Gate of Hell Blu-ray Review
地獄門 Jigokumon
Score: 60
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Gate of Hell is a visually stunning and profoundly moving film with a top-tier video transfer, despite lacking special features and featuring mono audio.
Disc Release Date
Video: 74
The Blu-ray presentation of Teinosuke Kinugasa's 'Gate of Hell,' restored in 4K and presented in 1080p by Criterion, is visually stunning with vibrant, perfectly saturated colors and excellent detail. The high-definition transfer is nearly flawless, breathing new life into this classic film.
Audio: 64
The Blu-ray of 'Gate of Hell' features a Japanese LPCM 1.0 audio track that provides clear, stable dialogue with minimal sound effects and occasional light background hiss, doing an admirable job with the source material from the '50s.
Extra: 16
The Blu-ray's extras include an illustrated booklet by film historian Stephen Prince and a brand-new English subtitle translation for improved accuracy. Disappointingly, Criterion has not provided additional features, which is unusual for their typically comprehensive releases.
Movie: 81
"Gate of Hell" Blu-ray showcases Teinosuke Kinugasa's 1953 masterpiece with Criterion's signature restoration, enhancing its lush color cinematography by Kohei Sugiyama. The film, a fusion of samurai honor and tragic romance, benefits from Sanzo Wada's striking costumes and Kisaku Ito's meticulous production design. An essential classic, Region-A locked.
Video: 74
Presented in its original aspect ratio of 1.37:1 and encoded with MPEG-4 AVC, Teinosuke Kinugasa's Gate of Hell arrives on Blu-ray courtesy of Criterion with a stunning 1080p transfer. Restored in 2011 through a collaborative effort by the National Museum of Modern Art in Tokyo, Kadokawa Shoten Co., Ltd., and NHK, and supervised by cameraman Fujio Morita, this high-definition transfer breathes new life into the film. The restoration utilized a new 4K digital transfer from a 35mm duplicate negative and several 35mm master positives, ensuring exceptional clarity and detail.
The visual presentation of this Blu-ray is breathtaking, particularly in its treatment of color. The vibrant hues—including rich golds, deep reds, purples, and greens—are impeccably rendered and maintain their integrity without any bleeding or oversaturation. This meticulous attention to color details enhances the film's visual appeal, providing an immersive viewing experience. Brightness levels appear to be finely tuned, enhancing the overall aesthetic without becoming distracting.
Additionally, the high-definition transfer displays impressive stability, free from symptoms of degraining and sharpening corrections. The daylight sequences especially stand out for their clarity and depth. Film purists will appreciate the absence of significant cuts, debris, damage marks, or warps. Though minor issues such as occasional film judder and overly heavy black levels are present, they do little to detract from an otherwise pristine transfer. Criterion's release of Gate of Hell exemplifies quality restoration work, retaining the essence of Kinugasa's vision while providing modern audiences with an exceptional viewing experience. Note: The disc is Region-A locked.
Audio: 64
The Blu-ray audio presentation of "Gate of Hell" features a single standard Japanese LPCM 1.0 audio track, complete with optional English SDH subtitles for the main feature. This mono mix, housed in a lossless format, effectively centralizes dialogue and steadily holds a clear and crisp presentation throughout the film. Despite the occasional light background hiss, a relic of the era in which the film was produced, the audio remains engaging and unintrusive. The preservation of dynamic range is understandably limited, reflecting the technical constraints under which the original soundtrack was created.
While sound effects are sparingly used, the delivery in fight scenes maintains a minimalistic approach that complements the visual focus of the film. The dialog remains stable with no noticeable audio dropouts or distortions, ensuring a consistently high-quality auditory experience. The English translation provided is accurate and enhances accessibility without detracting from the original language's nuance. Overall, this 1.0 LPCM mix represents the best possible audio reproduction for "Gate of Hell," given its historical context and source material constraints.
Extras: 16
The Blu-ray release of "Gate of Hell" includes a selection of extras that, while minimal, add substantial value for enthusiasts and historians. The highlight is an illustrated booklet featuring an insightful essay by renowned film historian Stephen Prince. This booklet provides depth and context to the film, enhancing the viewer's understanding and appreciation. Despite Criterion's usual reputation for extensive special features, this release is notably sparse in that department, with the most significant addition being a new, more accurate English subtitle translation. This effort ensures viewers receive a closer rendition of the original dialogue and its nuances.
Extras included on this disc:
- Booklet: An illustrated booklet featuring an essay by film historian Stephen Prince.
- New English Subtitle Translation: A brand-new translation for improved accuracy.
Movie: 81
Teinosuke Kinugasa's "Gate of Hell" (1953) is a visually captivating historical drama. Set during the upheaval of the Heiji Era in 12th-century Japan, the narrative follows the tragic intersection of honor, duty, and obsessive desire. The film stars Kazuo Hasegawa as the fiercely dedicated samurai Moritoh and Machiko Kyo as the alluring Lady Kesa. Moritoh saves Lady Kesa during a rebel uprising, igniting his obsession with her, despite her being married to Lord Watanabe Wataru (Isao Yamagata). This tale of unattainable love and honor is deftly directed by Kinugasa, whose treatment transforms the story into a cautionary tale akin to Shakespearean tragedy.
The film’s stunning visual presentation, orchestrated by cinematographer Kohei Sugiyama, is among its most acclaimed features. Recognized for its masterful use of color, "Gate of Hell" was the first Japanese color film released outside Japan. The rich, vibrant hues and meticulous costume designs by Sanzo Wada imbue the film with an almost painterly quality. Scenes such as the nocturnal garden encounter between Lady Kesa and her husband are particularly striking, showcasing a blend of elegant aesthetics and emotive narrative depth. The production designs by Kisaku Ito complement this visual splendor, enhancing the period setting with detailed authenticity.
Character interactions drive much of the tension in "Gate of Hell," diverging from the typical action-packed samurai films of its era. Instead, the plot delves into themes of obsession and duty. Moritoh's relentless pursuit of Lady Kesa sets off a dramatic chain of events that leads to inevitable tragedy. Despite its 89-minute runtime and focused character set, the film manages to explore complex emotional landscapes. The simple but potent dialogue maintains the dramatic tension without slipping into melodrama, ensuring viewer engagement throughout.
Criterion's Blu-ray treatment preserves the integrity of this classic piece, ensuring modern audiences can appreciate Kinugasa's vision in high definition. The absence of supplemental features aside from Stephen Prince’s essay makes the release somewhat sparse in additional content. Nevertheless, "Gate of Hell" stands as a visually and emotionally compelling study in obsessive love and honor-bound duty.
Total: 60
"Gate of Hell" is a resplendent showcase of Teinosuke Kinugasa's directorial prowess, offering viewers an artistic journey that remains unparalleled. The recent restoration undertaken by Criterion has breathed new life into the film, imbuing it with a vibrancy that allows it to resonate with modern audiences. The visual splendor is striking, with the lush and vivid colors of the film serving as a testament to its renowned status in cinematic history. The simplicity of its narrative only heightens its emotional gravity, making it a profoundly moving experience.
The characters in "Gate of Hell" are as dynamically crafted as the vividly painted backdrops they inhabit. Each performance adds depth to the gripping tale of obsession and honor, enriching the overall viewer experience. Criterion's transfer to Blu-ray exhibits meticulous care; while the audio presentation is monaural, it remains effective in delivering the film's auditory essence. However, the absence of additional special features does leave a noticeable gap for those seeking deeper insights or supplementary content.
There is a good reason why Martin Scorsese has stated that Teinosuke Kinugasa's "Gate of Hell" is one of the ten most beautiful color films ever made – the film overflows with lush, at times overwhelmingly beautiful colors. Recently restored, "Gate of Hell" now also looks healthier than ever before. The story it tells is very simple, but it is profoundly moving. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 100
Clarity is also outstanding, with the daylight sequences in particular looking very impressive....
Audio: 80
Overall dynamic movement is rather limited, but this should not be surprising considering the age of the film and the conditions under which it was shot....
Extras: 20
...
Movie: 90
Even the darker nighttime sequences - such as the one where Lord Watanabe Wataru and Lady Kesa are seen together in the garden - look notably elegant....
Total: 80
There is a good reason why Martin Scorsese has stated that Teinosuke Kinugasa's Gate of Hell is one of the ten most beautiful color films ever made - the film overflows with lush, at times overwhelmingly...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
There are robes of gold, red, purple, orange, green, you name it and the color probably exists at some point in this movie....
Audio: 80
There is some audible hissing from time to time, but that's to be expected with a release from the '50s....
Extras: 20
The back of the case states that this release has been given a brand-new English subtitle translation, which would lead me to believe that its more accurate than it has been in the past....
Movie: 80
What's also important to note is the time period and the fact that this was a completely male-dominated society....
Total: 60
The characters are just as rich and varied as the colorful menagerie going on in the film....
Director: Teinosuke Kinugasa
Actors: Machiko Kyô, Kazuo Hasegawa, Isao Yamagata
PlotDuring a tumultuous period in 12th century Japan, a rebellion breaks out in Kyoto, leading to chaos within the royal palace. A loyal samurai named Moritoh Endo risks his life to help the nobles escape and is enamored by the beauty and bravery of Lady Kesa, who volunteers to act as a decoy to ensure the empress's safety. In gratitude for his heroic efforts, Moritoh is granted any wish by the ruling shogun, and he boldly requests Lady Kesa's hand in marriage, unaware that she is already married to another samurai, Wataru Watanabe.
Despite learning of her marital status, Moritoh remains relentless in his pursuit of Lady Kesa, convinced that their destinies are intertwined. His unyielding desire and obsession lead him to devise a relentless plan to win her over, regardless of the obstacles. Torn between honor, duty, and personal desire, Moritoh's actions spur a series of events that test the boundaries of love, loyalty, and sacrifice. The tension escalates as Lady Kesa and Wataru must navigate the dangerous consequences of Moritoh's determination, leading to an inevitable and tragic climax that questions the true meaning of honor and devotion.
Writers: Kan Kikuchi, Teinosuke Kinugasa, Masaichi Nagata
Release Date: 10 Dec 1954
Runtime: 89 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: Japan
Language: Japanese