Harakiri Blu-ray Review
切腹 Seppuku Masters of Cinema
Score: 66
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Harakiri is a visually stunning, powerful critique of samurai philosophy, masterfully remastered by Eureka Entertainment. VERY HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.
Disc Release Date
Video: 73
Harakiri’s UK Blu-ray presentation boasts a near-perfect 1080p AVC-encoded transfer in the theatrically correct 2.35:1 aspect ratio, with impressive detail, rich colors, and strong contrast, while maintaining authentic film grain and avoiding artificial enhancement; a significant upgrade from previous releases.
Audio: 63
Presented with a Japanese DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track, the Blu-ray of 'Harakiri' boasts rich, layered narration, clear dialogue, and lush biwa solos by Toru Takemitsu. Atmospheric effects and steel slicing sounds are rendered cleanly, enhancing Kobayashi's intention, with minimal distortion and no distracting background noise.
Extra: 46
The Blu-ray extras for 'Harakiri' include a valuable 10-minute interview with director Masaki Kobayashi discussing the film's reception, score, and cinematography, alongside a 28-page booklet with a new essay by Philip Kemp, a 1963 interview, and rare production stills, plus the original Japanese trailer—all enhancing the viewing experience.
Movie: 91
Masaki Kobayashi's 'Harakiri' remains a brutal and unflinching masterpiece nearly fifty years on, epitomized by Tatsuya Nakadai's transformative performance. The Blu-ray from Eureka boasts an impressive new HD transfer with great depth and detail, complemented by a pristine lossless 2.0 audio track and insightful extras.
Video: 73
Harakiri arrives on Blu-ray with an impressive 1080p high-definition transfer, presented in a theatrically accurate 2.35:1 aspect ratio and encoded using the AVC codec. The source material, a new master from Shochiku, has undergone minimal post-production processing, resulting in a remarkably clean and stable presentation. The dark sequences, such as those inside Motome's house, maintain high levels of detail, while outdoor scenes exhibit spectacular clarity. The video quality shows significant improvements over previous DVD releases, with fine grain and sharpness offering a considerable upgrade.
The contrast balance of the film is notably strong but not overpowering, preserving the natural appearance of blacks without excessive boosting, and ensuring whites remain controlled without blooming. Each frame benefits from the transition to full HD, most notably in wider shots like the courtyard scenes, where Yoshio Miyajima's cinematography draws the eye through detailed layers of retainers to focus on central characters.
Fine details are immaculately preserved, evident in close-ups of theatrical hairpieces, perspiration, and ornate costume patterns. Notable sequences such as the final duel showcase the transfer's strengths, with detailed textures in clothing, hair movement in the wind, and cloud formations behind bringing the scene to life. The transfer is devoid of macroblocking and edge-enhancement, and there are no visible cuts, stains, or damage marks. Overall, this Blu-ray presentation of Harakiri stands as an excellent preservation of the film's visual integrity.
Audio: 63
The Blu-ray presentation of "Harakiri" features a singular audio track: Japanese DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0. The track, while not tasked with delivering an abundance of sound effects, excels in faithfully reproducing the rich and dynamic elements inherent in the film's audio landscape. Masaki Kobayashi's reliance on pauses and silence to build tension is expertly preserved, showcasing the high-quality mastering process. Tatsuya Nakadai's narration benefits significantly from the higher bitrate, which adds a potent depth and layered richness to his imposing tone, albeit slightly on the deep side. Dialogue reproduction is generally well-balanced, though minor imbalances can be noted — an understandable characteristic for a film of this vintage.
Toru Takemitsu's evocative score, especially the biwa solos, is particularly well-served by this DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track. The biwa comes through lush and clear, adding a unique atmospheric layer that enhances the film's dramatic sequences. Strings exhibit a mellow tonality with an improved range and natural fade. Notably, the high-frequency clashing sounds retain their eerie quality without appearing artificially heightened. The film's climactic duel introduces subtle atmospheric effects with the sounds of wind, dust, and whistling breezes rising and falling through the speakers in an engaging manner. The clean and even presentation stands out, devoid of crackle, sudden pops, or background hiss that could detract from the immersive experience.
Overall, "Harakiri's" audio track offers a pristine and impactful listening experience. It successfully preserves the film's intricate soundscape while enhancing key elements like dialogue clarity and musical resonance. This meticulous attention to audio detail serves to enrich Masaki Kobayashi’s masterful direction and Toru Takemitsu’s timeless score, making it a noteworthy presentation for fans and audiophiles alike.
Extras: 46
The Blu-ray release of "Harakiri" impressively enhances its value with well-curated extras. Highlighting these, the 28-page booklet provides essential reading with a historical interview of Kobayashi from 1963, coupled with an insightful essay by film critic Philip Kemp and rare production stills. A recorded interview conducted by Masahiro Shinoda in October 1993 for the Directors Guild of Japan provides rare insights directly from Kobayashi concerning the Cannes reception, collaboration with his cinematographer, and the film score by Toru Takemitsu. The added original Japanese trailer allows for a fascinating comparison with the theatrical release, featuring alternate shots not seen in the final cut. Collectively, these extras greatly enrich the viewing experience for aficionados and casual viewers alike.
Extras included in this disc:
- Booklet: A 28-page booklet featuring a 1963 interview with Kobayashi, an essay by Philip Kemp, and rare production stills.
- Kobayashi Interview: A 1993 interview with Kobayashi conducted by Masahiro Shinoda.
- Original Japanese Trailer: The theatrical trailer with alternate shots.
Movie: 91
Masaki Kobayashi’s Harakiri, though nearly half a century old, astounds with its unrelenting starkness and emotional depth. The film is a studied critique of feudal Japan, challenging its antiquated, often contradictory values through a narrative of seething human drama. Kobayashi masterfully balances a brilliant script, Yoshio Miyajima’s incisive cinematography, Toru Takemitsu’s haunting score, and Tatsuya Nakadai’s gripping central performance. Nakadai's portrayal of Hanshiro Tsugumo is multifaceted, presenting a fearless warrior, a deeply human figure through flashbacks, and ultimately a man consumed by anger. The film’s HD transfer by Eureka from Shochiku's archives delivers exceptional depth and detail, enhancing its lasting impact.
Set in 1630 Japan, the film follows the disillusioned ronin Hanshiro as he petitions to commit harakiri at Lord Lyi’s manor. Confronting the clan leader Kageyu Saito’s suspicions of dishonest intentions, Hanshiro narrates his poignant tale, deconstructing the romanticized samurai ethos. Unlike Akira Kurosawa's noble ronin, Hanshiro is a tormented outcast, highlighting the systemic flaws and cultural hypocrisy of the era. This film is visually distinctive with precise long shots and dynamic zooms by Miyajima that lend it a modern feel, accompanied by Takemitsu’s minimalist biwa solos enhancing the tense atmosphere.
Harakiri emerges not just as an indictment of a flawed feudal system but as an affirmation of individualism and ethical protest against social injustice. Its narrative is not only timeless but rendered with such craftsmanship that it remains profoundly evocative. The Blu-ray release features a lossless 2.0 track that is clear but limited in eliciting the “wow” factor some might desire. The additional material includes interviews with Kobayashi and archival production stills, providing insightful context for fans and scholars alike. This Blu-ray release by Eureka establishes a new benchmark in presenting this cinematic masterpiece.
Total: 66
Harakiri, directed by Masaki Kobayashi, is a profound critique of samurai ethos and the inherent duplicity within the feudal system of Japan's Edo period. This cinematic masterpiece's Blu-ray debut by Eureka Entertainment showcases a meticulously restored transfer, rendering the film with remarkable visual clarity and depth. The picture quality, enhanced by high-definition resolution, captures the intricate details and stark contrasts that Kobayashi employs to underscore the film's thematic gravity. Each frame embodies a level of precision that underscores both the director’s artistic vision and the demanding nature of samurai existence, making it an essential addition to any serious film collection.
The audio presentation is equally commendable. The DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono track remains faithful to the original score, ensuring an immersive experience that complements the film’s visual intensity. Dialogue is crisp and clear, maintaining its crucial narrative role without succumbing to distortion or imbalance. The score by Toru Takemitsu, characterized by its evocative minimalism, benefits immensely from the Blu-ray’s improved dynamic range, intensifying the film’s emotional and psychological impact. Moreover, Eureka Entertainment has delivered a robust selection of supplementary materials, including insightful commentaries and interviews that enrich the understanding of both the film and its broader historical context.
In conclusion, Harakiri on Blu-ray is a definitive presentation of Kobayashi’s groundbreaking work. The restoration and transfer efforts significantly amplify the film’s visual and auditory strengths, providing a vastly enhanced experience compared to previous releases. With its profound sociopolitical commentary and meticulously executed craftsmanship, this Blu-ray edition is indispensable for aficionados of classic cinema and those eager to explore the nuances of Japanese cultural narratives. VERY HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.
avforums review by Mark BotwrightRead review here
Video: 90
Wider shots show the greatest benefit from the transition to full HD, with the frame now having a depth it had previously lacked – the courtyard scenes especially show this upgrade with the eye being drawn,...
Audio: 70
There's minimal atmospheric effects until the final windy duel, but Nakadai's narration seems to benefit from the higher bitrate, taking on an even more forceful and imposing tone now, the timbre of which...
Extras: 50
BookletA 28 page booklet which includes an interview with Kobayashi from the year following the film's release, as well a new essay about Harakiri by film critic Philip Kemp, alongside the usual array...
Movie: 90
Harakiri has lost none of its edge, bringing together strands of a narrative that is quintessentially timeless in terms of tragedy, and weaving them around a backdrop of feudal values (some period, some...
Total: 80
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 90
Naturally, considering Eureka Entertainment's policy to use raw high-definition transfers (avoiding post-production corrections) for their Bu-ray releases, I believe that all of the minor image fluctuations...
Audio: 90
Some of the best sequences in the film are complimented by very atmospheric biwa solos that give the film a very unique flavor....
Extras: 50
The two directors discuss the success of Harakiri, the graphic scenes in the film, Toru Takemitsu's terrific score, etc....
Movie: 100
The film also boasts a spectacular music score, arguably one of the best ever conceived for a Japanese period film, courtesy of acclaimed composer Toru Takemitsu (Woman in the Dunes, Double Suicide) --...
Total: 80
Arriving for the first time ever on Blu-ray, courtesy of British distributors Eureka Entertainment, the film looks gorgeous, the best it ever has....
Director: Masaki Kobayashi
Actors: Tatsuya Nakadai, Akira Ishihama, Shima Iwashita
PlotIn the early 17th century, an impoverished samurai named Hanshiro Tsugumo arrives at the estate of the Iyi clan, requesting permission to commit seppuku (ritual suicide) in their courtyard. Suspecting that Hanshiro might be bluffing to gain financial assistance, the clan's senior counselor, Kageyu Saito, recounts the grim story of a fellow samurai, Motome Chijiiwa, who recently made a similar request. Believing Motome was dishonoring samuari code, the clan insisted he follow through with the ritual using his own bamboo sword, resulting in a brutal death. Emphasizing this tale, Saito hopes to deter Hanshiro from proceeding with his request.
Unfazed, Hanshiro insists on going through with the seppuku and begins to recount his own story, gradually revealing his ties to Motome. Through his tale, deep moral and ethical questions about the samurai code and the true meaning of honor are brought to light. As Hanshiro's story unfolds, the extent of the Iyi clan's hypocrisy and cruelty becomes apparent, leading to a suspenseful confrontation between rigid tradition and individual conscience.
Writers: Yasuhiko Takiguchi, Shinobu Hashimoto
Release Date: 04 Aug 1964
Runtime: 133 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: Japan
Language: Japanese