A Clockwork Orange Blu-ray Review
DigiBook 40th Anniversary Edition | Includes: O Lucky Malcolm! and Stanley Kubrick: A Life In Pictures
Score: 54
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
The 40th Anniversary Blu-ray release of 'A Clockwork Orange' offers minimal video and audio upgrades but includes valuable new featurettes and a Kubrick documentary.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 37
The 40th Anniversary edition of A Clockwork Orange retains the same 1080p/VC-1 transfer from 2007, presenting issues like inconsistent color saturation, contrast wavering, and noise. Despite preserving Kubrick's original intent, the transfer lacks the anticipated clarity and vibrancy seen in more recent restorations.
Audio: 47
A Clockwork Orange's newest Blu-ray audio presents an above-average DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track, comparable to the 2007 LPCM mix, delivering clear dialogue and a bold, commanding score. The audio remains front-heavy with minimal rear involvement, preserving Kubrick’s original sound design despite age-related limitations.
Extra: 81
The 40th Anniversary Edition of *A Clockwork Orange* offers extensive, candid insights through McDowell's engaging commentary and comprehensive documentaries like 'Still Tickin'' and 'Great Bolshy Yarblockos!' However, the set's reliance on standard definition for key features like 'A Life in Pictures' falls short of expectations.
Movie: 81
Kubrick’s "A Clockwork Orange" remains a cinematic masterpiece, its powerful narrative on crime, punishment, and societal control, enhanced by Malcolm McDowell's iconic performance and jarring visuals. The Blu-ray's 40th Anniversary Edition preserves the film’s visceral impact with impeccable picture and sound quality, making it essential for collectors.
Video: 37
The 40th Anniversary edition of "A Clockwork Orange" employs the same 1080p/VC-1 encoded transfer previously seen on the 2007 Blu-ray release. This transfer, unfortunately, does not represent a significant improvement and maintains noticeable inconsistencies. Softness, fluctuating contrast, and intrusive noise are prevalent throughout. Delineation issues and print fluctuations are apparent, and color saturation is inconsistent from shot to shot. These issues raise questions about the potential for a more thorough overhaul that could better preserve Kubrick's intentions while rejuvenating the film’s presentation. Still, it's worth noting that some elements, such as primary colors in daylight scenes and nighttime hues, remain reasonably faithful to the source material.
Despite this, several issues extend beyond the original source material or Kubrick's intent. Frequent instances of crush, artifacting, minor banding, and occasional aliasing are prominent. Although no single flaw critically undermines the entire presentation, their collective presence detracts from the overall viewing experience. This update does not offer an improvement over previous releases, which further disappoints given advancements in Blu-ray technology over the past decade. The video quality oscillates between moments of commendable fidelity in closeups and troubling haziness in other frames. Visually, this edition of "A Clockwork Orange" remains marred by numerous imperfections, requiring a more meticulous restoration to truly honor the film’s legacy.
Audio: 47
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track of the latest Blu-ray release of "A Clockwork Orange" offers a strong, though not radically different, auditory experience compared to the original Linear PCM mix. Dialogue is consistently clear and intelligible, even with the film's distinct cockney dialect, while Malcolm McDowell’s narration remains the central auditory focus, delivered with commanding precision. The evocative score, heavily featuring classical music, is rendered crisply, and most notably, it pierces through with clarity and dynamism, especially in moments of heightened intensity or emotional gravitas.
While the track is front-heavy, mostly aligned with Kubrick's original design, limited rear speaker engagement doesn't detract from the overall experience. The audio design complements the director's signature style, although it shows signs of age, such as occasional static and feedback. Bass output is robust and effective, particularly in scenes like the Billy Boy massacre. Despite minor auditory artifacts and selective directional challenges, the audio stays true to the essence of Kubrick's vision.
Ultimately, despite the forty years since its original release and the evolution of cinema sound design, the soundtrack maintains a faithful representation of Kubrick’s intent. This Blu-ray edition thoughtfully balances technical prowess with respect for the film's historical context, ensuring that both new viewers and long-time fans can appreciate Warner's efforts in preserving the film's distinctive sonic identity.
Extra: 81
The Blu-ray edition of "A Clockwork Orange" boasts an extensive array of supplemental content that delves deeply into both the film and Stanley Kubrick's storied career. Among the highlights are audio commentaries from Malcolm McDowell and historian Nick Redman, offering an engaging and thorough dissection of the movie. The disc includes a variety of documentaries such as the comprehensive "Still Tickin': The Return of Clockwork Orange" and the insightful "Great Bolshy Yarblockos! Making A Clockwork Orange," which explore the film's production, legacy, and impact on modern cinema. Notably, the new featurette "Turning Like Clockwork" hosted by McDowell offers a reflective look at the film's lasting influence. Although some content remains in standard definition, the inclusion of "Stanley Kubrick: A Life in Pictures" and "O Lucky Malcolm!" ensures a rich and captivating experience for any cinephile.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Candid insights from Malcolm McDowell and Nick Redman.
- Still Tickin': The Return of Clockwork Orange: In-depth analysis of the film’s cultural impact.
- Great Bolshy Yarblockos! Making A Clockwork Orange: Behind-the-scenes featurette.
- Turning Like Clockwork: Reflection on the film’s release and legacy.
- Malcolm McDowell Looks Back: Personal recollections from McDowell.
- Theatrical Trailer: Original 70s trailer.
- Stanley Kubrick: A Life in Pictures: Comprehensive documentary on Kubrick's career.
- O Lucky Malcolm!: Documentary on Malcolm McDowell’s career.
Movie: 81
Stanley Kubrick's "A Clockwork Orange," in its 40th Anniversary Edition Digibook, is a cinematic tour de force that continues to leave an indelible mark on viewers. Opening with an iconic scene where Alex, portrayed by a commanding Malcolm McDowell, and his droogs lounge in the Korova Milkbar, the film instantly immerses us into a dystopian future that is both alien and unsettlingly familiar. Kubrick offers no comforting exposition or context; instead, we are thrust into Alex's chaotic world, where ultraviolence and Beethoven coexist. This lack of orientation is a deliberate choice, heightening the psychological impact and setting the stage for a narrative that is as hypnotic as it is horrifying.
The portrayal of Alex's descent from a sadistic hooligan to a broken pawn in a sociopolitical experiment is powerful, unflinching, and disturbingly relevant even today. Alex thrives in his dystopian London, engaging in acts of unspeakable cruelty while manipulating authority figures and taking solace in Beethoven's symphonies. The transition to his life in prison, followed by his participation in the Ludovico technique — an experimental aversion therapy — showcases Kubrick's mastery in juxtaposing visceral violence with stark institutional control. The narrative hinges on this transformation, compelling viewers to grapple with complex ethical questions about free will, rehabilitation, and societal culpability.
Kubrick’s direction is a marvel of precision and audacity, transforming Anthony Burgess's novel into a labyrinthine satire. The film's ability to evoke empathy for such a vile protagonist like Alex speaks volumes about Kubrick's and McDowell's prowess. The synthesis of graphic imagery, soaring classical music, and darkly humorous dialogue creates an experience that is as intellectually provocative as it is emotionally jarring. "A Clockwork Orange" remains a challenging yet essential watch, reaffirming Kubrick's status as a visionary director who deftly explores the darker recesses of human nature with unparalleled artistry.
Total: 54
The 40th Anniversary Blu-ray release of "A Clockwork Orange" presents a cinematic experience that remains as thought-provoking and controversial as its original debut. This new edition features an identical video transfer to the 2007 release, maintaining the film's iconic yet disturbing visuals with comparable detail and color accuracy. Similarly, the audio track, now presented in DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1, mirrors the previously available uncompressed LPCM mix, offering a balanced yet immersive auditory experience. While these core elements remain unchanged, the Blu-ray package does introduce two newly produced high-definition featurettes and the comprehensive documentary, Stanley Kubrick: A Life in Pictures, adding supplementary value for Kubrick enthusiasts.
However, the apparent lack of significant technical improvements questions the need for this re-release. The video transfer, though visually precise, does not present any enhancement over its predecessor, and the shift in audio format offers minimal difference to the casual viewer. The added special features, albeit interesting and insightful, cater mainly to a niche audience already familiar with Kubrick's body of work. Consequently, this release comes across as a strategic move targeting die-hard collectors and completionists rather than offering substantial upgrades that justify its premium price point.
And would you believe it, o my brothers and only friends. There was your faithful narrator being held helpless, like a babe in arms, and suddenly realizing where he was and why home on the gate had looked so familiar, but I knew I was safe. For in those care-free days, I and my so-called droogies wore our maskies, which were like real horror-show disguises.
In conclusion, "A Clockwork Orange" remains an indispensable piece of cinema that continues to challenge and engage audiences. However, this particular Blu-ray edition brings little innovation to justify its purchase for those who already own previous releases. The new special features might hold some allure for Kubrick aficionados, but for most viewers, this edition's value may seem limited.
Blu-ray.com review by Kenneth BrownRead review here
Video: 70
Though some are certainly correctable, most of the aforementioned inconsistencies either trace back to Kubrick's intentions or the film's source, making Warner's transfer, by and large, a reasonably faithful...
Audio: 70
Granted, the track is unmistakably front-heavy, with minimal rear speaker involvement, but it stays true to the tone and tenor of Kubrick's original sound design....
Extras: 90
Turning Like Clockwork (Disc 1, HD, 26 minutes): A grizzled McDowell hosts this newly produced look back at A Clockwork Orange with yet another parade of renowned filmmakers, a discussion of the differences...
Movie: 90
Dancing verbal circles around authority figures, manipulating anyone he meets, indulging his base instincts while flexing his intellectual muscle, and giving himself over to the music of Ludwig van Beethoven...
Total: 80
A Clockwork Orange is many things to many people: disturbing, bizarre, strangely amusing, bitingly satirical, brilliant, unnerving, unwatchable, thought-provoking, cerebral and gratuitous, just to name...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 40
The change in content on the movie disc will account for a slightly different viewing experience, however, the deduction in score found here is accounted for by the fact that in three and a half years,...
Audio: 60
Still, this forty year old film doesn't exactly have to be all over the place like a modern flick, so the front heavy nature of this release isn't a bother at all....
Extras: 80
Providing a balanced overview of the production, the experience, and the film's notorious reputation, McDowell's candid comments and keen observations kept me hooked from beginning to end....
Movie: 80
With perplexing speech patterns, bizarre and otherwise complex scene compositions, and a labyrinthine plot whose motives can be interpreted a number of ways, as we see a character constantly theorizing...
Total: 80
A better, much needed transfer wasn't picked from the trees, so this disc looks like a real horror show...just like the other Blu-ray of this classic flick....
Director: Stanley Kubrick
Actors: Malcolm McDowell, Patrick Magee, Michael Bates
PlotIn a dystopian England, a sociopathic delinquent named Alex and his gang of "droogs" partake in a series of violent and sadistic crimes, including assault, robbery, and rape. Alex's love for classic music, particularly Ludwig van Beethoven, contrasts sharply with his thrill-seeking antisocial behaviors. The gang operates under a totalitarian regime, reveling in brutality and indulging in "a bit of the old ultra-violence." Alex is portrayed as both a charming yet deeply flawed character, whose interests in high culture do nothing to quell his violent impulses.
When a heist goes wrong, resulting in the death of a woman, Alex is betrayed by his droogs and arrested by the police. Facing a long prison sentence, he becomes aware of an experimental behavior correction program. This offers him the opportunity for an early release, which he eagerly accepts without fully understanding the consequences. The experimental treatment is a controversial technique aimed at rehabilitating criminals by conditioning them to associate feelings of sickness with violence, thus stripping them of their ability to commit crime.
Writers: Stanley Kubrick, Anthony Burgess
Release Date: 02 Feb 1972
Runtime: 136 min
Rating: X
Country: United Kingdom, United States
Language: English