Ministry of Fear Blu-ray Review
Score: 64
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Though not among Lang's top works, 'Ministry of Fear' shines with a stellar new 2K transfer, engaging noir elements, and Ray Milland's compelling performance.
Disc Release Date
Video: 73
Criterion’s 2K restoration of 'Ministry of Fear' offers superb gray scale variance, solid contrast, and rich black levels, maintaining the film's organic grain. While minor issues like occasional jitter and light debris are present, they do not detract from the overall excellent viewing experience of this espionage classic.
Audio: 65
The uncompressed English LPCM 1.0 audio track, remastered at 24-bit, offers an exceptionally clear and stable presentation with no problematic dropouts or distortions. Subtle effects like ticking clocks and rumbling bombs are well-rendered, and the dialogue is generally clear, making this a top-notch restoration for a 70-year-old film.
Extra: 37
The Criterion release of 'Ministry of Fear' provides valuable insights from Fritz Lang scholar Joe McElhaney and a Glenn Kenny essay, but the extras feel sparse without an audio commentary; the highlight being McElhaney's detailed yet sluggish interview, enriched with film clips and stills.
Movie: 78
Ministry of Fear, directed by Fritz Lang, arrives on Blu-ray with Criterion's hallmark quality, featuring a nuanced transfer in 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 and LPCM mono audio, along with insightful supplements, such as interviews and essays that offer depth to this suspense-laden film noir. Despite deviations from Graham Greene's novel, it stands out with its gripping narrative and strong performances.
Video: 73
Criterion's Blu-ray release of Fritz Lang's Ministry of Fear presents the film in an exceptional 1080p transfer, maintaining an aspect ratio of 1.37:1 and encoded with MPEG-4 AVC. The new 2K digital restoration was meticulously crafted from a 35mm safety fine-grain master using a Lasergraphics scanner. Through advanced tools like MTI's DRS and Pixel Farm's PFClean, thousands of imperfections were manually corrected, ensuring a pristine presentation. The color grading, managed by Jason Crump and Lee Kline, results in stable contrast levels, nuanced grayscale, and deep blacks and whites.
The detail and clarity afforded by the transfer are notably impressive, maintaining a pleasing grain structure that adds essential texture to the film's visual narrative. Although a few minor imperfections, such as small vertical lines and occasional jitter, appear, these do not detract from the overall quality. The restoration has ensured excellent shadow delineation and absent noise, even in murkier scenes, while background details remain distinct. Close-up shots offer significant detail, notably enhancing the film's dramatic moments.
Overall, Criterion’s handling of Ministry of Fear delivers a visually satisfying experience that stays true to Henry Sharp's original cinematography. The organic image quality and careful restoration heighten the viewing experience, providing a balance between preserving historical authenticity and ensuring modern clarity. This release stands as a testament to Criterion's dedication to classic cinema, offering an engaging and technically superb representation of Lang’s espionage drama.
Audio: 65
The "Ministry of Fear" Blu-ray's audio presentation is anchored by a single English LPCM 1.0 track, which has been remastered at 24-bit from an optical track print, resulting in a commendable audio experience. The clarity is consistent, with no dropouts or high-frequency distortions detected. Despite the film's age and inherent sound design limitations, the soundtrack remains crisp and stable throughout, with only the faintest presence of background hiss during quiet scenes.
Subtle sound effects, such as ticking clocks, creaky gates, footsteps, and the tapping of typewriter keys, are exceptionally well rendered, adding depth to the viewing experience. The Blitz sequence particularly stands out, where bass frequencies shine through rumbling plane engines and bombs, providing necessary weight to these scenes. Dialogue is mostly clear and intelligible, though it occasionally leans towards a sharp tone. The dynamic range is proficient enough to handle various audio scenarios without distortion. Victor Young's music score effectively fills the room, contributing to the film's atmospheric tension and foreboding mood, even though it doesn't exhibit the warmth and depth of more modern score reproductions.
In summary, the uncompressed mono track surpasses expectations for a film of this vintage. It retains a strong balance between dialogue, sound effects, and music, ensuring an engaging auditory experience for viewers. Optional English SDH subtitles are also provided for the main feature to accommodate diverse viewing needs. Overall, this audio presentation represents the best achievable quality for "Ministry of Fear," capturing its historical essence while delivering a polished and immersive soundscape.
Extras: 37
The Blu-ray extras for "Ministry of Fear" present a modest, yet insightful assortment that offers a deeper understanding of Fritz Lang’s work and the film’s context. The main highlight is an informative interview with Joe McElhaney, a Fritz Lang scholar, who provides compelling analysis on the film’s themes, Lang’s Hollywood image, and his adaptation challenges concerning Graham Greene's novel. Despite its somewhat lethargic pacing, McElhaney's discourse is enriched with stills and clips, giving essential context to the director's exile and anti-Nazi sentiments. The disc also includes the original theatrical trailer, providing a nostalgic glimpse into the film's initial release and underscoring the quality of the new restoration. Additionally, a well-crafted essay by Glenn Kenny is featured in the included leaflet, adding further depth to the viewing experience.
Extras included in this disc:
- On Ministry of Fear: Interview with Joe McElhaney discussing various aspects of Fritz Lang’s film.
- Trailer: Original trailer for "Ministry of Fear."
- Leaflet: Featuring an essay by Glenn Kenny.
Movie: 78
Fritz Lang's "Ministry of Fear" (1944) is a taut entry in the film noir genre, notable for its suspense, paranoia, and technical prowess. The film follows Stephen Neale (Ray Milland), freshly released from a mental institution, who becomes entangled in an elaborate espionage plot after winning a seemingly innocuous cake at a village fair. This cake thrusts him into a convoluted narrative filled with Nazi spies, murder, and political intrigue in wartime London. Lang's direction imbues the film with a palpable sense of unease, using both high and low camera angles, strategically placed shadows, and meticulous set design to heighten the atmosphere. Despite some choppy editing and narrative lulls, the film's lean 87-minute runtime ensures that the tension remains high.
Lang's adaptation of Graham Greene’s novel is marked by deviations from the source material—most notably the omission of the protagonist's amnesia—which nonetheless serve to enhance the story's tight pacing and sense of urgency. Ray Milland delivers a compelling performance as Neale, whose fragile mental state and enigmatic past make him both relatable and unpredictable. Marjorie Reynolds and Carl Esmond provide solid support, although Reynolds’ Austrian accent may come off as unconvincing to some viewers. Hillary Brooke’s role, though brief, is memorable, particularly in a tension-filled scene where she attempts to seduce Neale while he cautiously tries to steal a gun from her purse.
"Ministry of Fear" maintains elements reminiscent of Hitchcockian thrillers—the wrongly accused man on the run, the duplicitous protagonist, and dark humor—yet it firmly establishes its own identity through Lang’s distinct stylistic touches. While not as renowned as some of Lang’s other works or better-known noirs like "Double Indemnity," this film stands out for its layered narrative, atmospheric cinematography by Henry Sharp, and its astute commentary on paranoia and wartime propaganda.
Total: 64
Fritz Lang's "Ministry of Fear" may not rank alongside the director’s most celebrated masterpieces, yet this World War II anti-Nazi propaganda film masterfully blends mystery and intrigue. Ray Milland delivers a captivating performance as a bewildered man on the run, while Lang's artistic and fluid direction ensures engagement throughout the movie. Though the narrative has its occasional slow moments, the film's atmospheric noir elements and stylish cinematography provide a compelling viewing experience for fans of classic thrillers.
The Criterion Collection’s Blu-ray release of "Ministry of Fear" features a superb 2K digital restoration, showcasing the film’s visual nuances with remarkable sharpness and clarity. The audio transfer is also outstanding, maintaining Criterion's reputation for high-quality presentations. While the supplemental features might be lighter than usual, the included liner notes offer valuable insights into Lang's work and the film's historical context. The pristine transfer alone makes this release a must-have for film aficionados.
In conclusion, "Ministry of Fear" stands as a notable entry in Lang’s oeuvre, offering a dark, stylish, and engaging thriller experience that surpasses many contemporaneous films. Criterion's meticulous restoration efforts breathe new life into this vintage classic, ensuring its accessibility and appeal to modern audiences. Despite the modest supplement package, this Blu-ray edition is highly recommended for noir enthusiasts and collectors of classic cinema alike.
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 90
Thousands of instances of dirt, debris, scratches, splices, warps, and jitter were manually removed using MTI's DRS and Pixel Farm's PFClean, while Image Systems' Phoenix was used for small dirt, grain,...
Audio: 80
Obviously, the range of nuanced dynamic is quite limited, but this should not be surprising considering the film's age and native sound design....
Extras: 50
Mr. McElhaney also discusses Lang's image in Hollywood, the unique structure of his films and qualities of their protagonists, how some of his best known films compare to Alfred Hitchcock's films, the...
Movie: 80
The approach, however, enhances rather well the sense of paranoia that enters the film after the man with the cake is killed....
Total: 80
Ministry of Fear is a minor film in Fritz Lang's oeuvre, but still one that is a lot better than the majority of similarly themed films that were produced immediately after the war....
The Digital Bits review by Tim SalmonsRead review here
Video: 95
Audio: 80
Extras: 50
Movie: 85
the man offers the blind man a piece of the cake... the blind man sifts the cake through his fingers before eating it......
Total: 78
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Once again, Criterion does a classic title proud, enhancing the viewing experience with a silky yet natural image that brings out the beauty of Henry Sharp's black-and-white photography while keeping us...
Audio: 80
Distortion is never an issue, thanks to a dynamic scale that's wide enough to handle anything the movie throws at it, and Victor Young's music score fills the room nicely, even if it lacks the warmth and...
Extras: 20
The author and Fritz Lang scholar analyzes the film and its director in this interesting, but rather sluggish interview....
Movie: 80
True, the movie omits or alters several sections of the book, but as an exercise in suspense and example of noir filmmaking, it largely succeeds, thanks to Lang's sure-handed style, nuanced artistry, and...
Total: 60
'Ministry of Fear' may not rank up there with Fritz Lang's greatest works, but this bit of World War II anti-Nazi propoganda wrapped up in a tale of mystery and intrigue stands on its own as a taut, engrossing,...
Director: Fritz Lang
Actors: Ray Milland, Marjorie Reynolds, Carl Esmond
PlotStephen Neale is recently released from a mental asylum during World War II. He heads to London, hoping for a fresh start. At a village fair, he wins a cake by guessing its weight, a seemingly innocent act that triggers a series of unexpected events. Soon after, Neale finds himself entangled in a web of espionage and intrigue, as the cake appears to be the centerpiece of a Nazi spy ring's covert operations. He narrowly escapes an attempt on his life and realizes that he has stumbled upon something far more sinister than he could have anticipated.
Determined to clear his name and uncover the truth, Neale teams up with siblings Willi and Carla Hilfe. Together, they venture deeper into the shadowy world of counterintelligence. As Neale delves further, he discovers layers of deception, encountering enigmatic figures and puzzling clues that test his resolve and sanity. As the tension escalates and the stakes become increasingly high, Neale must navigate an elaborate maze of danger and betrayal, with each step bringing him closer to unraveling the conspiracy and potentially exposing the spies threatening national security.
Writers: Seton I. Miller, Graham Greene
Release Date: 04 Jan 1945
Runtime: 86 min
Rating: Passed
Country: United States
Language: English