Silent Night 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 73
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Silent Night: Stylish action, ludicrous plot, and impressive tech make it a must-see for John Woo fans.
Disc Release Date
True 4K
HDR10
Dolby Vision
Dolby Atmos
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 90
Silent Night's 4K UHD release enhances detail and color, offering a visually striking experience with vivid contrasts and a refined portrayal of dark and violent elements, balancing clarity with gritty realism.
Audio: 70
Silent Night's Dolby Atmos mix offers immersive action and Marco Beltrami's score, with dynamic sound effects but lacks in dialogue and height channel innovation, leaving some wanting more depth and immersion.
Extra: 56
The 1080 and 2160 disc package includes a glossily designed SteelBook and extras like a featurette and trailer, offering a unique take on Christmas colors and an ironic packaging twist, though some may find supplementary content and digital copy inclusion inconsistent.
Movie: 61
Lionsgate's *Silent Night*, a dialog-free action thriller by John Woo, showcases a father's wordless revenge quest in a 4K SteelBook exclusive at Wal-Mart, blending melancholy with visceral action.
Video: 90
Silent Night is showcased on 4K UHD Blu-ray with a striking HEVC / H.265 encoded 2160p transfer, boasting a unique 2.00:1 aspect ratio, courtesy of Lionsgate Films. The visual experience elevates significantly from the 1080p version, revealing fine details with remarkable clarity, whether it's the texture of a sweater or the vivid depiction of wounds, which might unsettle the more squeamish viewers. This heightened realism is further accentuated by HDR and Dolby Vision enhancements, which bring out the nuances in both the gruesomely vivid sequences and more subdued moments with an impressive depth of field and shadow detail. The color palette benefits from HDR/Dolby Vision, especially in scenes with less aggressive grading, rendering a more nuanced spectrum of tones that add to the film's atmospheric settings.
The presentation does a commendable job in handling contrast and color reproduction, navigating the gritty and often bleak thematic elements of the film with a balanced approach. Dark scenes are rendered with inky blacks without losing detail, ensuring that nighttime sequences maintain their intended intense and foreboding atmosphere. Flashbacks and specific locations come alive through vibrant color highlights, demonstrating a broad and varied palette that enhances the storytelling without detracting from it. The film's digital capture maintains a clean look throughout, devoid of any distracting noise or artifacts, while still portraying a slightly grainy texture in brighter scenes that adds to the cinematic quality without feeling artificial.
Flesh tones are portrayed with natural fidelity, crucial for maintaining immersion in the film's more intense and graphic scenes. The added detail in 4K makes every spatter of blood and facial expression strikingly vivid, contributing to an overall presentation that’s both visually arresting and narratively engaging. Despite some choices in digital grain that may not appeal to all, Silent Night's 4K release is a testament to how advanced video technology can enhance the horror genre, providing viewers with an exceptionally clear yet haunting visual experience.
Audio: 70
Silent Night's" Dolby Atmos audio track presents a curious case, blending a sparse use of intelligible dialogue with a heavy reliance on sound effects and Marco Beltrami's atmospheric score to create an immersive soundscape. The setup is intriguing, making use of background noises such as police radios to introduce moments of narrative clarity amidst a largely vocal-free film. This choice in sound design is complemented by action sequences that offer a genuine sense of immersion, sending effects cascading through the surround channels with precise and engaging dynamics. Beltrami’s involvement in the film’s making-of featurette highlights the unique challenge of scoring a nearly silent movie, a task he manages with effectiveness, ensuring his music envelops the listener from all angles of the soundstage. Optional English and Spanish subtitles are made available, providing a quirky yet appreciated nod to the film's minimal use of direct speech.
However, not all aspects of the audio presentation are without critique. While the visuals of "Silent Night" dazzle, the accompanying Atmos mix experiences moments of inconsistency, fluctuating between engagingly dynamic in action-packed sequences and disappointingly subdued during quieter scenes. This inconsistency extends to the utilization of the height channels, which rather than expanding the auditory experience with distinct Atmos effects, often revert to performing like a traditional 7.1 setup, thus underutilizing the potential for a more enveloping atmospheric presence. Additionally, despite robust moments where music and sound effects energetically challenge the subwoofer, there remains a palpable need for greater depth and diversity in the low-frequency extensions to match the onscreen action's intensity.
Surround sound utilization is competent, filling the environment with ambient sounds representative of various scene settings, from the bustling activity within a police station to the eerie silence of an empty home. Yet, here too lies a sentiment of missed opportunity for further innovative audio storytelling. The mix's dialogue approach, focusing on non-verbal sounds like grunts and screams, is effectively reproduced, fitting well within the film's unique soundscape. However, the overall impression is that "Silent Night's" audio mix, despite showcasing moments of brilliance and innovation, somewhat falters in fully leveraging its technical capabilities to consistently support and enhance the film's unconventional narrative structure.
Extras: 56
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Silent Night" presents its extras in a straightforward, albeit limited fashion, consistent across both the 1080p and 2160p discs. The highlight is "Actions Speak Louder Than Words," a featurette that enriches the experience by offering insights from the cast and crew, despite its brief runtime and somewhat EPK-like nature. Following this, the theatrical trailer serves to compile the film's most memorable moments, albeit not exhaustively. Packaging is notably striking, featuring a SteelBook design that playfully subverts traditional Christmas palettes with its neon red (almost purple) and green hues, showcasing key scenes and characters. Although the interior design lacks clarity, the overall presentation is lifted by a unique mylar O-ring. It’s worth noting this edition advertises digital copy inclusion, though it was missing in some instances, hinting at potential packaging inconsistencies.
Extras included in this disc:
- Actions Speak Louder Than Words: A concise behind-the-scenes look offering commentary from the production team.
- Theatrical Trailer: A quick glimpse into the film’s highlights.
Movie: 61
In an ambitious departure from conventional storytelling, "Silent Night" under the direction of John Woo, eschews dialogue for a purely visual and visceral narrative experience, setting itself apart in the action thriller genre. This exclusive 4K release by Lionsgate in partnership with Wal-Mart, encased in a collectible SteelBook, brings forth the harrowing tale of Brian Godlock (played by Joel Kinnaman), a man propelled into a vengeful quest following the tragic death of his son during a gang shootout on Christmas Eve. The movie's centrepiece, Brian's relentless pursuit of his son's killers, is underscored by his resultant muteness from a gunshot wound, an element that significantly shapes the film's dialogue-free premise.
John Woo's distinctive flourish in orchestrating high-octane action sequences shines through despite the film wearing its influences on its sleeve. However, it's the human tragedy at the heart of "Silent Night" that imbues it with a melancholic depth. The lack of spoken words is not merely a stylistic choice; it amplifies the emotional weight of the narrative, exploring themes of loss, retaliation, and the breakdown of familial bonds in silence. The performances, particularly Kinnaman's, are commendably conveyed through physicality and expression alone, albeit the film’s ambitious no-dialogue approach occasionally feels more like a gimmick than a necessity.
Despite some conventional revenge tropes and occasional lapses into B-movie territory, "Silent Night" is a testament to Woo's prowess in blending action with emotional storytelling. The film’s minimalist dialogue approach and raw, pulpy aesthetic render it a polarizing yet captivating watch. As the protagonist navigates his grief and seeks retribution without uttering a single word, "Silent Night" challenges viewers to find meaning in silence, offering a unique cinematic experience that is both engaging and reflective.
Total: 73
Silent Night," with its distinctive no-dialogue approach and intense action sequences, stands as a notable yet peculiar entry into the revenge thriller genre. Fans of John Woo's unique filmmaking style will find much to appreciate here, notably the fluid camera work and the meticulously crafted shootouts, which are hallmark features of Woo's direction. However, the film's decision to eschew dialogue altogether might not resonate with all audiences, leaving some to question its necessity. Despite these divisive creative choices, the technical execution of this 4K UHD Blu-ray release is undeniably impressive. With superior technical merits, including a brilliant Dolby Vision presentation, this edition elevates the viewing experience significantly, ensuring that those interested in the visual and auditory fidelity of their home entertainment will be well served choosing this format over its 1080p counterpart.
The package, exclusive to certain retailers, not only enhances the film's visual spectacle with its 4K resolution but also includes the 1080p version, offering versatility for various viewing preferences. Moreover, the behind-the-scenes insights into the film's production shed light on its constrained budget and expedited schedule, factors that inevitably influenced its tone and narrative pacing. From moments of intense rage to poignant sadness, "Silent Night" traverses a wide emotional spectrum, albeit in a manner that some may find somewhat disjointed.
In conclusion, while "Silent Night" may not secure a spot among the timeless action classics, it undeniably leaves its mark through its audacious storytelling and remarkable technical quality. This 4K UHD Blu-ray embodies an ideal purchase for enthusiasts of high-octane action and fans of John Woo's directorial flare, delivering a home cinema experience that faithfully captures the movie's stylistic and technical ambitions. Whether for the dedicated collector or the action aficionado seeking their next adrenaline rush, this release proves to be a commendable addition to any Blu-ray library.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
All of these grading choices have some kind of interesting new highlights courtesy of HDR and/or Dolby Vision, but some of the most noticeable changes to the palette are arguably in some of the less aggressively...
Audio: 90
Silent Night offers a rather interestingly designed Dolby Atmos track, one that relies on, yes, actual understandable words at least now and again courtesy of some background chatter on police radios and...
Extras: 100
The SteelBook packaging is nicely designed, and offers a kind of ironic "twist" on traditional Christmas colors with shades of red (almost purple) and green on the cover, with the front panel showing Brian...
Movie: 60
That's the "big" conceit of this John Woo film, which has a lot of Woo's trademark flourishes in the gunfire and fisticuffs departments, and which actually manages to convey its plot mechanics rather artfully...
Total: 40
The incredible action sequences and Woo's typically fluid camera might be enough to recommend this outing to that particular demographic at least....
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 100
Black Levels: A good portion of the flim takes place at night, so darkness and shadow detail are paramount to this presentation....
Audio: 60
This is a sound driven movie, so without the dialogue, I was hoping to be more immersed in the other audio items going on in every scene, but in some instances, the mix falls flat....
Extras: 20
The release ships with a digital code and bundled BD, but my review copy didn’t come with the code....
Movie: 70
Joel Kinnaman fills the bill as a silent, pained father building his instinct, survival skills, and body to fight back against those who’ve done him the ultimate wrong....
Total: 60
Silent Night may not become an action holiday hallmark like a Die Hard or even Violent Night, but for precise, cut to the chase action, my thirst for a good Shoot-em-up was satiated....
Director: John Woo
Actors: Joel Kinnaman, Kid Cudi, Harold Torres
PlotIn the heart of a city gripped by a relentless snowstorm, a trio of strangers find their lives unexpectedly intertwined on Christmas Eve. Joel, a disillusioned war veteran struggling to reconcile with his past, crosses paths with Cudi, a charismatic street artist with a mysterious agenda. As the night unfolds, they encounter Torres, an enigmatic figure with a complex connection to both men. Each harboring secrets and battling personal demons, they find themselves on a collision course with fate, forced to confront their deepest fears and desires.
As the storm intensifies, the city becomes a labyrinth of snow-covered streets and hidden dangers. The unlikely trio must navigate the treacherous urban landscape, pursued by a shadowy adversary with a vendetta that threatens to destroy them all. Their journey is a test of survival, friendship, and courage, pushing them to the limits of endurance and forcing them to make impossible choices. In the silence of the night, amidst the chaos of the storm, they discover the true meaning of redemption, sacrifice, and hope.
Writers: Robert Archer Lynn
Release Date: 01 Dec 2023
Runtime: 104 min
Rating: R
Country: United States, Mexico
Language: None