Row 19 Blu-ray Review
Ряд 19 Ryad 19
Score: 55
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Row 19 offers solid technical merits but falters with a confusing screenplay and an inadequate portrayal of its themes.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 71
Row 19's Blu-ray presentation delivers a competent 1080p transfer with typically sharp imagery and fine detail. Despite minor CGI flaws and occasional low-light noise, the film maintains stable clarity, vivid color accuracy, and effective contrast, though banding in exterior shots suggests original animation faults.
Audio: 71
Row 19's Blu-ray audio presentation offers a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 in both Russian—which delivers moments of subliminal eeriness and clear dialogue—and English, with robust yet occasionally excessive ambiance and bass that lacks depth, while maintaining a technically engaging sound design.
Extra: 4
The Blu-ray of 'Row 19' offers minimal extras, limited to an HD trailer and automatic trailers for other Well Go USA releases, with packaging that includes a slipcover.
Movie: 43
Row 19, clocking in at a brisk 78 minutes, awkwardly blends psychological horror with supernatural elements, echoing classic sci-fi motifs. It explores themes of strength and trauma inherent in Russian culture with limited success, offering disjointed, unrealistic dialogues and an illogical twist that mar its narrative efficacy.
Video: 71
"Row 19" is presented on Blu-ray by Well Go USA with an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in a 2.39:1 aspect ratio. Although specific shooting details like a 2K DI aren't confirmed, the film features competent capture quality. The transfer maintains sharpness and clarity, exemplified by well-rendered fine details such as textures in the cabin. Noteworthy is the natural grading that brings out the palette, despite the fuselage's often peculiar lighting. Minor compression anomalies are present, particularly in some CGI segments, showing slight artifacts without overwhelming the experience.
The digital cinematography of "Row 19" is generally satisfactory, though certain aspects, like low light noise, suggest its pedestrian origins. While overall clarity and definition are stable, mainly during close-ups, CG elements don't match this finesse and are marred by occasional noise and ringing artifacts. Furthermore, banding issues appear in exterior shots of the plane, which might stem from the original animation effects. The image boasts a compelling contrast, adding depth as horror elements introduce heavy shadows.
The Blu-ray manages color effectively, with accurate flesh tones and impressive primary colors that enrich the viewing experience. The striking blue of stewardess uniforms stands out, contributing to the visual appeal. In spite of its nearly single-location setting aboard an airplane, "Row 19" demonstrates an ability to showcase visual dynamism. The presentation achieves the dimensionality expected of modern productions, underpinned by robust black levels and an overall engaging color scheme.
Audio: 71
The Blu-ray audio presentation of "Row 19" remains consistent with Well Go USA's commitment to providing versatile sound options, featuring both DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 and Dolby Digital 2.0 in original Russian and English dub formats. The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track truly enhances the viewing experience with its immersive qualities, most effectively captured in the original Russian version. Although the plane crash scene may not fully leverage the potential of low-frequency effects (LFE), the film compensates with sporadic moments of sonic intensity that ricochet through side and rear channels, notably during Katerina's psychological turmoil.
Dialogues maintain clarity across the board, ensuring seamless comprehension without detracting from the film’s audio dynamics. That said, ambiance sometimes dominates, drawing unnecessary attention when engines or external weather pulse against the fuselage. Despite this, it avoids overwhelming the dialogue track, maintaining a balanced overall sound mix.
While bass frequencies exist, they could benefit from better refinement. The current implementation results in a clear rumble that lacks depth, settling into a rather average midtone without hitting deeper bass notes essential in contributing to full-bodied auditory suspense. Nonetheless, "Row 19" succeeds in crafting an occasionally eerie soundscape through its creative use of quasi-hallucinatory effects, which are particularly evident during scenes exploring the protagonist's mental breakdown. Optional English subtitles are provided, complementing the robust audio presentations effectively.
Extras: 4
The Blu Ray release of "Row 19" presents a streamlined offering in the extras department, tailored primarily for those interested in trailers. Absent of any substantial bonus features, the supplementary content is minimal but functional. A high-definition trailer for "Row 19" itself is included and plays automatically on disc startup, followed by trailers for other Well Go USA titles. This automatic transition to additional promotional content is characteristic of Well Go USA releases. Customers should note that beyond the trailers, there are no additional behind-the-scenes features, deleted scenes, or interviews to enrich the viewing experience. The disc is packaged with a slipcover, maintaining a conventional but aesthetically pleasing presentation. Overall, the extras provide a basic extension of the main feature without any significant added value.
Extras included in this disc:
- Trailer: An HD trailer for "Row 19," showcasing the film’s essence.
Movie: 43
"Row 19" presents a compelling yet flawed fusion of psychological thriller and supernatural horror, characterized by an intense, yet uneven narrative journey. Svetlana Ivanova's portrayal of Katerina, the sole survivor of a haunting plane crash from her youth, explores themes of internal fortitude and national identity. A backdrop of Russian mysticism intertwines with psychological elements, attempting to capture the essence of a "Russian Soul" through motifs of endurance and strength. Despite an intriguing premise, the film struggles with coherence, particularly as it fails to seamlessly blend its supernatural aspects with underlying psychological motifs. The allusive dialogue and mosaic-like montage hint at a deeper narrative that is unfortunately left underdeveloped.
The film is decisively short, clocking at 78 minutes, which aids in maintaining momentum but detracts from character depth and plot development. The majority of "Row 19" unfurls aboard an unsettling flight, where Katerina confronts her childhood trauma, accompanied by her daughter Diana. The tension is palpable from the outset, yet the narrative meanders through improbable scenarios and ambiguous realities. Notably, visual metaphors illustrate Katerina's internal conflict, employing startling imagery such as bloodied handprints that blur the line between sanity and madness.
Ultimately, "Row 19" grapples with an unrefined narrative that oscillates between horror and socio-cultural commentary. It casts a spotlight on themes of resilience against systemic forces; however, its portrayal is marred by an overwrought execution and inconclusive ending. While the film hints at probing Russian sociopolitical contexts and the dichotomy of science versus mysticism, these elements remain fleeting and superficial. Even with brief moments of effective psychological tension, the film's overambitious intertwining of genres leads to an unsatisfying conclusion that leaves much to be desired for those seeking a coherent and impactful cinematic experience.
Total: 55
"Row 19" on Blu-ray attempts to merge psychological themes with the allure of airborne horror, yet struggles to effectively transmit its concepts through a cohesive narrative. The film touches on deeper issues like anxiety and mental health, which are ripe for exploration, but these elements remain underdeveloped within a script that arguably leaves the viewer with more questions than satisfying revelations. The screenplay’s inherent confusion dilutes the potential depth of its plot twists, contributing to a viewing experience that lacks clarity and cohesion.
From a technical perspective, the Blu-ray presentation stands on solid ground. The audiovisual elements are commendable, with the disc delivering crisp video quality and immersive audio that suitably conveys the film’s eerie and tense atmosphere. The sound design particularly excels in capturing the claustrophobic setting of the airplane, enhancing both suspense and engagement despite the narrative's shortcomings.
In conclusion, while "Row 19" offers commendable technical quality for Blu-ray enthusiasts, its narrative fails to capitalize on its thematic aspirations. The film’s attempt to delve into psychological horror largely falls short, overshadowed by a convoluted script that may leave audiences unsatisfied. The Blu-ray's robust audiovisual performance can enrich the sensory experience, but it may not be enough to fully redeem the film's lackluster storytelling.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 80
While the interior of the fuselage gets lit in any number of peculiar ways, actual grading is minimal and helps to give the palette a natural look....
Audio: 80
As Katerina seems to be experiencing a mental breakdown, there are some quasi-hallucinatory audio effects that ricochet through the side and rear channels and help to achieve a kind of subliminal eeriness....
Extras: 10
Note: As tends to be the case with Well Go USA Blu-ray releases, the disc has been authored to automatically move on to trailers for other Well Go USA releases after the trailer for this film plays....
Movie: 40
A frankly confusing credits sequence which seems to interpolate actor's names into supposed "news coverage" of the aftermath of the crash and Katerina's understandable celebrity suggests that Katerina...
Total: 40
Vis a vis any perceived "Russian" angle to this film, kind of interestingly and to my memory uniquely in my reviewing life, Well Go USA actually reached out to me (and I assume every other reviewer on...
DoBlu review by Matt PaprockiRead review here
Video: 60
Also, banding shows in plane exteriors, possibly a fault of the original animation effects....
Audio: 60
While there’s clear rumble, it’s poorly contained, never hitting the lowest points, settling into a bland midtone....
Extras: 2
...
Movie: 40
Intent cannot be hidden, certainly not in the contemporary historical context, which regardless of the homeland release date, still holds a disquieting feeling over the finished production....
Total: 41
An attempt to portray anxiety and mental health through the lens or airline horror, Row 19 fails in connecting through its story....
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 92
Audio: 90
Ralph Potts AVS Forum Blu-ray Reviews Reference Review System: JVC DLA-NZ7 4K Ultra High-Definition Laser Front Projector (Calibrated with Calman color calibration software and Portrait Displays C6 HDR2000...
Extras: 10
...
Movie: 60
On the surface, given the nature of what is revealed in the trailer and synopsis, you might think that this film is horror first, psychological thriller second....
Total: 63
Ralph Potts AVS Forum Blu-ray Reviews Reference Review System: JVC DLA-NZ7 4K Ultra High-Definition Laser Front Projector (Calibrated with Calman color calibration software and Portrait Displays C6 HDR2000...
Director: Alexander Babaev, Samantha A. Morrison
Actors: Svetlana Ivanova, Rinat Abushaev, Laila Berzins
PlotA young female doctor named Katerina boards a night flight with her six-year-old daughter, Diana. The flight is nearly empty, with only a few other passengers scattered throughout the cabin. As the plane takes off, a severe storm engulfs it, leading to significant turbulence. Katerina tries to stay calm for her daughter’s sake, but soon strange occurrences begin to unfold. The passengers start experiencing inexplicable visions that seem connected to trauma from Katerina's past. The line between reality and illusion blurs as disturbing events escalate within the confines of the aircraft.
Tension rises when passengers start disappearing one by one under mysterious circumstances. Katerina struggles to differentiate between reality and hallucination as the visions intensify and terrifying truths come to light. With nowhere to escape in the skies, trust fractures among the remaining passengers, and fear spreads through the cabin. As Katerina digs deeper into the visions, she finds herself reliving haunting memories and uncovering secrets linked to her identity. Racing against time and losing grip on reality, Katerina must confront her fears to protect her daughter and herself from the menacing forces threatening their lives above the turbulent clouds.
Writers: Viktoriya Belyaeva, James Heth, Dmitriy Lemeshev
Release Date: 11 Nov 2021
Runtime: 77 min
Rating: TV-14
Country: Russia
Language: Russian