Girlhood Blu-ray Review
Bande de filles
Score: 73
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Despite needing tighter editing, 'Girlhood' offers potent emotionality and an exceptional A/V presentation, making it highly recommended for its universal themes.
Disc Release Date
Video: 86
The AVC encoded 2.40:1 1080p presentation of 'Girlhood' excels with pristine detail, vibrant color replication, and strong black levels, offering rich close-ups and impressive night shots. The HD-shot feature captures modern bluish and amber hues without compression artifacts or degrading crush issues.
Audio: 86
The 5.1 DTS-HD MA sound mix of 'Girlhood' expertly balances dynamic music, clear dialogue, and atmospheric effects, creating an engaging and emotionally rich audio experience, with standout moments like the Rihanna song sequence showcasing tonal richness and precise surround imaging.
Extra: 26
The Extras include a brief (2:56, HD) interview with Karidja Toure discussing casting and camaraderie, though it leaves much to be desired for deeper insights, accompanied by a solid 1:37, HD theatrical trailer that effectively captures the film's essence.
Movie: 76
"Girlhood" delivers a raw and compelling coming-of-age drama, highlighting exceptional performances and an authentic depiction of hardships, camaraderie, and identity struggles. Directed by Céline Sciamma, it deftly balances emotional impact with thoughtful storytelling, offering a richly rewarding cinematic experience.
Video: 86
The AVC encoded image (2.40:1 aspect ratio) presentation of "Girlhood" on Blu-ray excels in delivering a nuanced and visually captivating experience. The fine details are fresh and deep, emphasizing facial particulars, location textures, and fibrous costuming. The film's HD-shot cinematography favors modern bluish and amber hues, which are rendered beautifully to display vibrant fabrics and urban signage. Skintones are spot-on, while delineation effectively manages limited lighting and distances. Contrast is sharp and communicative, ensuring that the overall visual presentation is engaging and immersive.
The 1080p format truly shines in this Blu-ray release, offering pristine image quality that accentuates detail levels. Rich close-up images and scenic shots highlight the unique dress sense of the characters without losing any style elements. The color replication is exceptional, with vibrant daylight shots providing incredible primary pop, and night shots impressively retaining strong black levels and shadow separation. This results in a fantastic sense of dimensional depth, free from the usual degrading issues like crush. Compression artifacts are absent, with no noticeable banding or edge halos, making the visual presentation seamless and thoroughly beautiful.
Audio: 86
The audio presentation of "Girlhood" on Blu-ray is a compelling experience, driven by a DTS-HD MA 5.1 sound mix that brings out the richness and texture of the film's sound design. The soundtrack, featuring propulsive synth-based songs, utilizes the surround channels effectively to create a sense of space and immersion. Fullness is notably present in the low-end frequencies, enhancing the overall depth without overpowering the dialogue. Dialogue exchanges are clean and well-organized, maintaining clarity and emotional depth throughout. The mix captures the atmosphere of urban and apartment life with subtle precision, making each scene feel vibrant and alive.
The DTS-HD MA 5.1 French audio track maintains a perfect balance in levels, ensuring smooth transitions between quieter dialogue-heavy moments and more intense scenes. While the majority of the audio is anchored in the center channels, the surround channels are adeptly filled with ambient sounds and filler effects that add layers to the auditory experience. The imaging might not fully exploit the potential of directional audio, but it provides a circular sense of position and mood that enhances the storytelling. The standout moment is undoubtedly during the girls' rendition of Rihanna's "Diamonds," where the audio mix achieves a tonally rich, resonant quality that elevates the scene significantly, reaffirming its synergy with the video presentation.
Extras: 26
The extras on the "Girlhood" Blu Ray offer a glimpse into the production but leave a desire for deeper exploration. The brief interview with actress Karidja Toure provides charming insights into the casting process and camaraderie with director Celine Sciamma and her co-stars. However, the brevity of this segment limits its impact. The inclusion of the theatrical trailer effectively captures the film's essence and accolades in a concise manner. Overall, while the content provided is engaging, it lacks the depth that would enhance the viewer's understanding and appreciation of the film's production.
Extras included in this disc:
- Interview: Brief discussion with Karidja Toure, covering casting, camaraderie, and working with Celine Sciamma.
- Theatrical Trailer: Showcases the accolades and presents the film's feel succinctly.
Movie: 76
Céline Sciamma’s "Girlhood" intricately depicts the turbulent life of Marieme (Karidja Touré), a French teenager struggling against the harsh realities of her environment. Evoking the essence of a coming-of-age drama, Sciamma delivers a portrayal that is both unsettling and captivating. Marieme’s journey through domestic abuse, academic failure, and joining a gang for solace is depicted with a rawness that’s rarely seen. The film's exceptional strength lies in its unflinching honesty, diving deep into Marieme’s decisions and the emotional turmoil that ensues.
Transitioning from the suburbs of Paris to the bright lights of the city, Marieme’s story is one of rebellion and a desperate quest for identity and belonging. Joining a group of tough girls who offer her camaraderie, she finds herself navigating a new world filled with excitement, yet laden with moral complexities. The film excellently balances moments of euphoria with stark reality checks, illustrating the conflict between Marieme’s newfound freedom and the inescapable consequences of her choices.
Sciamma’s direction is noteworthy for its authenticity and emotional depth, bolstered by the convincing performances of Touré and her co-stars. Each actress brings a palpable sense of interplay and realism, making their experiences resonate deeply with the audience. The screenplay, inspired by real-life interactions with young girls in shopping centers and train stations, ensures that every scene pulsates with genuine life experiences. "Girlhood" doesn’t provide easy answers but instead offers a poignant exploration of adolescence fraught with strife, rendering it a significant entry in the genre.
Total: 73
Céline Sciamma's "Girlhood" is a poignant exploration into the nuanced realm of adolescence, capturing the raw essence of belonging and identity through a specific racial and cultural lens. The Blu-ray transfer, courtesy of Strand Releasing, boasts an impeccable audio-visual presentation that elevates the cinematic experience. Colors are vibrant yet natural, and the sound design underscores the film’s emotional depth without overshadowing the narrative.
The film itself is a compelling examination of young Marieme's journey, navigating her way through societal pressures and personal discovery. While the third act tends to meander and could benefit from tighter editing to enhance its pacing, the strength of "Girlhood" lies in its profound intimacy and emotional resonance. The director's ability to hone in on the precariousness of youth renders the film both authentic and universal.
In conclusion, "Girlhood" may overextend in parts, but its powerful themes and engaging narrative make it a valuable film, especially for younger audiences. The Blu-ray edition is highly recommended for its exceptional technical quality and the merit of the film’s storytelling.
Blu-ray.com review by Brian OrndorfRead review here
Video: 100
Delineation is communicative, making sense out of scenes with limited lighting and distances, and contrast is sharp....
Audio: 100
Fullness is felt in the low-end, and while directionals are subdued, a circular sense of position and mood is crisply defined....
Extras: 40
Interview (2:56, HD) with actress Karidja Toure is a brief discussion of casting and camaraderie with director Celine Sciamma and her co-stars....
Movie: 80
What works so well in "Girlhood" is the comprehension of Marieme's trials, studying the teen's whirring mind as she enters a troubling situation, finding comfort in bad influences and threat at home....
Total: 80
Still, madness is potent in the feature, with Sciamma zeroing in on a specific sense of belonging that's universal to the adolescent experience, only here it takes a bleak turn with a specific racial and...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 100
Black levels and shadow separation are strong giving a fantastic sense of dimensional depth without any degrading crush issues....
Audio: 100
Imaging does a decent enough job, but much of the audio keeps to the center channels leaving a lot of the surround elements to be filled with ambients and filler effects....
Extras: 20
Actree Karidja Toure (Marieme) discusses working on the film, the early casting process and working with the other girls....
Movie: 80
You care about these girls, you want them to experience the good life and and move on - but that wish is just as much a fantasy as the one they've created for themselves....
Total: 80
Sometimes this is the perfect place to be when you watch a movie this good - it allows you to be fully take away by the film....
Director: Céline Sciamma
Actors: Karidja Touré, Assa Sylla, Lindsay Karamoh
PlotMarieme, a teenage girl living in a rough neighborhood on the outskirts of Paris, struggles with oppressive family dynamics and a lack of opportunities at school. Feeling trapped by her environment and circumstances, she yearns for a sense of freedom and belonging. To escape her overbearing home life and oppressive social limitations, she joins an all-girl gang led by Lady, an empathetic yet assertive figure. The gang offers Marieme friendship, protection, and a newfound sense of identity. They engage in petty crimes and revel in their rebellious acts, exerting a sense of power they lack in their everyday lives.
As Marieme becomes more deeply involved with the gang, she adopts the alias "Vic" and embraces the group's tough, defiant lifestyle. Her new reality, however, brings its own set of challenges and moral dilemmas. Torn between loyalty to her new friends and her personal aspirations, Marieme is forced to make difficult choices about who she wants to be and how she wants to live her life. Her journey is marked by moments of self-discovery, conflict, and the pursuit of autonomy in a world that continually undermines her sense of agency.
Writers: Céline Sciamma
Release Date: 22 Oct 2014
Runtime: 113 min
Rating: Unrated
Country: France
Language: French