Paths of Glory Blu-ray Review

The Criterion Collection’s Blu-ray presentation of Stanley Kubrick's "Paths of Glory" offers a notable 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 transfer in an aspect ratio of 1.66:1. This high-definition transfer, supervised by Kubrick's technical assistant Leon Vitali on a HD Spirit 2K from a 35mm fine-grain master positive, showcases extensive cleaning through MTI's DRS system and Pixel Farm's PFClean system. The meticulous restoration eradicated thousands of instances of dirt, debris, scratches, splices, warps, and jitter, ensuring a pristine visual experience. Telecine colorist Jeff Chavez from Point 360, Los Angeles, balanced the contrast levels expertly, optimizing the visual quality in both daylight and nighttime sequences.

Overall, the transfer represents a significant upgrade over the 1999 DVD release. The greyscale is robust with impressive contrast performance, offering rich blacks and natural grays and whites. Fine object detail is particularly noteworthy during daylight footage, with clear delineation in textures. Subtle variations in uniforms and hair detail exemplify the careful attention to picture quality. Architectural details in indoor scenes maintain a depth and realism that enhances the film’s immersive quality. The battlefield sequences notably display intricate elements such as mud, barbed wire, and smoke with remarkable clarity, further emphasizing the fine detail of the transfer.

Grain structure is preserved effectively, delivering an authentic filmic feel without being distracting. Despite minor patches of softness and occasional slight wear, the overall stability remains solid with no significant compression artifacts. The comprehensive cleanup means there is a notable absence of large scratches or debris, ensuring an uninterrupted visual presentation. This Blu-ray rendition of "Paths of Glory" is a testament to Criterion’s dedication to preserving cinematic classics with superior care and precision. (Note: This is a Region-A locked disc; a compatible player is required.)

The audio presentation of the "Paths of Glory" Blu-ray is anchored by a single English LPCM 1.0 (Mono) track, meticulously remastered at 24-bit from Robert Gitt's 35mm monaural magnetic track. The restoration process involved the use of Pro Tools HD for manual removal of clicks, thumps, hiss, and hum, while AudioCube's integrated workstation was employed to attenuate crackle. Criterion has also provided optional English SDH subtitles for accessibility.

The remastered audio is impressively clear, with crisp and stable dialogue that ensures comprehensibility throughout. The soundstage is well-balanced, capable of effectively conveying the depth and fluidity of Gerald Fried's prominent music score, especially noticeable in the lower frequencies where the brass sections exhibit fullness and balance without distortion. Remarkably, the track maintains good dynamic range, exemplified by the realistic rendering of explosions and the nuanced elements during intense scenes, such as the machine gun fire. The careful attention to detail in sound effects creates a sense of immersion, from Dax’s echoing voice during courtroom scenes to the ominous low rumble of firing guns and high-pitched whines of passing bullets.

Overall, this LPCM 1.0 track delivers a solid and engaging audio experience that enhances the timeless visual narrative of "Paths of Glory." The restoration efforts ensure that despite the limitations inherent in a mono track over 50 years old, the auditory elements remain clean and free from any disruptive artifacts like pops, cracks, hiss, or dropouts. This high-fidelity audio performance stands as a testament to the meticulous care taken in preserving the film’s original sound integrity while bringing it into the lossless digital realm.

The extras on the Blu Ray edition of "Paths of Glory" provide a comprehensive and engaging dive into the making and legacy of Stanley Kubrick’s classic. Gary Giddins' commentary offers an exhaustive look into the film's production, political implications, and Kubrick's influence. The included interviews with key figures such as Kirk Douglas, Christiane Kubrick, and James B. Harris deliver personal insights and anecdotes, further enriching the viewing experience. The brief but illuminating segments featuring Jan Harlan and Theophile Maupas, along with the original theatrical trailer, round out a well-curated collection that enhances appreciation for this landmark film.

Extras included in this disc:

• Commentary: Audio commentary by critic Gary Giddins covering production history, political context, and Kubrick's legacy.
• Stanley Kubrick: Illustrated audio interview with Kubrick addressing cast challenges and film reception.
• Kirk Douglas: Interview discussing his career and work on the film.
• James B. Harris: Producer discusses filming challenges and collaboration with Kubrick.
• Christiane Kubrick: Christiane recalls meeting Stanley and their collaboration.
• Jan Harlan: Executive producer Jan Harlan on Kubrick’s legacy.
• Theophile Maupas: French news segment on historical events inspiring the film.
• Trailer: Original theatrical trailer.
• Booklet: Includes James Naremore's essay on Kubrick and the film.

Stanley Kubrick's 1957 film "Paths of Glory," based on Humphrey Cobb's novel, delivers a harrowing critique of military bureaucracy and the brutal realities of war. Set in France during World War I, the story follows Colonel Dax (Kirk Douglas), who is ordered by General Mireau (George Macready) to lead his men in a futile assault on a heavily fortified German position known as the Anthill. After the inevitable failure and severe casualty toll, three soldiers are arbitrarily chosen to be court-martialed for cowardice to serve as an example. The courtroom scenes are a masterclass in tension, showcasing Kubrick's disdain for the corrupt military hierarchy that sacrifices its men for personal gain. Douglas excels as the morally sound Dax, while Macready and Adolphe Menjou convincingly portray the callous generals.

Kubrick's meticulous direction shines throughout, particularly in the battle scenes filmed by cinematographer Georg Krause. The use of wide shots accentuates the vast, oppressive landscape and the improbability of success, while tracking shots immerse the viewer directly into the chaos and carnage. The film's aesthetic is defined by long continuous shots and close-up frames that capture both the minutiae of conflict and the intensity of personal struggle. These elements combine to create an almost unbearable tension that is only tempered by Dax's restrained yet impassioned speeches.

The narrative's potency is not limited to its battle sequences; substantive themes emerge from the dialogue and character interactions. Kubrick exposes the hypocrisy and misguided patriotism of military leaders through powerful exchanges, such as Dax’s contemplative rebuttal to Mireau’s quest for glory using Samuel Johnson’s famous quote: "Patriotism is the last refuge of a scoundrel." The courtroom drama further lays bare the absurdity and injustice of militaristic arrogance. Ending on a poignant note, the film briefly pivots to an epilogue featuring a German singer (Susanne Christian), whose performance evokes a shared humanity among soldiers, underscoring the anti-war message and elevating "Paths of Glory" beyond a simple war narrative.

Criterion’s release of Stanley Kubrick's “Paths of Glory” on Blu-ray is a meticulously crafted presentation that truly honors the famed director's work. The visual quality is stunning, showcasing a level of clarity and detail that has not been seen since its original theatrical run. This high-definition transfer maintains the film’s stark black-and-white cinematography while enhancing its textures, transforming each frame into a captivating visual study. The audio component has received equal attention, delivering a pristine and immersive sound experience that underscores the film's powerful narrative. Kubrick's direction and Kirk Douglas's compelling performance are further elevated by Criterion’s comprehensive restoration efforts.

In addition to the superior audio-visual quality, Criterion has included a robust selection of supplemental features that enrich the viewing experience. These new additions provide invaluable insights into the film's production, historical context, and enduring relevance. Interviews, documentaries, and behind-the-scenes footage collectively create an extensive and detailed archive that will satisfy both casual viewers and dedicated cinephiles alike. By offering these extras, Criterion not only acknowledges but also preserves the significance of "Paths of Glory," ensuring that contemporary audiences can fully appreciate its thematic depth and cinematic craftsmanship.

As expected, Criterion has given Stanley Kubrick's once very controversial "Paths of Glory" top-notch treatment. The film looks and sounds the best it ever has. Criterion's Blu-ray disc also contains some very good new supplemental features. This is definitely the type of treatment "The Killing" needs. VERY HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.