Crime of Passion Blu-ray Review
Score: 53
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Crime of Passion is an intriguing late 50s Americana film with standout performances, especially by Barbara Stanwyck, though its formulaic plot slightly detracts.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 72
Crime of Passion’s Blu-ray features a remarkable 1080p/AVC transfer with a 1.85:1 aspect ratio, offering solid contrast, stable patterns, and good black levels. Fine grain and chiaroscuro lighting shine, with occasional nicks not detracting from its excellence—a commendable tribute to LaShelle's cinematography.
Audio: 62
The DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono track of *Crime of Passion* offers clear dialogue and well-modulated sound, though it is hampered by occasional distortion in music cues and some muffled pops. Despite these minor flaws, the track maintains a wide dynamic range with distinguishable subtleties and no significant age-related artifacts.
Extra: 0
The Blu-ray of 'Crime of Passion' disappoints with its lack of supplementary content, offering no bonus features for viewers.
Movie: 63
"Crime of Passion" offers a nuanced critique of 1950s societal norms through Barbara Stanwyck's dynamic performance as an ambitious newspaperwoman stifled by suburban domesticity. Gerd Oswald's direction and Jo Eisinger's screenplay craft a compelling, feminist-leaning narrative, yet it occasionally veers into melodrama, diluting its impact. Despite its imperfections, Stanwyck’s portrayal, complemented by solid supporting roles from Sterling Hayden and Raymond Burr, elevates the film to an engaging, though not exceptional, piece of noir cinema. The Blu-ray release features solid video and audio quality, enriching its presentation.
Video: 72
ClassicFlix presents "Crime of Passion" on Blu-ray with an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in its original 1.85:1 aspect ratio, delivering a visual experience that honors the craftsmanship of nine-time Academy Award nominee, Joseph LaShelle. The transfer features robust sharpness, superb contrast, and well-managed grain that maintains the authentic feel of celluloid. The grayscale performance is especially notable, offering true-to-life whites and deep blacks that enhance the visual depth and detail. Despite occasional minor imperfections and slightly variable clarity in a few establishing shots, the transfer remains remarkably clean, free from age-related scuffs or scratches that could detract from the viewing experience.
This impeccable presentation also showcases LaShelle's chiaroscuro lighting techniques, a hallmark of his work that earned him an Oscar for "Laura," making the cinematic experience immersive and engaging. Elements such as Hayden's herringbone suit jackets are rendered with precise detail, and the shadows are sharp and clean, essential for appreciating the film's noir sensibilities. Close-ups effectively reveal facial features and hair details, even when slightly softened, adding to the overall authenticity of the transfer.
In summary, this Blu-ray edition of "Crime of Passion" is a standout release, providing the best home video transfer available for this classic film. With its seamless grain structure, stable patterns, and minimal distractions from minor nicks or marks, it’s an essential addition for fans of Barbara Stanwyck, film noir aficionados, and lovers of classic Hollywood cinematography.
Audio: 62
The DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono track of "Crime of Passion" delivers a mostly solid auditory experience, maintaining clear, well-modulated sound throughout the film. While some audio elements, such as Paul Dunlap's brass-heavy score, occasionally suffer from noticeable distortion, the overall sound quality remains commendable. Dialogue is consistently clean and easily comprehensible, benefiting from professional recording and mixing techniques. Key sound effects—such as gunfire and revving car engines—successfully punctuate the soundscape, adding notable sonic accents to the narrative.
Despite minor imperfections, including some muffled pops and rare age-related artifacts, the audio track effectively manages a wide dynamic range without introducing hiss, pops, or crackles typical of older films. The distinct subtleties in the sound mix, like footsteps and background noises, contribute to a rich aural environment, enhancing the immersive experience. Optional English subtitles are also available, ensuring that all dialogue is accessible and well-understood. Overall, the DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono mix upholds a high standard of audio clarity and presence for this classic film.
Extras:
The Blu-ray release of "Crime of Passion," despite presenting the main feature in high quality, is notably lacking in supplementary content. Multiple reviews highlight the absence of any bonus features, which diminishes the overall value for collectors and cinephiles seeking deeper insights into the film's production or context. The release is devoid of behind-the-scenes footage, interviews, commentary tracks, or any additional materials that often enrich the viewing experience. As such, while the primary film presentation may still be appealing, those looking for a more comprehensive package will find this release falling short in this regard.
Extras included on this disc:
- None: There are no supplements or bonus features included in this disc.
Movie: 63
"Crime of Passion," directed by Gerd Oswald, showcases Barbara Stanwyck in a commanding role that underscores her enduring legacy as a Hollywood icon. Stanwyck portrays Kathy Ferguson, an assertive, career-driven newspaperwoman in 1950s San Francisco. Her character grapples with the gender constraints of the era, battling pervasive misogyny and societal expectations. When she impulsively marries Bill Doyle, a run-of-the-mill cop played by Sterling Hayden, Kathy’s life takes a dramatic turn from career success to domestic dissatisfaction. Her subsequent efforts to propel her husband up the professional ladder unfold as both a critique of suburban conformity and an exploration of feminist discontent, capturing Kathy's tumultuous descent into desperate ambition.
The film skillfully navigates themes of gender roles and suburban ennui through Jo Eisinger’s incisive screenplay. Stanwyck’s performance is a tour de force, blending steely resolve with raw emotionality. While her depiction of Kathy’s transition from independence to marital confines feels credible, some narrative shifts—particularly her extreme maneuvers to elevate Bill’s status—stretch believability. Nonetheless, Oswald employs noir aesthetic effectively, using shadow and tension to heighten Kathy’s mounting frustrations. Sterling Hayden offers a subdued yet solid counterbalance to Stanwyck, while Raymond Burr brings smarmy charm to his role as Bill’s superior, Tony Pope. Supporting performances from Fay Wray and Virginia Grey add texture to the domestic stakes and societal commentary.
While "Crime of Passion" occasionally succumbs to melodramatic excesses, it remains a compelling character study enriched by its pointed social critique and Stanwyck’s powerful portrayal. The film’s examination of 1950s gender dynamics and suburban malaise renders it more resonant than many contemporaries, albeit sometimes at the expense of plot realism. Despite its flaws, the film captivates through its earnest engagement with feminist themes and its top-tier cast, driven by Stanwyck’s indomitable presence.
Total: 53
The Blu-ray release of "Crime of Passion" by Classicflix offers a visually refined and sharper presentation of this late 1950s film noir, capturing the essence of its era with enhanced clarity. The video transfer is commendable, bringing out the movie's cinematography and detailed visual elements, while the audio quality remains solid and well-balanced. However, it is notable that this Blu-ray edition lacks supplementary material, which may be a drawback for some enthusiasts looking for a more enriched viewing experience.
Barbara Stanwyck delivers an intense and natural performance that epitomizes her legendary status as one of Hollywood's quintessential film noir heroines. Alongside a compelling portrayal by Raymond Burr, just before his iconic television role as Perry Mason, their combined screen presence adds significant depth to the narrative. Directed by Gerd Oswald, the film delves into themes of ambition, frustration, jealousy, and manipulation. Despite these stimulating thematic explorations and finely drawn characters, the plot remains somewhat formulaic, and this predictability slightly detracts from an otherwise well-crafted production.
If you come to "Crime of Passion" expecting a twisty mystery or a traditional noir featuring a femme fatale leading an ordinary schlub to his doom, you may be disappointed. But those who are willing to let this patently odd film do its thing will find "Crime of Passion" to be a rather fascinating slice of late 50s Americana, seen through the lens of a square peg trying and failing to fit into a round hole. Recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 80
Clarity is just a little variable at times, and grain, while visible and organic looking, is fairly fine, but generally speaking this is a problem free presentation that nicely shows off some of the chiaroscuro...
Audio: 60
Dialogue is always cleanly delivered and easily understandable, and ClassicFlix has also provided optional English subtitles....
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 70
Even in roles where she was supposedly more or less completely vulnerable, as in her memorable turn in Sorry, Wrong Number, Stanwyck's undeniable strength can tend to work against the believability of...
Total: 70
But those who are willing to let this patently odd film do its thing, Crime of Passion is a rather fascinating slice of late 50s Americana, seen through the lens of a square peg trying and failing to fit...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
A few scenes look a tad soft, and some stray nicks and marks dot the print from time to time, but none of the imperfections distract attention or detract from the overall excellence of the presentation....
Audio: 80
A wide dynamic scale handles all the highs and lows without any distortion, and no age-related hiss, pops, or crackles intrude....
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 60
Unwilling to sublimate her personality, dumb herself down, indulge in frivolous pursuits, and endure endless hours of idle chatter, Kathy focuses all her energies on escaping the small-minded suburban...
Total: 60
Crime of Passion may not be one of Barbara Stanwyck's better known films, but this tidy, engrossing film noir showcases the type of natural, intense performance that defined the legendary star's career....
Home Theater Forum review by Matt HoughRead review here
Video: 90
Sharpness is very good throughout the presentation, and even slightly softened close-ups of the female stars reveal some details in facial features and hair....
Audio: 80
The music of Paul Dunlap and the atmospheric effects have all been combined with surety for a mostly solid presentation....
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 70
She can toss off a withering barb with the greatest of ease and yet also fully convince us of the deep emotions she feels at any given moment (when she commits murder late in the movie, it’s almost with...
Total: 70
It’s an entertaining drama of the 1950s with outstanding performances especially from leading lady Barbara Stanwyck and from Raymond Burr a mere few months before he segued into television work for the...
Director: Gerd Oswald
Actors: Barbara Stanwyck, Sterling Hayden, Raymond Burr
PlotKathy Ferguson is a fiercely independent and accomplished advice columnist in San Francisco. Her career takes a turn when she meets and quickly falls in love with police detective Bill Doyle, leading her to give up her job and move to Los Angeles after their marriage. Initially supportive of her husband's career, Kathy soon becomes restless and frustrated with her new domestic life. As she strives to advance Bill's career within the police department, her ambitions grow, and she becomes entangled in the machinations of police politics.
Kathy's drive to propel Bill up the ranks puts increasing strain on their relationship. She befriends Alice Pope, the ambitious wife of Bill’s superior, Tony Pope, hoping to use this connection to gain favor for her husband. As her manipulative tactics deepen, ethical boundaries blur and sinister consequences arise, shifting the course of their lives in unpredictable ways. The escalating tension between personal desire and professional duty creates a web of deception and moral conflict.
Writers: Jo Eisinger
Release Date: 08 Nov 1957
Runtime: 86 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United States
Language: English