Saturn 3 Blu-ray Review
Score: 66
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
“Saturn 3,” a flawed but cult-favorite sci-fi thriller with commendable Blu-ray release featuring excellent high-def transfer, engaging extras, and solid audio quality.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 74
"Saturn 3's Blu-ray presentation by Scream Factory delivers a remarkable 1080p AVC encoded transfer, overcoming the film's dated sets with well-defined details, vibrant colors, and strong contrast. Despite minor technical flaws, the high-definition upgrade enhances the visual experience significantly."
Audio: 63
The Blu-ray of 'Saturn 3' offers DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 and 5.1 options, with the 5.1 mix being front-heavy but clean and clear. Dialogue and Bernstein's score are well-prioritized, providing a somewhat immersive experience. While the mono mix is preferred for its authenticity, both tracks deliver crisp, satisfying audio.
Extra: 64
The Blu-ray extras for 'Saturn 3' are both highly informative and engaging, featuring in-depth interviews with voice artist Roy Dotrice and special effects director Colin Chilvers about their contributions, additional scenes from the network TV version, an infamous deleted ecstasy scene, and a detailed audio commentary by Greg Moss which thoroughly explores the film's production and legacy.
Movie: 49
Saturn 3, a sci-fi thriller marred by its troubled production, falls short of its potential despite a notable cast and impressive sets. The film's interesting ideas, such as a robot's human-like emotions, are overshadowed by a lackluster script and awkward casting choices, leading to an overall disjointed viewing experience.
Video: 74
The Blu-ray presentation of "Saturn 3" by Scream Factory showcases a remarkably robust high-definition upgrade, utilizing a 1080p AVC encoded transfer in a 1.85:1 aspect ratio. Featuring cinematography by Oscar-winning Billy Williams, the film’s visuals benefit greatly from this well-executed remaster. Despite the film’s budgetary limitations and occasionally uninspired set design, the natural grain structure is maintained, and fine details, such as close-ups, exhibit impressive clarity. The film does see some anomalies, like telecine wobble during the opening and closing credits, but these instances are minor in comparison to the overall quality.
Color fidelity is another highlight of this transfer, with a vibrant palette that breathes life into the production design and costumes. Primary colors appear bold and well-saturated, enhancing visual appeal significantly. Contrast and black levels are spot-on, ensuring deep, accurate shadows and strong image depth throughout. Although there are occasional issues with flesh tones appearing somewhat pallid, the overall consistency and sharpness of the image make this a minor concern. The transfer offers fans an unprecedented view of "Saturn 3," with every detail meticulously rendered, adding to the film’s charm and depth.
In summary, Scream Factory's Blu-ray of "Saturn 3" provides viewers with an upgraded visual experience that far surpasses expectations for a low-budget sci-fi film. The high-quality transfer captures every nuance, from intricate close-ups to immersive backgrounds, delivering a highly detailed and engaging viewing experience. Despite some minor technical hiccups, this release stands as one of Scream Factory's finest efforts to date, elevating the film's visual presentation to new heights.
Audio: 63
The audio presentation of "Saturn 3" on Blu-ray boasts two distinct DTS-HD Master Audio tracks: a 5.1 surround mix and a 2.0 stereo option. The 5.1 mix is a moderate upgrade from the original, with a front-heavy orientation where Elmer Bernstein's score primarily utilizes the surround channels. While the sonic landscape might not be immensely immersive, the mix manages to be engaging without overwhelming the listener. The effects occasionally spill into the side and rear channels, creating a balanced yet refined audio experience. Vocals and dialogue are consistently crisp and clear, ensuring that nothing detracts from the narrative delivery.
Despite some conservative use of the rear channels, the 5.1 mix does have moments where its subwoofer engagement and spatial placement of recorded voices stand out, offering brief but impactful auditory peaks. Bass lines can sometimes appear exaggerated during action sequences, yet overall, dynamic range remains commendable. For purists and those seeking a more original audio experience, the 2.0 DTS-HD Master Audio track is a closer replica of the theatrical sound design from 1980. This version provides clean, intelligible dialogue in the center channel with a well-managed dynamic range, though it falls short on upper and lower frequency activity. Both tracks make impressive contributions to this Blu-ray release, demonstrating a high level of audio fidelity and attention to preservation of the film’s auditory essence.
Extras: 64
The extras on the "Saturn 3" Blu-ray release provide a rich assortment of insightful and engaging content that delves into various aspects of the film’s production. The interviews are particularly notable, offering in-depth conversations with key contributors such as voice artist Roy Dotrice and special-effects director Colin Chilvers. Each of these segments brings a unique perspective on the behind-the-scenes processes, including the challenges faced and techniques employed. The additional network TV scenes and the infamous Ecstasy scene present rare content that adds to the film's lore. Moreover, the commentary by film expert Greg Moss, moderated by Dave Bradley, offers a comprehensive and passionate exploration of the movie, though it can be somewhat disjointed at times. Taken together, these extras enrich the viewer’s understanding and appreciation of "Saturn 3."
Extras included in this disc:
- Interview with Voice Artist Roy Dotrice: Discussion on the dubbing process over Harvey Keitel.
- Interview with Special Effects Director Colin Chilvers: Insights into practical effects and production challenges.
- Additional Scenes from the Network TV Version: Additional dialogue and character moments.
- Deleted Ecstasy Scene: Extended footage featuring Fawcett in a provocative costume.
- Theatrical Trailer: Original preview trailer of the film.
- TV Spots: Two television advertisements.
- Still Gallery: Collection of promotional shots and behind-the-scenes images.
- Audio Commentary with Greg Moss: In-depth commentary moderated by Dave Bradley.
Movie: 49
"Saturn 3" is a peculiar entry in the landscape of 1980s science fiction cinema, featuring a mix of star power and ambitious, yet often unfulfilled, thematic elements. Directed by Stanley Donen, the film juxtaposes an aging Kirk Douglas and the then-popular Farrah Fawcett against the youthfully threatening Harvey Keitel, an actor whose Brooklyn accent was dubbed over due to production choices. The story centers on Adam (Douglas) and Alex (Fawcett) residing on Saturn's third moon, running a hydroponic research station. Their peaceful existence is shattered by the arrival of a psychotic imposter, Captain Benson (Keitel), along with a menacing robot that shares his violent inclinations. The film presents an intriguing, albeit clunky examination of human-robot dynamics where emotional transference leads to chaos.
Visually, "Saturn 3" boasts some impressive set designs courtesy of John Barry, renowned for his work on "Star Wars". Despite workable effects and aesthetically pleasing settings, the film struggles to maintain narrative momentum, bogged down by repetitive scenes and dialogue. The tension promised by its premise never fully materializes, restrained perhaps by Donen’s apparent struggle to adapt his directorial prowess to the sci-fi genre, previously demonstrated in his successful handling of musicals and thrillers. Additionally, Elmer Bernstein's score flirts interestingly with influences from "2001: A Space Odyssey," yet follows its own unique path thereafter.
Despite its potential, “Saturn 3” falters due to a complex production history, budget cuts, and conflicting creative visions. Douglas' insistence on displaying a façade of youthful virility further complicates the on-screen dynamic with Fawcett, half his age. Though the film touches on compelling ideas such as AI influenced by human emotions and existential threats posed by technological overreach, it never fully capitalizes on these concepts. The result is a cult film that remains visually intriguing but narratively disjointed, leaving audiences with glimpses of brilliance overshadowed by missed opportunities.
Total: 66
"Saturn 3," directed by Stanley Donen and featuring an intriguing cast, including Kirk Douglas, Farah Fawcett, and Harvey Keitel, has managed to secure a place in the realm of cult classic sci-fi, though it is not without its flaws. The film, an apparent attempt to ride the wave of the genre's burgeoning popularity in its era, offers a mix of camp value and oftentimes lackluster execution. Despite its shortcomings, this release from Shout! Factory elevates the experience with a meticulously restored high-definition transfer and solid audio presentation. Fans of 80s sci-fi and cult cinema will appreciate the pristine quality of the print, which manages to make the film's retro aesthetics shine.
The Blu-ray package stands out, thanks to the diligent work on supplemental features. The extras are engaging and informative, with a particularly passionate commentary track offering insights into the production's history and the careers of its principal players. These supplements significantly enhance the viewing experience, providing context and depth that the film itself occasionally lacks. The visual quality of this release is exceptional, making "Saturn 3" feel fresh despite its decades-old origins. The care taken in preserving and presenting this film shows a deep respect for the fans and cinephiles who revel in niche cinematic experiences.
In conclusion, while "Saturn 3" may only hold limited appeal beyond its campy charm and brief moments of Farah Fawcett's nudity, Shout! Factory's Blu-ray release is a commendable effort that showcases their commitment to delivering high-quality editions of cult classics. This is a must-have for dedicated fans and curious viewers alike; however, those seeking a more substantial storyline may find it lacking. Ultimately, it’s an edition worth considering for its technical excellence and nostalgic value.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 80
Audio: 80
Extras: 70
Movie: 40
Total: 60
The Digital Bits review by Tim SalmonsRead review here
Video: 90
Audio: 85
Extras: 85
Movie: 55
Total: 79
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Audio: 60
Extras: 20
Movie: 60
Total: 60
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 100
Audio: 80
Extras: 90
Movie: 50
Total: 80
Director: Stanley Donen, John Barry
Actors: Farrah Fawcett, Kirk Douglas, Harvey Keitel
PlotIn a remote space station on Titan's moon Saturn 3, scientists Adam and Alex lead a tranquil yet isolated existence, conducting research to support an overpopulated Earth. Their solitude is disrupted when Benson, a mentally unstable Earth pilot, arrives with a new high-tech robot named Hector. Initially introduced as an advanced assistant to help with their work, Hector soon becomes a source of tension as Benson’s neurotic behavior and obsessive tendencies begin to influence the robot's programming.
As Hector grows more erratic and dangerous, Adam and Alex find themselves in a perilous situation, struggling not only to continue their vital research but also to survive the escalating threats from both Benson and his increasingly uncontrollable creation. The tight-knit environment of the space station becomes a battleground for control and survival, where the once peaceful atmosphere transforms into one of suspense and danger.
Writers: Martin Amis, John Barry
Release Date: 15 Feb 1980
Runtime: 88 min
Rating: R
Country: United Kingdom
Language: English