If You Are the One Blu-ray Review
非誠勿擾 Fēi Ch�ng W� Rǎo
Score: 54
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
With stunning cinematography and a fluid Dolby TrueHD 7.1 surround track, 'If You Are the One' offers a refreshing romantic comedy alternative, despite limited extras.
Disc Release Date
Video: 65
If You Are the One" in 2.35:1 with MPEG-4 AVC boasts a rich, bold color palette and stellar contrast ratios, enhancing cityscapes and scenic shots though occasionally over-saturated. The 1080p transfer ensures clarity and detail despite some softness, with virtually no compression artifacts or print damage.
Audio: 60
The Dolby TrueHD 7.1 track of 'If You Are the One' offers crystal clear dialogue and impressive front separation but is underutilized with minimal surround activity, making the Dolby Digital 5.1 track a competitive alternative for this largely dialogue-driven film.
Extra: 11
The Blu-ray of 'If You Are the One' disappoints with minimal extras, offering only two trailers encoded in MPEG-4 AVC, 1080p, for 'If You Are the One' and 'Look for a Star'.
Movie: 76
Feng Xiaogang's 'If You Are the One' employs expert cinematography, refined editing, and compelling performances to tell an elegantly familiar tale of two damaged souls finding love, framed by the beauty of Hokkaido and a seamless blend of comedy and drama.
Video: 65
The video presentation of "If You Are The One" on Blu-ray comes encoded in MPEG-4 AVC with a 1080p transfer, maintaining its original 2.35:1 aspect ratio. The color palette is bold and lush, evident in the deep purples of the Buddhist temple, the gold walls of the investor's apartment, and the vibrant greens of the foliage, as well as in more subtle hues like the pale upholstery in cafes and bars. Skin tones are rendered accurately across ethnic variations. The contrast ratio is notably strong, with solid blacks and well-preserved shadow details, particularly in night scenes. Clarity is high, though not exemplary as some scenes exhibit mild softness, preventing it from achieving reference-level sharpness. The print remains in near-perfect condition, with negligible instances of print damage and no compression artifacts detected throughout.
The cinematography by Lu Yue shines with impressive cityscapes and scenic shots of Asian countryside, providing a distinctive warm color-palette that mirrors the film's tone. Though the brighter outdoor scenes at times appear over-saturated, the overall color scheme remains rich and natural. Details are generally pleasing but fall short of the pinnacle set by top reference Blu-ray transfers. Importantly, macro-blocking and edge-enhancement are not concerns, and there are no visible signs of artificial sharpening. The subtitles are well-embedded and easily readable. Despite the occasional softness, the Blu-ray offers numerous moments of high-definition glory, particularly during facial close-ups. Moreover, this Blu-ray release is Region-Free, making it accessible on various players regardless of geographical location.
Audio: 60
The audio presentation of "If You Are the One" on Blu-ray boasts three tracks: Mandarin Dolby TrueHD 7.1, Mandarin Dolby Digital 5.1, and Cantonese Dolby Digital 5.1. The primary track, Mandarin Dolby TrueHD 7.1, offers a high-fidelity experience, although its full potential seems somewhat underutilized due to the film’s predominantly dialogue-centric nature. The clarity of the dialogue is impeccable, facilitating effortless comprehension throughout the film. However, rear channel activity is scant, with notable immersiveness occurring mainly during specific sequences like the rain scene in Hokkaido and ambient effects during the badminton training. Front separation is commendable, adding spatial depth particularly with directional sound effects such as bubbling springs.
The soundtrack significantly contributes to the auditory experience, ensuring a full-bodied soundstage that compensates for the dialogue-driven format. While orchestral and Asian pop elements paint distinct moods for major scenes, the sound design remains predominantly front-centered with occasional score bleed into surround channels. The score exhibits remarkable power and tonal balance, with notable bass and treble presence. The blend of laid-back 80's style tunes interspersed with solid bongo layers and violins exemplifies meticulous sound engineering.
Comparatively, the Mandarin Dolby Digital 5.1 track, although strong and competitive, lacks the depth and fluidity of the TrueHD 7.1 track. The 5.1 track, while adequate for the film’s needs, does not capture the same dynamic range or immersive quality, particularly in music-intensive scenes. Overall, despite some underutilization of surround capabilities, the Mandarin Dolby TrueHD 7.1 track provides a richly detailed and clear audio presentation that aligns well with the film's narrative focus, albeit a 5.1 track might have sufficed for this release.
Extras: 11
The Blu-ray of "If You Are the One" is disappointingly sparse in terms of supplementary content. The only extras available are two trailers. Despite this, the technical quality of these trailers is commendable, encoded in MPEG-4 AVC at 1080p resolution, showcasing clear and vibrant visuals. While the lack of additional features is a notable downside, the high-definition quality of the trailers provides a small consolation.
Extras included in this disc:
- Trailer for 'If You Are the One': High-definition preview of the main feature.
- Trailer for 'Look For A Star': High-definition preview for another film.
Movie: 76
Xiaogang Feng's "If You Are the One" is a masterful blend of romantic comedy and poignant drama, encapsulating the emotional journey of two individuals seeking closure from their haunting pasts. The narrative follows Qin Fen, a middle-aged entrepreneur on a quest for genuine love through online dating, and Smiley, a heartbroken flight attendant yearning to forget an unfulfilled relationship. The film's premise, while familiar, is elevated by its sincere storytelling and the undeniable chemistry between Ge You and Shu Qi. Their portrayal of two seemingly incompatible individuals finding solace in each other's company is both engaging and endearing.
Technically, "If You Are the One" is a visual delight. The Blu-ray release showcases the film with stunning clarity, reinforcing its vibrant color palette and meticulous attention to detail. Lu Yue's cinematography stands out, particularly his breathtaking capture of Hokkaido, which adds a layer of depth to the film's narrative. The blend of comedy and drama is seamless, thanks in part to Liu Miaomiao's expert editing, which maintains a fluid transition between the film's varied emotional beats. Additionally, the Blu-ray edition is English-friendly and region-free, making it accessible to a wider audience.
In summary, "If You Are the One" does not traverse new ground within the romantic comedy genre but distinguishes itself through its authentic portrayal of love and loss. The film benefits immensely from Feng's narrative structure, employing flashbacks that delve into the characters' pasts, thereby enhancing their credibility and relatability. Each aspect of production, from the refined cinematography to the adept editing, contributes to creating a visually captivating and emotionally resonant experience. The Blu-ray release is an excellent medium to appreciate these technical merits, ensuring that audiences receive a high-quality viewing experience.
Total: 54
If You Are the One, in Blu-ray format, delivers a solid presentation that effectively captures the visual and emotional essence of this romantic comedy. The video quality is notable, showcasing impressive cinematography with vibrant colors and sharp clarity in close-up shots. While there are occasional moments of softness, the overall presentation remains pleasing to the eye. The contrast levels are well-managed, and the picture quality maintains a natural aesthetic that complements the film's picturesque backdrops.
The audio presentation excels, featuring a meticulously engineered Dolby TrueHD 7.1 surround track. This creates an immersive listening experience, despite being somewhat constricted by the limitations of the original source material. The dialogue is clear and well-balanced with the musical score, providing a cohesive sonic environment that enhances the storytelling. However, audiophiles may note that it lacks the dynamic range found in more recent high-budget releases.
Unfortunately, this Blu-ray edition falls short in its supplementary content, offering only a couple of trailers. This lack of extras is a minor drawback but does not overshadow the merits of the primary video and audio quality.
The video presentation is at times impressive with some stunning cinematography. There are moments of softness throughout but the colour palette and clarity of facial close-ups make up for these shortcomings. The audio presentation, while boasting a very fluid and well engineered Dolby TrueHD 7.1 surround track, is somewhat limited by the source material.The extras are where this presentation falls down with only a couple of trailers available.
With strong video and audio presentations this movie comes recommended to those looking for a refreshing romantic comedy alternative to Western Cinema offerings.
avforums review by AVForumsRead review here
Video: 80
The level of detail, while never reaching reference levels, is very acceptable throughout and really enhances some of the more scenic shots....
Audio: 70
As a largely dialogue driven presentation there is relatively little or no surround activity, aside from score bleed, in the majority of the scenes....
Extras: 10
All we've got here are two trailers; one for 'If You Are The One' and one for 'Look For A Star'...
Movie: 70
Xiaogang Feng continues his string of hits with 'If You Are The One', a charming tale of true love involving two people who are striving to forget their past....
Total: 70
The extras are where this presentation falls down with only a couple of trailers available....
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 90
Presented in its original aspect ratio of 2.35:1, encoded with MPEG-4 AVC and granted a 1080p transfer, Feng Xiaogang's If You Are the One arrives on Blu-ray courtesy of Tai Seng Entertainment....
Audio: 90
Still, the more sensitive amongst you should quickly notice that it lacks the depth and fluidity of the Mandarin Dolby TrueHD 7.1 track (there are a couple of scenes in particular during the second half...
Extras: 20
Mot unfortunately, the only extras on this Blu-ray disc are two trailers, one for If You Are the One and one for Look for a Star....
Movie: 90
Because the two main protagonists are so obviously incompatible � he is an average looking man while she is a stunningly beautiful woman � we know that by the time the end credits roll, the two will fall...
Total: 90
...
Director: Xiaogang Feng
Actors: You Ge, Shu Qi, Wei Fan
PlotQin Fen, a middle-aged inventor, finds sudden wealth after selling his latest invention. He decides to use his newfound fortune to find a life partner, placing an advertisement online for potential matches. With humor and sincerity, he meets an array of women, each encounter revealing the complexities and absurdities of modern relationships. Along the way, he befriends a stewardess named Liang Xiaoxiao who is dealing with her heartbreak from an unfaithful lover.
As Qin continues his search, his bond with Liang deepens, creating an intricate web of emotions and personal growth. They engage in deep conversations about life, love, and happiness, becoming confidants and allies in their separate quests for fulfillment. Their evolving relationship and shared experiences lead them to confront their own desires and misconceptions.
Writers: Kuo-Fu Chen, Xiaogang Feng
Release Date: 22 Dec 2008
Runtime: 130 min
Rating: N/A
Country: China
Language: Mandarin