The Guilty Blu-ray Review
Score: 61
from 1 reviewers
Review Date:
The Guilty excels in storytelling and performance, with a Blu-ray that balances solid quality and price. Firmly Recommended.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 70
Magnolia's 1080p Blu-ray of The Guilty excels in showcasing the film's confined settings and dialogue-driven narrative through detailed close-ups and a modest visual depth, achieving a precisely decent and stable presentation with minimal need for improvement.
Audio: 80
The Guilty's Danish audio mix is immersive with strategic use of silence and rear channels, enhancing realism, unlike the adequate but less authentic English dub. Subtitles are literal, favoring accuracy over dubtitles.
Extra: 0
This release comes in a basic keepcase with generic art, lacking inserts or a slipcover, and misses out on extras, except for a subtitled Danish trailer.
Movie: 86
The Guilty, a minimalist thriller, shines in its original and remake, with the former's nuanced focus and ambiguous end slightly edging out. Both films captivate with intense storytelling and solid performances.
Video: 70
The Blu-ray release of "The Guilty" showcases a 1080p video presentation that aligns seamlessly with the essence and limitations of its source material. Given the film's narrative, tethered primarily to the confines of office settings and a palette confined to the dimensions of these interiors, the visual experience relies heavily on creative camera work. The cinematography, characterized by dynamic and varied angles, endeavors to introduce a level of visual intrigue that compensates for the inherent constraints of the setting. It's noteworthy that the presentation excels in rendering fine details in close-ups and mid-range shots, which is commendable given the film's reliance on facial expressions and subtle interactions to drive the narrative forward. The depth of field varies, adding a modest sense of depth to the scenes, though the overall visual experience remains squarely within the expectations for a production that's more narratively than visually driven.
A key aspect of this Blu-ray presentation is its stability and clarity. Despite the film's deliberately limited visual scope, the transfer benefits from being mostly free of artifacts, ensuring that what viewers see is an accurate reflection of the filmmaker's vision, albeit within a narrowly defined visual ambit. The lack of visually spectacular scenes or diverse locations could be perceived as a limitation; however, within this constraint, the Blu-ray delivers a technically proficient display. It mirrors the film's essence with a fidelity that leaves little room for improvement, considering the material it works with.
The absence of showy visuals and varied locales in "The Guilty" does not detract from the efficiency and effectiveness of this Blu-ray presentation. Instead, it showcases how well-executed technical work can support a film that opts for simplicity in its visual narrative, opting instead to focus on emotional depth and character dynamics. Through its detail-oriented and stable visual presentation, this Blu-ray succeeds in delivering a viewing experience that is both fitting and faithful to the original cinematic vision, underscoring the technical prowess behind it.
Audio: 80
The Guilty" Blu-ray's audio presentation offers a dual experience, focusing on its original Danish DTS-HD 5.1 Master Audio mix and the optional English DTS-HD 5.1 Master Audio dub. The original Danish track stands out for its unique sonic approach. Predominantly, it's a front-heavy mix that makes sparse, yet effective use of the rear channels during phone conversations, particularly those involving Asger and Iben. This method creates an immersive experience by providing exaggerated clarity and depth, distinctively more pronounced than what one would expect from a typical phone call. The absence of background music or common auditory embellishments further enhances the clarity, drawing the viewer more profoundly into Asger's psychological state in a subtle yet impactful manner.
Conversely, the English dub offers a competent, albeit less nuanced audio experience. Asger's voice, in the English version, is notably more prominent and vigorous, which doesn't entirely match the film's naturalistic setting. Despite this, it remains a viable option for viewers who prefer to avoid subtitles, offering an overall satisfactory albeit slightly less immersive experience. The execution of sonic tricks is maintained across both tracks, preserving the film's original intention to envelop the audience in its tense, claustrophobic atmosphere.
Regarding subtitles, the release provides accurate translations that reflect the original Danish dialogue without resorting to dubtitles. This decision might detract from the experience for some but ensures fidelity to the source material. Overall, while both audio options have their merits, the original Danish mix offers a more authentic and engaging auditory journey, rich in detail and subtlety, which complements the film's intense narrative and character-driven focus.
Extras:
The Blu-ray release of "The Guilty" stands out as a modest yet focused package, aimed squarely at enthusiasts of minimalist cinema and Danish storytelling. The presentation is simple, with a standard keepcase and an understated design that mirrors the film's own stark approach. While extras are notably scarce, the inclusion of a subtitled Danish-language trailer offers a glimpse into the intense, tightly-wound narrative that has garnered acclaim. This singular extra provides both a nod to purists and a practical asset for those intrigued by the film's original marketing efforts.
Extras included in this disc:
- Danish-Language Trailer: Subtitled trailer giving insights into the film's tension-filled story.
Movie: 86
The Guilty," the 2019 Danish thriller directed by Gustav Müller, presents a compelling narrative enhanced by Jakob Cedergren's one-man performance as Asger Holm. Situated almost entirely within the confines of an emergency call center, the film follows Holm, a police officer turned dispatcher, as he navigates a tense and complex case during what seems to be a routine shift. This original version offers a closer look at Asger's multifaceted character, exploring his personal turmoil and professional dedication. With minimal yet effective interactions, the film accentuates the gravity of the situation unfolding over the phone, presenting a storyline that is both gripping and immersive. The movie's suspense is tactile, with its slow build-up leading to a series of startling revelations that keep viewers on edge.
While comparisons with its 2021 American remake starring Jake Gyllenhaal are inevitable, the Danish original holds its ground with a more nuanced exploration of its protagonist. The ambiguity of the ending and subtle story beats specific to its cultural context may resonate differently across audiences but add layers of depth not as prevalent in the remake. Despite the minimalistic setting, "The Guilty" successfully expands its narrative scope through well-timed plot twists and character revelations. The tension is palpable as Asger becomes increasingly entangled in a caller's life-threatening situation, showcasing Cedergren's ability to convey a spectrum of emotions that bolsters the film's psychological complexity.
Technical merits of the Blu-Ray release of "The Guilty" align well with the movie's high-caliber storytelling. Despite lacking in special features, the A/V quality is commendable, ensuring that the film's atmospheric tension and auditory nuances are preserved. For those intrigued by story-driven cinema and willing to navigate the language barrier, this Blu-Ray does not disappoint. Coupled with its affordability, it makes for an excellent addition to any collection, embodying minimalist filmmaking at its finest. Its focus on character-driven narratives set against a backdrop of suspense makes "The Guilty" a memorable cinematic experience.
Total: 61
Gustav Müller's original "The Guilty" has found its way to Blu-ray, offering audiences an insight into a tightly-woven narrative that thrives on its claustrophobic setting and compelling storyline. Led by Jakob Cedergren's exceptional performance, the film presents a masterclass in suspense and emotional depth, all encapsulated within the confines of its limited setting. The Blu-ray edition, released by Magnolia Entertainment, is notable for its proficient audio and video quality, ensuring that viewers can fully immerse themselves in the film's tense atmosphere without distraction. However, it's worth noting the package comes somewhat light on additional content, with minimal extras included to complement the primary feature.
The technical presentation of the Blu-ray merits particular praise, as it successfully captures the film's nuanced sound design and visual clarity, elements that are pivotal to maintaining the movie's intense mood. While the shortage of supplementary features might be seen as a missed opportunity to delve deeper into the film's creation and the director's vision, the Blu-ray is competitively priced, making it an appealing acquisition for both fans of the American remake wanting to explore the original and newcomers to Müller's work. The balance between price point and quality makes this edition an excellent value proposition.
In conclusion, "The Guilty" on Blu-ray represents a solid option for those looking to experience Gustav Müller's riveting thriller in high-definition. Though the lack of extensive extras may discourage some, the film's outstanding lead performance and the technical proficiency of the Blu-ray compilation itself make it a recommended purchase. Whether you're revisiting the story or coming to it fresh, this edition offers a compelling reason to witness Cedergren's gripping portrayal and the film's intense cinematic journey.
Blu-ray.com review by Randy Miller IIIRead review here
Video: 80
Fine detail is quite good in close-ups and mid-range shots alike, with modest depth achieved thanks to varying focal length, but let's face it: this is not a visually-driven production, so the simple fact...
Audio: 90
These brief segments are slightly exaggerated with much better clarity and depth than you'd normally get from a mono headset connection, but the technique firmly places you inside the head of its main...
Extras: 0
This one-disc release ships in a standard keepcase with unavoidably generic cover artwork and no insert or slipcover....
Movie: 90
Finally, the remake adds a young child for our hero, as well as a more dialed-in focus on the relationship between police officers and the general public; considering the current climate on that subject,...
Total: 80
Gustav M�ller's The Guilty, recently remade for American audiences, is a sturdy close-quarters thriller led by great storytelling and an outstanding lead performance from Jakob Cedergren....
Director: Gustav Möller
Actors: Jakob Cedergren, Jessica Dinnage, Omar Shargawi
PlotIn the confines of an emergency call center, a demoted police officer, Asger Holm, answers a distress call from a woman named Iben who subtly indicates she's been kidnapped while pretending to speak to her child. The call abruptly disconnects, leaving Asger with limited information. Despite being assigned to desk work, Asger's instincts kick in, and he becomes determined to save the woman from her abductor. He embarks on a tense and critical mission, using only his phone to piece together Iben's situation while confined to the call center. As the night unfolds, Asger uses his wits and breaks protocol, contacting police officers and other parties directly, trying to track down the moving vehicle Iben is in and rescue her.
Asger’s initial self-assuredness gradually cracks as the complexity of the crisis spirals. He grapples with the nuances of the limited information he has, often leaping to conclusions as the severity of the situation intensifies. Wrestling with the constraints of his role and his own troubled past, Asger becomes increasingly entwined in Iben's predicament. His personal investment blurs the lines between professional duty and a desperate need for redemption. Throughout this one-location thriller, the depths of Asger’s character are revealed as he faces the unfolding drama of the night, responding to each unpredictable twist in the desperate hope of ensuring Iben’s safety.
Writers: Gustav Möller, Emil Nygaard Albertsen
Release Date: 19 Oct 2018
Runtime: 85 min
Rating: R
Country: Denmark
Language: Danish