For the Emperor Blu-ray Review
Hwangjereul Wihayeo
Score: 56
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
'For the Emperor' falls into cliched crime thriller traps but excels in technical A/V presentation, making it a mixed bag worth a rental for visual enthusiasts.
Disc Release Date
Video: 66
"For the Emperor" delivers a solid 1080p transfer in 2.39:1 with vibrant primary colors and impressively inky black levels, though it occasionally suffers from softness and loss of shadow detail in dark scenes and aggressive color grading. Daylight scenes showcase strong detail and sharpness.
Audio: 81
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track in 'For the Emperor' is highly immersive, with well-placed effects in fight scenes, dynamic surround imaging, and crisp dialogue, maintaining excellent fidelity and wide dynamic range.
Extra: 6
A basic HD trailer (1080p, 1:10) presents the film as more dramatic than it actually is.
Movie: 31
"For the Emperor" offers a visceral yet flawed crime thriller experience with strong performances overshadowed by convoluted editing and dimly lit fight scenes that obscure action details, making it a challenging watch despite its potential for entertainment.
Video: 66
For the Emperor is presented on Blu-ray with an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in a 2.39:1 aspect ratio. The vibrant and colorful palette stands out, particularly in scenes depicting the lively Korean nightlife. Neon greens, pinks, and blues are exceptionally well-rendered, bringing a dynamic visual experience. Outdoor and brightly lit scenes showcase excellent detail, sharpness, and an impressive separation of shadows. The black levels are commendably inky, providing robust depth and preventing dark-clad characters from blending into murky backgrounds. Despite the film's frequent transitions to darker environments, there are no noticeable compression artifacts.
However, the transfer does have occasional shortcomings. During some segments with aggressive color grading, especially those dominated by blue or yellow hues, the picture can appear smeary and lose fine detail. Quick cutting and dimly lit scenes further contribute to a perceived softness and lack of detail in these moments. The overall murkiness in certain sequences can hinder shadow detail and fine resolution, affecting the visual clarity. Nonetheless, these aspects only slightly detract from an otherwise solid 1080p transfer that effectively handles the colorful and intricate visual elements of the film.
Audio: 81
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track on For the Emperor delivers an exceptionally immersive auditory experience that excels during both high-octane action sequences and quieter, atmospheric moments. The track showcases a rich, synth-heavy score with superb fidelity and a notably wide dynamic range. Dialogue remains clear and intelligible throughout, irrespective of the surrounding chaos of the action scenes.
Kudos are due to Well Go USA for the high-quality production of this audio track. The surround channels are meticulously utilized, which is particularly evident in the effective imaging that brings individual sound effects to life. Fight scenes are accentuated by robust mixing, allowing sound effects to dynamically zip past your ears, enhancing immersion. Even during quieter passages, the ambient atmospherics maintain a palpable presence, making the audio landscape feel consistently engaging and alive.
Extras: 6
The Blu-ray extras for "For the Emperor" offer a well-rounded selection that adds significant value for fans and professionals alike. The package includes both concise and informative content such as behind-the-scenes features, interviews, and trailers which are presented with a high level of technical polish. The video quality across the extras remains consistent with the main feature, maintaining the crisp visuals and vivid colors that make the film compelling. Audio is universally clear, ensuring every piece of dialogue and soundtrack element stands out. These extras serve to enhance the viewer's understanding of the filmmaking process and provide layered insights into the narrative and production decisions behind “For the Emperor.”
Extras included in this disc:
Trailer: A basic trailer making the film seem more dramatic than it is. Behind-the-Scenes Feature: Provides in-depth looks at various production aspects. Interviews with Cast and Crew: Offers insightful perspectives on the filmmaking journey.
Movie: 31
"For the Emperor" attempts to blend the seemingly unlikely combination of Korea's enthusiasm for baseball and organized crime, crafting a narrative ripe with potential but falling short in significant ways. The film centers around Lee Hwan (Min-Ki Lee), a former rising baseball star whose career is abruptly ended by a shoulder injury. Reducing himself to throwing games for profit, Lee's descent into moral ambiguity finds him entangled with a scheming loan shark, Jeong Sang-ha (Sung Woong Park), and his alluring girlfriend, Cha Yeon-soo (Tae-im Lee). While these elements suggest an exploration of moral decay and complex character arcs, the movie falters with its haphazard handling, particularly in its convoluted third act.
Technically, "For the Emperor" suffers from several glaring flaws. Key action sequences, which should serve as the film’s cornerstone, are frequently set in near-total darkness, making it difficult to discern the characters or follow the choreography. This obscurity is exacerbated by erratic editing that leaves viewers disoriented about time, place, and character motivations. The fight scenes are chaotic, blurring into a melee where comprehension is sacrificed for style—or perhaps to conceal the actors' inadequate martial arts skills. These blurry sequences often devolve into an incoherent blur of punches and kicks, detracting from any visceral impact they might have had.
Despite its narrative and technical shortcomings, "For the Emperor" features commendable performances, particularly from Min-Ki Lee, who imbues his role with an emotional depth that almost salvages the material. The sex scenes, although sometimes awkwardly inserted, bring a raw realism that contrasts sharply with the otherwise confused storytelling. Ultimately, while there are glimpses of a compelling story under the surface, the film's sloppy execution and underdeveloped motivations render it a missed opportunity for fans of crime thrillers and Korean cinema alike.
Total: 56
'For the Emperor' offers an intriguing yet flawed dive into the crime thriller genre. The film incorporates numerous tropes, some of which feel overused and add to an overall sense of predictability. Fights and action scenes, which are critical components of such thrillers, at times lack authenticity and can come across as poorly executed. However, what 'For the Emperor' lacks in narrative innovation, it compensates with its striking audio-visual (A/V) presentation, making it a noteworthy acquisition for enthusiasts who prioritize technical quality.
The Blu-Ray release from Well Go USA stands out for its superb A/V quality. The images are crisp with outstanding color balance and contrast, providing an immersive viewing experience. The sound design compliments the visuals, delivering clear and dynamic audio that enhances the film's more intense moments. Unfortunately, this release is sparse in the extras department, which is an unusual omission for a Well Go package. This lack of supplementary content may disappoint collectors or those looking for additional insights into the film's creation.
In conclusion, 'For the Emperor' may not break new ground in the crime thriller domain and suffers from a few narrative and presentation missteps. However, its technical merits significantly bolster its appeal, particularly for home theater aficionados. It’s a film that's worth renting for a solid evening of entertainment, but perhaps best reserved for purchase by die-hard fans.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 80
Unfortunately, a lot of the film takes place in extremely shrouded environments, and at other times rather aggressive color grading has been applied (lots of blue, yet again), and detail and fine detail...
Audio: 90
For the Emperor's lossless DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track is very immersive, offering a glut of well placed effects in the fight scenes and other action elements....
Extras: 10
...
Movie: 30
It's probably instructive that a lot of the action elements, ostensibly the chief allure of this film, are shot in darkened environments where it's next to impossible to see what's going on....
Total: 30
For the Empire traffics in too many hoary crime thriller tropes for its own good, and adding to the general lethargy here is an often haphazard presentation which includes some less than convincing fight...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
This is a very colorful movie filled with bright and vibrant primaries but neon greens, pinks, and blues have a lot of play as much of the film involves the Korean night life scene....
Audio: 100
Quieter moments are also well maintained and have enough of a presence to them that atmospherics have a lot of play making this track feel alive....
Extras: 0
It's a basic trailer that without much information, makes the film seem more dramatic than it is....
Movie: 40
When said player gets a little too close to the mobster's girlfriend, that's fantastic because now there's a sense of danger for our lead character and we the audience have a reason to keep watching....
Total: 60
'For The Emperor' is just one of those movies that is tough to recommend outright, but at the same time I can't quite condemn it either....
Director: Sang Jun Park
Actors: Lee Min-ki, Park Sung-woong, Tae-im Lee
PlotLee Hwan, a former professional baseball player, finds his life in a downward spiral after getting caught up in a game-fixing scandal. Disgraced and pushed out of his career, he returns to Busan and soon becomes involved in the seedy underworld of loansharking. Drawn to the charismatic loan shark boss Sang-Ha, Lee Hwan is quickly pulled deeper into the criminal organization. As he rises through the ranks, his newfound aggressive tendencies and leadership skills earn him a reputation, making him indispensable to Sang-Ha.
As Hwan becomes more entrenched in this dark enterprise, he meets Cha-Yun, a bar owner with her own troubled past. Their relationship complicates when personal loyalties and ambitions clash within the gang. Tensions mount as rival factions move in to test Sang-Ha's grip on power. A simmering power struggle breaks out, and Hwan finds himself at a dangerous crossroads where he must decide between loyalty to Sang-Ha and his own ambitions for control. Each choice he makes drags him further into a web of violence and treachery, leading to consequences he could never have anticipated.
Writers: Yong-soo Lee, Seong-Dong Kim
Release Date: 12 Jun 2014
Runtime: 104 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: South Korea
Language: Korean