Westward the Women Blu-ray Review
Warner Archive Collection
Score: 85
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
Westward the Women is an unheralded gem, blending progressive drama and stunning cinematography with a top-tier 4K restoration and compelling extras.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 91
Westward the Women dazzles in this 1080p transfer from a 4K scan of preservation elements, offering sharp clarity with excellent contrast, rich blacks, and vivid grays. This top-tier Blu-ray captures stunning vistas and intricate details true to the original nitrate negative, without visual artifacts.
Audio: 84
The DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono track impressively delivers clear dialogue and robust sound effects, erasing age-related imperfections and providing dynamic sonic accents that enhance the film's adventurous atmosphere without distracting from its rich narrative.
Extra: 79
The Blu-ray release of "Westward the Women" features a rich array of extras, including a thorough commentary by Scott Eyman on director William Wellman, a 1951 promotional featurette on its Utah location shooting, a 1952 Lux Radio Theater adaptation with original cast, and newly restored Tom and Jerry cartoons, all enhancing the historical and cinematic context of the film.
Movie: 84
"Westward the Women" is an engrossing and uniquely progressive Western under Wellman's direction and Capra's pen, depicting the perilous journey of midwestern brides-to-be led by Robert Taylor's rugged Buck Wyatt. Despite episodic pacing and occasional tropes, its resilient female protagonists break Golden Age norms, bolstered by a well-restored Blu-ray release.
Video: 91
"Westward the Women's" Blu-ray release is a remarkable visual presentation, benefiting tremendously from a 4K scan of preservation elements, including the original nitrate camera negative. This meticulous approach results in a pristine 1080p transfer that captures the essence of William Mellor's cinematography. The black-and-white imagery, presented in its original 1.37:1 aspect ratio, exudes clarity and depth, with a grain structure that maintains a beautiful film-like appearance. The sharp delineation of facial details, coupled with a rich grayscale, provides excellent contrast without artifacts, staying true to the source material.
The cinematic journey across diverse landscapes—from mountainous terrains to expansive deserts—is presented with awe-inspiring compositions reminiscent of documentary style filming. Mellor's adept handling of light results in crisp, sun-drenched visuals, allowing the natural setting and harsh reality of the wagon train's voyage to shine through authentically. High-angle and tracking shots are masterfully executed, showcasing not only the physical journey but also the emotional depth of this rugged adventure.
Overall, this Blu-ray presentation excels in preserving and enhancing Mellor's vision. The absence of filters and minimal alteration preserves the raw, unembellished look intended by director William Wellman, offering viewers an immersive experience as if witnessing the film's debut with no age-related distractions. This transfer triumphs as a testament to Warner Archives' commitment to maintaining high-quality releases that stay true to their cinematic origins, providing a truly captivating visual experience for both new audiences and dedicated fans.
Audio: 84
The DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono track on the "Westward the Women" Blu-ray offers an impressive audio presentation that respects the original source material while providing substantial enhancements. Dialogue is consistently clean and crisp, and the soundtrack preserves the dynamic range required to fully engage with the film's soundscape. Jeff Alexander's score seamlessly blends with the audio effects, adding a layer of depth. The restoration effectively eliminates age-related issues like hiss and crackle, though a few minor imperfections remain inconspicuous.
Subtle yet significant sonic elements—such as the sounds of wagon wheels, gunshots, thunder, and water—are well-modulated, providing an authentic audio environment that immerses viewers in the film's rugged Western landscape. Even generally understated moments, including the jingling of harnesses and the patter of rain, are rendered with clarity. Although the track can sound slightly flat at times, and some sound effects might benefit from further enhancement, the overall sound quality remains robust. The optional English (SDH) subtitles add accessibility.
Ultimately, this DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono sound mix succeeds in delivering a vibrant auditory experience, ensuring that both dialogue and musical scores are captured with precision. The track skillfully balances between effects and spoken words, creating a nuanced audio environment free from significant age-related distortions. In essence, it fulfills the demands of a Western genre audio track quite adeptly by maintaining authenticity and character while providing enhanced clarity and depth.
Extras: 79
The Blu-ray release of "Westward the Women" is a well-curated collection that enriches the main feature with a set of engaging and informative extras. The standout Audio Commentary by film historian Scott Eyman offers a comprehensive analysis of director William A. Wellman, highlighting his contributions and style, including minimal use of makeup and preference for diverse shot compositions to enhance storytelling. The commentary successfully bridges thematic parallels with John Ford’s works and provides essential insights into MGM's historical dynamics. Supplementary features include a vintage promotional short, "Challenge the Wilderness," which delves into the practical challenges faced during location shooting in Utah. The Lux Radio Theater adaptation condenses the film’s essence while retaining its core emotional impact. The collection is rounded off with classic Tom and Jerry cartoons, adding a nostalgic touch, and an original theatrical trailer.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: In-depth discussion by Scott Eyman on director William A. Wellman and more.
- Challenge the Wilderness: Behind-the-scenes featurette on filming techniques and location challenges.
- Lux Radio Theater Broadcast: Radio adaptation featuring original cast members Robert Taylor and Denise Darcel.
- Vintage Cartoon: Texas Tom: Restored Tom and Jerry short set on a cattle ranch.
- Vintage Cartoon: The Duck Doctor: A classic chase with Tom pursuing a duck assisted by Jerry.
- Theatrical Trailer: Original promotional piece in HD.
Movie: 84
"Westward the Women" is a bold and engaging entry in the Western genre, directed by William A. Wellman with screenplay contributions from Charles Schnee and inspired by Frank Capra’s original story. Released during Hollywood's Golden Age, this film diverges from conventional Westerns by focusing on a compelling cadre of strong female characters at its core. Set against the backdrop of 1851 California, the narrative follows rancher Roy Whitman, played by John McIntire, as he orchestrates a formidable expedition to bring 140 women from Chicago to settle in his community in need of familial stability.
This unconventional Western boasts a strong thematic focus on resilience and survival, framed around the women's treacherous journey west. The film thrives on its episodic structure, seamlessly incorporating elements of danger—from natural perils to human conflict—that enhance its suspenseful and emotionally charged narrative. Robert Taylor’s portrayal of Buck Wyatt, a no-nonsense trail leader tasked with overseeing the journey, effectively anchors the film’s tension and drama. The character development is robust, particularly for female leads like Hope Emerson’s Patience Hawley and Denise Darcel’s Fifi Danon, who navigate individual arcs of fortitude amidst adversity.
Technically, the production benefits from Wellman's adept handling of on-location shoots in Utah, which imbues the film with authenticity and visual depth. It also utilizes a distinct lack of sentimentality while maintaining moments of raw human emotion, ensuring that its storytelling resonates with contemporary audiences. Despite some narrative conveniences, "Westward the Women" remains a textured and multifaceted film that breaks conventional molds, showcasing female resilience with vigor and paving new paths within its genre. The Blu-ray release from Warner Archive provides an impressive A/V restoration that honors this cinematic endeavor's enduring qualities.
Total: 85
William A. Wellman's "Westward the Women" is a compelling Western that defies the conventions of its era, showcasing a progressive narrative and strong character development. The film's storyline is rich with drama and action, emphasizing women who rise to meet the arduous challenges of crossing a punishing and majestic landscape. It is a visually stunning piece, marked by sweeping cinematography that dramatically captures the epic journey of a wagon train as it navigates the imposing American wilderness. It authentically portrays the resilience and tenacity of pioneer women, making it both a classic piece of historical fiction and a forward-thinking cinematic work.
The Blu-ray release by Warner Archive is commendable for its exemplary restoration work. Utilizing a new 4K scan of preservation elements, the film’s vibrant visuals and remastered audio come to life with exceptional clarity, allowing modern audiences to experience the full impact of its original beauty. The disc includes an impressive selection of supplemental materials that deepen appreciation for Wellman's artistry and the film’s enduring themes. This meticulous effort cements the movie's importance and ensures its legacy continues to reach new viewers.
In conclusion, "Westward the Women" stands out not only as a remarkable Western but as a significant piece of cinema that addresses themes of courage and determination. The film’s Blu-ray edition, complete with its comprehensive restoration and engaging extras, makes it an indispensable addition to any collection. Whether you are a fan of Westerns or simply appreciate a well-crafted story with profound performances, this release is highly recommended for its entertainment value and historical significance.
Blu-ray.com review by Randy Miller IIIRead review here
Video: 100
Whatever the specifics may be, it's clear from the look of this Blu-ray that the former was a primary ingredient, with long stretches of the handsomely-shot and mostly outdoor film boasting the kind of...
Audio: 90
Dialogue remains clean and crisp, background effects are handled nicely, louder moments -- including a few scenes of action -- enjoy a decent dynamic range, and there's plenty of room left over for the...
Extras: 80
Challenge the Wilderness (10:30) - A vintage promotional short created by MGM, this 1951 black-and-white featurette introduces a few of Westward the Women's stars but mostly focuses on its shooting locations...
Movie: 80
Although portions of its story don't quite hold up to scrutiny (Roy's decades of experience as a frontier scout would have led him to at least a few strong and capable women before this, for example),...
Total: 80
A progressive drama with memorable characters, terrific cinematography, and a true "something for everyone" vibe, it's a forgotten classic ripe for rediscovery and should play smoothly for newer audiences...
The Digital Bits review by Dennis SeulingRead review here
Video: 95
Taylor is bearded for most of the film, suggesting the long time on the trail and the lack of time to shave daily....
Audio: 80
The mono track sounds a bit flat in places and the gun shots could have used some “sweetening,” but other than that, the overall sound quality is fine....
Extras: 95
It’s noted that “the film was nearly strangled in the cradle,” and reasons for the film’s difficult genesis are described....
Movie: 95
Buck chooses fifteen men and warns them to treat the women with respect or they will answer to him personally....
Total: 91
The story is a good one, there’s plenty of action, and the women prove themselves to be equally up to the privations of a long journey through punishing land as men....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Excellent clarity and contrast, rich blacks, vivid whites, and nicely varied grays also distinguish the picture, which flaunts a fair amount of depth....
Audio: 80
Sonic accents like cracking whips, gunfire, screams, fisticuffs, echoes, splashing water, crackling flames, and rumbling thunder are crisp, while subtleties like ringing bells, the jangling and creaking...
Extras: 60
Vintage Featurette: Challenge the Wilderness (SD, 11 minutes) - This promotional short chronicles the movie's location shooting in Utah with behind-the-scenes footage of studio transport vehicles navigating...
Movie: 80
Tough, often gritty, and packed with action, Westward the Women enjoys a solid reputation among western aficionados, but has flown under the radar of mainstream movie fans for decades....
Total: 80
Wellman's film shines a spotlight on a rarely explored topic and Warner Archive honors it with a top-notch transfer struck from a new 4K scan of preservation elements, remastered audio, and a fine array...
Home Theater Forum review by Matt HoughRead review here
Video: 100
It’s a magnificent transfer, sharp as a tack and with a glorious grayscale that features rich, inky blacks and lots of details in the vast vistas on display....
Audio: 100
The DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono sound mix is a wonderful combination of excellently captured dialogue, Jeff Alexander’s engaging background score, and the various sound effects which give the film great...
Extras: 90
Lux Radio Theater (49:14): 1952 radio adaptation of the film with Robert Taylor and Denise Darcel reprising their roles....
Movie: 90
But he also takes the time for some personal, human touches that give the film a nobility and humanity that throbs with emotion: survivors reciting with fierce pride the names of the fallen into a windy,...
Total: 90
William A. Wellman’s Westward the Women is one of the most harrowing yet enjoyable westerns one is likely to find with a fascinating cast of characters acted to perfection and with a succession of gorgeous...
Director: William A. Wellman
Actors: Robert Taylor, Denise Darcel, Hope Emerson
PlotIn the mid-19th century, a group of over a hundred women from Chicago is recruited by Roy Whitman, a rancher, to travel westward to California. His goal is to provide brides for the lonely settlers in his growing community. Buck Wyatt, a tough and experienced trail guide, is hired to lead the perilous journey across treacherous terrain. At first, Buck is skeptical of the women's capabilities and warns them of the grueling conditions ahead, urging anyone with doubts to abandon the trip. Despite his warnings, nearly all the women choose to continue, driven by the promise of a better life and eager to find new beginnings.
The journey challenges the women in ways they had never anticipated, forcing them to summon courage and resilience. As they encounter harsh weather, difficult landscapes, and confront dangers from bandits and Indigenous tribes, the group must learn to work together and share responsibilities. In time, Wyatt's initial skepticism evolves into respect as he witnesses their determination and strength. Bonds are formed among the diverse group of women from different walks of life, each with her own dreams and sorrows. Tension mounts within the group as leadership is tested, but the women become empowered through their shared trials. The successful outcome of their arduous journey hinges on their growing solidarity and the lessons learned along the way.
Writers: Charles Schnee, Frank Capra
Release Date: 31 Dec 1951
Runtime: 118 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United States
Language: English, French, Japanese, Italian, North American Indian