12 Strong 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 75
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
While 12 Strong's 4K UHD Blu-ray boasts outstanding A/V quality with tightly encoded 100GB discs, the film itself is clichéd and unlikely to draw collector interest.
Disc Release Date
2K Upscale
HDR10
DTS-HD MA
Video: 95
12 Strong's 4K UHD Blu-ray offers a near-perfect video presentation with a pristine 2160p/HDR transfer that excels in crispness, contrast, and stability. The cool color palette, bolstered by HDR10, brings depth and variation, creating an exceptionally potent visual experience.
Audio: 85
The 4K UHD Blu-ray of '12 Strong' offers a robust DTS-HD 5.1 Master Audio mix with crisp dialogue and thunderous action sequences, yet misses the opportunity for a Dolby Atmos track and the original theatrical 7.1 mix, leading to a good but not overly impressive audio experience.
Extra: 41
The 4K UHD Blu Ray of '12 Strong' lacks expected Blu-ray and Digital Copy, featuring only two extras from the Blu-ray: 'The Making of an Impossible Mission' (22:05) with insights from Jerry Bruckheimer and ODA 595, and 'Monumental Effort' (10:13) detailing Douwe Blumberg's Ground Zero monument.
Movie: 36
12 Strong's 4K UHD release by Warner Bros. significantly enhances the visual and auditory experience with HDR10 and meticulous 100GB encoding, despite the film's controversial portrayals and Jerry Bruckheimer's over-the-top production.
Video: 95
"12 Strong" on 4K UHD Blu-ray showcases an impressive elevation in video quality compared to its Blu-ray predecessor. Retaining its digitally-shot smoothness, the 2160p/HDR transfer amplifies the film's already stellar image clarity and texture. Presented with HDR10 encoding, the film’s predominantly cool color palette benefits from enhanced depth and variation, further enriching the already striking cinematography. The meticulously encoded transfer on a generous bit rate ensures an image free from compression artifacts like banding or macro blocking, with details so crisp that they rival or surpass original theatrical presentations.
The desert landscapes and mountainous backdrops exhibit a rich contrast that intensifies the gritty feel of the film, evoking a visual ambiance akin to Spielberg's "Saving Private Ryan." The 2.40:1 HEVC 4K image offers razor-sharp precision, making every scene visually arresting. The high dynamic range solidifies black levels, boosts contrast, and maintains bright whites without blooming. Even though the film lacks Dolby Vision, WB’s HDR10 application provides ample dynamic support that leaves viewers thoroughly impressed. The result is an unparalleled viewing experience that solidifies "12 Strong" as a visual spectacle, despite any narrative shortcomings.
Those with an appreciation for high-quality visuals will undeniably find value in this flawless transfer. The enhanced 4K image quality not only heightens the existing strengths seen in the Blu-ray version but also paves the way for a more immersive and engaging viewing experience. However, one can only imagine the potential impact if WB applied such meticulous effort to their other classic titles.
Audio: 85
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "12 Strong" features a DTS-HD 5.1 Master Audio mix that, while unchanged from the 2018 Blu-ray edition, delivers a robust and engaging auditory experience. The dialogue is crisp and well-defined, ensuring clear communication even amid the film’s intense action sequences. The sound mix handles thunderous moments with precision, maintaining a polished overall feel while retaining some rawness that matches the film's gritty nature. However, it fails to include the original theatrical 7.1 mix, which remains a noteworthy omission.
Despite the missed opportunity to upgrade to a Dolby Atmos track, the existing DTS HD Master Audio track demonstrates significant dynamic range and depth. The LFE channel is actively utilized, providing a solid low-end rumble that adds weight to explosive scenes. Vocals generally remain clear but occasionally get overshadowed by the more chaotic on-screen action. Surround channels offer moderate support, enriching the listening experience during high-energy scenes, though they do not impress with their presence. Overall, while the audio presentation is effective and satisfying, it falls short of being exemplary.
Extras: 41
The "12 Strong" 4K UHD Blu-ray extras are concise, providing valuable behind-the-scenes insights and historical context. The primary extras focus on both the making of the film and the significance of tangible historical commemorations. Jerry Bruckheimer, along with members of ODA 595, delves into the intricate details and challenges of creating an authentic cinematic portrayal in "12 Strong: The Making of an Impossible Mission." The bonus feature "Monumental Effort: Building America’s Response Monument" showcases sculptor Douwe Blumberg's creative process and inspiration for the monument at Ground Zero, bridging a compelling connection between the film’s subject matter and real-world events. These supplementary features, while limited in number, robustly support the thematic elements of the main feature.
Extras included in this disc:
- 12 Strong: The Making of an Impossible Mission: Jerry Bruckheimer and ODA 595 discuss the film’s production and mission.
- Monumental Effort: Building America's Response Monument: Sculptor Douwe Blumberg talks about creating the Ground Zero monument.
Movie: 36
Warner Bros. revisits "12 Strong" with a new 4K UHD edition, benefiting from HDR10 and a full-strength triple layer (100GB) disc, elevating the already solid 2018 Blu-ray version. Directed by Nicolai Fuglsig and produced by Jerry Bruckheimer, the film features a capable cast, including Chris Hemsworth, Michael Shannon, and Michael Peña. The story, set just days after September 11, 2001, follows Capt. Mitch Nelson (Hemsworth) and his elite special forces team as they venture into Afghanistan to forge an alliance with Gen. Rashid Dostum (Navid Negahban) against Al Qaeda and the Taliban. Despite compelling source material and robust sound and visuals, the film's execution is inconsistent, marred by clichéd storytelling and moments that verge on the demoralizing.
The narrative is hindered by an uneven tone and Fuglsig's novice direction. Hemsworth’s portrayal of Capt. Nelson lacks gravitas, overshadowed by unrealistic dialogue and over-the-top action sequences typical of Bruckheimer productions. Flashbacks involving Nelson’s wife (Elsa Pataky) attempt to add emotional depth but feel forced. Pleasing visuals and tight encoding don't suffice to save "12 Strong" from its disjointed exposition and underwhelming delivery, resulting in a movie that feels more like an overindulgent spectacle rather than a respectful recounting of true events. While some viewers may find the plot’s peculiarities intriguing, the film ultimately fails to leave a lasting impression.
Total: 75
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "12 Strong" presents a technically impressive package, delivering a robust audiovisual experience that excels in both picture and sound quality. The tightly encoded disc, leveraging 100GB of storage, ensures that the visual presentation is sharp, detailed, and vibrant, with rich colors and deep contrast levels. The film's audio track is equally commendable, offering a dynamic range that immerses viewers in its intense battle sequences. Technically, this release sets a high standard for 4K catalog upgrades.
However, the film itself does not quite match up to its pristine presentation. Directed by Nicolai Fuglsig, "12 Strong" follows a rather formulaic narrative, populated with one-dimensional characters and a plethora of war movie clichés. While the movie attempts to deliver emotional weight, it ultimately feels like a jingoistic drama that fails to engage its audience fully. The supplementary content on the disc is also lackluster, featuring a minimal assortment of extras that do little to enhance the viewing experience. Notably, the absence of a UV code is a disappointing oversight and may deter some consumers.
I'm all for no-nonsense 4K catalog upgrades, especially ones that are tightly encoded on 100GB discs with outstanding A/V merits and an affordable price tag. Without question, WB should churn out as many as possible in the near future. But how's about we focus on more deserving titles than Nicolai Fuglsig's "12 Strong," a nearly brand-dead and jingoistic drama that very few people were clamoring for on UHD? With that said, fans of the film should nonetheless take note, as this great-looking and sounding disc supplants the earlier great looking and sounding Blu-ray edition.
Blu-ray.com review by Randy Miller IIIRead review here
Video: 100
It doesn't, of course, as this tightly-encoded transfer -- which practically gets an entire 100GB disc to itself and runs at a very generous bit rate from start to finish -- looks even more crisp, stable,...
Audio: 90
I'm almost positive that whatever lengths were taken to sweeten the visuals on 12 Strong's new 2160p/HDR transfer did not include any sort of upgrade to (or modification of) the DTS-HD 5.1 Master Audio...
Extras: 40
Please note that both a Blu-ray and Digital Copy of the film were initially advertised in WB's April press release, but neither are included....
Movie: 40
Nonetheless, this barely-advertised MOD title will be of interest to fans, because it takes an already great-looking (and sounding) release and makes it that much better, thanks to HDR10 and tight encoding...
Total: 50
With that said, fans of the film should nonetheless take note, as this great-looking and sounding disc supplants the earlier great looking and sounding Blu-ray edition....
Blu-ray Authority review by Matt BrightonRead review here
Video: 100
The mountains, the desert all have a very rich contrast to them that gives the film an almost surreal look....
Audio: 90
At any rate, the mix has more of a constant low grade “mumble” for lack of a better term, but it will engage the LFE....
Extras: 50
Monumental Effort: Building America’s Response Monument – Douwe Blumberg, the sculptor who created the monument that stands at Ground Zero in New York, gives as a bit of history and his inspiration....
Movie: 0
But then again this is a Jerry Bruckheimer-produced film and, as such, it’s got to have things that are way over the top....
Total: 60
The characters are one-dimensional and the film is full of cliches while attempting to tug at the heartstrings of its viewers....
Director: Nicolai Fuglsig
Actors: Chris Hemsworth, Michael Shannon, Michael Peña
PlotFollowing the September 11 attacks, Captain Mitch Nelson leads a U.S. Special Forces team, consisting of 12 soldiers, who are deployed to Afghanistan as the first American troops to take on the Taliban. Their mission involves teaming up with General Dostum of the Northern Alliance to take over the strategic city of Mazar-i-Sharif from the Taliban's control. Facing challenging terrain, they must make a treacherous journey on horseback, adapting quickly to unfamiliar guerrilla warfare tactics while fostering a fragile alliance with Dostum, who has his own methods and motivations.
As the soldiers advance, they engage in deadly combat with the Taliban fighters and navigate the complex political landscape of their involvement. Their resolve is tested by immense danger and the cultural divide between them and their Afghan allies. The team’s strategy relies heavily on coordinating airstrikes while relying on horseback mobility to overcome numerically superior Taliban forces. The soldiers witness the harsh realities of war and the resilience required to endure in such an environment, realized through a compelling combination of action and emotional intensity.
Writers: Ted Tally, Peter Craig, Doug Stanton
Release Date: 19 Jan 2018
Runtime: 130 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English, Dari, Russian, Spanish, Uzbek