I Love You Phillip Morris Blu-ray Review
Score: 59
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
'I Love You Phillip Morris' shines with Jim Carrey's hilarious performance and solid video quality, though bonus features are lacking; still recommended for fans.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 57
I Love You Phillip Morris presents a 1080p AVC transfer with notable clarity, excellent detail, and vibrant primary colors. However, the film suffers from inconsistent contrast, murky blacks in some scenes, and a generally flat appearance, making it a mixed but adequate viewing experience on Blu-ray.
Audio: 67
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix for 'I Love You Phillip Morris' offers a nuanced, immersive listening experience with well-balanced channel separation and clear dialogue, especially in quieter scenes. While it lacks blockbuster-level surround activity, it effectively uses ambient effects and selective LFE to enhance this character-driven dramedy.
Extra: 46
The Blu-ray extras for 'I Love You Phillip Morris' feature an engaging audio commentary with in-depth technical insights on cinematography and lighting, a standard 'Making of' featurette with interviews and behind-the-scenes footage, a collection of extended scenes adding minimal value, and a set of eclectic trailers.
Movie: 61
“I Love You Phillip Morris” on Blu-ray delivers a compelling mix of humor and drama, with Jim Carrey excelling as the charming yet deceptive Steven Jay Russell. Directed by Glenn Ficarra and John Requa, the film masterfully balances outrageous comedy with tender romance despite occasional narrative disjointedness.
Video: 57
The Blu-ray presentation of "I Love You Phillip Morris" delivers an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in a 1.78:1 aspect ratio that yields mixed reactions. On the positive side, the film features an impressively vibrant and candy-colored palette. The saffron hues of the Texas prison scenes are particularly striking and beautifully saturated, while the hues shift to cooler pastels when the setting moves to Miami. Such nuanced color grading adds depth and variety to the viewing experience. The image quality itself is sharp and detailed, offering a natural grain structure and excellent contrast. Even challenging textures like fishnet stockings are rendered without aliasing or other artifacts. However, there are moments when the image appears slightly dark, notably in some dimly lit bedroom scenes, likely for content sensitization.
Despite these attributes, the transfer has some drawbacks that prevent it from being exceptional. Firstly, while facial complexions appear healthy with revealing textures in close-ups, contrast levels seem inconsistent overall. Shadow details suffer in multiple interior scenes, resulting in blacks that occasionally look murky or dark gray rather than deep black. While daylight exteriors are handled well with great clarity and resolution, some scenes appear flatter and less dynamic due to weaker contrast levels, which contributes to a generally dull appearance at times. Additionally, there are occasional moments when the image does not match the high level of detail exhibited in other parts of the film.
In summary, while the Blu-ray’s video quality of "I Love You Phillip Morris" boasts vibrant colors and good clarity, it is marred by inconsistencies in contrast and shadow detail, making it an overall decent but not exceptional transfer.
Audio: 67
The audio presentation of "I Love You Phillip Morris" on Blu Ray is crafted through a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix that, while not overly bombastic, provides an engaging and well-balanced auditory experience suitable for its genre. The front soundstage is notably wide with commendable channel separation and smooth panning effects, facilitating clear and intelligible dialogue, particularly capturing the Southern drawls of the leads with remarkable clarity. The mix achieves a delicate balance between ambient effects, such as chirping birds and the bustling sounds of prison halls, contributing significantly to the atmosphere without overpowering the more nuanced, quieter moments.
Despite its character-driven narrative, which necessitates a focus on dialogue, the mix doesn't falter in providing some immersive elements. Chase sequences and occasional jolts of low-frequency effects, like the impactful car crash scene, are executed with finesse, ensuring that the less frequent action sequences feel dynamic and engaging. The environmental effects across various scenes are subtle yet effective, enhancing the listening experience by providing a touch of realism and directionality.
While the mid-range frequencies remain clean and expansive, they are reservedly utilized, maintaining appropriateness for a dramedy rather than pushing towards blockbuster territory. Similarly, while the bass frequencies do not dominate the sound field, they are responsive and effectively used to support the broader soundscape. Overall, the audio mix is articulate and immersive without drawing unnecessary attention to itself, making it a fitting accompaniment to the film's character-focused storytelling.
Extras: 46
The Blu-ray edition of "I Love You Phillip Morris" offers a concise but informative collection of extras that enhance the viewing experience for fans and those intrigued by filmmaking. The feature commentary, led by writers/directors Glenn Ficarra and John Requa along with producers Andrew Lazar and Far Shariat, chief lighting technician Max Pomerleau, and director of photography Xavier Pérez Grobet, provides rich insights into the technical aspects of production, specifically cinematography and lighting. The behind-the-scenes featurette delivers standard interviews and glimpses into the origin and development of the story. The deleted scenes compilation, albeit limited in scope, includes slightly extended takes and an unnecessary storm sequence. Trailers for the film and other titles round out the extras.
Extras included in this disc:
- Feature Commentary: Discusses cinematography and lighting extensively.
- The Making of: French-produced featurette with interviews and behind-the-scenes footage.
- Deleted Scenes: Collection of extended scenes.
- Trailers: Assortment of film trailers.
Movie: 61
'I Love You Phillip Morris' masterfully navigates the boundary between comedy and drama, presenting an astonishing yet true story that defies the expectations of a con artist's life. Directed by Glenn Ficarra and John Requa, the film introduces Steven Jay Russell (Jim Carrey), a former Georgia cop who, after coming out as gay post-accident, embarks on a life of crime. Russell's astonishing versatility in impersonating multiple professionals and his relentless prison escapes evoke parallels with 'Catch Me If You Can'. The Texas setting adds a stark contrast, making Russell's escapades even more remarkable against the backdrop of one of America's strictest legal systems.
The film's success lies notably in its nuanced performances and the delicate handling of its unique narrative. Jim Carrey delivers one of his most riveting performances, balancing Russell's inherent sweetness with his deceptive nature, while Ewan McGregor shines as Phillip Morris, Russell's innocent and endearing lover. Despite some narrative disjointedness and tonal shifts—from laugh-out-loud comedy to poignant drama—the film retains a captivating quality throughout. The characters' devotion, set within the confines of a chaotic prison environment, imbues the story with surprising tenderness and emotional depth, making even outlandish scenarios feel vivid and touching.
Technically, this Blu-ray presentation by Lions Gate Films features solid visuals and sound quality, capturing the film's colorful aesthetics and dynamic soundtrack authentically. While the film may have undergone significant post-production edits for viewer accessibility, which occasionally results in a fragmented flow, it nevertheless successfully conveys the essence of Steven's outlandish escapades and enduring love story. Ultimately, 'I Love You Phillip Morris' entertains through its unpredictable blend of humor and heart, driven by charismatic performances that turn an unbelievable true story into a genuinely moving cinematic experience.
Total: 59
"I Love You Phillip Morris" presents a unique blend of dark comedy and heartfelt romance, crafted meticulously by directors Glenn Ficarra and John Requa, known for their work on 'Bad Santa.' Jim Carrey delivers an outstanding performance as the real-life con artist Steven Jay Russell, capturing both the manic energy and deep affection his character holds for Phillip Morris, portrayed tenderly by Ewan McGregor. The chemistry between Carrey and McGregor is palpable, adding depth to the film's humorous yet melancholic narrative.
The Blu-ray release showcases a commendable video presentation, with sharp detail and vibrant colors that enhance the viewing experience. The audio quality is fine, providing clear dialogue and an engaging soundscape that complements the film's dynamic scenes. However, the bonus features are somewhat lacking, offering minimal insight into the production process and behind-the-scenes content that fans of the genre typically appreciate.
"I Love You Phillip Morris" manages to rise above its disjointed structure through its inherent sweetness and the compelling performances of its lead actors. Despite its flaws, the film maintains an endearing quality that makes it worth watching. The blend of humor and melancholy, driven by a fascinating real-life story, results in a movie that resonates emotionally. Highly recommended for those who enjoy offbeat comedies with a touch of pathos.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
But even if the saffron hues of that extended segment are beautifully saturated and very memorable, the entire film is candy colored and very bright, offering a nice variety of solid primary colors as...
Audio: 90
The fact is, for such a character-driven story, there are surprising amounts of admittedly subtle surround activity, including lots of nice environmental effects in various outdoor scenes, and good use...
Extras: 60
Because of the participation of Grobet and Pomerleau, this is a really fascinating track that discusses lighting and cinematography more than they usually are in such commentaries....
Movie: 70
Already obviously caught up, at least in certain ways, in a life of deceit and subterfuge, Russell decided to leave his wife and child and pursue an openly gay lifestyle, a lifestyle which is in the film...
Total: 70
I Love You Phillip Morris' inherent sweetness elevates it above the faults of its disjointed final version, as well as the somewhat formless approach the filmmakers take toward a fascinating real life...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
Overall, the video comes with many positives, but it's not all hunky-dory from beginning to end....
Audio: 80
The mid-range is clean and expansive, though it never seems to be pushed very far except for a couple, minor action sequences....
Extras: 40
The Making of (1080i/60, 12 min) — With behind-the-scenes footage sprinkled throughout, this is a typical EPK piece that shows cast and crew talking extensively on the characters, the story's real-life...
Movie: 60
Next logical step, I suppose, would be portraying an out-of-the-closet con artist that makes no secret about his lifestyle, but remains somewhat of a laughing matter through most of the dramedy....
Total: 60
Overall, it's a good package for fans and recommended for those wanting to enjoy a bizarre comedy based on the story of real-life con artist Steven Jay Russell....
Director: Glenn Ficarra, John Requa
Actors: Jim Carrey, Ewan McGregor, Leslie Mann
PlotSteven Russell is a seemingly average married man living in Virginia, working as a police officer. However, a car accident leads him to a significant self-realization: he is gay. Embracing his true identity, Steven leaves his wife and embarks on a flamboyant lifestyle that he finances through prolific and elaborate cons. His criminal activities eventually land him in prison, where he meets the love of his life, Phillip Morris. Steven's devotion to Phillip is unyielding, and he goes to extraordinary lengths to be with him.
In prison, Steven continues using his con artist skills to manipulate the system and make life easier for Phillip. His ingenuity knows no bounds, resulting in multiple daring and clever escapes. Throughout their turbulent relationship, Steven's relentless pursuit of freedom and happiness for Phillip illustrates his deep, albeit unconventional, love. As Steven’s schemes grow increasingly audacious, their consequences become more severe, leading to a dramatic turning point that profoundly impacts both men's lives.
Writers: John Requa, Glenn Ficarra, Steve McVicker
Release Date: 07 Jan 2011
Runtime: 98 min
Rating: R
Country: France, United States
Language: English, Spanish