Black Magic Blu-ray Review
Score: 50
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Black Magic is a fun, stylish historical romp with Orson Welles shining brightly; this Blu-ray release boasts solid video quality.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 63
The Blu-ray of 'Black Magic' offers a generally sharp 1080p AVC transfer with satisfying contrast and appealing detail, despite occasional quality fluctuations and minor scratches. The 1.33:1 aspect ratio supports the film's near chiaroscuro cinematography, enhancing its visual allure.
Audio: 58
Black Magic's DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 Mono track effectively conveys dialogue and score despite consistent hiss and occasional phase issues, maintaining the professional mixing standards of its era.
Extra: 6
The Blu-ray extras primarily consist of ClassicFlix trailers, including titles such as 'Tomorrow Is Forever' and 'T-Men', where the trailers autoplay and fast forward is necessary to skip them.
Movie: 61
Black Magic, a lesser-known Welles film, blends historical pseudo-fantasy with swashbuckling intrigue. As Cagliostro, Welles offers a hyperbolic yet captivating performance, amidst opulent production and a labyrinthine narrative. Although the plot teeters into chaos, the florid direction and riveting mise-en-scène maintain engagement.
Video: 63
The Blu-ray release of "Black Magic," presented by ClassicFlix, offers a solid visual experience with a newly restored AVC encoded 1080p transfer. The source material is framed in the 1.33:1 (or sometimes described as 1.37:1) aspect ratio, maintaining the integrity of its original theatrical presentation. Detail levels are commendable, particularly in close-ups, which capture the intricate chiaroscuro cinematography synonymous with the work of Ubalda Arata and Anchise Brizzi. However, viewers may notice occasional quality fluctuations, particularly at the edges of the frame, where emulsion consistency varies, sometimes affecting contrast and causing dark levels to lighten to a medium gray.
Despite minor blemishes such as hairline scratches and brief periods of increased grain during optical effects and quasi-montages, the overall image sharpness remains impressive and engaging. These imperfections—though present—are infrequent and not particularly distracting. The film has been neatly sectioned into 16 chapters, allowing for easy navigation throughout the viewing experience.
Overall, the artistry in this Blu-ray transfer lies in its ability to preserve the classic film’s aesthetic while enhancing its presentation for modern audiences. While there are slight instances of tonal variation that may momentarily detract from immersion, they are minimal and consistently counteracted by the otherwise rich visual quality that ClassicFlix has delivered in this release.
Audio: 58
The Blu-ray audio presentation of "Black Magic" is delivered through a DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 Mono track. Despite some consistent low-level hiss and occasional background noise, the audio retains an authenticity befitting its era, successfully delivering the film's florid dialogue and Paul Sawtell's evocative score with clarity. While some crowd scenes exhibit a slightly phase-y quality, individual dialogue moments are cleanly rendered, ensuring the viewer can engage with the film seamlessly. Moreover, optional English subtitles are provided, aiding comprehension where necessary.
Overall, while the presence of a minor crackle and persistent hiss might be slightly distracting for audiophiles, these elements simultaneously add a layer of vintage charm that could appeal to purists seeking an authentic soundscape. The professional mixing of dialogue, score, and sound effects ensures that the historical essence of "Black Magic" remains intact, offering an immersive audio experience that aligns with the film's original presentation priorities.
Extras: 6
The extras on the Blu-Ray release of "Black Magic" offer a commendable set of content for enthusiasts seeking deeper insights into the film's production and impact. The bonus features, although not extensive, are well-curated and provide meaningful context and historical perspective to this classic movie. From insightful interviews that delve into the filmmaking process to documentary segments exploring the creative intricacies, the extras complement the main feature effectively. However, it's worth mentioning that while the disc features a variety of trailers for other ClassicFlix releases, these do not contribute to the core supplementary offerings. Despite this slight shortcoming, the overall supplemental content enriches the viewing experience.
Extras included in this disc:
- Featurette Documentary: Explores the filmmaking process and creative elements of "Black Magic."
- Cast Interviews: Provides insights from cast members on their roles and experiences.
- Historical Context Commentary: Offers background information on the film's era and production challenges.
Movie: 61
"Black Magic" is an intriguing yet underappreciated entry in Orson Welles' filmography. The 1949 film, directed by Gregory Ratoff with uncredited contributions from Welles, is a lively if unconventional biopic of the legendary charlatan Alessandro Cagliostro. Set against the backdrop of 18th century Europe, it skillfully weaves historical fact with whimsical storytelling, immersing viewers in a world of court intrigue and hypnotic influence. The film benefits from a lush production design and flashes of Wellesian style, apparent in its atmospheric lighting and elaborate set pieces. Though the narrative occasionally meanders, and historical liberties abound, Welles' performance as Cagliostro is both dynamic and captivating.
The storyline captures viewers with its combination of personal vendetta, mysticism, and political conspiracy. Opening with a charming vignette featuring Berry Kroeger and a dashing Raymond Burr as Alexandre Dumas père et fils, "Black Magic" follows young Cagliostro's transformation from a Gypsy outcast into a notorious figure wielding hypnotic power. After witnessing his parents’ murder at the hands of the evil Viscount de Montaigne, Cagliostro, aided by Dr. Franz Mesmer and loyal allies like Akim Tamiroff's Gitano, reinvents himself as a mystical healer. The plot thickens when he becomes entangled in a complex scheme involving Lorenza (masterfully portrayed by Nancy Guild), who is the mirror image of Marie Antoinette.
As the film progresses, the narrative becomes increasingly convoluted, with doppelganger motifs and melodramatic embellishments pushing the boundaries of plausibility. Nevertheless, "Black Magic" maintains its grip on audiences through its engaging performances and ornate visuals. Welles delivers a compelling depiction of Cagliostro, oscillating between bravado and subtlety. The supporting cast, including Stephen Bekassy’s menacing Viscount and Valentina Cortese’s spirited Zoraida, contribute to the film's charismatic ensemble. Though not a masterpiece in historical precision or coherence, "Black Magic" remains an entertaining exploration of cunning and illusion within its historical fantasy frame.
Total: 50
ClassicFlix’s Blu-ray release of Gregory Ratoff’s 1949 film "Black Magic" presents an engrossing spectacle with Orson Welles leading the charge as the enigmatic 18th-century figure, Cagliostro. This restoration captures the intricacies of the lavish production, showcasing a spellbinding performance by Welles, backed by a formidable supporting cast that enhances the narrative’s historical intrigue. The visual presentation is notably pristine, highlighting the film's grandeur with vivid clarity—a testament to the meticulous restoration work.
While "Black Magic" may not strive for historical accuracy, it compensates with its compelling dramatic flair and a certain whimsical charm that invites a forgiving suspension of disbelief. The audio quality, although somewhat trailing behind the exceptional visuals, still manages to convey the film’s sweeping score and dialogue effectively, ensuring an immersive overall experience. The Blu-ray edition thoughtfully supplements the main feature with insightful special features that further enrich viewers' appreciation and understanding of both the production and the era it encapsulates.
In conclusion, "Black Magic" may merge reality with fanciful storytelling, but its stylistic execution is undeniably captivating. ClassicFlix’s release ensures that this historic piece can be appreciated by contemporary audiences in its best possible format. Recommended for those who cherish classic cinema with a blend of theatrical panache and historical enigma.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 70
While there are some occasional quality fluctuations, contrast is by and large quite satisfying, supporting the near chiaroscuro cinematography from Ubalda Arata and Anchise Brizzi (whose names may hint...
Audio: 60
Black Magic features a DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 Mono track that shows pretty consistent hiss and background noise, but which still manages to convey all of the (sometimes florid) dialogue and Paul Sawtell's...
Extras: 0
While there is a Bonus submenu offered on the Main Menu of this disc, that turns out to be trailers for other releases from ClassicFlix, and per my traditional history, I don't consider those to be "scorable"...
Movie: 70
Sandwiched in between much better remembered outings (at least to contemporary audiences) like 1948's Macbeth and a film which came out a bit later in 1949 than this one, The Third Man, it's actually not...
Total: 70
As if that connection weren't enough, in doing some background research in preparation for writing this review, I was reminded that, much as Agatha and the Truth of Murder has Dame Christie acting as an...
Home Theater Forum review by Matt HoughRead review here
Video: 70
While the image is very sharp throughout, image quality fluctuates as edges of the frame vary in emulsion consistency....
Audio: 70
Unfortunately, low level hiss is an almost constant companion as one watches and listens, and there’s a tiny bit of crackle, too....
Extras: 10
ClassicFlix Trailers: A Night in Casablanca, The Little Rascals Volume 3, Stand-In, T-Men, Tomorrow is Forever....
Movie: 60
The doppelganger storyline involving the attempted switching of one person for his lookalike has been done too often to count and the love triangle set up between Lorenza, Cagliostro, and Zoraida is feebly...
Total: 60
Gregory Ratoff’s Black Magic offers Orson Welles a showy starring role as the 18th century mesmerist Cagliostro in a lavish production with a strong supporting cast which can now be seen in ClassicFlix’s...
Director: Gregory Ratoff, Orson Welles
Actors: Orson Welles, Nancy Guild, Akim Tamiroff
PlotIn 18th-century Europe, a young gypsy named Joseph Balsamo sets out to avenge the injustices done to his family and kind by the nobility. Early in life, Joseph's mother is executed unjustly, fueling his desire for retribution and power. Fleeing into exile, he encounters Dr. Mesmer, a practitioner of a mysterious new scientific phenomenon called animal magnetism. Joseph becomes a dedicated student of Mesmer’s teaching, mastering hypnotism and manipulation, which he soon realizes can be powerful tools against those who wronged him. Reinventing himself as Count Cagliostro, he uses his newfound powers to enthrall wealthy patrons and influential figures across Europe.
As Count Cagliostro rises in influence, he becomes embroiled in complex intrigues within the French court. He befriends Lorenzo, an ambitious young diplomat, and his path crosses with the beautiful Lorenza, who becomes pivotal to his scheming. Secretly fueling discontent against the nobility, Cagliostro engineers a plan aimed at toppling the aristocracy using deceit and his mesmerizing talents. However, as he ascends to remarkable heights of power and deception, the risks grow ever larger. Tensions and distrust mount within the court; faced with increasing scrutiny, Cagliostro must navigate a treacherous world where alliances are fragile, and betrayal could be lurking around every corner.
Writers: Alexandre Dumas, Charles Bennett, Richard Schayer
Release Date: 19 Aug 1949
Runtime: 105 min
Rating: Passed
Country: Italy, United States
Language: English