Vengeance: A Love Story Blu-ray Review
Score: 43
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Vengeance: A Love Story's interesting elements are marred by exploitative content and lackluster performance from Cage, with adequate video but only lossy audio.
Disc Release Date
Video: 60
Vengeance: A Love Story on Blu-ray features a competent AVC encoded 1080p transfer at 1.85:1. The release, marked by a neutral color palette and sound natural flesh-tones, lacks demo potential but maintains crisp definition and clarity throughout. Outdoor scenes impress, however, nighttime sequences can appear slightly murky.
Audio: 50
The Blu-ray of 'Vengeance: A Love Story' from MVD Visual and FilmRise features only lossy audio options, including Dolby Digital 5.1 and 2.0. Despite the lack of a lossless track, the surround mix offers clean dialogue, dynamic directional cues, and a nuanced score, though it might have sounded even better in lossless format.
Extra: 2
Trailer in HD impresses with 1080p clarity over 2 minutes and 26 seconds.
Movie: 41
Despite a veteran cast and some suspenseful moments, 'Vengeance: A Love Story' falters with a rote screenplay, contrived trial scenes, and Nicholas Cage’s aloof performance, ultimately rendering it a generic revenge thriller with missed potential for deeper socio-economic commentary and emotional depth.
Video: 60
The Blu-ray presentation of "Vengeance: A Love Story" is delivered by MVD Visual and FilmRise in an AVC encoded 1080p transfer with a 1.85:1 aspect ratio. The presentation benefits from a clean 2K digital intermediate, ensuring clarity and crispness throughout the 99-minute runtime. Outdoor scenes, particularly in daytime sequences, are rendered with vibrant details and natural hues. However, some nighttime sequences, including significant moments set at Niagara Falls, exhibit minor murkiness and a lack of fine detail, which slightly diminishes their impact. Additionally, occasional banding can be noticed, though it does not detract significantly from the overall viewing experience.
This reissue by MVD largely mirrors the A/V quality of the original 2017 BD-R version distributed by FilmRise, maintaining a neutral color palette with excellent contrast and realistically rendered flesh tones. While the visual presentation does not reach the level of demo material, it ranks well for direct-to-video content, offering a competent viewing experience devoid of artifacts or signs of age-related deterioration. The unprocessed transfer adheres closely to the movie's master, reproducing the intended visual style with high fidelity. Overall, the Blu-ray video quality aptly supports the film's content and production values without aiming for visual extravagance.
Audio: 50
Audio presentation on the Blu-ray release of "Vengeance: A Love Story" by MVD Visual and FilmRise opts for lossy Dolby Digital audio tracks, available in 5.1 or 2.0 configurations. While this may be a consistent choice from FilmRise, the absence of a lossless audio option is a noticeable shortfall. The 5.1 surround mix makes commendable use of directional cues and channel separation, particularly during action sequences and scenes set near Niagara Falls, which feature well-placed ambient environmental sounds. Dialogue clarity is maintained throughout the film, ensuring that viewers can easily follow the story.
Frederik Wiedmann’s score, presented through the surround channels, adds a layer of emotional depth to the film’s narrative. However, the overall audio experience could have been significantly enhanced with a lossless format such as DTS-HD Master Audio or Dolby TrueHD. Despite this limitation, the provided Dolby Digital track does a competent job in delivering a balanced mix. The bass levels remain impactful and immersive even in their lossy form. Additionally, an optional English SDH subtitle track in a white font is available for accessibility, and the included secondary 2.0 Dolby Digital track fairly mirrors the broader surround mix experience.
Overall, while the audio quality offered is functional and effective for general viewing, there remains an evident potential for improvement through the inclusion of lossless audio options.
Extras: 2
The Blu-ray release of "Vengeance: A Love Story" offers a concise selection of extras that enhance the main feature. The included trailer provides a high-definition glimpse into the film's gritty and intense narrative, clocking in at 2 minutes and 26 seconds. The overall presentation of these supplementary materials complements the main feature well, although the standard offering of just a trailer might feel sparse compared to other releases. The visuals are presented in 1080p resolution, maintaining clarity and giving potential viewers an enticing preview. For those seeking comprehensive coverage, detailed screenshots and additional perks are accessible via Patreon, adding value for dedicated fans and enthusiasts who wish to dive deeper into the film’s production nuances.
Extras included in this disc:
- Trailer: High-definition preview of "Vengeance: A Love Story" (02:26 in HD).
Movie: 41
"Vengeance: A Love Story" chronicles the harrowing ordeal of Teena Maguire (Anna Hutchinson) and her daughter Bethie (Talitha Bateman), whose lives are torn apart following a brutal assault. The narrative delves into their trauma and the ensuing miscarriage of justice, providing a poignant backdrop for Detective John Dromoor (Nicolas Cage) to embark on a revenge quest. The film, based on Joyce Carol Oates' novella "Rape: A Love Story," juxtaposes a stark portrayal of emotional devastation with a critique of the legal system. Despite the film's gritty premise, its execution is marred by character cliches and a somewhat mechanical performance from Cage, although Talitha Bateman's portrayal of the traumatized daughter adds genuine emotional depth.
Director Johnny Martin’s work, though brisk and action-packed, comes with its criticisms. The Niagara Falls setting, employed seemingly to enrich the plot, is actually largely shot in Georgia. This choice alongside an underused subtext of meth activity does not fully explore potential socioeconomic nuances. Unfortunately, the narrative over-indulges in Teena’s assault, leading to perceptions of exploitation rather than thoughtful examination. Key courtroom scenes intended to amplify the moral decay within the legal system trip over into implausibility, straining audience credulity and overshadowing potential character development.
In supporting roles, Don Johnson shines as an unscrupulous defense lawyer, though his screen time is regrettably limited. His character could have balanced the plot more effectively. The film's most significant flaw lies in its simplistic script and stereotypical villains, reducing complex human experiences to rote plot devices. While "Vengeance: A Love Story" attempts to carve out a niche in the revenge thriller genre, its potential is hampered by uninspired writing and missed opportunities for richer narrative exploration. Nevertheless, for those who can overlook these shortcomings, the film does deliver sporadic intense moments and succeeds in maintaining narrative tension through its runtime.
Total: 43
"Vengeance: A Love Story" is a mixed bag that brings interesting elements to the table but often falls short of its potential. Adapting Joyce Carol Oates' work, the film sacrifices much of its literary gravitas for a more exploitative tone, leading to uneven storytelling. Nicolas Cage delivers a lackluster performance, appearing almost zombie-like throughout, while Deborah Kara Unger and Talitha Bateman are commendable in their roles as the victimized mother and daughter. Unfortunately, the antagonists come across as cartoonishly evil, detracting from the realism the film aims to achieve.
From a technical perspective, the Blu-ray release is satisfactory but not exceptional. The video quality is adequate, capturing the film's gritty visuals with decent clarity and contrast. However, the audio presentation is disappointing, limited to only lossy formats. For audiophiles or those particular about sound quality, this could be a dealbreaker. The overall production values are modest, aligning well with a movie that bypassed theatrical release entirely.
In conclusion, "Vengeance: A Love Story" is an uneven experience with both commendable and lackluster elements. While the film does offer moments of compelling drama and decent performances from some cast members, it ultimately leans too heavily on exploitative tropes to resonate fully. Its technical presentation on Blu-ray also leaves room for improvement, particularly in the audio department. Potential viewers should weigh these factors before committing to a purchase.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 80
This is a perfectly competent looking presentation aside from some passing issues of banding, but the dour content and ostensible "realism" mean that there's not a lot of "wow" to the visuals....
Audio: 60
As I've repeatedly mentioned in other reviews of discs with only lossy audio, while there may be nothing inherently "wrong" with what's offered, I am still of the firm and unwavering belief that this far...
Extras: 10
...
Movie: 50
This film in a way might make for an interesting double feature with the long ago and now little remembered Hammer outing Never Take Candy from a Stranger, in that both films feature a plot based at least...
Total: 50
Vengeance: A Love Story has some interesting elements, but it may ultimately be too smarmy for its own good, discarding some of Oates' perceived literary reputation in favor of more exploitative and even...
DoBlu review by Christopher ZabelRead review here
Video: 60
The color palette has a neutral grading with excellent contrast and naturalistic flesh-tones....
Audio: 60
The surround mix has a lively combination of directional cues and strong channel separation in several action scenes....
Extras: 2
For an additional 20 Vengeance: A Love Story screenshots, early access to all screens (plus the 20,000+ already in our library), 75+ exclusive 4K UHD reviews, and more, support us on Patreon....
Movie: 40
His lawyer is the real villain in the film, not the mindlessly crude caricatures that sexually assault the woman and act like props to push the plot forward....
Total: 41
A rough tale of revenge for a brutally assaulted woman as her knight-in-shining armor delivers retribution....
Director: Johnny Martin
Actors: Nicolas Cage, Anna Hutchison, Talitha Eliana Bateman
PlotSet in a small town, the story follows single mother Teena, who endures a brutal sexual assault by a gang of men while her young daughter Bethie witnesses the horrific crime. Despite presenting compelling evidence against the assailants, Teena faces daunting challenges in bringing them to justice due to a corrupt legal system that heavily favors the perpetrators. Police detective John Dromoor, haunted by the injustice he sees and driven by his own sense of morality, decides to take matters into his own hands. He becomes a protector for Teena and her daughter, stepping in as a vigilante when the system fails them.
The narrative delves deeply into themes of justice, vengeance, and morality, highlighting Detective Dromoor’s internal struggle between adhering to the law and delivering the retribution he believes the assailants deserve. As the tension builds, Dromoor meticulously tracks down each of the attackers, confronting his own dark impulses along the way. The story leaves audiences questioning the very nature of justice and retribution, making it clear that not all battles are fought within the confines of a courtroom. The plot builds to a suspenseful climax where the true face of justice is finally revealed, leaving lasting questions about right and wrong.
Writers: John Mankiewicz, Joyce Carol Oates
Release Date: 15 Sep 2017
Runtime: 99 min
Rating: TV-MA
Country: United States
Language: English