Thieves Like Us Blu-ray Review

The Blu-ray presentation of "Thieves Like Us" maintains the film's original 1.85:1 aspect ratio through an AVC encoded image, crafted meticulously to reflect the cinematographic decisions made by Jean Boffety. The 1080p/AVC-MPEG-4 encoded transfer superbly portrays the muted, period-minded color palette intended by the filmmakers, with skin tones appearing secure and natural. While fine detail is generally consistent, the use of diffusion techniques, such as shooting through rain and glass, results in many scenes where objects lack sharp outlines, fitting seamlessly into the artistic vision of the era's depiction.

The visual presentation stands out in terms of grain structure, which remains prominently evident, particularly against lighter or grayer backdrops such as the skies in the opening scene. Despite some occasional noisy qualities in the grain, the image remains stable, and key details emerge distinctly in close-ups, especially highlighting Robert Duvall's unique facial features. Black levels are well defined and contribute to a strong contrast, noticeable in scenes like Chicamaw's hair against darker backgrounds or in dynamically lit environments where shadow and light interplay harmoniously, as seen during Keechie's bath scene.

In terms of minor issues, the transfer does exhibit some minor speckling and rough patches within the print. Additionally, slight banding may be perceived around exposed light sources, though this does not significantly detract from the overall viewing experience. Location specifics and landscape hues—like the green fields of Mississippi—are rendered with precision, thereby preserving the film’s authentic feel and demonstrating the quality and care invested in this Blu-ray release.

The Blu-ray presentation of "Thieves Like Us" features a 2.0 DTS-HD MA sound mix that brings a balanced auditory experience to the film. The mix doesn’t demand much dynamically, as it predominantly features silences and diegetic audio, such as radio recordings. Dialogue clarity is a focal point; however, it does experience some distortive highs during emotionally charged exchanges. The ambient sounds effectively reflect small-town life and rural environment, offering a grounding sense of place. The audio excels in maintaining the sharpness and impact of sudden violent events, such as gunshots.

This DTS-HD 2.0 Mono track delivers dialogue with precision and ensures that the spoken words are consistently clear. A distinguishing feature of the soundtrack is its use of period-appropriate radio broadcasts instead of a traditional score. These broadcasts, while authentically enhancing the narrative context, occasionally present anachronistic auditory qualities, like modern clarity or aged hiss, which can be slightly jarring. The track showcases a commendable dynamic range, adeptly capturing the delicate nuances of scenes such as crackling fires and juxtaposing them against the potent bursts of gunfire.

The Blu-ray extras for "Thieves Like Us" offer a commendable enhancement to an already classic film. Presented with a high degree of professionalism, these extras deepen the viewer's understanding and appreciation of the film's production processes. The key feature is the director's commentary by Robert Altman, recorded in 1997, which provides comprehensive insights into all stages of the film’s production. This commentary is both engaging and informative, reflecting Altman's unique perspective and creative process. Additionally, the inclusion of a short but impactful theatrical trailer offers a nostalgic glimpse into the film’s original marketing strategy.

Extras included in this disc:

• Commentary: Recorded in 1997 for a DVD release, director Robert Altman shares detailed insights covering all stages of film production.
• Theatrical Trailer: A 2-minute standard definition trailer, providing a nostalgic look at the film's original promotional material.

Robert Altman's "Thieves Like Us" is an intricate adaptation of Edward Anderson’s 1937 novel, offering a subdued yet authentic portrayal of Depression-era bank robbers. Starring Keith Carradine, John Schuck, and Bert Remsen, the film shifts focus from action-packed heists to the quieter, more human moments of its characters' lives. Altman's commitment to authenticity is evident in the meticulous attention to period-specific details such as radio broadcasts and the prevalent Southern culture, which help ground the narrative in its historical context. However, the film’s slow pace and fragmented structure can make it feel drawn out at times, intensifying the viewer’s immersion in the mundane aspects of the robber's lives.

Character development is a cornerstone here, allowing viewers to delve into the psychological and emotional states of these outlaws. While the movie includes some elements of action, such as bank robberies and jailbreaks, much of this takes place offscreen. Notably, a sequence involving a car accident where Bowie (Carradine) receives care from Keechie (Shelley Duvall) stands out for conveying profound emotional depth. Unfortunately, some technical glitches—like flawed sound synchronization during a pivotal romantic scene with a Shakespearean play on the radio—detract from its otherwise technically sound presentation.

Distinctly unromantic in its portrayal of crime, "Thieves Like Us" eschews the glamorization often seen in the genre. Secondary characters as Chicamaw (Schuck), portrayed with menacing undertones, reinforce this grim realism. Shelly Duvall's Keechie is especially poignant; her unease and desire for a normal life underscore the uncertainty and danger inherent in their outlaw existence. The film has a methodical pace that contrasts sharply with the frenetic energy of other crime dramas, creating an experience that is atmospherically rich but demands patience.

Kino Lorber's Blu-ray release of "Thieves Like Us" offers a meticulous high-definition presentation that stays true to the film's quiet, calculated aesthetic. The transfer is commendable, preserving the film-like qualities with a clear visual integrity that captures the nuances of the era depicted onscreen. The audio, while not groundbreaking, delivers clear dialogue, ensuring that Altman's intended subtleties in speech and sound are well-maintained.

However, it is essential to acknowledge that "Thieves Like Us," consistent with much of Robert Altman's oeuvre, demands a patient viewer. Its pacing can be considered glacial, with an almost punishing lack of traditional drama. Yet, for those willing to engage at its methodical speed, the film provides a rich period experience that transcends mere entertainment. This Blu-ray release serves both as a worthwhile collectible for Altman enthusiasts and as an immersive time capsule for cinephiles interested in deeper dives into American lawlessness and societal shifts.

Despite its inherent challenges, "Thieves Like Us" offers considerable rewards for those who persevere. Provided with a high-definition presentation and the unique opportunity to hear Altman discuss his work, this release stands as a respectable enhancement to one's film collection. Kino Lorber's effort in bringing this film to Blu-ray merits recommendation.

Like much of Altman's filmography, "Thieves Like Us" is best approached as a movie to be studied, not necessarily enjoyed. It's glacial, punishingly so at times, but it offers much to a viewer willing to match its speed, taking a time machine ride back to an era of lawlessness and approaching change to the American way.