The Prodigy Blu-ray Review
Score: 68
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
The Prodigy suffers from disjointed subplots and lacks suspense, despite Schilling's commendable performance, leading to an obvious and underwhelming conclusion.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 80
The Prodigy's Blu-ray video presentation excels with its AVC encoded image and 2.39:1 aspect ratio, delivering detailed close-ups, refined depth, and dynamic blacks. Its cooler palette with muted primary colors and darker cinematography enhances the film's autumnal mood, without any video-related artifacts.
Audio: 73
The lossless DTS-HD MA soundtrack provides detailed clarity, utilizing the entire surround platform to enhance thematic elements, while dialogue is crisp and centered. Though the sound mix isn't overly lively, it effectively captures atmospherics, delivering solid dynamic range and immersive low-frequency effects.
Extra: 51
The Extras of 'The Prodigy' Blu-ray feature an engaging director's commentary, but the promotional featurettes and gallery offer limited substance, primarily showcasing on-set interviews in a sales pitch style.
Movie: 46
The Prodigy offers a less icky yet still disturbingly brain-dead take on the Killer Kid subgenre, with a script by Jeff Buhler and direction by Nicholas McCarthy that falls back on routine scares and a supernatural twist involving an eight-year-old boy possessed by a serial killer.
Video: 80
The video presentation of "The Prodigy" on Blu Ray delivers a high-definition experience that thoughtfully complements the film's ominous and atmospheric tone. The AVC encoded image, presented in a 2.39:1 aspect ratio, provides excellent resolution, offering clear and refined detail that is particularly noticeable in close-up shots. The visual style employs cooler tones and a subdued palette, emphasizing darker blues and grays to create an autumnal and haunting ambiance. While the chromatic range is limited to a spectrum of muted primary colors and softer secondary hues, the deliberate choice of drab lighting schemes and dark cinematography renders a thematically immersive look.
Skin tones across the cast are natural and lifelike, with texture variations from rosy to pale. The high-definition presentation ensures that facial surfaces and fibrous details in costuming, from comfy cold-weather attire to crisp uniforms, are captured with precision and clarity. Depth of field is well executed, offering discernible distances in wide-angle shots, and interior and exterior scenes both maintain a sense of palpable dimension. The colors, where they do appear—such as the vivid greenery of exteriors or the appealing decoration—stand out effectively against the otherwise muted background. This careful balance of subtle cinematographic choices ensures that the imagery remains engaging while supporting the film's thematic goals.
Blacks are portrayed with depth and dynamism, and shadow details are excellent, maintaining clarity even in the darkest scenes. The image remains free from video-related artifacts, contributing to a clean, thorough presentation. Overall, this Blu Ray transfer succeeds in delivering a visually striking experience that aligns perfectly with the film’s creative vision.
Audio: 73
The DTS-HD MA 5.1 soundtrack on the Blu-ray of "The Prodigy" delivers a detailed and immersive audio experience that thoroughly supports the film's thematic elements. Dialogue is anchored firmly in the center channel, providing clear and distinct renderings of voices and effects within the front soundstage. The soundtrack excels at capturing subtle background sounds and off-camera cues, and offers a notable spatial dimension within the room’s acoustic environment. The dynamic range is robust, enhancing low-frequency effects and enriching the overall mix.
While not perpetually engaging the surround channels and subwoofer, their application is strategic and impactful when utilized, elevating suspenseful and intense moments effectively. The surrounds manage atmospherics competently, ensuring a feel for expansive outdoor settings and eerie interior scenes. Musical scoring is precise, offering clear instrumentation that supports suspenseful moods and quieter, domestic sections alike. Overall, the sound effects are well-defined, with certain nightmare sequences generating immersive circular pressure. Despite some restraint in low-end activity, moments of violence carry a satisfactory heaviness that adds to the film’s unsettling ambiance.
Extras: 51
The Blu-ray release of "The Prodigy" offers a collection of bonus features that, while brief, provide some interesting insights into the film's production. The commentary by Director Nicholas McCarthy is a standout, giving viewers a deeper understanding of his creative choices. The three promotional featurettes cover various aspects of the film but mainly consist of surface-level interviews with the cast and crew. They touch on the story, genre, and character Miles, but lack substantial content. The gallery offers a quick look at behind-the-scenes snapshots and film stills, and the theatrical trailer is also included for completeness.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary by Director Nicholas McCarthy: Detailed insights from the director.
- Promotional Featurettes: Brief segments on the story, genre, and character Miles.
- Gallery: A collection of behind-the-scenes photos and film stills.
- Theatrical Trailer: Original promotional trailer.
Movie: 46
"The Prodigy" ambitiously delves into the Killer Kid subgenre, seeking to blend supernatural elements with psychological horror. Following Sarah and John Blume's joy at their son's rapid development, the narrative quickly veers into unsettling territory as young Miles exhibits violent and erratic behavior. Screenwriter Jeff Buhler employs standard tropes but introduces a fresh reincarnation twist: Miles is revealed to be the vessel for a deceased serial killer. Despite this intriguing premise, the story development feels somewhat pedestrian, offering limited genuine scares and leaning heavily into routine jump scares.
Director Nicholas McCarthy delivers a visually competent film but struggles to inject genuine fear and tension. The opening sequence starkly contrasts the innocence of Miles's birth with the brutality of the Thrush Creek Killer's death, establishing a foreboding atmosphere. However, as the plot progresses, scenes like Miles's brutal attack on a classmate with a pipe wrench tend to drift into implausibility rather than building sustained dread. The film intermittently offers visceral moments, such as an impactful scene of glass-removing gore, but these instances are overshadowed by a screenplay that overlooks logical consequences in favor of shock value.
The character dynamics attempt to explore the erosion of suburban tranquility, as Sarah grapples with increasingly inexplicable and violent behavior from her son. Yet, moments like Miles speaking Hungarian in his sleep hint at deeper psychological underpinnings that remain underdeveloped. The Prodigy paints a chilling portrait of corrupted innocence but ultimately remains undermined by a lack of narrative depth and genuine suspense.
Total: 68
The Prodigy, directed by Nicholas McCarthy, tackles complex themes of manipulation and abuse, largely through the lens of the young antagonist, Miles. Actor Taylor Schilling delivers a compelling performance as Sarah, a mother entangled in her son's increasingly disturbing behavior. However, the film often dips into superficial confrontations and predictable plot points, particularly with the subplot involving John, the father, whose character arc feels abruptly curtailed. The psychological depth hinted at with Dr. Jacobson's invasive therapy remains unexplored, as the film opts for surface-level shock value reminiscent of "The Exorcist," rather than building sustained suspense.
The Blu-ray transfer is technically proficient, offering sharp visuals and seamless audio balance that enhance the film's grim atmosphere. The high-definition format captures every eerie detail with precision, making for an immersive viewing experience. Notably, the sound design is well-calibrated, emphasizing the film's chilling moments through meticulous audio placement and clarity. The inclusion of director commentary and behind-the-scenes featurettes add value for aficionados looking to delve deeper into the film's production nuances. Despite these strengths, the overall narrative falls short of its potential, especially in its disjointed attempt to intertwine psychological horror with family drama.
In conclusion, "The Prodigy" on Blu-ray provides a technically solid presentation that underscores its atmospheric tension. While the performances—especially Schilling’s—are commendable, the film's execution leaves something to be desired with its unfocused storyline and reliance on horror tropes. For fans of psychological horror, it stands as a serviceable addition to their collection, but those seeking a cohesive and thrilling narrative may find it lacking.
Blu-ray.com review by Brian OrndorfRead review here
Video: 90
The feature's cooler palette is explored with care, finding the autumnal mood with darker blues and grays, while some domestic highlights contribute livelier hues, communicating childhood innocence....
Audio: 80
The 5.1 DTS-HD MA sound mix isn't quite as wound up as most horror endeavors, but the basics in performance are handled accurately, finding dialogue exchanges crisp and communicative, exploring whispered...
Extras: 50
There's nothing of substance here, with cast and crew interviews (conducted on-set) in pure used car salesman mode, discussing how "amazing" everything is and how "amazing" the performers are....
Movie: 40
"The Prodigy" soon examines the erosion of this suburban comfort, finding Miles playing malicious games with his babysitter and, more importantly, speaking Hungarian in his sleep, which, understandably,...
Total: 70
And there's Sarah, with Schilling forced to play a mother with a full view of her child's problems, and yet remain in a state of doubt, extending the plot as far as it can go before action is introduced....
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 90
That coupled with the drab lighting schemes and dark cinematography makes for a visually pallid but thematically affecting look....
Audio: 86
Dialog is firmly planted in the center channel and clearly renders voices and effects with appropriate distinction and balance within the front soundstage....
Extras: 60
Audio Commentary by Director Nicholas McCarthy 3 Promotional Featurettes Gallery Theatrical Trailer DVD Digital Copy...
Movie: 60
After seeking help from two experts, Sarah is horrified to learn that her beloved prodigy may be under the grip of a dark and supernatural force....
Total: 74
Gen 3 Seven Channel Amplifier Emotiva XPA-11 Gen 3 Amplifier Panasonic DP-UB820 Ultra HD Blu-ray Player System Controller: Apple iPad/iRule Pro HD Universal Remote Control Canton "Ergo" and Canton In-Ceiling...
Director: Nicholas McCarthy
Actors: Taylor Schilling, Jackson Robert Scott, Peter Mooney
PlotSarah and John Blume are thrilled when their son, Miles, exhibits extraordinary intelligence and abilities at a very young age. However, their joy turns to concern as Miles begins to display increasingly disturbing behavior. Seeking answers, they consult various specialists but make little progress until they meet Dr. Arthur Jacobson, a psychiatrist who specializes in reincarnation. Dr. Jacobson suggests that Miles's talents and troubling actions might be the result of a fractured psyche due to his body hosting two souls: that of Miles and an unknown entity.
As Sarah delves deeper into this theory, she uncovers a series of chilling details that point towards a dark and violent past life intertwined with their son's modern existence. Their once-promising prodigy could potentially harbor a sinister force with malevolent intentions. Facing escalating danger within their own home, Sarah is driven to confront the terrifying reality of her son's true identity and origin. As she grapples with her disbelief and fear, Sarah must make harrowing decisions to protect her family and seek a solution that could either save or doom them all.
Writers: Jeff Buhler
Release Date: 08 Feb 2019
Runtime: 92 min
Rating: R
Country: United States, Canada, Hong Kong
Language: English, Hungarian