Footnote Blu-ray Review
Hearat Shulayim
Score: 64
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
'Footnote' is an engaging, character-driven film with nuanced direction, superb performances, and a high-quality Blu-ray release; very highly recommended.
Disc Release Date
Video: 69
The 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 transfer for 'Footnote' maintains a film-like appearance with light grain, solid fine details in close-ups, and naturally rendered colors. The palette is often desaturated with blue and teal hues, providing respectable blacks and good contrast, aligning with the director’s artistic vision.
Audio: 67
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track for 'Footnote' offers a solid, frontal-oriented soundstage with excellent music clarity, immersive dialogue, subtle surround ambiance, and creative sound design that enhances key moments, despite some minor balance issues.
Extra: 41
Extras of 'Footnote' feature a 24-minute making-of documentary in Hebrew with English subtitles offering in-depth production insights, a 9-minute Q&A session with director Joseph Cedar in 1080p, and the theatrical trailer in HD and Dolby Digital 5.1.
Movie: 83
Footnote delivers a profound exploration of familial rivalry and moral dilemmas through excellent direction, standout performances, and clever, subtle humor. The film juxtaposes old-school stubbornness against modern academic success, creating a gripping story that is both intellectually stimulating and emotionally resonant.
Video: 69
The Blu-ray presentation of "Footnote" boasts a solid 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 transfer, presented in the 2.35:1 aspect ratio, and achieves an excellent balance of fidelity and artistic intent. The film features a subdued color palette, with frequent blue and teal tints that align with the director’s vision, resulting in a slightly desaturated look. This muted chromatic scheme means the image isn't particularly vibrant or eye-catching, but it sustains a stable and consistent visual coherence that respects the original material. Flesh tones are generally accurate but can appear flat under certain lighting conditions, though they do exhibit appreciable complexional distinctions.
The transfer exhibits a light sheen of grain throughout, which contributes to the film-like appearance and enhances texture without succumbing to excessive sharpness. Detail levels are commendable, especially in close-ups, revealing fine details in facial features and fabric textures. Despite the occasional softness, the image maintains an impressive level of clarity and natural precision. Blacks are rich and deep with above-average delineation, and shadow detail is particularly good, enriching the perception of scenes shot in limited lighting.
Overall, the video quality is quite strong, offering a clean and visually appealing image free from noticeable issues such as banding, blocking, or edge enhancement. While "Footnote" might not amaze with its pop or depth, the authentic visual presentation respects the filmmaker's intentional aesthetic decisions. The subdued tones, coupled with meticulous preservation of details and natural precision, provide a gratifying viewing experience that aligns well with the narrative and emotional tone of the film.
Audio: 67
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 lossless soundtrack of "Footnote" delivers an immersive yet front-focused auditory experience that accentuates the film's distinctive music with unparalleled clarity. Listeners are treated to a silky smooth, tonally neutral, and detailed soundscape, making the music feel almost orchestral in presence. Dialogue is consistently clear and centered, flowing naturally from the center channel with distinguishable intonation and requisite clarity, ensuring that every spoken word is easy to follow. Surround activity, though restrained, offers subtle ambient effects that blend seamlessly into the larger sound field, providing a sense of spatial dimension.
The audio design is both creative and multilayered, enhancing the narrative during key moments by putting us within the characters' headspace through specific effects. The mix is particularly notable for instances where Eliezer utilizes noise-reducing ear muffs; during these sequences, the background ambiance is artistically muted, creating a subdued vacuum of sound that intensifies focus on primary dialogue and effects. The quirky and dynamic original score stands out with great fidelity and separation, supporting comedic and dramatic beats without overwhelming the narrative. The track demonstrates impressive dynamic range—delicate sounds like heavy breathing are rendered softly and naturally, while more powerful effects (such as racquetball hits and drums) emerge with impact and precision.
Although the mix is primarily frontloaded, occasional bursts of immersive surround activity and ambiance do enhance the experience. Environmental sounds and specific scenes, particularly those involving applause or crowded spaces, fill the soundstage with lifelike accuracy. There are minor balance issues, especially with the score occasionally mixed a bit high, but the overall sound presentation remains strong and cohesive. Optional English, English SDH, French, Portuguese, and Spanish subtitles further enhance accessibility. This well-engineered track not only complements the film’s visual story but also brings it to brilliant sonic life.
Extras: 41
The Blu-ray extras for "Footnote" offer a comprehensive and engaging look into the film's production and thematic elements. The Behind the Scenes feature provides a 24-minute deep dive into the crafting of the film, including interviews with cast and crew, behind-the-scenes footage, and discussions on the plot, characters, and soundtrack. An Evening with Joseph Cedar is a 9-minute Q&A session with the director at the Toronto Film Festival, offering insights into the story’s origins and the casting process. The Theatrical Trailer is presented in 1080p with Dolby Digital 5.1 sound. These features are complemented by BD-Live capabilities for additional content.
Extras included in this disc:
- Behind the Scenes of Joseph Cedar's Film: Footnote: 24-minute documentary in Hebrew with English subtitles.
- An Evening with Joseph Cedar: 9-minute Q&A session in HD.
- Theatrical Trailer: Film trailer in HD.
Movie: 83
Joseph Cedar’s "Footnote" is a compelling drama that intricately explores the strained relationship between two Talmudic scholars, father Eliezer (Shlomo Bar-Aba) and son Uriel (Lior Ashkenazi). The elder Shkolnik, whose life's work has been overshadowed by an unfortunate timing of discoveries, embodies the stubborn purist overlooked by his peers, aching for the recognition he’s never received. In stark contrast, Uriel basks in academic accolades, embodying a new generation’s success. The plot thickens when Eliezer is mistakenly informed that he’s won the Israel Prize, sparking a series of ethical dilemmas that peel back layers of familial resentment and pride. Cedar’s precise direction and tight script seamlessly blend heartfelt drama with subtle humor in what becomes an electrifying narrative of aspiration, misrecognition, and moral ambiguity.
The power of "Footnote" lies not only in its storytelling but also in its performances and cinematography. Shlomo Bar-Aba masterfully portrays a man both detestable and sympathetic, caught between his life's passion and the crushing weight of unmet recognition, while Lior Ashkenazi’s Uriel wrestles visibly with his selflessness and selfishness, particularly in a poignant scene with the Israel Prize committee that encapsulates the film’s core conflict. Cedar’s creative visual techniques, including close-ups and kinetic on-screen rundowns, enrich the narrative’s emotional depth. Scenes are meticulously constructed to amplify dramatic tension or inject a dose of humor, as evidenced by Uriel’s confined debate with the committee in a comically cramped room. These elements coalesce, ensuring "Footnote" not only entertains but also provokes thought about pride, compassion, and the complexities of truth.
"Footnote" transcends simple storytelling through its exceptional character study and compelling ethical dilemmas. Cedar’s nuanced direction combined with standout performances creates a richly textured narrative rife with intellectual gravitas and emotional resonance. This film is an exquisite exploration of the human quest for acknowledgment and the profound, often heartbreaking intricacies inherent in father-son relationships.
Total: 64
"Footnote" is a cinematic gem, effortlessly melding humor with profound drama. Directed by Joseph Cedar, the film skillfully delves into the complexities of father-son relationships through a nuanced narrative and compelling character portrayals. This refined drama captivates audiences with its deeply layered storytelling, presenting a thought-provoking moral quandary that resonates deeply. The interplay of brilliant performances, an intelligent script, and masterful direction creates an absorbing experience that stands out as one of the year's best films, foreign or otherwise.
Sony’s Blu-ray release for "Footnote" does justice to the film's meticulous craftsmanship. The visual presentation is impeccable, with a high-definition transfer that preserves the director’s nuanced cinematography. The audio mix is equally impressive, providing clear and immersive sound that enhances the viewing experience. The disc also includes a couple of extras—a featurette and a Q&A—that, although limited, add valuable insights into the film's production and thematic depth.
In conclusion, "Footnote" on Blu-ray offers an exceptional package that highlights the film's dramatic integrity and technical excellence. Despite the sparse special features, this release remains an essential addition to any cinephile's collection. Very highly recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
Whether all the books in the library during the opening shot, all of the clothes seen throughout the film, or the grays and whites inside the committee's closet, the transfer enjoys a rich palette that...
Audio: 90
The sound is absolutely big yet crisp, very accurate through the whole range and solidified by a prominent but true low end....
Extras: 40
Behind the Scenes of Joseph Cedar's Film: Footnote (480p, 24:01): An overview piece that looks at the actors and their work, behind the scenes glimpses at the making of various scenes, clips from the film,...
Movie: 100
Goodbye, Lenin! is a wonderfully funny film, but Footnote differs from that picture with its more balanced tone, delivering heartfelt drama, high inter-character intensity, and subtle humor to construct...
Total: 90
The film tells a simple yet very well-drawn story and captivates audiences with remarkably deep and nuanced characters, brilliant performances, and astoundingly nuanced direction....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Footnote' doesn't offer a lot of pop or depth in its image, but the video presentation is still quite good....
Audio: 80
Though the soundfield can be rather quiet and small during specific stretches, the track demonstrates decent variety and absolutely explodes when it needs to (a scene involving one character's epiphany...
Extras: 0
Behind the Scenes of Joseph Cedar's Film Footnote (SD, 24 min) - Presented in Hebrew with hardcoded English subtitles, this is an interesting look at the movie's production....
Movie: 80
While this might leave some viewers unsatisfied, in this case, I feel that the vague ending is quite fitting, and works well to enhance the story's tone and intentions....
Total: 60
Though intentionally ambiguous, the ending brings us to an appropriate climax, leaving the story's ultimate resolution in the hands of its viewers....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 84
This seems to coincide with the creative decisions of the filmmakers and results in stable imagery that lacks the eye popping definition that some may expect from a newer film....
Audio: 78
The DTS-HD Master Audio sound quality is solid and offers a one dimensional, frontal oriented perspective that is highlighted by the film’s great music which sounded silky smooth, tonally neutral and exquisitely...
Extras: 50
Footnote – 24 minute making of documentary (HD) An evening with Joseph Cedar – 9 minute Q&A (HD)...
Movie: 80
FOOTNOTE is the tale of a great rivalry between a father and son, two eccentric professors, who both dedicated their lives to work in Talmudic Studies....
Total: 73
Screen Onkyo PR-SC5508 THX Ultra 2 Audio/Video Processor Sherbourn Technologies - 7/200 Seven Channel Amplifier Oppo BDP-93 Universal Disc/3D capable Blu-ray Player (HDMI Audio/Video)...
Director: Joseph Cedar
Actors: Shlomo Bar-Aba, Lior Ashkenazi, Aliza Rosen
PlotEliezer Shkolnik, a philologist specializing in Talmudic studies, has spent his entire career at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem entrenched in meticulous and largely unrecognized scholarly work. He toils in obscurity, overshadowed by his son, Uriel, who is a celebrated academic in the same field. The father harbors deep resentment, feeling that his life's work has gone unnoticed, while the son basks in the limelight of academic acclaim. Their complicated relationship becomes even more strained as professional jealousy mixes with familial bonds.
Expectations collide when Eliezer receives unexpected recognition—he is informed he will be awarded the prestigious Israel Prize. This momentous event shifts the family dynamic and brings long-simmering tensions to the surface, leading to a series of revelations and ethical dilemmas that challenge both characters' principles and loyalties. As the story progresses, personal and professional conflicts intertwine, revealing deeper layers of rivalry, pride, and the complex nature of paternal relationships.
Writers: Joseph Cedar
Release Date: 25 May 2011
Runtime: 107 min
Rating: PG
Country: Israel
Language: Hebrew