Grandma Blu-ray Review
Score: 68
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Grandma's Blu-ray impresses with Tomlin's stellar performance and strong emotional script, featuring excellent video and quality audio—though extras are average.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 76
This high-definition Blu-ray of 'Grandma' features a striking 1080p transfer with deeply saturated colors, strong black levels, and impressive detailing, especially in clothing textures and skin tones. Elevated contrast enhances dynamic highlights in sunlit scenes, maintaining solid resolution without noticeable compression errors.
Audio: 68
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 lossless soundtrack delivers rich, clear dialogue with excellent center placement and natural vocal clarity, complemented by dynamic music elements and mild ambient effects that add depth without overwhelming the soundstage.
Extra: 51
The Blu-ray extras for 'Grandma' include a comprehensive 25-minute making-of featurette, a 21-minute Q&A, an insightful audio commentary with the main cast and director, and the theatrical trailer, all in HD, delivering an engaging and thorough exploration of the film's production, themes, and performances.
Movie: 71
"Grandma" is a poignant, intimate journey of reflection centered on Lily Tomlin's standout performance which captures a spirit of depth and emotional resonance. The film, directed by Paul Weitz, blends humor with heartfelt drama in a brisk runtime, focusing more on personal growth than the abortion subplot driving the narrative.
Video: 76
Sony's Blu-ray release of "Grandma" offers a commendable 1080p video presentation that stands out with its lively and deeply saturated color palette. The blu-ray impressively manages to maintain a consistent depth in primary colors that vividly pop on the screen. The flesh tones, although possessing a slightly balmy quality, avoid looking unnatural and contribute to the film’s aesthetic realism. Elevated contrast plays a crucial role in separating the dynamic highlights, particularly noticeable in sunlit exterior shots, without impinging on the overall detail work of the image.
Resolution is robust, delivering finely detailed imagery that allows for subtle delineation and exquisite depth in both long-range and close-up scenes. Textures are particularly noteworthy; clothing details are rendered with remarkable clarity, capturing intricate material and stitch patterns, while skin tones—whether aged or makeup-heavy—remain true-to-life. The Blu-ray handles blacks with aplomb, offering profound depth even in shadowed or low-light scenes, enhancing the overall viewing experience. Importantly, no compression errors or distracting video anomalies were observed, highlighting the precision of the encoding process.
Additionally, attention to detail extends to supporting elements such as wood and paint textures in various settings, or the natural greens of outdoor scenes. These aspects are presented with nuanced coloration and immaculate sharpness that remains stable throughout most of the film, albeit with occasional minor fluctuations. This release from Sony Pictures Classics exemplifies a top-tier transfer, presenting "Grandma" with a visual fidelity that significantly enriches the narrative’s impact.
Audio: 68
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 lossless soundtrack for "Grandma" offers a competent auditory experience that, while not pushing the boundaries of a high-end surround system, capably conveys the film’s audio elements. Dialogue shines as the primary component, achieving effortless center placement with clear and rich tonality. The vocal clarity is excellent, allowing for consistent prioritization within the sound mix. Dynamics are punchy, and the bass response is supportive without overpowering, providing suitable extension predominantly for musical elements.
The front channels handle the majority of the audio, presenting a wide two-dimensional soundstage. This effectively places dialogue and music at the forefront, with supporting ambient details like chirping birds and mild traffic noise enhancing scene realism. The surrounds offer subtle yet noticeable depth, supplying ambience that lightly immerses listeners in the film’s key locations. Music throughout is rich and detailed, particularly highlighted by a standout Hip-Hop track that benefits from robust intensity, depth, and spacing. Overall, the audio mix complements the source material well, contributing to an engaging listening experience.
Extras: 51
The Blu-ray extras for "Grandma" offer a comprehensive and engaging look into the film's production and thematic elements. The Audio Commentary features insights from actors Lily Tomlin, Sam Elliott, Julia Garner, and director Paul Weitz, who discuss various aspects such as character development, film style, emotional arcs, and behind-the-scenes camaraderie. The 25-minute featurette, A Family Portrait, delves into the production's history, casting processes, and story themes while highlighting the challenges of working within a small budget. Additionally, a 21-minute Q&A Session with Tomlin, Elliott, and Weitz provides a deeper understanding of the film’s narrative choices and thematic approaches, particularly regarding its abortion storyline and feminist perspectives. The inclusion of the Theatrical Trailer further complements these engaging extras.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Insights from principal cast and director.
- A Family Portrait: In-depth production featurette.
- Q&A with Lily Tomlin, Sam Elliott, and Paul Weitz: Discussion on themes and production.
- Theatrical Trailer: Original trailer for the film.
Movie: 71
"Grandma" masterfully blends heartfelt humor with poignant drama, centered around Elle Reid (Lily Tomlin) and her granddaughter Sage (Julia Garner) on a quest for $600 to fund an abortion. Writer/Director Paul Weitz crafts a microscopic road trip movie, rich with personal growth and rekindling relationships. Elle, a retired feminist poet and professor, is recovering from heartbreak when Sage’s unexpected plea propels them into a whirlwind day filled with introspection and reconciliation.
Tomlin delivers a standout performance, impeccably capturing Elle's complexity, history, and emotional depth. Her portrayal of an elderly lesbian reconnecting with past acquaintances provides both sincere moments and solid comedic relief. While Elle’s personal journey takes precedence, Sage’s emotional struggle becomes a secondary focus, which affects the balance of the narrative.
Supporting performances from Marcia Gay Harden and Sam Elliott add layers to Elle's multifaceted past. The film's brevity ensures an engaging pace, avoiding unnecessary filler while allowing thematic elements to mature organically. Despite overshadowing young Garner’s role, Tomlin’s nuanced acting anchors the film, making "Grandma" a resonant and well-executed exploration of self-reflection and familial bonds.
Total: 68
The Blu-ray release of "Grandma" presents an engaging yet polarizing film that is held aloft by Lilly Tomlin's stellar performance. Notably, Tomlin's portrayal of Elle makes for a compelling viewing experience, thanks to a sharp script accompanied by nuanced emotional depth. However, the movie's focus on Elle’s perspective somewhat overshadows Sage's very poignant journey to fund her abortion, which could deter more traditional viewers seeking a balanced emotional narrative. Despite this, the underlying apolitical themes of reflection and self-realization resonate strongly.
From a technical standpoint, Sony delivers high-quality video and audio, capturing the film's vivid visual textures and intricate soundscapes with precision. The Blu-ray transfer ensures that the diverse color palette and fine details of the cinematography are rendered beautifully. Audio clarity is equally exceptional, offering a balanced mix that underscores both dialogue-driven scenes and more subtle ambient sounds. While extra content is adequate, it does not notably enhance the overall offering, making it functional but unremarkable.
In conclusion, "Grandma" on Blu-ray is highly recommended for its technical excellence and Lilly Tomlin's outstanding performance, even if its emotional scope may not appeal universally. Sony has delivered a visually and sonically impressive package, though the supplementary content leaves room for improvement. This makes it a worthwhile addition for fans of character-driven narratives and robust acting showcases.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
Support elements are impressive, too, whether wood and heavy paint textures in a coffee shop seen near film's start, natural grasses seen at Sam Elliott's character's home, or the cleaner lines inside...
Audio: 80
Music is rich and detailed, with a Hip-Hop song enjoying the most robust intensity, depth, and spacing in the movie....
Extras: 50
A Family Portrait: Making Grandma (1080p, 25:15): An in-depth look at the production and its history, including the original script, Tomlin's casting and writing the part for her, casting and performances,...
Movie: 70
Her ability to inhabit the character, to understand the character's history not just as it is written in the script but emote the longstanding emotional resonances, carry the scars, and juxtapose a complicated...
Total: 70
Grandma soars thanks to Lilly Tomlin's remarkable performance but suffers from a lack of a more thorough and thoughtful emotional journey on the other side of the coin, in Sage's quest to raise the funds...
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 88
Elevated contrast adds pop to colors and dynamic highlights to the sun splashed exterior sequences without interfering with the perception of detail....
Audio: 82
The front channels handled the bulk of the audio and presented a wide two dimensional soundstage with the surrounds supplying ambience detail that added depth....
Extras: 60
(HD) A Family Portrait: The Making of Grandma – 25 minute featurette (HD) Q&A with Lily Tomlin, Sam Elliott, and Paul Weitz – 21 minutes Audio Commentary with Lily Tomlin, Sam Elliott, Julia Gardner, and...
Movie: 80
Temporarily broke, Grandma Elle and Sage spend the day trying to get their hands on the cash, as their unannounced visits to old friends and flames end up rattling skeletons and digging up secrets....
Total: 78
Sony Playstation 3 Blu-ray disc Player (HDMI Audio/Video) System Controller: Apple iPad/iRule Pro HD Universal Remote Control Canton "Ergo" and In-Ceiling series speakers Axiom Audio QS8 Quadpolar speakers...
Director: Paul Weitz
Actors: Lily Tomlin, Julia Garner, Marcia Gay Harden
PlotElle, a sharp-tongued, aging poet, finds her life upended when her teenage granddaughter, Sage, unexpectedly shows up at her door in need of immediate help. Sage is pregnant and requires $600 for an abortion, but she has neither the funds nor the nerve to face her mother, Judy. The two set off on an impromptu journey around Los Angeles in Elle’s decrepit 1955 Dodge Royal to scrounge up the necessary money before Sage’s appointment later that day. With Elle’s financial situation as dire as Sage’s, they visit old friends, ex-lovers, and anyone else who might be swayed to lend them some cash.
Throughout their daylong odyssey, Elle and Sage’s relationship deepens as they confront painful memories from the past and tackle their own individual struggles. Each encounter reveals more about Elle’s grief over her recently deceased partner, her estranged relationship with her daughter Judy, and her unresolved guilt. Their quest exposes the generational divides and the complexities that bind them. As they race against time, both women must navigate their own frailties and secrets, leading to moments of dark humor, heartfelt poignancy, and ultimately, an exploration of family dynamics and personal redemption.
Writers: Paul Weitz
Release Date: 18 Sep 2015
Runtime: 79 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English