Commitment Blu-ray Review
Score: 65
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
Commitment offers exciting action with heartfelt moments, strong video and audio quality, though falls short with subpar extras and inconsistent execution.
Disc Release Date
Video: 80
Commitment's Blu-ray boasts a pristine, high-definition AVC 1080p transfer with an aspect ratio of 2.39:1, delivering superb fine detail, rich colors despite a narrow palette, and stable black levels. The image clarity is only occasionally affected by artistic choices, making it a cinematic and expressive presentation.
Audio: 75
The Korean DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix on the Blu-ray of 'Commitment' delivers crystal-clear dialogue, dynamic range, precise imaging, and a balanced sonic experience. Action sequences benefit from immersive surround sound and robust LFE, offering a high-fidelity, high-impact audio presentation that impresses.
Extra: 21
Extras on the 'Commitment' Blu-ray are limited to a standard making-of featurette (SD, 10-11 mins) and an unremarkable theatrical trailer (HD, 1-2 mins); the content is relatively uninspired with little substantive insight from the cast.
Movie: 63
Commitment merges high school drama with the ferocity of a spy thriller, showcasing Choi Seung-hyun (T.O.P.) in a compelling role. Though marred by clichés and uneven narrative shifts, the film delivers expertly staged action sequences and solid performances. The Blu-ray enhances these elements with high-quality visuals and sound.
Video: 80
The video presentation of "Commitment" is an impressive display of Blu-ray quality, brought to us by Well Go USA with an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in a 2.39:1 aspect ratio. This release boasts remarkable visual fidelity, characterized by nearly flawless detail rendering and articulate textural nuances. Close-ups reveal intricate facial features and finely etched textural elements, ensuring a visually sharp and crisp experience. Despite the film being shot on a relatively modest budget, it exhibits a theatrical depth and scale that immerses viewers effectively, without any visible compression artifacts or noise.
Graphically, the film utilizes a somewhat monochromatic palette with frequent instances of a bluish tint. Nevertheless, this doesn't detract from the image’s vibrancy or saturation. Primary colors are rich and well delineated with oversaturation that adds vibrancy to the cinematic experience. The Blu-ray faithfully reproduces the intended tonal shifts, whether bold and vivid or more drab, as directed by the source material. Contrast levels are consistently strong across different lighting scenarios; brightly lit scenes and low-light sequences both benefit from stable black levels that maintain excellent balance and gradational precision. Flesh tones appear natural and varied among the cast, devoid of any unwanted color shifts or over-saturation.
In conclusion, "Commitment" on Blu-ray delivers a superior video experience that stands out for its high-definition clarity, color accuracy, and minimal artifacts. This video presentation offers a cinematic quality that belies the production’s smaller budget, making it an exemplary addition to any collection.
Audio: 75
The audio presentation of the "Commitment" Blu-ray, featuring a high-resolution DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix in both Korean and English dubbed versions, is a triumph of sonic fidelity and dynamic range. Opting for the original Korean track, listeners are rewarded with an immersive, action-packed experience where the dynamic range is noteworthy, rendering action sequences with powerful impact and energy. The surround mix masterfully integrates dialogue and explosive effects; dialogue is presented with crystal-clear intonation, full-bodied texture, and deep room penetration, ensuring that character interactions are always clear amidst the chaos. Imaging across the front soundstage is impeccable, offering precise integration of sound elements, while the rear channels contribute significantly to a three-dimensional auditory landscape.
The DTS-HD MA 5.1 mix excels in balancing the film’s dual sensibilities—its hard-hitting action sequences and its dialogue-heavy drama. The dialogue remains cleanly centered and occasionally enhanced by rear channels, providing added depth. This balance is perfectly struck without overshadowing either aspect of the film. The dynamic sound field accommodates high-volume action scenes with thunderous punch effects, gunshots, and explosions that fully utilize the low-frequency extension to impressive ends. The active engagement of rear channels envelops the listener, creating an atmospheric experience even during quieter moments, maintaining an immersive and exhilarating auditory environment.
Lastly, Commitment's sound design supports its thrilling narrative with a near-reference-quality surround sound presentation. The subwoofer channel shines during action set pieces, handling intense low-frequency requirements with aplomb, while the rear channels remain highly active throughout. Whether depicting bullet storms, speeding cars, or dramatic explosions, the surround sound presentation ensures the viewer is right in the midst of the action. Overall, Commitment’s audio track is meticulously crafted, offering a commanding, engaging experience that will undoubtedly satisfy audio enthusiasts and action fans alike.
Extras: 21
The extras on the Blu-ray release of "Commitment" offer limited supplementary content, which may leave viewers wanting more depth. The standard "Making Of" featurette runs approximately 10 to 11 minutes and presents a mix of interviews and behind-the-scenes footage in either SD or HD. However, it lacks significant insights, as the cast often contribute generic comments about the film and their roles. The theatrical trailer is also available in HD, spanning just over a minute, but fails to capture the more compelling aspects of the movie. Additionally, the disc contains previews for other Well Go USA titles.
Extras included in this disc:
- Making Of: A combination of interviews and making-of footage; standard and unremarkable content.
- Trailer: A brief and underwhelming preview of the film.
- Previews: Includes trailers for other Well Go USA titles such as "The Suspect," "Special ID," and "Confession of Murder."
Movie: 63
"Commitment," directed by Park Hong-soo, presents a compelling fusion of thriller dynamics and high school drama. The film follows Myung-hoon (Choi Seung-hyun, aka T.O.P), a North Korean teenager forced into espionage to save his sister, Hye-in (Han Ye-ri). As he embeds himself in a South Korean high school under the alias Kang Dae-ho, Myung-hoon navigates the dual pressures of maintaining his cover and executing his deadly missions.
The movie engages viewers with its intriguing premise—a North Korean spy caught in the throes of high school life, reminiscent of Peter Parker's dual identity while incorporating the visceral impact of "Bourne" franchises. The initial scenes, characterized by exhilarating high school conflicts and the development of an endearing romance with another Hye-in (Kim Yoo-jeong), render an energetic atmosphere akin to a "high-octane John Hughes film by way of Doug Liman." Unfortunately, as the narrative shifts towards a more standard spy thriller, focusing on South Korean intelligence closing in and North Korean assassins being dispatched, it loses some of its initial vibrancy.
Despite these tonal shifts, "Commitment" succeeds partly due to the strong performances, particularly by Choi Seung-hyun. His portrayal balances youthful vulnerability with lethal efficiency, making for an engaging protagonist. The action sequences are meticulously choreographed, providing a visual spectacle that compensates for the somewhat predictable spy plot. Thematically, the film explores significant concepts such as identity, loyalty, and survival within the context of geopolitical strife, though the latter part tends to meander into cliché territory. Overall, "Commitment" melds high school drama and spy thriller tropes into a uniquely watchable experience.
Total: 65
"Commitment" features a solid performance by T.O.P., capitalizing on his pop idol status to appeal to a diverse demographic, especially young women. The film skillfully blends heart-pounding action sequences with tender, romantic undertones, creating a unique balance that is not entirely successful but still commendable. The movie might remind keen viewers of a junior Bourne film, with lead actor Choi Seung-hyun delivering enough charm and emotional depth to make the plot's more intense moments feel authentic and engaging.
Technically, the Blu-ray release of "Commitment" is outstanding, boasting nearly flawless picture quality and superb sound design. These attributes enhance the viewing experience significantly and make up for the film's less convincing segments. The inclusion of early, compelling action sequences sets a strong pace, although the rest of the film doesn't always maintain this momentum. Despite some shortcomings in narrative execution, it remains an enjoyable watch for those seeking an action-packed diversion with an emotional twist.
In conclusion, "Commitment" on Blu-ray is a worthwhile addition to your collection, particularly if you appreciate dynamic action combined with heartfelt drama. While the extras are somewhat lackluster, the impeccable video and audio quality ensure an immersive viewing experience. It's recommended for a rental or purchase, especially if you're looking for engaging entertainment to pass the time.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
This digitally shot feature was evidently done on a relatively small budget, and that results in a somewhat monochromatic look some of the time, with several sequences taking place in unadorned settings...
Audio: 90
Commitment's lossless DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix (in the original Korean) provides a nicely bombastic sonic experience in the action sequences, with nicely placed foley effects immersing the listener...
Extras: 20
...
Movie: 60
The film has a good feel for action (including some expertly staged set pieces) and character, but it's never as visceral as it seems to be aiming for, though there's a stab at topicality when the impending...
Total: 70
Commitment is obviously trying to cash in on T.O.P.'s status in Korea as a pop idol, and while not completely successful, the film offers a nice mix of action and more heartfelt romantic underpinnings....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 100
Now, granted, much of the film leans toward the same color palette, but the typical bluish tint doesn't detract from anything else the image has to offer....
Audio: 80
Otherwise, the mix is fixated on presenting a commanding, hard-hitting action experience that punches up the sound effects and the score without overdoing it....
Extras: 20
– This is your standard Making of featurette with some interviewers interlaced with footage from the film....
Movie: 40
In this case, once the high school portion of the story has reached the point where it is actually compellng and could possibly lead to a story that works well beyond the mechanical parameters set in place...
Total: 60
Still, there is a handful of entertaining early sequences that capitalize on the film's basic conceit; it's just too bad the rest of the film doesn't follow suit....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 100
Detail rendering is nearly flawless with lucid visual acuity and fine articulation that brings forth lots of subtle detail in the images onscreen....
Audio: 90
Dynamic range is noteworthy which renders the film’s action based sequences with defining impact and energy....
Extras: 30
...
Movie: 80
While attending high school in the South, he meets another girl named Hye-in (KIM Yoo-jeong) and rescues her when she is attacked....
Total: 75
Sony Playstation 3 Blu-ray disc Player (HDMI Audio/Video) System Controller: Apple iPad/iRule Pro HD Universal Remote Control Canton "Ergo" Series speakers Axiom Audio QS8 Quadpolar speakers SV Sound PB-13...
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 80
Commitment had lots of depth and scale – the Blu-ray made me feel as if I was in the middle of it all....
Audio: 90
There’s a gentle stillness when no one is getting attacked or killed but once the action begins its beyond high-octane and the Blu-ray representation of that is stellar....
Extras: 20
It’s standard stuff as the actors talk about the characters they are playing and then switches to the “fly on the wall” portion as we see them performing their scenes....
Movie: 80
He also has to look out for both Hye-in’s and make sure that nothing happens to the both of them....
Total: 70
Commitment can almost be described as a junior Bourne film and Choi Seung-hyun carries enough charm and pent up sensibility to make it all seem plausible....
Director: Hong-soo Park
Actors: Choi Seung-hyun, Han Yeri, Yun Je-mun
PlotAfter his father, a North Korean spy, fails a mission and is accused of treason, Myung-hoon and his younger sister Hye-in are sent to a labor camp. In order to save his sister and redeem his family's honor, Myung-hoon agrees to become a spy himself. He is sent to South Korea, posing as a defector while attending high school. There, he meets Hye-in, a bullied girl of the same name as his sister, and becomes entangled in her plight while trying to fulfill his mission.
As Myung-hoon navigates his dual life, he is constantly watched by both North Korean operatives who distrust him and South Korean agents who suspect his true identity. Performing covert missions ordered by his superiors, he finds his determination strained by moral dilemmas and the growing bond with the South Korean Hye-in. Survival becomes increasingly uncertain as loyalty, betrayal, and survival clash, pulling Myung-hoon deeper into a labyrinthine power struggle.
Writers: Soo-young Kim
Release Date: 06 Dec 2013
Runtime: 113 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: South Korea
Language: Korean