Beauty and the Beast Blu-ray Review
La Belle et la B�te
Score: 62
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Christophe Gans’ 'Beauty and the Beast' offers impressive visuals and a solid Blu-ray presentation, though its storytelling feels shallow and lacks sincerity.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 69
Despite some cold and murky visuals early on, the 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 transfer of 'Beauty and the Beast' progressively enhances color saturation and clarity, especially in brighter, more detailed scenes. Blacks occasionally falter but improve as the film unfolds, offering substantial detail in costumes and settings.
Audio: 72
Beauty and the Beast's Blu-ray audio presentation impresses with DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 tracks in both French and English, showcasing clear dialogue, immersive atmospherics, and well-balanced low frequency extensions, especially during action scenes; however, English subtitles could be improved for a better viewing experience.
Extra: 33
Shout! Factory's Blu-ray for 'Beauty and the Beast' offers comprehensive extras, featuring 1080p interviews with director Christophe Gans, Vincent Cassel, and L�a Seydoux that cross cover topics from green screen work to fairytale themes, alongside a theatrical trailer and both DVD and Digital Copy formats.
Movie: 57
The 2014 French adaptation of 'Beauty and the Beast' by Christophe Gans impresses with its lush visuals, period-accurate costumes, and creative yet faithful blend of the original narrative, but falters in underdeveloped character arcs and an unconvincing central romance, leaving the film beautiful yet hollow.
Video: 69
The Blu-ray release of "Beauty and the Beast" boasts a 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 transfer in the 2.35:1 aspect ratio, offering an overall commendable visual presentation. The film utilizes a predominantly cold color scheme that is frequently contrasted by vivid reds, such as in rose petals and Belle's costumes. Early scenes appear unexpectedly dark and murky, presenting a slightly soft, faded look with dim contrast. However, as the narrative progresses and Belle enters the Beast's world, the image quality significantly improves with brighter and more saturated scenes, showcasing fine textures in ornate costumes and CG sets. Notable colors like blues, greens, and reds become more vibrant and striking.
Detail reproduction is high, particularly around the castle and various interiors where wood and stone textures are evident, though they lack the lifelike clarity of the finest transfers. The fur of the Beast and the fabric of Belle’s gowns demonstrate good detail. Depth is robust, with effective dimensional spacing and clean cinematic movements. Black levels present a mixed bag; while they improve as the film unfolds, early scenes suffer from a slightly grey appearance rather than true inky blacks. Light macroblocking is visible in certain areas, though no significant source or encoding issues are detected.
Skin tones maintain a slightly cool appearance throughout, with detailed renderings of stubble, scarring, and makeup in medium and close-up shots. The transfer retains an enchanting fairytale softness without sacrificing sharpness or clarity. Colors are consistently beautiful, with Belle’s gowns and various rich hues like the reds on roses looking particularly vivid. Overall, while some initial visual letdowns are present, the Blu-ray ultimately delivers a richly textured and satisfying viewing experience that accentuates "Beauty and the Beast's" elaborate production design.
Audio: 72
The Blu-ray audio presentation of "Beauty and the Beast" is marked by its dual DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 lossless soundtracks, available in both the original French and an English dubbed version. Both tracks are noteworthy for their clarity and depth, with a marginally superior spatial openness and richness in the French version. The audio exhibits notable low-end engagement, particularly during the film's dramatic moments like the opening sequence featuring crashing waves and an approaching storm. However, while the low frequencies are effectively rendered, they tend to lack the aggressive thump that some scenes demand.
Dialogues are impeccably reproduced and well-prioritized in both languages, making every whisper and growl distinctly audible, though synchronization naturally favors the French track. The sound design is intricate, with atmospheric effects such as blustery winds, reverberating dialogue within the castle, and subtle environmental noises effectively enhancing the immersive experience. Surround sound utilization is exemplary, with effects strategically placed to maximize spatial awareness, particularly with echoey voices expanding naturally to the rear speakers.
Furthermore, the score is beautifully balanced across the soundstage, albeit more front-focused than rear, ensuring an enjoyable auditory experience. Low-frequency effects perk up notably during climactic scenes, such as when giant statues spring to action, providing a satisfying sense of weight and impact. The ambiance consistently reflects a careful balance between sound effects, musical score, and vocals, resulting in a well-rounded and engaging 5.1 audio experience. This Blu-ray release ensures that "Beauty and the Beast" delivers a sumptuous sonic performance in both its available DTS-HD MA formats.
Extras: 33
Shout! Factory’s Blu-ray release of "Beauty and the Beast" presents a robust selection of extras that brilliantly explore the film’s production. All extras are in 1080p with DTS-HD MA 2.0 sound and come with English subtitles, ensuring an immersive viewing experience. Interviews with Director Christophe Gans offer an insightful look into the film’s all-ages appeal, fairytale origins, and green screen processes. Vincent Cassel discusses his familiarity with the story and the challenges of performing under a digital mask. Lea Seydoux shares her enthusiasm for fairy tales, her casting story, and the intricate costumes. The theatrical trailer provides a crisp preview with English DTS-HD MA 5.1 audio, neatly rounding off the supplementary content.
Extras included in this disc:
- Interview with Director Christophe Gans: Discussion on the film's themes, symbolism, and green screen work.
- Interview with Vincent Cassel: Insights on his role, digital mask, and green screen sets.
- Interview with Léa Seydoux: Commentary on her casting, fairy tale fondness, and costumes.
- Theatrical Trailer: A preview with dubbed English DTS-HD MA 5.1 audio.
Movie: 57
Christophe Gans' 2014 adaptation of "Beauty and the Beast" is a visually stunning film that remains closer to Gabrielle-Suzanne Barbot de Villeneuve's original tale than many previous versions. Léa Seydoux stars as Belle, whose family faces financial ruin, pushing them to live a simpler life in the countryside. Vincent Cassel portrays the Beast, with whom Belle trades her freedom for her father's. The film introduces deviations from the classic story, such as a subplot involving a magical golden deer and a unique interpretation of the Beast's servants.
Technically, the film excels in establishing a lush, fantastical world, filled with breathtaking visuals and elaborate costumes. The production design effectively balances between natural beauty and a decrepit yet hospitable environment. Despite its modest budget, the digital effects, including the depiction of the Beast and his wet fur, are commendably handled. However, some CGI elements, like over-the-top magical dog creatures, tend to appear less convincing and detract from the otherwise painterly aesthetic.
While the movie captures the spirit and setting of the tale beautifully, it falls short in its narrative execution, particularly in building a believable romance between Belle and the Beast. The script's focus on Belle discovering the Beast's past, involving another love interest, leaves little room to develop their connection. Seydoux and Cassel deliver strong performances despite limited material and an age gap that affects their on-screen chemistry. Ultimately, the relationship lacks the heartfelt evolution showcased in Disney’s animated classic, leaving viewers with an underdeveloped love story. Despite its shortcomings in narrative depth, Gans' rendition remains an engaging visual spectacle worth viewing for its artistic merit.
Total: 62
Christophe Gans’ adaptation of 'Beauty and The Beast' offers a visually impressive but ultimately mixed take on the timeless fairy tale. While the film excels in its inventive and colorful visuals, the storytelling can at times feel shallow and lacks depth, particularly in exploring the core relationship between its title characters. This can lead to moments that feel convenient for the plot rather than genuinely heartfelt. The Blu-ray release from Shout! Factory showcases a good video transfer and audio mix, preserving the film's striking visual and auditory elements effectively.
On the technical front, Shout! Factory's Blu-ray presentation demonstrates a solid commitment to quality. The video transfer is crisp, capturing the lush details of the film’s artistic production design. The audio mix succeeds in delivering a robust and immersive sound experience. While the Blu-ray does not overflow with extras, it includes insightful interviews with the director and actors, adding some valuable perspective on the production.
Though this adaptation may not become the definitive version of 'Beauty and The Beast', it offers enough charm and originality to appeal to some viewers, potentially garnering a niche fan base over time. For enthusiasts of the genre and those interested in different takes on classic tales, this version is worth adding to their collection. With strong technical merits and a few engaging extras, Shout! Factory’s Blu-ray release stands as a worthwhile acquisition despite its narrative shortcomings.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 70
Color springs to life in a few more evenly and naturally lit exteriors where costumes and vegetation stretch the palette, but expect a predominantly cold color scheme that's more thematically accentuating...
Audio: 80
Both are similar, with perhaps a sight edge to the French in terms of openness, depth, and overall clarity....
Extras: 40
...
Movie: 50
Belle's family is larger and more fleshed out in this version, keeping with the original story, while the "storming of the castle" will be familiar to Disney fans, albeit as the movie takes rather giant...
Total: 60
The film does a fair job on the surface, blending elements of the original tale and various filmed versions while making many parts its own, sometimes to good effect, sometimes to not-so-good effect....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Thankfully, once Belle enters The Beasts' fantastical world, clarity ramps up thanks to a several brighter and more saturated scenes, highlighting the fine textures in all of the ornate costumes and little...
Audio: 80
Surround use is also well implemented, bringing key effects to the rears, including echoey voices that naturally expand to the back speakers as the sound reverberates throughout the large castle....
Extras: 20
Interview with Lea Seydoux (HD, 9 min) – The actress elaborates on how she was cast, her love for fairy tales, the film's costumes, and special effects....
Movie: 60
With that said, The Beast's backstory is relatively engaging, but some of the script's embellishments of the original fairy tale feel unnecessary, overly complicated, and a little odd -- adding in extra...
Total: 60
This latest take on the classic story isn't likely to become anyone's new favorite, but this disc is still worth a look....
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 90
Greens, whites and yellow all had good pull while an overall blue filter look to a many parts of the film holds strong....
Audio: 90
Effects and ambiance carry a distinct, well rounded sound that is carefully displayed throughout every channel....
Extras: 50
She talks her fandom of the Cocteau and Disney films and goes on to celebrate working with Vincent Cassel, the challenges of technology, her gowns in the film and the enjoyment of being in a cross-generational...
Movie: 70
You’ll have to see for yourself, but its a rather well put together sequence that feels pretty large and brings a sense of intensity around a group of characters you could care less of what their fates...
Total: 70
The extras give you a bit of static interviews with the director and actors, but they give colorful enough answers for it to be worthwhile....
Director: Christophe Gans
Actors: Vincent Cassel, Léa Seydoux, André Dussollier
PlotIn a distant land, a widowed merchant loses his fortune when his ship is wrecked in a storm. Desperate, he moves his six children to a modest country home. One day, he stumbles upon a magnificent castle hidden in the forest, where he discovers abundant riches and a garden filled with beautiful roses. Taking one rose for his daughter Belle, the merchant is confronted by the castle's owner, a fearsome Beast. As retribution for the theft, the Beast demands that the merchant return or send one of his daughters to live in the castle. Belle, feeling responsible, decides to sacrifice herself and takes her father's place.
At the castle, Belle soon discovers that the Beast, though terrifying in appearance, is cursed and lives a solitary life, bound by his past sins. Gradually, she uncovers the enchanted world within the castle and learns more about the Beast's tragic history through vivid dreams and conversations with the enigmatic creature. The bond between Belle and the Beast grows stronger as they navigate their complex emotions and hidden secrets. As Belle's compassion begins to bring light to the Beast's dark existence, she faces challenges that test her courage and resolve. Ultimately, the journey reveals truths about forgiveness, love, and transformation.
Writers: Sandra Vo-Anh, Christophe Gans, Jeanne-Marie Leprince de Beaumont
Release Date: 23 Sep 2016
Runtime: 112 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: France, Germany, Spain
Language: French, English