Our Town Blu-ray Review

The Blu-ray release of "Our Town," presented in an AVC encoded 1080p transfer at a 1.33:1 aspect ratio, represents a significant restoration achievement by ClassicFlix. Utilizing elements preserved at the Library of Congress, with a notable use of a 35mm fine grain element and a 35mm master positive print for reel 6, the restoration remedies the previously muddy, difficult-to-view condition of past versions. A comprehensive cleanup involved removing millions of dirt instances, reducing flicker, and correcting stains and severe warping, resulting in remarkable image stabilization.

Contrast improvement is a standout feature, replacing milky past nuances with convincingly deep blacks and well-balanced grayscale tones. Details are favorably enhanced, bringing out the film's almost Expressionist framings, attributed to Bert Glennon and possibly influenced by Production Designer William Cameron Menzies. While some slight moments appear anamorphically squeezed, they are barely noticeable and may be more perceptual than actual. Grain fluctuations are present but managed without significant resolution issues, maintaining clarity and consistent grain structure across different source elements.

Ultimately, this Blu-ray release delivers the most faithful presentation to date, overcoming significant age-related wear evident in past editions. Film grain, fine details, and grayscale reproduction are markedly improved. Minor residual damage instances, such as scratches and warping, are minimized. This marks a definitive upgrade from previous public domain video releases, promising audiences an unparalleled viewing experience of Thorton Wilder's classic.

The audio presentation of the "Our Town" Blu-ray is anchored by a DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 Mono track, capturing the essence of Aaron Copland’s Oscar-nominated score and the film's original soundtrack. The dialog is delivered with clarity, effectively rendering the unique sound elements such as the crickets in the opening Stage Manager monologue. Despite these strengths, the track is not without its flaws; there exist instances of distortion, including noticeable crackling, popping, and occasional hissing, which may detract from the listener’s experience.

While these imperfections are apparent throughout the presentation, they do little to overshadow the improvements made over previous public domain DVD releases. The quality of this Blu-ray release surpasses those earlier offerings significantly, presenting what is likely the best rendition of the film's soundtrack available for home viewing. It captures the historically significant elements of the audio while maintaining an authenticity that remains faithful to the original material.

The Blu-ray extras for "Our Town" provide a compelling exploration of the film's historical and cultural context. The audio commentary by Ray Faiola offers an in-depth analysis of the film’s production and origins, enriching the viewer's understanding of the material. Complementing this are two distinct radio adaptations. The Campbell Playhouse production, featuring Orson Welles and associates from the Mercury Theatre, is notable for its historical significance and theatrical rendering. Meanwhile, the Lux Radio Theatre adaptation captures the essence of the cinematic release with its original cast reprising their roles. Additionally, a rare 1953 interview with Thornton Wilder provides further insight into the playwright’s influences and thoughts. For further appreciation, a brief restoration comparison showcases the meticulous efforts undertaken to preserve this classic work. These supplements, coupled with trailers for other releases, form a rich tapestry of extras that enhance the viewer's experience.

Extras included in this disc:

• Audio Commentary by Ray Faiola: Insightful examination of the film’s production and its connections to the original play.
• Thornton Wilder Interview with Lilli Palmer: A 1953 conversation on Lope de Vega's influences.
• The Campbell Playhouse Radio Version: Pre-release adaptation led by Orson Welles.
• The Lux Radio Theatre Version: Film cast revisits roles in promotional broadcast.
• Restoration Comparison: Demonstrates restoration efforts.
• ClassicFlix Trailers: Previews for additional releases.

The cinematic adaptation of "Our Town," directed by Sam Wood, provides a compelling interpretation of Thornton Wilder's classic play. Set in the quintessential small town of Grover’s Corners, the production deftly portrays early 20th-century life and examines profound themes of love, life, and loss through the entwined stories of George Gibbs and Emily Webb. The screenplay, co-adapted by Wilder himself, maintains the original's metatheatrical characteristics while the introduction of physical sets adds a new dimension. Willy Wilder and cinematographer Bert Glennon contribute to this visual transition with their exemplary work, while Aaron Copland's score underpins the film's emotional resonance. Notably, Wood's direction successfully balances the theatrical origins with cinematic expression, further evidenced by four Academy Award nominations, including Best Picture.

The film benefits from its stellar cast, many reprising their stage roles, providing not only continuity but poignant performances. Martha Scott stands out with her portrayal of Emily Webb, earning an Oscar nomination. William Holden, early in his career yet delivering one of his most sincere performances, impeccably depicts George Gibbs. Supporting actors like Fay Bainter and Thomas Mitchell, as George's parents, alongside Beulah Bondi and Guy Kibbee as Emily’s parents, enrich the narrative with depth and authenticity. Frank Craven's role as the Stage Manager bridges the narrative seamlessly from stage to screen.

Ultimately, this adaptation strikes a delicate balance between authenticity to its source and cinematic innovation. While some purists might prefer Wilder’s original stage conclusion, the film's altered ending arguably serves its new medium well. The production not only represents a significant achievement in Sam Wood’s directorial career but remains a noteworthy contribution to American film heritage, capturing the melancholic beauty and meta-nature of Wilder's vision.

ClassicFlix’s Blu-ray release of "Our Town" revitalizes this classic American theater piece, offering much-needed attention to a film that has long been undeservedly neglected in the home theater space. The transfer to HD is commendable, ensuring the film's cinematography shines with clarity and detail that does justice to the careful artistry of its original production. Visuals are broadly superior to audio, though the audio track remains faithfully restored. This release corrects past oversights, making it a worthy acquisition for collectors and enthusiasts alike.

The supplementary materials elevate the value of this edition, enriching the viewing experience with insightful extras. Notably, the inclusion of two radio adaptations adds historical depth and context, enhancing appreciation of Wilder’s enduring narrative. These features reflect a thoughtful effort by ClassicFlix to respect and preserve the cultural significance of "Our Town," validating its esteemed place in theatrical and film history.

In conclusion, ClassicFlix has succeeded in honoring "Our Town" with a Blu-ray presentation that balances technical robustness with historical fidelity. This edition stands out not only for its superior visual restoration but also for its carefully curated special features, making it arguably one of the standout Blu-ray releases of 2023. It is an essential upgrade for anyone with previous home video versions and an excellent addition to any classic film library. Recommended without reservation.