Topaz 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 69
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Topaz suffers from poor pacing, unconvincing lead, making it a niche Hitchcock film best for devoted fans.
Disc Release Date
True 4K
HDR10
DTS-HD MA
Video: 75
Topaz's 4K restoration impresses with vibrant colors, deep blacks, natural skin tones, and superb detail, with some grain and minor issues, greatly enhancing its visual appeal.
Audio: 70
Topaz's DTS-HD mono track excels in clarity, balancing crisp dialogue and dynamic score while authentically presenting its era's sound, despite some age-related coarseness.
Extra: 61
The 4K re-release of 'Topaz' keeps its special features: a Leonard Maltin appreciation, alternate endings, storyboards, production stills, and the trailer, detailed in the original release.
Movie: 56
Universal's UHD release of Hitchcock's 'Topaz' (1969) offers enhanced visuals/audio, part of a set with 4 other films. Despite its historical intrigue, 'Topaz' remains a Hitchcock anomaly, criticized for its disconnected plot and lack of signature style.
Video: 75
The 4K UHD Blu-ray presentation of "Topaz," Alfred Hitchcock's less-celebrated espionage thriller, emerges as an illustrative showcase of how superior restoration and transfer techniques can breathe new life into classic films. The true 4K scan elevates the movie's visual narrative, delivering razor-sharp details and a vibrant color palette that enhances the film's aesthetic appeal. Despite its storyline drawing mixed reviews, this release shines in video quality, boasting a hefty grain structure that remains faithful to its cinematic roots while introducing a clarity and depth previously unseen. The color rendition is particularly noteworthy; the HDR enhancement significantly deepens the contrast, creating a visually arresting image that is at times almost too bold but invariably compelling. Natural skin tones provide a consistent reference point amidst the vivid display of primaries, with scenes involving sunsets, clothing, and flags benefiting most from the enhanced saturation and brightness.
The meticulous attention to detail is evident in both the bustling street scenes and the more intimate interiors like the porcelain shop and the production facility, where every element, from facial features to environmental textures, stands out with remarkable clarity. This is complemented by a natural grain presence that adds a filmic texture to the image without detracting from the overall sharpness. However, it's worth noting that there are moments, such as a scene around 35 minutes in, where quality appears slightly compromised due to source material limitations, manifesting as minor chroma noise primarily in background details. Furthermore, the use of a hazy filter in the Cuba scenes intentionally limits fidelity for stylistic reasons, indicating a thoughtful balance between preserving artistic intentions and technological advancements.
Despite these minor inconsistencies, the 4K UHD presentation of "Topaz" extends beyond mere incremental improvements over its Blu-ray predecessor, presenting a significantly enhanced visual experience that fans of Hitchcock and cinephiles with an appreciation for film restoration will find deeply satisfying. The depth and texture of the image, together with the enriched color dynamics and strategic grain management, underscore the film’s atmospheric tension and period setting, reaffirming "Topaz" as a visually compelling entry in Hitchcock’s filmography on this format.
Audio: 70
The 4K UHD Blu-ray's DTS-HD two-channel mono track presents an audio experience for "Topaz" that is both respectful to its era and impressive in its clarity. The film, primarily reliant on dialogue, allows for its intricate spy narrative to unfold with remarkable intelligibility. Voice articulation is crisp, ensuring that every whispered secret and hushed conversation is rendered with precision, essential for a film so dependent on its verbal exchanges. The sound effects, while perhaps not meeting contemporary expectations in terms of depth and range, evoke the period effectively and add a layer of authenticity without ever seeming out of place or detracting from the overall experience.
Musical scores within "Topaz" enjoy a clarity and dynamism that complement the visual restoration marvelously. There's an appreciable balance achieved between music and dialogue, ensuring that neither overwhelms the other. The opening military march sets a commanding tone, with the audio mix showing off a fine range from the highs to a slightly enhanced low-end, giving a nod to the film’s age without sacrificing quality. The age of the original recordings is acknowledged through the occasionally faded and coarse dialogue which, while lacking in some areas of precision, is largely mitigated by the skilled restoration work, evoking a sense of time and place rather than detracting from the film's appeal.
Throughout "Topaz," there are stretches of silence or near silence, handled with such care that they speak volumes, demonstrating the power of restraint in the film's audio presentation. This intentional use of silence, coupled with the film’s meticulously clear and balanced audio restoration, ensures an engaging auditory experience. Notably, no significant audio defects detract from the viewing experience, affirming the attention to detail given to this release. This blend of historical authenticity with modern mastering techniques makes the 4K UHD's audio track a notable success for both cinephiles and fans of Hitchcock's meticulous craftsmanship.
Extras: 61
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Topaz" enriches the viewing experience with an array of special features that cater both to cinephiles and those fascinated by the thriller’s production intricacies. Meticulously compiled, the extras include everything from in-depth appreciations to alternate endings, providing a comprehensive dive beyond the film's surface. Noteworthy is Leonard Maltin's penned appreciation, which offers keen insights into the film's standing within Hitchcock’s oeuvre. The inclusion of storyboards and production photographs offers a rare glimpse into the creative process, while the alternate endings present fascinating "what could have been" scenarios. All features are presented in standard definition, preserving their original formats and ensuring that enthusiasts and newcomers alike have a rich trove of content to explore, enhancing their understanding and appreciation of this classic suspense film.
Extras included in this disc:
- Topaz An Appreciation: A detailed appreciation by Leonard Maltin.
- Alternate Endings: Diverse conclusions to Hitchcock’s thriller.
- Storyboards: The Mendozas: Visual pre-planning scenes.
- Production Photographs: Behind-the-scenes stills.
- Theatrical Trailer: Original promotional material.
Movie: 56
Universal's reissue of Alfred Hitchcock's 1969 espionage thriller "Topaz" on 4K UHD as part of a distinguished boxed set including 'The Man Who Knew Too Much', 'Rope', 'Torn Curtain', and 'Frenzy', signifies a noteworthy attempt to present this often overlooked film in the best possible light. Boasting a 2160p/HDR video transfer and DTS HD Master Audio, "Topaz" has never looked or sounded better, making it a tempting proposition for Hitchcock aficionados and cinephiles keen on experiencing this historical artifact in unparalleled clarity. The inclusion of legacy special features enriches the offering, though the primary allure remains the film’s upgraded visual and auditory presentation.
"Topaz", initially received with lukewarm enthusiasm, draws its narrative from the Cold War’s nerve-wracking days following the Cuban Missile Crisis, presenting a spy story that intertwines historical facts with cinematic fiction. Hitchcock's decision to cast Frederick Stafford as Andre Devereaux, in lieu of his first choice Sean Connery, and the behind-the-scenes script challenges highlight a production marred by compromise and artistic tension. Yet, despite these struggles, "Topaz" emerges as a curiously uncharacteristic entry in Hitchcock’s oeuvre, forsaking his trademark suspense and psychological depth for a more measured, albeit fragmented, exploration of espionage.
The film’s treatment of its subject matter—with its reliance on period-specific espionage tactics and a plot that suffers from its own convoluted ambition—renders "Topaz" as much a testament to its time as it is a narrative experiment. Despite its innovative use of color and setting to drive the story, "Topaz" falters in delivering a cohesive narrative experience, primarily due to its unmemorable protagonist and a finale that leaves much to be desired. Nevertheless, for those invested in the era’s geopolitical intricacies or Hitchcock’s directorial journey, "Topaz" offers an intriguing glimpse into both.
Total: 69
"Topaz," Alfred Hitchcock's espionage thriller, has endured as one of his most divisive works, exacerbated by its meandering pace and a central performance by Fredrick Stafford that fails to captivate. As Andre Devereaux, Stafford struggles with the charisma and persuasiveness expected of a leading French agent, rendering his character's morally ambiguous actions less palatable and, by extension, affecting our investment in the narrative's progression. This lack of engagement is a significant barrier to the film's success, highlighting how crucial casting and character development are to the overall impact of a story. Despite these narrative and character shortcomings, "Topaz" commands attention for its technical achievements, presenting a visually compelling piece that merits examination particularly in its 4K UHD Blu-ray presentation.
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Topaz" stands as a testament to the film's technical prowess, offering a visual upgrade that breathes new life into Hitchcock's meticulous framing and vibrant color palette. While the film itself may not rank among Hitchcock's most universally acclaimed works, this release showcases the undeniable craftsmanship involved in its production. Special features included on the disc provide valuable insights into the film's complex creation process, appealing to cinephiles and Hitchcock aficionados who seek a deeper understanding of his experimental forays during this period.
In conclusion, while "Topaz" might not appeal to the casual viewer due to its pacing issues and a lead performance that lacks the necessary allure and complexity, the 4K UHD Blu-ray presentation affords a renewed appreciation for Hitchcock's technical finesse. This edition is recommended primarily for hardcore Hitchcock fans or those with a particular interest in the evolution of his directorial style. With improved visual quality and intriguing special features, it represents an important piece for collectors, albeit with the caveat that its story and performances may not conform to everyone's taste.
Blu-ray.com review by Justin DekkerRead review here
Video: 80
Detail levels are consistently very high, with it being very easy to pick out facial particulars and environmental specifics - especially in busy interior locations like the porcelain shop and production...
Audio: 70
As is often the case with Hitchcock's movies, there are some protracted sequences that play out largely in complete or near silence, and of course, those sound terrific as well....
Extras: 70
All of the previous special features are brought forward to the 4K disc and are as follows: Topaz An Apppreciation (SD, 29 minutes)...
Movie: 60
It is available individually (this release) or as part of a five-film boxed set along with 'The Man Who Knew Too Much', 'Rope', 'Torn Curtain', and 'Frenzy'....
Total: 70
He's never wholly convincing in his role as a French agent, nor does he have the charisma to hold our attention in the manner of the silver screen's best spies of the era....
DoBlu review by Matt PaprockiRead review here
Video: 80
It’s borderline too much, but no less attractive, and when combined with the pure, dense black levels, produce a sensationally deep image....
Audio: 80
Released in 1969, Topaz reveals age in its audio via the faded and coarse dialog, lacking precision and some clarity, but entirely due to time, not the mastering....
Extras: 60
Alternate endings, an appreciation penned by Leonard Maltin, storyboards, production stills, and a trailer make up the bonuses....
Movie: 60
There’s a behind-the-scenes struggle that led to Topaz too, beginning with novel author Leon Uris who failed to connect with Hitchcock’s personality, and the script then went through phases, sometimes...
Total: 70
A convoluted and even experimental mess, Topaz is among Hitchcock’s least accessible works for a wide audience....
Director: Alfred Hitchcock
Actors: Frederick Stafford, Dany Robin, John Vernon
PlotIn the midst of the Cold War, a high-ranking Soviet official, Boris Kusenov, defects to the West, bringing with him alarming intelligence that suggests the Soviet Union is placing nuclear missiles in Cuba, potentially triggering an international crisis. To verify this critical information, the CIA enlists French intelligence agent André Devereaux to investigate. Devereaux's mission leads him to Cuba, where he must navigate the dangerous waters of espionage, dodging the watchful eyes of Cuban secret police and gathering the necessary evidence to confirm the missile placements. His investigation also reveals a network of spies, code-named "Topaz," an intricate web of deception that spans across different countries, adding layers of complexity to his task.
As Devereaux digs deeper, his personal and professional worlds collide, bringing tension and risk not only to himself but also to his family and associates. His journey takes him next to New York, where a crucial meeting with a NATO official is supposed to unfold. Along the way, the line between allies and enemies blurs, making trust a valuable yet scarce commodity. The stakes are exceptionally high, as the outcome of Devereaux's mission has the potential to influence global politics and the very fabric of international relations during one of the tensest periods of the 20th century. Through a labyrinth of espionage, betrayal, and secrets, the quest for truth tests the limits of loyalty and courage.
Writers: Leon Uris, Samuel A. Taylor
Release Date: 19 Dec 1969
Runtime: 143 min
Rating: M/PG
Country: United States
Language: English, Spanish, French, Russian