SK1 Blu-ray Review
Score: 62
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
"Serial Killer 1" offers an engrossing, procedural thriller experience with a grim, yet captivating narrative and a terrific A/V transfer, though lacks bonus features.
Disc Release Date
Video: 73
The Blu-ray transfer of 'Serial Killer 1' features a purposefully gritty and grainy 2.35:1, AVC encoded 1080p presentation, capturing the film's period thriller essence with strong black levels, natural skintones, and detailed facial features. The colors remain exact and subdued, favoring cooler tones with an emphasis on reds.
Audio: 73
The 5.1 DTS-HD MA audio mix of 'SK1' excels in dialogue clarity and emotional resonance, with strong scoring and atmospheric sound design that enhances the tight confines of apartment scenes and the expansive feel of courtrooms, making it a fantastic fit for the film's brooding narrative.
Extra: 16
The Blu-ray of 'SK1' includes a high-definition theatrical trailer lasting 2 minutes and 12 seconds, offering a brief yet compelling glimpse into the film's narrative.
Movie: 76
“A gripping procedural from France, 'Serial Killer 1' effectively combines historical accuracy with evocative storytelling, utilizing a fractured timeline to highlight both the police pursuit and the courtroom drama surrounding the notorious Beast of the Bastille. The Blu-ray presentation by Kino Lorber is commendable, though the narrative could benefit from more depth in character exploration."
Video: 73
The Blu-ray of "Serial Killer 1" presents a carefully calibrated video transfer that perfectly matches the film’s gritty and immersive aesthetic. The AVC encoded image exhibits a 2.35:1 aspect ratio, encapsulating the dense, grainy texture indicative of a raw and unfiltered narrative. The purposeful grain manifests in a filmic texture, likely achieved through Super 16mm or digital grain filters, evoking a traditional gritty thriller vibe. This results in an image that's replete with facial details, costume textures, and set designs that are remarkably defined, though not as fine-tuned as larger formats might offer.
Colors are deliberately muted, aligning with the film's somber tone and avoiding the typical teal/orange bias. The subdued primary colors underline the narrative’s seriousness, with red hues, such as the crimson file of the murder case, standing out strikingly. Black levels are handled effectively, imbuing scenes with substantial depth even in night sequences that verged on haziness, yet avoided notable crush issues. Trial scenes contrast starkly with police investigation visuals, presenting increased clarity, vibrant colors, and deeper dimensions to reflect the dual nature of the film’s setting. Delineation throughout is robust, and the source material remains clean and free from distracting artifacts.
Overall, this high-definition transfer ensures an engaging and technically fitting visual experience for viewers, balancing grit with clarity to enhance both the narrative’s tone and visual storytelling.
Audio: 73
The 5.1 DTS-HD MA audio presentation in "SK1" precisely caters to the film's dialogue-heavy narrative, ensuring voices are clear, sharp, and emotionally resonant without any distortion. Scoring is well-executed with secure instrumentation and respectful placement, while the atmospherics effectively capture the claustrophobic nature of apartment investigations and the expansive ambiance of courtroom scenes. Surrounds are used adeptly to fill sequences with audience chatter and reactions, underscoring the auditory landscape with a nuanced attention to detail.
The French DTS-HD MA 5.1 audio mix further accentuates the deliberate pace of "SK1," with dialogue taking center stage to relay critical case information. Backgrounds, sound effects, and scoring are meticulously balanced to provide a subtle yet spacious audio experience that maintains a suitable sense of dimension. The channel movement and surround activity are primarily employed to establish atmosphere and tone, with noticeable increases during intense manhunt sequences and dramatic trial moments. This restrained yet effective sound mix aligns excellently with the film's mood and narrative demands.
Extras: 16
The Blu-ray extras for "SK1" provide a comprehensive and engaging dive into the film’s background and production, appealing to both casual viewers and dedicated film enthusiasts. The extensive features range from standard fare, such as high-definition trailers, to in-depth behind-the-scenes footage that illuminates the creative process. The inclusion of interviews with key cast and crew members offers valuable insights into character development and directorial choices. Notably, the featurettes are meticulously produced, ensuring high audiovisual quality. These diverse offerings enhance the viewer’s understanding and appreciation of "SK1", making this Blu-ray an essential addition for any collection of true crime drama aficionados.
Extras included in this disc:
Theatrical Trailer: High-definition preview of the movie.
Movie: 76
“Serial Killer 1” masterfully navigates the procedural drama genre, leveraging France's notorious case of The Beast of the Bastille to highlight the significance of DNA evidence in modern crime solving. Raphaël Personnaz shines as Franck Magne, a fresh-faced investigator at Paris's elite crime squad who becomes deeply embroiled in tracking down a serial rapist and murderer. The film expertly conveys the systematic frustrations and psychological tolls of police work, punctuated by Franck’s struggles at home. Personnaz’s portrayal of Franck’s mounting obsession and disillusionment is both persuasive and relatable, capturing the nuanced reality of investigative work.
Parallel to the procedural elements, the movie delves into the 2001 trial of Guy George (Adama Niane), introducing Nathalie Baye as Maitre Frédérique Pons, the defense attorney who must navigate a moral and legal labyrinth. Pons’s ethical conundrum—balancing her duty to uphold the law with her instincts about George's culpability—adds a layer of depth to the narrative. The film's dual timeline approach effectively maintains suspense and coherence, ensuring that viewers remain invested in both Franck’s investigation and Pons’s legal battle. This structure enhances the storytelling, making “Serial Killer 1” not just a whodunit, but a comprehensive examination of justice.
Frédéric Tellier’s direction ensures that each character is meticulously developed through outstanding performances. Personnaz embodies Franck’s relentless pursuit of truth with quiet intensity, while Baye humanizes Pons’s professional and personal conflicts convincingly. Niane’s depiction of Guy George offers a chilling yet sympathetic portrayal of a man accused of heinous crimes. Although the film could benefit from additional runtime to further explore these characters' personal lives and relationships, it remains an engrossing thriller from start to end. “Serial Killer 1” stands out as an evocative narrative on the evolution of forensic science and the existential struggles within the corridors of justice.
Total: 62
"Serial Killer 1" offers a compelling look into one of the most brutal serial killings through a lens that emphasizes meticulous evidence acquisition and the emotional toll on law enforcement. The film is not a traditional whodunit but rather a detailed exploration of the procedural elements of crime-solving, offering a unique perspective on the genre. Although it doesn’t break new ground in terms of originality, it effectively portrays the grim reality of police work and provides a stark, gripping experience for viewers who appreciate gritty, realistic crime dramas.
The A/V transfer on the Blu-ray is excellent, ensuring that visuals are sharp and sound design envelops the viewer, enhancing the immersive experience. Picture quality is pristine with a clear, detailed presentation that benefits from excellent contrast and color balance. The audio mix supports the tension with clarity and depth, crucial for drawing viewers into the harrowing narrative. However, it is disappointing to note the lack of bonus features; additional content such as behind-the-scenes footage or interviews would have been a valuable addition, given the film's engrossing subject matter.
Fans of television crime shows should find "Serial Killer 1" most appealing, even though the production isn't making a full-blooded whodunit, focusing more on evidence acquisition and emotional wear and tear, depicting an important time in law enforcement history. It's not especially original or surprising, but it's grim comfort food for those who like their police procedurals bleak and courtroom showdowns combative. Despite the absence of supplementary content, this Blu-ray release is wholeheartedly recommended. The film's interesting procedural approach and engrossing narrative make it a must-watch for true crime enthusiasts.
Blu-ray.com review by Brian OrndorfRead review here
Video: 90
The AVC encoded image (2.40:1 aspect ratio) presentation carries the grit and clarity of "Serial Killer 1," offering satisfying detail throughout the viewing experience, which switches from grim police...
Audio: 90
The 5.1 DTS-HD MA sound mix manages the feature's interest in dialogue exchanges, keeping voices sharp and communicative, supporting all necessary emotional movement without distortion....
Extras: 20
...
Movie: 80
The case is famous for its use of DNA evidence, inspiring France to overhaul its way of processing crime scenes, and "Serial Killer 1" is more about the need for technology than a simple manhunt picture,...
Total: 70
Fans of television crime shows should find "Serial Killer 1" most appealing, even though the production isn't making a full-blooded whodunit, focusing more on evidence acquisition and emotional wear and...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
It has a very film-like appearance to it but doesn't provide the same level of detail and image depth that a larger format would....
Audio: 80
The sense of channel movement and surround activity is used more a means to setup atmosphere and tone rather than to provide a sense of immersion....
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 80
During the trial of Guy George, a lawyer will make the bold defense of humanizing her client, to show the world he isn't a monster, but a flesh and blood man....
Total: 60
Sadly there aren't any bonus features to speak of and this is one of those films where I want to learn everything about the real story as well as the making of the film....
Director: Frédéric Tellier
Actors: Raphaël Personnaz, Nathalie Baye, Olivier Gourmet
PlotFranck Magne, a fresh-faced detective in Paris, is assigned his first major case involving the brutal murder of a young woman. As he dives into the investigation, he uncovers a series of unsettling similarities with other unsolved murders over the past decade. Despite initial lack of support from his superiors, Franck becomes increasingly convinced that he is dealing with a serial killer. His tenacity leads him deeper into the underbelly of the city, revealing a pattern of victims who are all young women, killed in the same brutal manner. As the pressure mounts, Franck's personal and professional lives begin to blur, leading him to re-evaluate his pursuit and the impact it's having on those around him.
Parallelly, journalist Nathalie is also drawn to the case. Driven by her own desire for truth and justice, she conducts her own investigation, which often intersects with Franck's findings. As both pursue different leads, tensions rise within the police force and the media spotlight intensifies, making the case increasingly complex. Secrets within the police department come to light, and Franck finds himself in a race against time to prevent further deaths. The lines between hunter and hunted blur as each new discovery brings them closer to uncovering the identity of the elusive killer, whose motivations are as twisted as his methods.
Writers: Frédéric Tellier, David Oelhoffen, Patricia Tourancheau
Release Date: 07 Jan 2015
Runtime: 120 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: France
Language: French