Meet Dave Blu-ray Review
Score: 55
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Meet Dave delivers passable entertainment with quality video/audio on Blu-ray, though it's better suited for a rental night than a purchase.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 62
Meet Dave’s Blu-ray video presentation offers definitive high definition detail, with nicely saturated colors, dynamic contrast, and stable blacks. However, bright scenes can look overly vivid, with occasional flesh tone inconsistencies. The lossless sound quality delivers clear dialogue, dynamic highlights, and involving surround activity.
Audio: 62
The Blu-ray of *Meet Dave* features a high-powered DTS-HD MA 5.1 lossless soundtrack that offers dynamic bass, precise and clear sound effects, and immersive 360-degree atmospheres. Dialogue is crisp, and while the audio isn't nonstop, it delivers a lively, above-average experience for a comedy film.
Extra: 41
Meet Dave's Blu-ray includes interactive crew profiles, a gag reel, four deleted scenes, an alternate ending, and a standard making-of featurette. Complementing these are three Fox Movie Channel segments highlighting the director's insights, an important effects-heavy scene, and red carpet interviews.
Movie: 31
Meet Dave, featuring Eddie Murphy in dual roles, offers lighthearted fun with plenty of laughs and an original premise, although it suffers from forced dramatic elements and some subpar visual effects; ultimately, it’s an amusing but not exceptional family-friendly comedy.
Video: 62
The Blu-ray video presentation of "Meet Dave" offers a high-definition transfer framed at 1.85:1 and encoded in 1080p. The attention to fine detail is commendable, particularly in exterior shots of New York City, which exhibit realistic textures and intricate details that contribute to a film-like appearance. The transfer showcases nicely saturated colors, though it features a pervasive reddish tint that sometimes affects flesh tones, giving them a warm, red/orange hue. This can vary from natural to slightly enhanced, depending on the scene. Bright scenes occasionally appear a bit overexposed, resulting in slightly washed-out whites and muted colors, yet blacks generally remain stable with good shadow delineation.
The overall visual experience is enhanced by dynamic contrast and vibrant hues, contributing to an engaging viewing experience despite some inconsistencies. While the image often presents fantastic detail with ample depth, it does encounter some challenges in specific scenes where colors look somewhat soft and washed out. However, these are interspersed with sections where the color palette is bright and alluring. Flesh tones exhibit significant variability without clear correlation to lighting conditions or location but typically stay within a realistic depiction.
In summary, "Meet Dave" on Blu-ray provides a strong high-definition transfer that, while not reference-grade, delivers an engaging and visually cohesive experience. The transfer excels in detailed portrayals and dynamic range despite occasional issues with color uniformity and brightness.
Audio: 62
The audio presentation of "Meet Dave" on Blu-ray is delivered through an energetic DTS-HD MA 5.1 lossless soundtrack, showcasing a rich sonic landscape that immerses the viewer in the film's quirky adventures. The soundtrack is robust with significant bass activity that frequently reverberates through the floorboards, enhancing the immersive experience. Noteworthy is the sound effects placement throughout the surround stage, offering superb precision and clarity. This helps to create a thoroughly engaging 360-degree atmosphere, particularly noticeable in scenes that involve complex sound staging like those in the Havana restaurant where music and ambient sounds are rendered with remarkable accuracy.
Dialogue delivery is consistently clear and natural, ensuring that verbal exchanges are easily understood amidst the dynamic audio backdrop. The film also leverages discrete surround effects to bolster its front-heavy scenes, making even quieter moments feel enveloping and alive. A standout auditory scene occurs in chapter seven, where Starship Dave listens to headphones, generating a cacophony of bass sounds within the ship. This particular moment showcases deliberate muddy bass to align with the chaotic scene, adding an additional layer of character to the audio design.
"Meet Dave’s" soundtrack maintains a balance between the lively auditory elements and more restrained moments typical for a comedy film. It delivers a well-above average audio performance that complements the visual components seamlessly, ensuring an enjoyable viewing experience across varied scenes without overwhelming the viewer with constant audio intensity.
Extras: 41
The Blu-ray release of "Meet Dave" offers a suite of engaging extras that provide fans with a comprehensive behind-the-scenes look at the film. Among the features are three segments presented by Fox Movie Channel, including "Life After Film School" with director Brian Robbins, discussing his insights and experiences, "Making a Scene," which delves into the creation of an effects-heavy scene, and the "World Premiere," capturing interviews with cast and crew on the red carpet. Additionally, "The Making of Meet Dave" featurette examines the film's origins, script appeal, and behind-the-scenes footage. An interactive "Crew Profiles" segment allows deeper exploration of the Starship's team. The disc is rounded off with a humorous gag reel, four deleted scenes, and an alternate ending, all presented in high definition.
Extras included in this disc:
- (HD) Crew Profiles: Interactive feature about the Starship's crew.
- (HD) Gag Reel: Humorous outtakes.
- (HD) 4 Deleted Scenes: Unused footage from the movie.
- (HD) Alternate Ending: Different conclusion to the film.
- (HD) The Making of Meet Dave: Featurette on origins and production.
- Life After Film School With Director Brian Robbins: Interview with the director by students.
- Making a Scene: Examination of an effects-heavy scene.
- World Premiere: Red carpet interviews with cast and crew.
Movie: 31
Fox's Blu-ray release of Meet Dave delivers Eddie Murphy in a dual role that demands more from his acting and comedic abilities than his earlier works reliant on heavy makeup and visual gags. Murphy's performance is commendable, assuming the roles of both a tiny, high-strung alien captain and his human-sized vessel. The film's premise—an alien spaceship in human form navigating Earth's culture to save its home planet—proves sufficiently original, albeit executed through generic comedy tropes. Murphy's interactions, especially attempting basic human actions like a handshake or adjusting his voice for typical human dialogue, yield numerous laugh-out-loud moments. Although Meet Dave isn't Murphy's finest outing, it provides a lighthearted, family-friendly experience with regular laughs and charmingly awkward moments.
The narrative follows Starship Dave and its crew of miniature, English-speaking aliens as they search for a powerful orb to extract salt from Earth's oceans to save their planet. This plot converges with the lives of an Earth woman, Gina (Elizabeth Banks), and her son, Josh (Austin Lynd Myers), resulting in comical yet predictable entanglements. The supporting cast delivers modest performances, with Marc Blucas standing out in a minor yet notable role. While the comedic elements of Meet Dave hold strong, the film struggles with its dramatic elements and plot devices, such as the forced romance between Murphy's characters and the subplot involving a zealous police officer (Scott Caan). The film's visual effects are inconsistent, occasionally detracting from the overall experience.
In summary, Meet Dave is anchored by Murphy’s dual performance and its unique storyline, offering viewers a decent 90-minute romp. Despite its flaws in plot coherence and special effects, it remains an entertaining watch for those seeking a lighthearted comedy without serious expectations.
Total: 55
Meet Dave delivers a light-hearted, family-friendly comedy with Eddie Murphy's commendable dual performances at its core. The film primarily relies on various comedic sketches centered around Starship Dave's attempts to navigate modern culture, making it enjoyable if somewhat lowbrow. While it certainly doesn't qualify as a classic or an exceptional cinematic achievement, it offers passable entertainment for viewers looking for an easygoing movie experience. Film purists might shy away, but general audiences searching for a fun, slightly quirky comedy can find some satisfaction here.
From a technical standpoint, Meet Dave arrives on Blu-ray courtesy of 20th Century Fox, presenting a largely average package. The disc features decent quality video and audio presentations that should suffice for most home viewing setups, though they fail to distinguish themselves as exemplary within the format. Despite the film’s lackluster performance at the box office, the Blu-ray manages to capture the film’s vibrant scenes and dynamic soundtracks adequately, albeit unremarkably. The supplemental features are minimal, which is disappointing given today’s standard expectations for Blu-ray extras.
In conclusion, Meet Dave is far from a cinematic masterpiece but provides harmless fun suitable for family movie night. Given its relatively high MSRP, this Blu-ray is arguably best enjoyed as a rental rather than a purchase. If you're in the mood for some light-hearted laughs delivered by Eddie Murphy’s interesting performances, Meet Dave may just fit the bill.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 80
Oftentimes, the transfer sports fantastic attention to fine detail and offers plenty of depth, making for what is usually a very film-like transfer....
Audio: 80
There is plenty of surround activity as well, both in support of the fronts and through the inclusion of discrete effects that seem to always create a full sense of 360-degree realistic atmosphere....
Extras: 40
Making a Scene (480p, 9:54) looks at the creation of one of the film's most effects-heavy and important scenes....
Movie: 40
There are some very funny moments in the film, such as when the crew of the Starship Dave try to fine-tune the vessel's voice at the right pitch for proper dialogue and human interaction....
Total: 50
The film offers plenty of laughs in the form of a number of sketches that serve as the heart of the film, everything else playing second fiddle to Starship Dave's attempts to fit into modern culture....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 84
Surround activity offered a nice balance of discrete and spatial sound effects that were spread out over the course of the presentation....
Audio: 84
Marantz DV7001 Universal Disc Player Denon AVR 5308CI THX Ultra 2 Preamp/Video Processor B&K Reference 200.7 Series 2 seven Channel amplifier Canton "Ergo" Series speakers Axiom Audio QS8 Quadpolar speakers...
Extras: 50
(HD) Crew profiles - interactive feature (HD) Gag reel (HD) 4 Deleted scenes (HD) Alternate ending (HD) The making of Meet Dave - Featurette Fox Movie Channel Presents: Life after film school with Director...
Movie: 30
Torn between the voices in his head - a tiny alien crew led by a high-strung, miniature version of himself - and the world around him, Dave struggles to appear normal....
Total: 62
Marantz DV7001 Universal Disc Player Denon AVR 5308CI THX Ultra 2 Preamp/Video Processor B&K Reference 200.7 Series 2 seven Channel amplifier Canton "Ergo" Series speakers Axiom Audio QS8 Quadpolar speakers...
Director: Brian Robbins
Actors: Eddie Murphy, Elizabeth Banks, Gabrielle Union
PlotA small spaceship resembling a human is sent to Earth with a crew of tiny alien beings inside it. These aliens, led by their captain, have arrived to save their home planet, Nil, which relies on salt to survive. Disguised as a human named Dave, the spaceship begins searching for a way to extract the ocean's salt without alerting Earth's inhabitants. The aliens must adapt to human behavior and customs without drawing too much attention. "Dave" encounters Gina Morrison, a single mother who helps him learn more about human emotions and establish a connection with her and her young son.
As the mission progresses, the crew inside "Dave" faces unexpected challenges and dilemmas. They must decide between pursuing their planet-saving directive or embracing the newfound empathy and relationships they have developed on Earth. The captain and his crew become increasingly conflicted as they learn more about human beings and the potential consequences of their actions. Their experiences force them to reevaluate their priorities, leading to choices that will impact both their home planet and the lives of the humans they have come to care about.
Writers: Rob Greenberg, Bill Corbett
Release Date: 11 Jul 2008
Runtime: 90 min
Rating: PG
Country: United States
Language: English