The Life Before Her Eyes Blu-ray Review
Score: 57
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
High-end home cinema setup meets 'The Life Before Her Eyes'—a visually striking, flawed yet engaging film.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 62
'The Life Before Her Eyes' captivates with vivid, finely detailed visuals and smart use of color, amidst intriguing directorial choices and a clean, dynamic transfer.
Audio: 51
The detailed lossless audio delivers excellent dynamics, clarity, and textures, emphasizing ambient sounds and dialogue, with minor issues in surround presence and instrument separation.
Extra: 57
The 'Life Before Her Eyes' Blu-ray extras offer a mix of standard and impressive features, with highlights including a detailed audio commentary, a thorough documentary, and unique deleted scenes, amidst standard galleries and trailers, primarily in standard definition.
Movie: 63
The Life Before Her Eyes, marked by a blend of teen drama and existential reflection, contrasts high school tragedy with adult survival, weaving intricate details and emotions into a narrative that encapsulates resilience and the poignant aftermath of a life-altering decision.
Video: 62
"The Life Before Her Eyes" Blu-ray presentation is a visual feast that showcases an adept use of color and detailed cinematography to enrich storytelling. The AVC encode, averaging 25 Mbps, delivers sharpness and clarity that bring out the minutiae of the film's varied and vivid palette. From the macro photography of flora and fauna to the broader scopes, each frame is infused with life, rendered with a precision that enhances the emotional tone of every scene. Contrast is well-calibrated, with deep blacks and smooth shadow details contributing to a clean, pristine image. The film's choice to employ a wide 2.39:1 aspect ratio, although unconventional for its intimate narrative, adds an intriguing layer to its visual storytelling, perhaps aimed at intensifying the viewer's experience through a more enveloping field of view.
Skin tones are rendered naturally, benefiting from the transfer's fidelity to detail and color variation, ensuring that every character appears as lifelike as possible. The presence of subtle film grain complements the texture, seamlessly integrating with the vividness of the colors and the depth of the blacks without detracting from the sharpness of the image. This balance between realism and stylization is meticulously maintained throughout, with scenes transitioning from brilliantly saturated to more subdued yet equally tantalizing visuals.
Despite occasional challenges like a slight crush in blacks that could marginally affect detail, the overall video presentation remains exemplary. Directors and cinematographers’ choices in framing and composition invite curiosity about their impact on the narrative’s intimacy and intensity. "The Life Before Her Eyes" stands out as a masterclass in how technical prowess in video encoding can elevate a film's visual story, making it more immersive and emotionally resonant for its audience.
Audio: 51
"The Life Before Her Eyes" Blu-ray audio presentation offers listeners two English track options: a Dolby Digital 5.1 and a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1. The DTS-HDMA track, in particular, enhances the film's atmosphere, lending an eerily fitting backdrop to its non-linear narrative. Scene transitions from quiet conversations to intense moments are seamless, avoiding any jarring audio shifts that might prompt volume adjustments. The soundscape is rich in detail, with the clarity of the tracks allowing for even the subtlest environmental sounds—such as leaves rustling or a distant sprinkler—to be distinctly heard. Dynamics are notable, providing depth to dialogues and a textured auditory experience. However, despite the high quality of the tracks, their use of surround sound is conservative, mostly employing it for ambient effects and bolstering the musical score rather than aggressive action sequences.
The mix quality across both options is generally excellent, ensuring dialogue remains clear and predominantly centered, complementing the film’s dramatic essence rather than overpowering it. Front channels occasionally take on speech duties but mainly support scoring and ambiance, while rear channels subtly contribute to environmental sounds. The Low-Frequency Effects channel adds necessary depth to the film's few loud scenes without overwhelming. Nevertheless, the soundtrack, particularly the score by James Horner, arguably doesn’t reach its full potential in immersion due to a pronounced front-heavy mix that neglects the surround channels, resulting in a somewhat missed opportunity for a richer auditory environment.
In summary, "The Life Before Her Eyes" offers a solid yet somewhat restrained auditory experience. While it showcases impeccable clarity and detail in its sound design, with effective use of dynamics and low-end support, it falls slightly short in fully exploiting the surround channels for a truly enveloping experience. The audio presentation stands as a competent accompaniment to a primarily dialogue-driven film, ensuring clarity and mood enhancement without distracting from the narrative flow, but it could have benefited from a more ambitious use of spatial audio for an even more impactful audio-visual experience.
Extras: 57
The Blu-Ray extras for "The Life Before Her Eyes" offer a surprisingly rich dive beyond the film's surface, albeit with a presentation that doesn't quite match this depth, mainly due to the standard definition quality of most features. Despite this, the Audio Commentary by Vadim Perelman and Maia Javan provides insightful discussions into the film's production and thematic elements. The extensive behind-the-scenes documentary "Flashback: Behind The Life Before Her Eyes" stands out for its comprehensive look at the filmmaking process, enriched by interviews with key cast and crew. While the inclusion of personal near-death experiences in "Reflections Back and Beyond" feels slightly out of place, it tangentially complements the film's exploration of life-and-death themes. Deleted scenes and an alternate ending offer further intrigue into narrative choices, and visually, the Flower Montage adds a brief, albeit HD, aesthetic embellishment to the package. Noteworthily, the HD Theatrical Trailers bridge this extras package back to its cinematic origin, albeit the extras' overall standard definition presentation subtly undermines the Blu-Ray's high definition promise.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary with Director Vadim Perelman and Production Designer Maia Javan: In-depth discussion covering production challenges and thematic insights.
- 5 Deleted Scenes: Additional scenes highlighting character development and alternate narrative paths.
- Alternate Ending: Provides a nuanced twist to the film's conclusion.
- Eva Amurri Casting Tape: Insight into the casting process with actress Eva Amurri.
- Flower Photo Gallery: A collection of digitally manipulated flower images from the film.
- Flower Montage: Video sequence of the film's flower imagery without credits.
- Flashback: Behind The Life Before Her Eyes: An extensive making-of documentary featuring interviews and behind-the-scenes footage.
- Reflections Back and Beyond: A featurette exploring near-death experiences, loosely connected to the film's themes.
- Theatrical Trailer (HD): High-definition trailer of the film.
Movie: 63
"The Life Before Her Eyes," a movie adaptation of Laura Kasischke's novel, presents a captivating yet tumultuous narrative that bridges the innocence of youth with the irreversible consequences of a singular moment of terror. The film explores the intertwined lives of Diana (Evan Rachel Wood as the younger version and Uma Thurman as the adult counterpart) and her friend Maureen (Eva Amurri), whose fates are forever altered in the wake of a harrowing school shooting. Through the lens of Vadim Perelman's direction and Emil Stern's screenplay, viewers are drawn into a complex tale of survival, guilt, and existential introspection. The film's non-linear storytelling oscillates between Diana's rebellious teenage years and her subsequent life, grappling with survivor's guilt and the shadows of past decisions that continue to haunt her.
Evan Rachel Wood delivers a compelling performance, encapsulating the wild-hearted Diana with an intensity that contrasts Thurman's more subdued portrayal of Diana's adulthood, marked by an idyllic but superficial existence that slowly unravels as the anniversary of the tragedy approaches. Though Thurman's role appears less dynamic, her portrayal effectively conveys a spectrum of nuanced emotions, from grief to disarray. The film benefits from Pawel Edelman's exceptional cinematography, weaving a visually stunning backdrop that underscores the depth of the narrative. From close-ups of nature's minutiae to the stark, uncomfortable reality of a school under siege, each frame adds a layer of significance to the unfolding story.
However, "The Life Before Her Eyes" is not without its critiques. Despite its intriguing premise and strong performances, the film occasionally succumbs to pacing issues and a climactic twist that, while thought-provoking, may not deliver the emotional resonance expected. Some narrative elements feel underexplored or too subtly connected, requiring viewers to piece together the intricate tapestry of symbolism and foreshadowing meticulously laid out. While the movie strives to navigate through complex themes and moral quandaries, it leaves one pondering whether certain aspects would have been more effectively conveyed through its original literary form. Nonetheless, it stands out for its daring to delve into dark themes and its challenge to the viewer's perception, making it a noteworthy albeit imperfect cinematic experience.
Total: 57
In evaluating the Blu-ray presentation of "The Life Before Her Eyes," a deeply introspective and occasionally divisive film, it becomes clear that its merits largely rest upon the unsuspecting viewer's shoulders. The initial moments are designed to captivate, with a narrative and aesthetic detail that rewards not only the first watch but subsequent viewings as well. This sense of discovery is enhanced by the Blu-ray’s technical prowess, boasting a commendable picture quality that captures the film’s intricate visuals and an audio presentation that supports the unfolding drama without overwhelming it. The assortment of supplemental materials provided does well to extend the film's reach beyond its runtime, offering deeper insights into its creation and thematic exploration.
The hardware used to scrutinize this Blu-ray release—ranging from the JVC DLA-RS1x 1080p High Definition Front Projector to the nuanced auditory capabilities of Canton Ergo Series speakers—ensures a comprehensive assessment of its technical specifications. Each component, whether it be for visual or auditory output, contributes to an immersive viewing experience that few films manage to achieve through home media. Despite criticisms of its narrative being overly sensational or convoluted, the sheer quality of its Blu-ray presentation demands acknowledgment. The encoding captures the film's varied palette with fidelity, while the audio track navigates the fine line between subtlety and intensity, complimented by a robust selection of cables and conditioning equipment that underscores the importance of an untainted signal path.
In conclusion, "The Life Before Her Eyes" manifests as a Blu-ray release that not only transcends its narrative imperfections but also showcases the potential of home cinema when backed by superior technical integrations. While the film itself might adjudicate division among viewers, the quality of this release—visual clarity, auditory depth, and enriching extras—consolidates its position as a worthy acquisition for those seeking cinema that dares to venture beyond conventional storytelling. Its commendation is further nuanced by the setup utilized in this review, highlighting how optimal hardware can elevate the home viewing experience to rival theatrical presentations.
Blu-ray.com review by Lindsay MayerRead review here
Video: 80
Filmed in 2.39:1, the subject matter doesn't exactly lend itself to the vista-like views of a scope movie - better suited to epic, sweeping landscapes and the like....
Audio: 70
The sound equalization is done well - even when "jump" scenes catch the viewer by surprise, the sound never suffers from such an imbalance that it causes one to reach for the remote....
Extras: 60
Thematically, it kind of fits in with the content of the film, but it seems to jump out of nowhere here on the extra features, and is more baffling than insightful....
Movie: 70
Though it makes for interesting cinematic material, one does have to wonder whether this story, with all of its strange turns and mysterious happenings, fared better on the page than as a silver screen...
Total: 70
So much detail is sprinkled throughout, both visually and via the narrative, that the film can even be rewarding upon a repeat viewing....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
The film settles down into a more everyday (if still slightly surreal) quality, with a color palette that continues to tantalize the eyes but is otherwise more subdued....
Audio: 60
Technically, the track is clean, with ample if not exceptional dynamic range and low bass that's appropriate to the dramatic subject matter....
Extras: 60
This is a thorough (if a tad serious) overview of the entire production with extensive interviews with Perelman, Thurman and Wood, plus all of the main supporting cast and crew....
Movie: 60
Thurman is largely left to react to memories of past events, which begins to make her feel like a passive character -- it's a shame that Stern, even though he was working off of previously-published material,...
Total: 60
Though the story often moves in unexpected directions -- and the film is certainly beautifully photographed -- it's still flawed enough to not quite rate full sleeper status....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 88
A variety of colors are effectively used in this film to help set the tone/setting based upon the mood of the scene and characters within it....
Audio: 84
Subtle background sounds such as the mist generated by a sprinkler, or leaves being rustled by a gentle breeze through the woods were clearly audible thanks to the tracks excellent clarity and detail....
Extras: 60
Audio commentary with Director Vadim Perelman and Production Designer Maia Javan 5 Deleted scenes Alternate ending Eva Amurri casting tape Flower photo gallery Flower montage...
Movie: 70
But Diana's aura of invincibility is shattered when a moment of life and death decision-making forever changes the lives of the two best friends....
Total: 76
Marantz DV7001 Universal Disc Player Denon AVR 5308CI THX Ultra 2 Preamp/Video Processor Outlaw Audio Model 7700 seven channel amplifier B&K Reference 200.7 Series 2 seven Channel amplifier Canton "Ergo"...
Director: Vadim Perelman
Actors: Uma Thurman, Evan Rachel Wood, Eva Amurri
PlotThe story revolves around Diana, a high school student, who faces a harrowing decision during a school shooting. Alongside her best friend Maureen, she is confronted by the shooter in the school bathroom, forced into a terrifying moment that asks them to choose who lives and who dies. This traumatic event is the focal point around which the narrative is constructed, exploring the themes of choice, survival, and the burdens of guilt. The incident starkly contrasts the innocence and simplicity of teenage concerns they were immersed in moments before, bringing a profound and life-altering seriousness to their young lives.
Years later, Diana is now an adult, struggling with the psychological aftermath of the shooting. As she navigates her role as a mother and wife, her memories of the past and the choice she made in that bathroom continue to haunt her. The film explores the ways in which trauma shapes and distorts reality, intertwining flashbacks of her teenage years with her current life. It delves into the complex interplay between memory and present experience, revealing how unresolved issues can seep into one's everyday existence. The narrative builds around Diana's struggle to come to terms with her past, examining the impact of trauma on identity, relationships, and one's perception of life.
Writers: Laura Kasischke, Emil Stern
Release Date: 05 Sep 2008
Runtime: 90 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English