The Bat Blu-ray Review
Roland West's The Bat
Score: 66
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
"The Bat," with its solid technical merits and stunning Blu-ray transfer, offers a thrilling mix of suspense and devilish comedy, perfect for a chilling evening.
Disc Release Date
Video: 71
The Blu-ray of 'The Bat' showcases an engaging 1080p transfer with a commendable 2K restoration from archival 35mm sources. Despite some minor age-related wear, the preservation of fine details and solid contrast effectively captures the film's shadowy cinematography and production values.
Audio: 76
The Bat's audio presentation, featuring an LPCM 2.0 track, showcases Ben Model's energetic theater organ score that expertly balances suspense and comedy, offering a rich, immersive experience reminiscent of classic movie houses, with flawless fidelity and effective incidental sound effects.
Extra: 36
Engaging extras feature 'Roland West: Cinematic Man of Mystery,' an informative career tribute utilizing HD clarity in under 9 minutes, while the comedic short 'A Fraternity Mixup' offers 19 minutes of lively, madcap hijinks with satisfactory visual quality despite some roughness, complementing the main feature.
Movie: 76
The 1926 silent film 'The Bat,' now available on a Blu-ray from a 2K restoration, combines elements of classic thriller, horror, crime, and comedy with expressive art direction by William Cameron Menzies and cinematography by Arthur Edeson. This version surpasses its remakes with moody atmosphere, suspenseful storytelling, and hidden identity twists while retaining its historical influence.
Video: 71
The Blu-ray presentation of "The Bat" by Undercrank Productions offers a meticulously crafted AVC encoded 1080p transfer in the 1.32:1 aspect ratio, sourced from a 35mm nitrate print provided by Boise State University. The film benefits from a new 2K restoration, which effectively balances maintaining the film's authentic, archival appearance with noticeable enhancements in clarity. Viewers will appreciate the compelling detail levels—especially apparent in the intricate costumes and the infamous Bat emblematic throughout the film.
Despite these notable improvements, some age-related issues are unavoidable in older films like "The Bat." These include recurrent scratches and occasional severe emulsion damage, particularly noticeable in the last half hour. However, these flaws do not overshadow the overall restoration achievement. The shadowy cinematography is well-supported by the generally solid contrast, enhancing the tension that defines the visual narrative.
The restoration stands out for its competent cleanup work, striking a balance between preserving the film's historical integrity and providing a visually engaging experience. Although nicks and speckles are visible, such imperfections are minor when considering the alternative softness often plaguing de-grained silent film transfers. Silent film enthusiasts will find this presentation remarkable, with fine details preserved to capture the production's rich values and atmospheric costume design, delivering an extraordinary visual experience for both connoisseurs and casual viewers alike.
Audio: 76
The Blu-ray audio presentation of "The Bat" features an LPCM 2.0 track, showcasing a remarkable theater organ score by Ben Model. This original composition masterfully draws on the ambiance of classic movie houses, delivering a rich, vibrant sound that complements both the suspenseful and comedic elements of the film. The theater organ-based score is energetic and, despite the eerie nature of the property, often anchored in major keys, adding an unexpected levity to the viewing experience.
Model's score ensures that the film captivates the audience without overstaying its sonic welcome, maintaining a consistently clear and immersive audio quality. While there are no dialogues, the score itself is complemented by subtle yet effective incidental sound effects, such as door buzzers, that enhance key scenes seamlessly. The fidelity of the audio is commendable, with no noticeable issues reported, ensuring that the musical accompaniment keeps viewers engaged throughout.
Extras: 36
The Blu-Ray extras for "The Bat" offer a compact yet insightful look into cinematic history. The highlight, Roland West: Cinematic Man of Mystery, serves as a concise biographical piece exploring West's intriguing career, providing an engaging overview filled with intriguing details. Accompanied by the 1926 comedic short A Fraternity Mixup, these extras combine to deliver an enjoyable viewing experience. This silent two-reeler captures the spirit of classic college antics in under twenty minutes, balancing madcap comedy with a hint of visual humor. Despite some rougher edges compared to the main feature, the restoration quality is commendable, making it a visually appealing addition that enhances the overall value of the disc.
Extras included in this disc:
- Roland West: Cinematic Man of Mystery: A brief but informative overview of West's career.
- A Fraternity Mixup: A lively 1926 comedic short featuring college hijinks.
Movie: 76
Roland West’s 1926 "The Bat" delivers a beautifully atmospheric experience, merging elements of thriller, horror, crime, and comedy. Known as an enduring classic of American stage and screen, this adaptation captures the essence of Mary Roberts Rinehart's play, widely regarded as the origin of multiple film iterations, including the better-known 1959 version starring Vincent Price. Set against the backdrop of moody ambiances and subterranean dread, West's film marks the genesis of what would become a cinematic tradition engulfed in shadowy suspense. Under the artistic helm of William Cameron Menzies and the cinematographic prowess of Arthur Edeson and Gregg Toland, this film elevates its narrative with stunning chiaroscuro visuals, crafting a hauntingly beautiful tapestry that complements its tense narrative.
Central to this film’s success is its ability to blend genres, threading suspense and comedy seamlessly through its brisk 86-minute runtime. The performances by Louise Fazenda and Jewel Carmen inject a high dose of energy and serve as the narrative anchors, enlivening the plot dynamics with humor and intrigue reminiscent of their later 1959 counterparts. This rendition further distinguishes itself through well-concealed plot twists surrounding the titular villain, enhancing the suspenseful atmosphere considerably compared to its successors. For enthusiasts keen on exploring cinematic history or appreciating early storytelling techniques in film noirs, this is an defining piece of work.
"The Bat," preserved by Undercrank Productions through a commendable 2K restoration from UCLA Film & Television Archive’s elements, is not solely remarkable for its narrative refinement. It is also acknowledged for its cultural significance, offering fun nods to Batman’s origins—a curious delight for any comic book aficionado. As such, this Blu-ray release elegantly packages a treasured film relic that embodies timeless thrill and eeriness, inviting viewers to rediscover an iconic piece of cinema heritage with revitalized brilliance.
Total: 66
Roland West’s "The Bat" receives an impressive Blu-ray release, capturing the suspense and intrigue of nearly a century-old classic. This adaptation of Mary Roberts Rinehart's play is arguably unparalleled, boasting a formidable cast that masterfully blends suspense with darkly comedic elements. The film’s transfer showcases stunning visual restoration, ensuring it remains a standout in the horror and mystery genres. The newly composed original score enriches the atmospheric tension, making this release a must-have for connoisseurs of classic cinematography.
The Blu-ray’s technical merits are commendable, with the crisp image quality highlighting the meticulous restoration efforts. Undercrank Productions has delivered a product that enhances the viewer's experience, offering an engaging auditory and visual journey. Accompanied by intriguing supplementary materials, this edition serves both new viewers and devoted fans. It immerses the audience in a chilling narrative that is as relevant today as when it was first conceived, making it an invaluable addition to any film library.
In conclusion, "The Bat" is a cinematic gem that stands the test of time, offering thrills and plot twists reminiscent of influence on later works like Agatha Christie's "The Mousetrap." The film plays on Hitchcockian suspense tactics long before their time. As recommended, gather your coziest blankets for a gripping experience enhanced by its outstanding technical presentation and engaging supplements.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 70
This is by and large a rather appealing restoration, though those used to the kinds of age related wear and tear frequently seen in these older, often uncurated, elements may be better prepared for some...
Audio: 80
This one is theater organ based, and has that big "fluffy" sound so redolent of old time movie houses....
Extras: 40
Roland West: Cinematic Man of Mystery (HD; 8:44) is a brief but interesting overview of West's career....
Movie: 80
This is in every way an early Old Dark House mystery (and in fact that James Whale film probably owes at least some of its moody ambience to The Bat as well), and for anyone familiar with the general outlines...
Total: 80
Vis a vis finding out whom The Bat is, and without posting an overt spoiler, I'll only say my hunch is the venerable Dame Agatha Christie may have been aware of this property and kinda sorta stole an idea...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
There are still the expected nicks, scratches, and speckles to be seen, but you can tell a lot of cleanup work was managed for this restoration while also preserving the natural film-like appearance....
Audio: 80
Adding to the suspense but also playing to the comedy elements, this original piece sounds lovely in LPCM 2.0 making sure the film has your full attention without sounding canned....
Extras: 40
The comedy short runs a swift twenty minutes and is a hoot all on its own lending more to classic madcap comedy than visual simple hijinks....
Movie: 80
While The Bat himself bears little resemblance to the superhero (outside of the rooftop stalking scenes), the moody mansion serves as a perfect Wayne Manor surrogate, the cops look pretty familiar to the...
Total: 80
Roland West’s The Bat is just one of several adaptations of Reinhart’s stylish whodunit play, but I’d argue it’s probably the best of the lot....
Director: Roland West
Actors: George Beranger, Charles Herzinger, Emily Fitzroy
PlotSet against the backdrop of a sprawling mansion, a notorious criminal known only as "The Bat" strikes terror into the hearts of the residents. The elusive thief and master of disguise has been terrorizing the city with a series of daring robberies and is rumored to be targeting a hidden stash of stolen loot at the mansion. Cornelia Van Gorder, the primary resident of the eerie home, finds herself ensnared in the mystery when a detective arrives, warning her of The Bat's next likely target. As night falls and a storm brews, Van Gorder decides to take matters into her own hands, determined to protect her home and uncover the truth behind this criminal enigma.
As tension mounts and darkness envelopes the mansion, a mix of eccentric characters gathers, each with their own secrets and motives. The detective, a suspicious gardener, and an inquisitive maid add to the growing web of intrigue. Strange occurrences unfold, and shadows flit across the walls, intensifying the air of danger and suspicion. Clues surface, masked figures appear, and false leads abound. Hidden passages within the mansion reveal dark pasts, while cryptic messages hint at concealed intentions. Amidst this growing turmoil, Van Gorder must deftly navigate through deception and danger to solve the puzzle before terror strikes once more. As alliances shift and truths emerge, suspense teeters on a knife’s edge.
Writers: Avery Hopwood, Julien Josephson, George Marion Jr.
Release Date: 21 Mar 1926
Runtime: 86 min
Rating: N/A
Country: United States
Language: English