleted Scenes: Extended sequences with initial silent footage.
Cast/Crew Interviews: Extensive segments with principal cast and director.
Movie: 71
"Ip Man 2: Legend of the Grandmaster" continues the narrative of the legendary Wing Chun master, Ip Man, played by Donnie Yen, as he relocates to post-war Hong Kong. The film swiftly moves into a more mainstream martial arts genre than its predecessor, showcasing extravagant and meticulously choreographed fight sequences. One of the most captivating scenes involves Ip Man facing numerous kung fu masters on a precariously balanced restaurant table, highlighting not only the stunning martial arts prowess but also Wilson Yip’s visually striking directorial approach. The cinematography features dynamic, careening shots, employing creative angles that heighten the viewer’s engagement.
Set in an era of economic fragility, the film exhibits Ip Man's struggle to establish his martial arts academy amidst a complex network of rival schools already entrenched in Hong Kong. Sammo Hung’s portrayal of Hung Chun-nam, a competing master, adds depth to the narrative, although the development of their relationship lacks nuanced storytelling. Despite its compelling action sequences, the film's portrayal of the British characters leans towards exaggerated stereotypes, detracting from a balanced narrative. This nationalistic tone may resonate more with a native Chinese audience, though it limits the film’s international appeal.
Overall, "Ip Man 2" remains fundamentally accessible due to its phenomenal fight choreography. The film may not delve as deeply into character development as its predecessor and tends towards a more anecdotal, vignetted structure. However, Donnie Yen’s commanding presence and the expertly staged combat scenes ensure that it delivers a satisfying cinematic experience, appealing both to martial arts aficionados and mainstream audiences. Despite its more contrived elements, it holds significant cultural resonance and continues to uphold the legacy of its revered protagonist.
Total: 66
"Ip Man 2" on Blu-ray offers a captivating viewing experience, combining high-energy martial arts choreography with an engaging storyline. While the film aligns more towards formulaic narratives compared to its predecessor, this approach broadens its appeal, as evidenced by its remarkable box office success. Under Wilson Yip's direction, the fight sequences demonstrate meticulous choreography and dynamic camera work, elevating the action to an impressive level. Donnie Yen shines as the titular character, bringing charisma and depth to an otherwise fictionalized portrayal of the real Ip Man.
In terms of technical specifications, this Blu-ray release surpasses the first installment significantly, particularly regarding image quality and color fidelity. The high-definition presentation ensures a vivid and immersive visual experience, capturing every detail with clarity. The sound design is equally engaging, providing an enveloping auditory experience that accentuates the film's intense action sequences and atmospheric score. Both the video and audio elements come together to deliver a superior home theater experience.
Conclusion: Despite its formulaic narrative approach, "Ip Man 2" retains exceptional entertainment value, bolstered by stellar fight choreography and high-quality technical execution on Blu-ray. Wilson Yip's direction and Donnie Yen's performance elevate this film, making it a worthy addition to any martial arts aficionado's collection. This Blu-ray release is highly recommended for both its engaging content and outstanding technical presentation.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 80
While its AVC encoded 1080p image was often incredibly sharp (maybe too sharp, looking harshly digital at times), the entire film had a drab, colorless look that really started to bother me after a while,...
Audio: 80
One thing that is perhaps a bit bothersome in this film is the wrongheaded decision to crowd the soundfield with nonstop underscore as well as sound effects in a couple of fight sequences, something that...
Extras: 70
Shooting Diary (3:05) is really more of a long form trailer, with no dialogue, just music and onscreen titles (in Chinese translated into English via forced subtitles) and a series of scenes from the film....
Movie: 80
Despite the oddly truncated feeling ending of the first Ip Man, nothing could seriously detract from that film's excellent, if highly fictionalized, recreation of a tempestuous time in Chinese history....
Total: 80
The image quality, specifically the color, on this Blu-ray release is head and shoulders over the first Ip Man's Blu-ray release, and the sound design is also quite involving a lot of the time....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 86
There is a fine veneer of film grain that provides texture without emphasizing the low level digital noise that crops up from time to time....
Audio: 86
The sounds of breaking objects, hand to hand combat, and Kenji Kawai’s beautifully orchestrated music is reproduced with sparkling clarity....
Extras: 70
Disc 1: (Blu-ray) (HD) International, Theatrical, and Teaser trailers Making of documentary (1080i boxed in center of screen) – 17 minutes Disc 2: Bonus features DVD: Behind the sets The community Fish...
Movie: 70
But Ip must first prove himself to the corrupt cabal of Hong Kong martial arts masters— which he does, in one of the most amazing fight sequences ever committed to film, showcasing a dazzling variety of...
Total: 78
THX Ultra 2 Preamp/Video Processor Sherbourn Technologies - 7/200 Seven Channel Amplifier Oppo BDP-93 Universal Disc/3D capable Blu-ray Player (HDMI Audio/Video)...
Director: Wilson Yip
Actors: Donnie Yen, Xiaoming Huang, Sammo Kam-Bo Hung
PlotAfter escaping Japanese-occupied Foshan, the renowned martial artist relocates to British ruled Hong Kong in 1950. Struggling to establish a new life for his family, he decides to open a Wing Chun school to teach local students. However, he faces challenges from rival martial arts schools, particularly from the powerful Hung Ga master who controls the martial arts community. To gain the right to teach, he must pass a series of grueling tests set by other masters, demonstrating his skill and resilience in a series of intense fights that test both his physical prowess and philosophical beliefs.
Throughout his journey, he encounters various students and begins to build a reputation, attracting unwanted attention from corrupt British officials and local enforcers. Amidst growing tension between the local martial arts schools and the British authorities, the protagonist’s principles are put to the test. His dedication to martial arts and justice brings him into conflict with not only local adversaries but also powerful foreign foes. As tensions escalate, he must uphold the honor of his martial art while navigating treacherous political landscapes and standing against oppression. The challenges he faces solidify his legacy as a symbol of resistance and integrity.
Writers: Tai-Lee Chan, Hiu-Yan Choi, David Tadman
Release Date: 29 Apr 2010
Runtime: 108 min
Rating: R
Country: Hong Kong, China
Language: Cantonese, Chinese, English