Beach Red Blu-ray Review
Score: 70
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Beach Red stands as a haunting, masterfully underrated gem, its powerful visuals captured in Kino Lorber's strong HD transfer, though lacking meaningful bonus features.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 77
Presented at 1080p in its original 1.85:1 aspect ratio, Beach Red’s Blu-ray from Kino Lorber, despite using an older MGM master with some softness and minor archival deterioration, offers a fine organic visual quality, superior color balance, and stability, making it a substantial upgrade over the previous DVD.
Audio: 86
Beach Red's Blu-ray features an English DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track with clear, sharp dialogue and a dynamic action audio landscape, though it may benefit from a Dolby Atmos remaster for added depth. The audio presentation, free of distortions, is likely the best rendition on home video.
Extra: 23
The Extras on the 'Beach Red' Blu-ray are a well-rounded collection, featuring the original vintage trailer and an array of bonus KLSC trailers for classic war films, offering a nostalgic and comprehensive look at the genre.
Movie: 83
Beach Red's Blu-ray release by Kino Lorber preserves Cornel Wilde's unflinching depiction of WWII's brutality with impressive archival footage integration, despite some deterioration. The film’s narrative mirrors classics like Saving Private Ryan, showcasing the raw human struggle and psychological toll of war through masterful editing and poignant flashbacks.
Video: 77
Presented in its original aspect ratio of 1.85:1 and encoded with MPEG-4 AVC, the Blu-ray release of "Beach Red" by Kino Lorber offers a commendable 1080p transfer. Sourced from an older master provided by MGM, the video quality exhibits a slight softness but retains a fine organic appearance. Notably, there is no intrusive digital alteration, allowing the visuals to maintain a natural quality. While the archival footage shows some deterioration, it integrates well with the primary content, demonstrating impressive blending despite occasional drops in density.
The film exhibits consistent overall image stability, with no significant age-related imperfections. The color palette is well-balanced and stable, although there is room for improved saturation. Instances of scratches, dirt, and tears are minimal and do not detract significantly from the viewing experience. Given these factors, this release surpasses the previous MGM DVD version, representing perhaps the best quality of "Beach Red" available on home video to date.
Audio: 86
The Blu-ray release of "Beach Red" features a sole audio track: English DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0, with optional English SDH subtitles. The overall audio presentation is commendable, maintaining the integrity of the original mono soundtrack. Dialogue is consistently sharp and clear, and the sound mix is well-balanced, ensuring no one element overpowers another. The sparse musical score is presented clearly, without intrusion on spoken elements or action sequences. Notably, there are minimal instances of distortion, crackling, popping, or hissing, ensuring an immersive yet unobtrusive listening experience.
Action sequences convey dynamic intensity, particularly during the assault on the island, capturing the chaos of explosions, machine gun fire, and the physical exertions of soldiers in combat. These elements produce a rich auditory landscape that makes for a compelling viewing experience. Additionally, moments of silence are used effectively to heighten tension, especially in scenes set within the jungle's thick, obscuring foliage. The melancholy quality of the title song, performed by Jean Wallace, provides a poignant contrast to the intense action sequences it accompanies.
While the presentation is strong, there is room for potential improvement through modern remastering tools. Some sequences might benefit from enhanced depth and impact, suggesting a fresh Dolby Atmos track could elevate the auditory experience further. Nonetheless, this release represents likely the best home video audio rendition to date, improving upon previous iterations significantly.
Extras: 23
The Blu-Ray of "Beach Red" includes a well-curated selection of extras that provides significant context and enhances the viewing experience of this classic war film. The content comprises both vintage and contemporary perspectives, enriching the audience's understanding of the film's historical and cinematic significance. Among the standout features are archival trailers that capture the film's original promotional strategies, juxtaposed with bonus trailers highlighting contemporaneous war-focused cinema. This balanced mix of materials ensures that viewers are not only entertained but also educated, making for a comprehensive and immersive experience. The extras are a valuable addition for cinephiles and historians alike.
Extras included in this disc:
- Trailer: Vintage trailer for "Beach Red." In English, not subtitled.
- Theatrical Trailer: Official theatrical trailer for "Beach Red."
- Bonus KLSC Trailers: Promotional trailers for films including "Wake Island," "Fixed Bayonets!," "Beachhead," "Attack," "Time Limit," "Run Silent, Run Deep," "The Train," "The Secret Invasion," and "Ambush Bay."
Movie: 83
Cornel Wilde’s "Beach Red" is an evocative portrayal of World War II, focusing on American soldiers' efforts to seize a Japanese-held island. The film opens with a visceral invasion sequence, where archival footage seamlessly integrated with original content heightens the realism. This meticulous blend underscores the sheer brutality of war and has drawn comparisons to Steven Spielberg's depiction of D-Day in "Saving Private Ryan." The stark authenticity is further enhanced through detailed soundscapes of battle cries and explosions, bringing to life the chaotic desperation faced by soldiers. Wilde's portrayal does not glamorize war but instead showcases soldiers as real human beings, deeply affected by their harrowing experiences.
The narrative progresses as Captain MacDonald, played by Cornel Wilde, and Sergeant Honeywell, portrayed by Rip Torn, lead their men through relentless combat, from beachfront skirmishes to jungle warfare. Voiceovers and flashbacks offer glimpses into soldiers' past lives, adding depth to their characters and emphasizing their shared humanity. Wilde's direction poignantly illustrates that war is not only a fight against the enemy but also a struggle with nature and oneself. Notably, the film provides a nuanced depiction of Japanese soldiers, presenting them as complex adversaries rather than faceless enemies.
"Beach Red" stands out for its unflinching depiction of war's savagery and its impact on those involved. Shot in the Philippines, Wilde ensures the location serves as an oppressive force rather than an exotic backdrop. The compelling performances of Wilde's cast, including Rip Torn and Jaime Sánchez, are matched by the technical prowess behind the scenes. Despite relying on stock footage due to contemporary military constraints, the integration is masterfully restored and executed, demonstrating Wilde's capability to craft an extraordinary narrative from seemingly straightforward material. This film remains a powerful testament to the real horrors of war and its lasting psychological scars.
Total: 70
"Beach Red," directed by Cornel Wilde, is an underappreciated gem from the 1960s that brought a fresh and nuanced perspective to the war film genre. Distinctively portraying soldiers as complex individuals, it broke away from the conventional depiction of unwavering heroes and one-dimensional villains. Instead, it offered a more authentic and humanizing view of men in battle, addressing their noble and flawed instincts alike. This layered portrayal remains an affecting and haunting exploration of the human condition during wartime.
The Blu-ray release by Kino Lorber significantly enhances the visual quality of this classic. Sourced from an old yet well-preserved organic master by MGM, the high-definition transfer breathes new life into Wilde's remarkable cinematography. Although the release does not boast a wealth of special features, the pristine presentation alone makes it a worthy upgrade from previous DVD editions. The lack of supplementary material is a minor drawback, yet it does not diminish the overall value and significance of this release.
In conclusion, everything that later acclaimed war films such as "Saving Private Ryan" and "The Thin Red Line" accomplished, "Beach Red" did first and often better. Without the aid of digital effects, Wilde managed to craft an intense and visually powerful narrative. "Beach Red" stands as a genuine masterpiece that deserves a spot among the pantheon of cinema’s greatest works. Despite its initial lackluster reception, this film's re-release is a long-overdue celebration of its artistry and enduring impact. Highly recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 80
Its main strength is the lack of any compromising digital work, which is why all of the visuals have a fine organic appearance....
Audio: 90
However, I have to speculate that modern remastering tools will likely be able to produce some improvements if the audio is fully redone....
Extras: 10
...
Movie: 100
On the other hand, anyone expecting to see just a series of big and small battles where the soldiers always behave like heroes and strike down their enemies will be quite surprised because this isn't how...
Total: 80
If you do some very careful deconstruction work, eventually you will conclude that Saving Private Ryan and The Thin Red Line for instance are simply inferior variations on key themes from Beach Red, which...
The Digital Bits review by Dennis SeulingRead review here
Video: 95
Audio: 90
The assault on the island features explosions, machine gun and rifle fire, huge splashes of water as mortar fire hits, men’s utterances as they are shot, and the sound of men crawling through sand....
Extras: 40
Movie: 80
We see the men at various stages of the assault—on board the ship carrying them within miles of the target, the landing craft braving the waves as it approaches the island, the fighting on the beach, and...
Total: 76
Later films, such as The Thin Red Line and Saving Private Ryan, have dealt with soldiers in often gripping ways, but Beach Red was the first to portray men in war as diverse human beings with both noble...
Home Theater Forum review by t1g3r5fanRead review here
Video: 80
Film grain, fine details and color palette are all mostly given a faithful representation here; there are noticeable shifts in quality present due to the condition of the stock footage used in some parts...
Audio: 100
Overall, this is likely the best the movie will ever sound on home video and represents another improvement over the MGM DVD....
Extras: 30
Theatrical Trailer (3:08) Bonus KLSC Trailers – Wake Island, Fixed Bayonets!, Beachhead, Attack, Time Limit, Run Silent, Run Deep, The Train, The Secret Invasion & Ambush Bay...
Movie: 80
Following this, Wilde – who also contributed to the script under the pseudonym “Jefferson Pascal” – also delves into the minds of the men fighting the conflict through a combined use of voiceovers and...
Total: 70
Kino’s Blu-ray release should help in that appraisal with a strong HD transfer of the movie (despite being largely bare bones in the special features department); overall, it’s worth upgrading from the...
Director: Cornel Wilde
Actors: Cornel Wilde, Rip Torn, Burr DeBenning
PlotA rugged and intense portrayal of war, the story centers on a platoon of American soldiers during World War II as they prepare for and execute an amphibious assault on a Japanese-held island in the Pacific. The narrative delves deeply into the soldiers' psychological states, highlighting their pre-battle anxieties, personal reflections, and memories of their lives back home. This emotive exploration creates a poignant juxtaposition against the brutal reality of combat. Throughout their perilous mission, the soldiers face heavily fortified enemy positions, booby traps, and relentless opposition from a determined Japanese force.
As the battle intensifies, the story provides insight into the Japanese perspective, showing their preparation and determination to defend their territory. This dual viewpoint underscores the shared human element amidst the horrors of war. The unfolding events relentlessly test the soldiers' endurance, resilience, and camaraderie as they navigate through chaotic and deadly encounters. Subplots touching on elements of leadership, sacrifice, and moral ambiguity add depth to the central theme of survival in an unforgiving environment.
Writers: Clint Johnston, Don Peters, Cornel Wilde
Release Date: 18 Nov 1967
Runtime: 105 min
Rating: GP
Country: United States
Language: English, Japanese