Bonnie and Clyde Blu-ray Review
DigiBook
Score: 53
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
'Bonnie & Clyde' revolutionizes crime films with a modern, sexy approach, changing Hollywood's portrayal of violence and historical crime.
Disc Release Date
Video: 60
Warner's meticulous remaster of 'Bonnie & Clyde' brings vintage charm to Blu-ray with vibrant colors, solid blacks, and improved detail, celebrating its cinematic artistry in 1080p.
Audio: 30
The 'Bonnie & Clyde' Blu-ray disappoints with its limited original mono audio, lacking dynamism and bass, despite a clear dialogue and decent score. Warner's efforts fall short, missing a chance for HD remastering amidst technical challenges.
Extra: 67
Warner's 'Bonnie & Clyde' Blu-ray honors its 40th with engaging extras like documentaries and booklets, despite some SD features and missed HD updates.
Movie: 83
'Bonnie & Clyde,' a groundbreaking film, masterfully explores violence, fame, and American culture, with influential cinematography and performances, now vividly revived on Blu-ray.
Video: 60
Warner's Blu-ray presentation of "Bonnie and Clyde" marks a significant milestone in the restoration and digital remastering of classic cinema, providing an astonishingly good 1080p/VC-1 video presentation that respects the film's original theatrical aspect ratio of 1.85:1 widescreen. The meticulous remastering effort showcases a clean and practically dirt-free image, where consistent grain presence enhances the filmic quality without overwhelming. The restoration strikes an exquisite balance between preserving the movie's period authenticity and embracing modern expectations for picture clarity, ensuring that the film's inherent grain and texture detail are not only noticeable but are integral to its visual appeal. The effort to retain these elements without succumbing to excessive digital noise reduction (DNR) reflects Warner's commitment to authenticity, allowing for a viewing experience that is both noise-free and vibrant.
The improvement in color rendition is particularly notable, with a more vibrant and smooth palette highlighting details and textures that prior video releases had obscured. Scenes are rendered with considerable depth, and though the film may not compete with the sharpness of contemporary productions, its cinematography benefits immensely from this upgrade. The warmth of the colors, combined with the natural fleshtones—highlighted by Faye Dunaway's portrayal—and balanced blacks showcase the film's atmospheric and stylistic choices beautifully. This reinvigorated color scheme enhances both the intense and subtle moments, drawing viewers into the film's world with an immediacy that belies its age.
The preservation of detail, especially in wider shots, and the careful attention to minimize artifacts and noise, underline Warner's expertise in film restoration. Although some softness is acknowledged in closer frames, this does not detract from the overall detail and clarity afforded by the high-definition upgrade. Moreover, the careful handling of scenes depicting varying degrees of light demonstrates the transfer's dynamic range, from the dark, gritty sequences to those bursting with color and life. As such, this Blu-ray release of "Bonnie and Clyde" not only surpasses previous versions in terms of video quality but also serves as a benchmark for how vintage films should be revitalized for modern audiences.
Audio: 30
The audio presentation of the Blu-ray release for "Bonnie and Clyde" has garnered attention, not for its innovation but rather for its adherence to the original Dolby Digital Plus 1.0 mono track. This decision has inevitably led to a mixed reception among audiophiles and home theater enthusiasts. Despite the visual upgrade to 1080p high definition, the audio has not received a similar treatment, remaining in a monoaural format capped at 192 kbps. This limitation significantly impacts the dynamism and spatiality of the soundtrack, rendering it somewhat lacklustre. While dialogue remains generally clear and the music retains its lushness - albeit with a slightly rolled-off treble - the overall experience is marred by a lack of bass and auditory depth.
Warner faced considerable challenges in remastering the audio due to the unavailability of the original source elements, making a surround mix unfeasible. However, this constraint does not fully excuse the absence of a lossless, high-definition track that could have enhanced the aural experience, even within the confines of mono sound. The effort to provide a clean, if not entirely crisp, sound is evident; dialogues are mostly unobstructed, and there's an appreciable warmth to the audio that is commendable for a film from 1967. Yet, instances of muffled low tones and grating louder scenes highlight the limitations of the restoration process.
In summary, while Warner has managed to preserve the essence of "Bonnie and Clyde's" original aural experience with a serviceable mono track, the absence of a more ambitious audio upgrade leaves much to be desired. The soundtrack does convey realism and a certain degree of warmth, making it a perfectly fine mono track by vintage standards. Nevertheless, the expectation for a more robust and detailed audio component in line with the visual restoration remains unmet, underscoring a missed opportunity to elevate this classic film's home theater presentation.
Extras: 67
Warner's dedication to celebrating the 40th anniversary of "Bonnie and Clyde" is evident through their enriched Blu-ray and remastered DVD release, showcasing an array of supplementary content that admirably compensates for the absence of an audio commentary. The disc features an engaging lineup of documentaries and featurettes, albeit in standard definition, that delve into the making of this iconic film and the true story behind the notorious couple. The standout elements include a comprehensive hour-long making-of documentary, essential viewing for cinephiles interested in the film's storied production and historical context provided by a History Channel special. Additionally, unique extras like wardrobe tests and deleted scenes without audio offer a tantalizing glimpse into the cutting room floor decisions. Although some may find the featurettes' presentation in standard definition a missed opportunity for a high-definition upgrade, the overall package is significantly enhanced by the addition of a glossy digibook, combining a collectible aesthetic with insightful film and actor bios, notwithstanding minor omissions. Warner's meticulous assembly of these extras reflects both a labor of love for the film's legacy and a strategic nod to consumer desires for tangible memorabilia.
Extras included in this disc:
- Love and Death: The True Story of Bonnie and Clyde: A History Channel documentary focusing on the real-life stories of Bonnie and Clyde, bypassing the film to explore their crimes and societal impact.
- Revolution! The Making of Bonnie & Clyde: An exhaustive one-hour documentary covering all aspects of the film’s creation with insights from the directors, stars, and creative team.
- Deleted Scenes: A collection of scenes excluded from the final cut, presented without sound but offering a rare look at what might have been.
- Wardrobe Tests: Featuring Warren Beatty’s costume fittings, providing a behind-the-scenes glance at the film’s aesthetic choices.
- Theatrical Trailers: Original promotional materials in standard definition with Dolby Digital monaural sound.
- Collectible Booklet: A special edition release that includes a digibook with production notes, cast bios, rare photographs, and selected press kit excerpts.
Movie: 83
The 1967 film "Bonnie and Clyde," directed by Arthur Penn and starring Faye Dunaway and Warren Beatty, redefined Hollywood's portrayal of violence and sexuality, emerging as perhaps the most influential movie of the '60s. This adaptation strikingly balances the folklore and brutality of America's infamous criminal duo, delving into their bank heists and barbaric spree with a mesmerizing blend of romanticism and stark realism. Its presentation on Blu-ray breathes new life into the stunning cinematography that won Burnett Guffey an Academy Award, despite the audio quality falling short of the visual splendor. The Warner digibook release not only enhances the film's iconic visuals with a 1080p transfer but also enriches the experience with a generous array of documentaries, shedding light on its enduring legacy.
At its core, "Bonnie and Clyde" explores the complex interplay between societal allure towards anti-heroes and the grim consequences of their actions. It casts an unflinching gaze on the couple's rampage across Depression-era America, compellingly portrayed by Beatty and Dunaway, whose performances catapulted them to stardom. Their depiction transcends mere criminal exploits, delving into themes of fame, ambition, and the elusive American dream. This scrutiny is further deepened by Robert Benton and David Newman's tightly woven screenplay, which doesn't waste a word in unfolding its narrative. The film's audacity in subject matter was matched only by its technical accomplishments in storytelling and visual composition, cementing its place in cinematic history.
The Blu-ray release captures the dichotomy of "Bonnie and Clyde's" beautiful yet violent journey with unmatched clarity, although its auditory presentation does not meet the same exemplary standard. Nonetheless, this does not detract from the overall effectiveness of the film's transfer to high definition, ensuring that Arthur Penn's masterpiece remains influential. Through this definitive version, complete with significant bonus material and an informative booklet, Warner Home Video secures "Bonnie and Clyde’s" resonant impact on audiences and filmmakers alike, illustrating its pivotal role in shaping modern cinema's approach to storytelling and visual aesthetics.
Total: 53
The Blu-ray presentation of "Bonnie and Clyde" offers a splendid viewing experience that encapsulates not just the revolutionary essence of the film but also its historical significance in the evolution of Hollywood cinema. This landmark film, celebrated for its raw portrayal of violence and the glamorization of criminality, marked a turning point in the industry's treatment of such themes, challenging even the reservations of Warner Bros' studio head. Its blend of comedy, tragedy, and romance, punctuated by the legendary performances of its leads and groundbreaking cinematography, is further enhanced by this high-definition release. The package is not only commendable for its visual restoration but also for the rich collection of retrospective extras that delve into the movie's profound impact and legacy.
Despite the original soundtrack being presented in mono, it does little to detract from the overall experience, exemplifying the technical limitations of its time with an authenticity that audiophiles might appreciate for its historical accuracy. The remastering effort is first-rate, ensuring that both enthusiasts of American cinema and newcomers alike can fully appreciate the depth and innovation of "Bonnie and Clyde" as if viewing it for the first time. This Blu-ray edition serves as an essential addition to any collection, underscoring the film's pivotal role in the modernization of narrative and visual storytelling within the crime genre.
In conclusion, this Blu-ray release not only pays homage to "Bonnie and Clyde" as a seminal work that pushed the boundaries of Hollywood filmmaking but also serves as a vital educational tool for understanding the film's cultural and cinematic significance. It is a must-have for cinephiles, offering an immersive experience that celebrates the film's enduring legacy while providing comprehensive insights into its creation, reception, and influence on both past and contemporary cinema narratives.
avforums review by Casimir HarlowRead review here
Video: 80
You still have to take the age into consideration, but detail is generally very good throughout, with a little acceptable grain, some softness, but negligible edge enhancement and decent clarity throughout....
Audio: 50
Dialogue is clear enough, and we get a few gunshot effects and a sporadically punchy score, but with it all crammed into a track almost totally devoid of dynamism or spatiality, and with no significant...
Extras: 70
...
Movie: 90
There's also a nice set of interesting extras to round off the disc, and - irrespective of the audio track - the end result is still a release that is worthy of a place in anybody's collection....
Total: 80
Blu-ray.com review by Greg MaltzRead review here
Video: 80
Erring on the side of the former is not always a bad idea, and in the case of Bonnie and Clyde, ample cues from the original film are still visible, with grain prevalent but by no means distracting....
Audio: 60
But the push for a lossless, high definition track should have been a priority, even if monaural and traced to inadequate sources....
Extras: 80
However, from the experts and writers interviewed for the documentary, one can understand how and why the film diverged from reality....
Movie: 70
But even forgetting that Bonnie and Clyde was a remarkably influential study of violence, sexuality and Americana, it is noteworthy in other respects, helping to establish the careers of Beatty, Dunaway...
Total: 70
Bonnie and Clyde is a noteworthy film not just because of the writing, acting and cinematography, but because it marks a point in Hollywood when there was a conscious decision to really modernize and "sex...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
This new version of 'Bonnie & Clyde' is also a test case for how far the art of digital compression has come in the ten years since the DVD format debuted -- just check out that old disc if you want to...
Audio: 40
At least the source that Warner did have to work with sounds rather good for a 1967 film, with a decent sense of realism and warmth....
Extras: 60
Instead of the usual blue keepcase, the disc comes housed in a matted book-like cover, which opens up to reveal 24 full-color pages containing production notes, cast bios, rare photographs, and excerpts...
Movie: 100
The story is a well-known piece of revisionist history, but what makes 'Bonnie & Clyde' masterful is not how its plot unfolds (we already know the fate awaiting these thrill-seeking degenerates), but rather...
Total: 60
'Bonnie & Clyde' is one of the best films produced by Hollywood in the '60s, which is more than just high praise -- it makes it a landmark of the medium and a must-see for any serious student of American...
Director: Arthur Penn
Actors: Warren Beatty, Faye Dunaway, Michael J. Pollard
PlotIn the midst of the Great Depression, a small-town girl with dreams of fame meets a recently-paroled crook with a charismatic edge and a penchant for danger. The two quickly become infatuated with one another, discovering a mutual desire to escape their mundane realities. Seizing this rebellious spirit, they embark on a bold journey of crime, robbing small banks across the American South. Their exploits draw the attention of the public and the press, who romanticize the duo's lawless adventures, casting them as modern-day folk heroes. As their notoriety grows, so does the fervor of their rebellion, leading them to recruit a young mechanic and a disillusioned farmer, expanding their gang.
Despite their escalating fame, the gang's journey is fraught with challenges. Each heist grows more daring and dangerous, drawing the ire of law enforcement. The authorities, humiliated by the gang's audacity and the public's fascination with them, intensify their efforts to bring the spree to an end. Meanwhile, the gang members must navigate the complex dynamics of their relationships, the strain of living on the run, and the consequences of their actions. As they continue to evade capture, they must confront the realities of their chosen path and the inevitable fate that history reserves for outlaws.
Writers: David Newman, Robert Benton, Robert Towne
Release Date: 14 Aug 1967
Runtime: 111 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English